I enjoyed a lox everything bagel for brunch at Brooklyn Bagel, while my friends split a mushroom and egg bowl. My bagel had a nicely toasted exterior with a generous everything seasoning and plenty of cream cheese, capers, and lox. The bowl was a colorful, hearty combination of eggs, greens, avocado, and potatoes, with the crispy potatoes being an especially big hit with my friends. The slick, modern atmosphere inside flows naturally from the design of the surrounding Arsenal development, and the friendly staff had our order ready promptly. No complaints about this solid Lawrenceville brunch option. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Lox bagel - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I recently learned that the ownership changed, and I can really tell the difference of the quality of food. The bagels have seemed to have gotten better and the toppings taste more homemade. Plus, they switched to De Fer for coffee/espresso! read more

See all

One of the best pickup spots in town. Great for a true bagel. I usually get The Burgh (sub bacon for sausage) because it has a great hot and crispy hash brown. The coffee gets great reviews. The bowls provide a nice alternative for healthiness with the flavor still intact. I don't like that they allow dogs in because the space is too small. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Outside sign - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This was a terrible bagel. I had it a few years ago and didn't like it, and so it's been a while and wanted to give it another chance. It's reasonably priced and there are many options. However, the taste of the bagel is very average and the taste of the cream cheese is very bland. It doesn't taste fresh. They didn't even cut it down the middle! read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Holy terrible bagel. Went to try the place that's been on my list on a Sunday morning and got a hard disappoint for a 12 dollar bagel lox sandwich. The bagel was hard as rock and has dry bits that you now is caused by improper preparation or storage. Went to the clerk and asked about it and got a "all our bagels are made fresh on the day, it could be the bagels are overheated" answer. Really? How do you heat up bagels for a lox sandwich? This place either thinks their customers are stupid animals or they just straight up lie about their process quality. See the photos and tell me how is this even remotely a Brooklyn bagel. Where is the responsive structure inside? Where is the chewiness? I taste crunchy, stale, and hard grainy edges. I can't have another bite of the bread. It's hard as rock on the outside and plain cardboard inside. The bread failed so hard. Just no redemption from here. If the clerk has a showed a tiny bit interest in looking at their batch of bagel, I would have had a different thought. Sorry, this place is not for a real bagel fan. read more

See all

Stopped here for our first breakfast while in PGH. Located in Lawrenceville, this is on a Main Street in a retail building with several stores. We walked in and perused the menu. I ordered a Pittsburgher breakfast sandwich on egg bagel. It was very good - but the breakfast sausage on the sandwich - although thicc, was somewhat slimy. I hate that. I should have went with bacon. Coffee drink was solid, and the staff was attentive and friendly. read more

See all

Was super disappointed by my visit to Brooklyn Bagel recently. My brother was in town and was in the mood for bagels so I decided to check out a place that's been on my list for a while. Ordering was easy on a Saturday morning and the bagels were great! I think they used expired milk in my vanilla latte because I was mid drinking it when I started to swallow chunk of milk with my latte. I've shown pictures below but it was disgusting. I was shocked to visit during such a busy time and this was the latte I was given. I would avoid their coffee at all costs and it felt so bad in my stomach for the rest of the day. I'd like to give them benefit of the doubt but stay safe anyways and don't order coffee from here. read more

See all

Amazing staff! Great place. Really cute interior and whole vibe. Bagels were delicious. Had a nice chewey interior with a nice crust. I got the 'burgh sandwich no egg and everything melded so well. 10/10 would recommend. My favorite thing there was also the hammajack hot sauce. Even if you don't like spice, it has a great peppery taste that works perfectly with the bagel! read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - The 'Burgh' no egg and iced tea - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

One of my favorite breakfast sandwiches ever the chorizo and hash brown was the best thing ever together. It is a really nice place cool vibes and the employees are really cool. Next time I stop in I'm definitely going to try out the coffee! read more

