Expensive pizza, but tasty. Ordered before closing and was grateful that they didn't seem annoyed. I ordered the White Gourmet. When I picked it up, the cashier showed me my pizza. I was like okay cool. Then I was like wait. Where's the chicken? So he had to ask his boss, and then I spotted teeny tiny cut up pieces. I do wish the chicken quality was better. It looked like a spam version of chicken. Brooklyn Joes is located in the Target shopping center. It has two entrances. One is accessible by parking at the "lower" parking area and walking a short distance across the parking lot. The easier more accessible entrance is where the parking spots are directly in front of the pizza parlor. The vibe inside is very pizza parlor'y. I did a carry out order, so didn't stay long enough to give you more details. read more

Wow I guess Jim B the owner would rather debate over USDA guidelines rather than what his customers are fcommenting on in past reviews. Learn from me and don't buy their pizza by the slice unless you want some thing that's been sitting out for a long time, sprinkled with a few shards of fresh cheese and then reheated. Went in for a few slices at 11:45 AM it was in from the pizza that waitress said was made at 9 am AM si already it was two hours plus old when I ordered it. I don't care what USDA guidelines say pizza sitting out too long it's not healthy or fresh enough to eat. I should have known better past few times I've eaten here I have gotten sick. Shame on me. And shame on Jim B For not being professional and educated enough not to debate or argue with customer comments on quality. Not sure if he's the original owner but this place consistently has gone downhill over the past few years and will continue to do so and probably go out of business if management is not smart enough to avoid negative reviews. Did I mention that playing Christmas music the day after Christmas is over it's stupid? read more

We have lived in the same house for 5yrs, Eaten Brooklyns Joes that entire time. 2 weeks ago we order and they delivered pizza to us . Tonight we were told that we are out of the delivery area! When we said that they had delivered to us for years the person taking the order claimed it has ever happened because the address was out of the area. Sorry lost your business moving forward. read more

I like their spaghetti with meat sauce, Linda pasta special, and pizza. I like ordering to go and picking up on my way home from work

Very disappointed. I did bow tie pasta with vodka sauce and salmon-NO FLAVOR AT ALL. It's like they forgot to add the salt. I think it all made it to the fries tho. They were SUPER SALTY. The pizza was good tho. Maybe that's their specialty and should focus on that. What a complete waste read more

Great food, great staff, great prices and great service. Hard to beat that! We're long-term customers that will keep going back.

This was one of my favorite places around, until today. Order a xl chezz, it was completely buried underneath to the point it was not possible to eat. Not sure what happened but never experienced this before, for the cost of 20$ I'm at a loss for words. read more

This Margarita Pizza with sausage was absolutely delicious! Their pie is legit so go try it. The service was amazing too. I went back the next night and they made a dish that wasn't even on the menu, Chicken Sorrento, which was great too. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Margarita Pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Do Not get the Penne alla Vodka Pasta! Sauce tasted off, a little bitter not good. My dish had huge pieces of garlic and chunky onion. Not crushed, not minced, instead huge slices. I found my first garlic piece by biting straight into it. Was pretty nasty. Then I dug out five more slices! Pretty much a whole clove or two in one dish. That's ridiculous!!! Service is nice but they forgot our daughters order. We just shared our food with her. She loves pasta but kept spitting out pieces of onion. For a $17.50 dinner plate I expected it to at least taste good. Very disappointed. I will not be returning. Pros: Portions are Large Cons: Pasta is not a specialty here, cleary. Get pizza or a calzone ( My husband's joecalzone tastef fine but almost too big ). read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

The food is always great & the employees are very friendly! I highly recommend eating here!

Great food! Keep coming back! We have been in several times, have tried many items and never disappointed!

I was recently diagnosed with Celiac Disease so it has been very hard to find places near to me that serve gluten free food, and I really want to stick to this diet so I can get better. In the past I have visited Brooklyn Joe's and have ordered their pizzas and they have always been tasting great. I got the gluten free cheese pizza today and it wasn't the best. The crust was very chewy and even after heating it up I had to knaw through the one piece I had and my jaws hurt afterwards actually. The topping was good but I wouldn't recommend getting the gluten free pizza here. As always though, no matter how busy they get their customer service has always been wonderful. That is the reason I gave a 3. I would have given a 5 if the pizza was edible though. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - A chewy gluten free cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

The pizza has declined/recipe changed in the last year or so. This was once one of the best pizzas in the area and we ordered nearly weekly for many years. Now the crust is DRY and HARD, not even burned, just near cardboard-like and seems like frozen. Their crust used to be very fresh, the dough raised high and pillowy at the edges where now the edge is flat and hard. The sauce has no flavor, almost like plain tomato sauce without seasonings. This has been the case consistently the last several times we've had their pizza over the last year. We'd so hoped things would return to how they used to be, but after trying multiple times it looks like this is how it is now. Sadly we won't be ordering any longer. read more

Brooklyn Joe's is situated just off Highway 9 in the Target shopping center. The ambiance is casual, and it is usually pretty busy. I recently ordered the Margarita pizza to go, and I was not at all impressed. The sauce was definitely a bottled or canned sauce and tasted like it. There were maybe 4 pieces of burnt basil that were meant to cover a large pizza, and the cheese quality was poor. The pizza crust was so thick that it tasted like paste. I usually love pizza crust, but not this time. Overall, I was disappointed in the quality of their food. Service was prompt. read more

