So, the good: everyone was wildly helpful and my order was taken quickly and efficiently. This was a to-go order, and I wasn't getting pizza, so this review is of the more side-ish items you might get. The garlic knots are great. Really great. I had a few leftover and ate the rest today. Great even the next day. The bad: I would not bother with the boneless wings. They were Dino-nugget level in terms of texture with some sweet-baby Rays dumped on top. Not really my thing. The small Caesar was also sub-par. The lettuce was old and wilted, the cheese directly from a table shaker and the croutons super croutonian. The dressing was good, though. Overall, was generally disappointed at this price point. Will return at some later date to try the wood fired pizza and regular bone-in wings. read more

See all

Great pizza. We ordered the Spinach and Feta Pizza and the Spinach Feta Calzone. Both were excellent. They use a wood fired oven and the crust is baked to perfection. It's smoky inside from the wood smoke and lack of adequate ventilation, so we ate outside. read more

The food may be on the pricier side, but it's definitely worth it. This isn't your typical big chain pizza place. It's a local gem that everyone needs to try. Stepping into Broadway feels like stepping into someone's own home. The atmosphere is family. And family is what they're all about. The employees make u feel like there own. I would definitely recommend this to anyone visiting town. read more

Good pizza but people there are pretty much clueless. Tried to order their special online with their code they show on their website. Code would not work. Called store and explained and you would have thought I had ask her a quantum physics question. Finally had to ask for a manager who was just as clueless. Finally ask could I just place the order with her and use the code since your online ordering isn't working correctly? "Ohhh no... we can't do that...". Finally just had to hang up and ordered from Pizza Hut. read more

Love this place and all their food. Haven't had anything that I did not enjoy. Decently priced and overly delicious

Ordered for the first time here. It was a great pizza. The restaurant was very smoky inside - not cigarette smoke but inside from cooking. Maybe a venting issue. read more

One of the best pizza spots in Tuscaloosa County. I came in for lunch and got a calzone on their specials. The staff was very friendly. They are a few minutes slower than your chain pizza places, but their quality is impeccable. The calzone was a huge portion for right at 8 dollars after tax. It was fresh out of the oven and had a great flavor. They do have another location as well. This was my first time in this location. Will definitely be back when I'm craving pizza. read more

Broadway Pizzeria 43 - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

Place is gross I had the meatball sub and the meatballs were still cold inside. They must be using frozen ingredients.

Love it. Best pizza in Northport by a long shot. I have been here 4 times and they never disappoint!

Good pizza, friendly employees, reasonable soft drink prices. Kind of hidden from view up on a hill.

This is the closest thing I could find in town to Ny style pizza and it will not disappoint!!

Amazing calzone: check Appropriate quantity for price: check Perfectly cooked: check Homemade amazing ranch: check Marinara on the side: RUINED THE EXPERIENCE. Calzones are meant to be dipped in marinara. This marinara side I got tasted like tomato sauce and sugar. It almost put me off of finishing my calzone. A pinch of sugar is fine in a good marinara to cut acid, but this was positively saccharin :( read more

Great food and great service. Friendly greeting and the calzones were fantastic! The spinach and cheese sticks were a nice complement to the meal. Will be back! read more

Broadway pizza is by far the best pizza in Northport area. Although a small hole in the wall, once found you will come back again and again! I love the pesto chicken pizza. My husband loves the Greek salad ( although they should include a Greek dressing), and a the meat pizza. The ambiance is cold, but hey... when the food is good! Support your local restaurants, sometimes they're the best in town!!! read more

I agree with others who have reviewed this location! It's A Great Neighborhood Place! My cousin always enjoys this place! An has been telling my daughter about it! We are from out of town and just got the opportunity to try it out! I will say the staff are very nice and helpful! They are quick as well! The pizza's were great tasting and the toppings were not skimpy either! Would recommend their philly cheesesteak pizza it was absolutely great! The pepperoni was on point for the discerning palate of the six-year old critic, she ate two slices an really enjoyed it! This location also serves a selection of bottled beers for those that like a beer with a pizza! They also offer carry-out and limited delivery! We will be back when in town to visit family! read more

Broadway Pizzeria 43 - Philly CheeseSteak Pizza! It was Great! - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

Took my family here to have pizza. It was excellent. My wife and I split a pie and our boys got the kids pizzas. It was delicious. Recommended read more

I never leave a review on Yelp like this but if you close at 9 you should take orders up until 9. I called at 8:48 and they said they are not taking any more orders. The food here is pretty good but this is an F in customer service. Simply pathetic! read more

I have not ordered from here in a while. However, the food was excellent the last time I did.