See all

Brooklyn deli was a quick walk from where I was staying and they opened at 9 am which was earlier than most places for breakfast in the area of Lawrenceville. This place has a lot of charm and loved the vibe. I ordered their Pittsburgh bowl with delicious scrambled cheddar cheese eggs, at least three eggs maybe four and a hash brown cooked to perfection plus delicious sausage for around $10 which was a nice change of pace from other places near me. They have a good selection of coffee and tea too. I loved the ambience of this place. Staff helpful. Easy to find and convenient. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Scrambled cheddar eggs - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We walked over to Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal from our Airbnb and found the place absolutely buzzing with energy! There was a line practically out the door, which we took as a good sign, and despite the wait, the staff moved quickly and kept everything running smoothly. By the time our bagels were ready, we lucked out and snagged a spot inside to eat--which was definitely a good call since these bagels were loaded! I ordered the Torta Bagel Sandwich with egg, chorizo sausage, cheddar cheese, cilantro sauce, jalapeño, and lime, and it did not disappoint. The bagel was packed with bold flavors, and the hearty fillings made it super satisfying. The cilantro sauce and lime added a fresh, zesty twist that tied everything together. If you're in the area and craving a flavorful, hearty breakfast, Brooklyn Bagel is a must-visit. Just be ready to get there early and don't eat it in your car--these bagels are no joke! read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Torta Bagel Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Was super excited to order a breakfast bagel from Brooklyn Bagel this morning because last time I ate there the food was exceptional. When I got my food today my bagel was burned and everything inside my bagel tasted overcooked too. I was already home at this point and wasn't able to go back and ask for another bagel. I'll continue to support this business because the prices are fair and I've had good bagels here before but today was a miss for sure. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Cute coffee shop with yummy bagels! Avocado bagel super flavorful, bagel itself not the most fluffy but solid. Really friendly staff, nice place to study! read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I got a bacon, egg, cheese and jalapeño cream cheese. I'm so glad I did the cream cheese, even though it definitely made my sandwich messy. The bacon was good and not soggy. I do wish there was more seasoning on the everything bagel but it was good. The service was good. My food came out fast. I got mine to go but there were places to sit and enjoy your bagel. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

My food and coffee were delicious! Service was quick and it was very nice inside. Would go back again. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Nice environment with plenty of seating. Good service with friendly staff. Bagel was mid, kind of bland. Good prices though and free wifi

I'm always happy to go to Brooklyn Bagel. Even though it's a small shop, they bring big flavor with their fresh bagel sandwiches. They also have a nice selection of coffees. I'm happy I tried this place, I'm sure you will be too! read more

Grabbed a bagel for the first time today, even though I've driven by and been in lawrenceville a million times! I ordered the Torta bagel sandwich on a sesame bagel. This sandwich had a has brown, fried egg, cheese, cilantro sauce and chorizo. It was incredibly greasy (as most things with chorizo are) but it was so good! Loved the texture of everything together and thought the flavor was good! Personally, the chorizo could have been saltier and spicier but I thought it was well done! Nice place to sit and have a meeting or meet a friend for coffee. Even at 10am, there was plenty of searing. Friendly, quick service. read more

Ordering online was great! Our food was ready by the time we got to the register while we waited in a line out the door. Delicious!

Great location, sunny area. Excellent coffee and food. I enjoyed our experience here.

Super disappointed with this place. Spent $20 for a bagel sandwich, coffee & side potatoes. There were nothing to the side potatoes just a bunch of seasoning dumped in the container. Bagel tasted stale to the point where I couldn't even finish it. One of the worst bagel sandwiches i've had read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Great place to come for a bagel and coffee. Some of the best breakfast sandwiches in the city. The one with chorizo on it is fantastic. Surprised to see a 3.9 overall Yelp review. This place is much better than that. It gets busy on the weekends so expect a short wait but during the week, service is friendly and fast. Brooklyn Bagel has been a great addition to the neighborhood. read more

We were visiting Pittsburgh for college tours for a couple of days, and the food here was hands-down the best food we ate during this visit! We ordered the chorizo/egg bagel sandwich, one with sausage/egg/hashbrown, and the granola yogurt bowl. SO yum!! Lots of flavor. The yogurt was not super tart, and was super creamy. The granola was fabulous. Our vanilla lattes could have been hotter, but great anyway. We travel with our pup, so it was nice to have tables available outside. read more

Friends and I were in town for a quick visit and before we parted ways we were in despaate need of breakfast. After a little browsing on Yelp and delivery sites we decided to give the bagel sandwiches here a try. I believe we placed the order on door dash and roughly an hour later our order arrived, hot and ready to be devoured. I went with your classic egg and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel. Most of my friends ordered something very similar. I was very surprised to see how big my sandwich was and it was super tasty. It was a little bit dry but overall good. Next time I would probably add some cream cheese. Lastly, I know the order was messed up a little bit, but it wasn't a huge deal. I'm the only one that has dietary restrictions and mine was perfect, so it all worked out. I can see why folks like having this bagel shop in the neighborhood. read more

A very good bagel experience not easily found in Pittsburgh. All of the sandwiches I have tried seem to be made with great care in ingredient selection. This is something we can only find with an independent owner operator with a high level of culinary credential and commitment to a vision. The coffee is less talked about but deserves a mention because it really rounds out the experience and is as good as or better than most coffee shop offerings. read more

Generally speaking I really enjoyed my visit to Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal. They have a fun variety of breakfast sandwich options. I selected the Burgh and was impressed if not overwhelmed by the size and thickness of the sausage patty. It was as thick as a burger patty! I liked the combination of the egg, cheese, sausage patty, and hash brown and thought adding the hash brown to the sandwich was a fun touch. That being said, my everything bagel was mediocre at best. It was nowhere on par with a real NY bagel in terms of flavor and texture and just felt a bit disappointing. I loved my apple pie latte and thought it had great flavor and really felt comforting on a brisk morning. The staff was friendly and helpful and the space is cute with a decent amount of indoor and outdoor seating options, but could easily get full during busy times. This is a fun option to get some creative bagel sandwiches and tasty coffee, but don't let the name "Brooklyn" fool you. The bagels themselves just don't live up to the name. read more

The bagels are very good, coffee is good, but the staff was not very welcoming or kind. The person who took our orders seemed like they did not want to be there at all and did not look up from what she was working on or address us kindly. I understand it's exhausting to be nice to people all day at work and maybe she had something going on at home but that shouldn't impact your work. read more

I stopped by here earlier today with my wife and our twins for our morning coffee. Every Sunday morning we try to hit up a new local coffee shop and on this morning we decided to go to Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal. Since it's located on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, parking is at a premium, so it's nice that there is retail only parking behind the shop for customers. The inside of Brooklyn Bagel is nice with giant windows meaning that everything is bright. They have exposed brick walls with some crazy chandelier type lighting and then both indoor and outdoor seating. It wasn't too crowded whenever we got there but by the time we left about 15 minutes later the place was bumping. I should also note that our cashier here on this morning was super engaging and nice talking to both us and our twins. For our coffees on this morning I went with a latte while my wife went with one of their specials, a coco-moco (coconut and mocha) cold brew. Then we both also went with sandwiches and I chose the Burgh while my wife went with a cheddar bagel with chive cream cheese. The menu described my bagel as coming with egg, sausage and hash brown and then I chose pepper Jack cheese for it on a jalepeno bagel. I first had my sandwich which I really enjoyed. The bagel was flavorful and I really enjoyed the hashbrown on the sandwich. Why more places don't do it, I don't know. Then the sausage was flavorful and the egg was cooked well which made for a nice sandwich. My wife's bagel and cream cheese was good as well as the bagel had a nice chew and the cream cheese a good flavor. After I had finished with my bagel I was able to try my coffee. My first impression of it was that you could tell the coffee was fresh. After that first sip I thought that the espresso was more difficult to taste and that the milk was the main flavor. My wife did enjoy her cold brew though, especially loving the pairing of chocolate and coconut. The bottom line for me is that I would head back here again in the future. Our whole family felt welcomed at Brooklyn Bagel and we both loved our bagels and my wife loved her coffee too. read more

See all

Stopped in to get a hold dozen bagels and some smear to take home. Was able to park in front. Nice little store in a new building. The staff was super nice. The bagels were good and loved the homemade smear. read more

They aren't enough bagel spots in Pittsburgh. I drove 25 minutes to try this one, and it was worth every minute of the trip! I got a Burgh sandwich and it was well worth $9, which isn't how I always feel about pricy bagel sandwiches. The sausage was flavorful, and the hash brown had a great crunch without feeling oily. I loved the taste of getting it on an everything bagel, and my partner agreed the everything bagel was a better choice than the sesame he got it on. Service was quick and there was no line around 9am on a Saturday. read more