The best pizza we have had since moving to the area. We have tried several others hoping to find something close to what we would eat back home. Broadway has been excellent. read more

One of the best pizzas in town. Great food, average prices for specialty pizza. I've always got it to go but restaurant looks clean when I pick it up. read more

There are no words to express the quality of the food here. It's literally a 10/10 every time. I never leave reviews but their buffalo rolls and what can only be homemade ranch have changed my life... also the best salads I've found. I could eat here everyday. read more

I've picked up food here several times and always happy with the service and food quality I receive. My favorite item is the Cheesesteak pizza! It's absolutely delicious! My second favorite are the Parmesan wings which have a great flavor to them. The service is always great and they keep the inside of the place very clean. They have an area for dinning in and a big TV in the event you want to watch a game there. It's a little hidden from view off highway 43 but loved they added this location here. It's much easier to order delivery and pick up here instead of the other two locations for me. When I want pizza, I go to Broadway off 43. read more

See all

The menu says their chicken Alfredo has bell pepper, mushrooms, olives, onions.. maybe more. However! The only things actually in it are pasta, chicken cheese and sauce. Plain. Tastes ok, but not what is advertised at all!! read more

Broadway Pizzeria 43 - Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

If you are in the Northport area don't go anywhere else for pizza but here! Pizza, cheese sticks, or calzone doesn't matter! They make it fresh and the best read more

I am a pizza-holic and I have no shame in admitting it and this place definitely does a great job of continuing my love of pizza. Their staff is wonderful, the restaurant is always clean and most importantly the food is good! We love their Parmesan garlic wings, every pizza we have tried is amazing, fresh, and made right in front of you in the brick oven! Their cheese sticks are also a favorite of mine and their marinara and garlic butter are great. Can you tell I'm a fan? So happy they deliver also!! read more

So good! Will definitely be ordering again! I loved their crust (not as thick and doughy as other places) and their sausage had a much better texture/taste than other places (I normally cannot eat pizza place sausage). Well baked and perfect! We ate it all before I remembered to take pictures read more

This is an excellent restaurant. We have become frequent customers because of their garlic knots! They've been perfect every time we have ordered them. They have great flavor and I love the garlic butter and marinara that come with them! Follow their Facebook page for special deals. The pizza is amazing! We ordered a cheese pizza once and it had too much cheese but who doesn't like cheese? I'm SUPER impressed by the staff. Friendly and welcoming. read more

Ordered pizza. For no reason, not only did they add Jalapeno, but it was also delivered to us with every single ingredient scrunched on one side of the pizza for no reason. Will not order from again. read more

Today was my first time ordering from Broadway. i got a large manhattan & large philly cheese , both were very good

Placed online order 30.min prior to arrival. Got there and they had no record, this was an issue because I was on lunch break. Ordered chef salad to go because it was quick, then get out with no dressing. And now I am back at work with a decent salad but no dressing. Next time I will call in my order, and check for dressing with a darn salad order. read more

Local business that offers quality food and good customer service.

Great pizza, calzones, sandwiches, wings and whatever else they have! It's all fantastic. Great service too!!!

To start, I would like to say that I had held out hope that this restaurant would be my family's go-to pizza spot, but after tonight, they have shot themselves in the foot. We recently moved to Northport, so in doing so, we had to find our pizza spot. The first time we order delivery we were told it was going to be an hour, I was like, wow but ok ill go with it (it was a small order, week night, and we live 5 minutes away). Over an hour later, we got out food, it was ok so all in all, fine. We ordered again and were again told a long wait, fine but we would need to adapt when we ordered again. The next time we ordered to pick up. I went in and payed and because of Covid was told to wait in my car, 5 minutes later an employee came out to the car saying that there had been a mishap with the printing machine and that we would need to wait for them to make our food. 30 minutes later our food its brought out with a complimentary bottle of Pepsi. Oh wow, on an order that was well over 60$. Writing all this down, I'm almost impressed that I gave them so many opportunities but nevertheless now we come to tonight and our final straw. I order dinner at 5:30 and has told it would be 45-60 minutes, ok. At 7 with no food, I had to call, I was told that it was out for delivery, ok. At 7:20 I call again this time I'm pretty upset the kids are wondering where the pizza is and so am I. At this point, I'm told the delivery driver has been out for delivery for 47 minutes! The food finally arrives at a little after 7:30 and looks like food that has been in a bag for over 45 minutes. I am literally writing this review for others to understand what kind of restaurant this is. A 14 inch pizza starts at 18$ and for those prices you would expect a much higher quality of food and service. Hate to say it but you'd be better of going with any of the chains than this place. They are both over priced and over rated. read more

Excellent pizza and great customer service.... sometimes it's a little slower than dominos, Pizza Hut, papa johns, but it's definitely worth the extra 10 minutes.... Highly recommended read more

Great pizza at a reasonable price. 14 inch pizza is $12.99 and each topping is $1.50. Then they have speciality pizza which are $16.99 for a 14 inch. read more

Fantastic choice! We had the Manhattan Calzone and Chef salad. So fresh and flavorful. Homemade Italian dressing was soooooo good! I highly recommend this place!!!! And they deliver read more