First time in Pittsburg. I came to drop off my son at CMU. I am so happy I found this place. The service was good and everything was made fresh.. This breakfast sandwich doesn't disappoint, it's everything you expect from a bagel sandwich. The breakfast cookie was a nice sweet surprise I really enjoyed eating it. Very savory and sweet satisfaction without the guilt. I like the atmosphere it's very casual. Try it! read more

See all

Nice little bagel shop in Lawrenceville They bring in par baked bagels from NYC Got myself a nice plain bagel toasted with a coffee the bagel was 2.99 plenty of seating to sit and enjoy friendly service they also have a fancy looking coffee machine my bagel was fine my coffee was fine metered street parking around these part can sometimes be hard to find but wait a few minutes I will be back read more

I definitely feel that Pittsburgh is in need of more (good) bagel spots so I was excited when Brooklyn Bagel opened! I've stopped a few times and gotten an everything bagel (my favorite) and really enjoyed it. Coffee is great too!! I also appreciate that it's one of the only spots in Lawrenceville that I can regularly get a close parking in the front of the shop. Staff is really friendly too! Check it out! read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Everything bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

So when they first opened it was great. Decent priced and service. However the price has slowly creeped up, but that's not my issue. I've ordered online multiple times with no issue. However, on Father's Day I mobile ordered, went to pick up. As I got to the counter, the person working couldn't have been more rude. They decided it was better to berate me in front of the customers for taking the order that had my name on it. They proceeded to make sure to make it a point to say these orders were for mobile customers. Surprise, I was a mobile customer! Just unnecessary and absurd behavior. There are a plenty of other breakfast spaces in my Lawrenceville neighborhood I'll frequent instead of Brooklyn again! Try to treat customers better. read more

I just tried a breakfast sandwich from Brookyln Bagels for the first time yesterday, and woah! It was perfect! I rarely eat a bagel, but for some reason I was just craving it! I knew I was going to have a busy day so I needed something heavier than my normal breakfast. My boyfriend went down to pick it up for us. He ordered a sausage, egg and cheese bagel, and he got me the lox bagel with veggie cream cheese on a multigrain bagel. They were out of everything bagels or that's what I would have tried. I love how fresh the actual bagel was. It was soft and spongy but crisp on the outside. It was comparable to a Bruegger's Bagel, but bigger and honestly more flavorful. We both really liked what we ordered. The veggie cream cheese has actual pieces of veggies in it. In addition to the smoked salmon on top, it has fresh dill, capers, and red onion. It was exactly what I was looking for! This bagel breakfast sandwich was definitely 5 stars. I am looking forward to stopping in the shop next time and trying their coffee too. This is another great business to have on Butler St. read more

See all

Nice place inside, but not the best bagels. They came with so much cream cheese it was almost impossible to eat. The everything bagel had had almost no seasoning on it, the little it did was burnt. The only good part was the jalapeño cream cheese. The fresh jalapeños gave it a great flavor. read more

Brooklyn Bagel At Arsenal - Everything bagel - not the best - Bagels Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Just really basic bagels. Same quality as you would get from a grocery store in my opinion. I had the everything bagel with plain cream cheese and a plain bagel with jalepeno cream cheese. The everything bagel had no flavor. I will say the jalepeno cream cheese was amazing!!! It had real jalepenos in it. So definitely give that a try if you come. I also had a cold brew coffee which was good but nothing special. They have different syrups which is nice. The inside was super quick, service was quick, and everyone there was very nice. read more

See all

I was trying Brooklyn Bagel for the first time so I ordered something simple - a sausage, egg & cheese on pumpernickel. I was not impressed by the quality of the bagel - it was dry! Additionally, the sausage was unreasonably thick. It was shaped more like a meatball than a patty - which was unpleasant and made for weird, unbalanced bites. Bagel spots are limited in Pittsburgh - I was hoping this would be better! read more

Quick and friendly service. Street parking if you can find it and don't mind a bit of a walk. The lean breakfast bowl has egg whites, tomatoes, and avocado. It could have used some seasoning and the avocado was not quite ripe. I would go back and try a bagel instead. read more

Excellent bagels Unfortunately, we got there close to closing time, so selection was limited. read more