Tried this place out for the first and likely last time. We ordered a chicken tender basket which I thought would be impossible to mess up but boy was I wrong. Barely any chicken, completely over cooked and all breading. Fiancé ordered the philly cheese steak and wasn't impressed. Also forgot our drinks and were still charged for them. Giving them two stars because the wings were semi decent and I didn't get food poisoning... yet. Hoping our order was a fluke but judging by other reviews it seems to be hit or miss. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Chicken Finger Basket - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Although we weren't able to eat here due to an emergency situation, everyone here was so helpful with my mother in law. She is doing fine. Will certainly take her back to enjoy dinner. read more

Consistently GOOD FOOD ! Every time my husband swings by this area- he picks up dinner for the family. We are never disappointed in anything !!! Consistently good food cooked and sauced perfectly, every time ! Portions are generous and fair for the price, quality control seems Top priority because, there is never anything to complaint about! Lol :) keep up the great job! Customers notice ! We do ! read more

We have been to this location now a few times and each time has been really good. Great service and very tasty. The lunch pasta portions are HUGE though. I feel wasteful sometimes if I can not take the leftovers with me if going errands in this heat. Other than that never a complaint. read more

The pizza is big and sooo good but the straws smell like pee when you go don't get a large pizza get xtra small it's like one meter big

Best NY pizza since I left, all the food is fresh and excellent Italian . Staff are good As well! But if it's crowded it's because it's good. Wait your turn and you will ENJOY ! read more

I was in for lunch about a week ago and they had on the menu meat raviolis! Nice gentleman said I could order also for dinner so tonight I ordered them for dinner they were outrageous. Big and round and stuffed with meat. Meat is usually very hard to find. read more

Love this place! The best pizza and chicken parm! Great location and service is always on point!

This is our local go-to pizza spot. We have dined in but mostly we get takeout. The staff is great, and they always show you your pizza to ensure accuracy and it's up to your liking before you pay for it. Love the pizza's, salads, kid meals, etc. A great family spot or just a good place to grab a beer and wait for your order. Brooklyn Joe's also delivers too, added bonus! read more

Great New York style pizza! It reminded me of the pizza I had while living in New York. The service was off which is why I took away one star. I walked in to purchase an 18" pizza (about $20 for half cheese and half pepperoni) and the person who was supposed to be running the front counter looked at me, didn't say a word and walked away. Another employee who was on their break had to come and take my order when they saw me waiting, I was on the verge of walking out before she came over. She was pleasant. I'd go back for the pizza though as it is one of the better places to get New York style pizza in the burbs. Good pizza, however service could be better. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Half Cheese + Half Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

After 40 years in NJ we moved down to Milton and went in search of pizza that made us think of home. Brooklyn Joe's is as close as you'll get to real NY style pizza in this area. Their strombolis and hot subs are great as well. This is our go-to pizza place. read more

I've only been here for lunch. They have a nice lunch menu with many options at a good price which includes a soda. Servers are generally friendly and good. They serve Coke Zero so that's a plus to me. The food is tasty. Wide variety of salad dressings. The side salad is larger and above average for most places. I can't think of anything negative to say so they get 5 stars from me! read more

Salads are great - they give you extra salad dressing without having to ask for it. The White Pizza is the best around. Just the right amount of garlic - perfection! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - The Best White Pizza in or Outside the Perimeter! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I'm glad my co-worker recommended this place because as many times as I've been in the shopping plaza where it's located, I seemed to have missed it. I had 2 extra cheese slices. The crust was thin and crispy, the amount of cheese was just right...and it was a lil greasy...exactly how I remember eating it in NJ. It also had the flavor that I grew up on. The service was excellent and therefore I added an extra star for that! I normally save my pizza eating for the weekend...but I can tell I'll be breaking that rule every now and then to come back for lunch or dinner, after work. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Extra cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

This place is as authentic Brooklyn sub, sandwich and pizza destination as being anywhere in Brooklyn. You really can't beat the prices, the fantastic service and the over the top portions and deliciousness of this food. This is my family's go to spot for a great meal and family outing. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Chicken Parm sub with fries. This and every other sandwich is ridiculously delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I drive by this location quite often and my go to pizza place is closed Monday's, so I tried their delivery this evening. I appreciate that the guy on the phone was very courteous and well spoken while also very clear that the delivery time was longer tonight. We ordered a large pineapple and ham pizza and an extra large extra cheese pizza. The pineapple and ham has a lot of flavor but it's a bit too much topping. The XL extra cheese is my favorite of the two and will def be ordered again. The crust is good. It's normally left behind and I didn't do that tonight! There is a delivery charge of 2.00 that was not mentioned over the phone. It's a small fee but I feel it's important to disclose. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - xl extra cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

I enjoyed this restaurant a lot. I come here often and am always satisfied. Noah is a great employee, very polite and well mannered .

A solid four stars for food quality and service. We've been going here for several years and never been disappointed with our meals. Friendly staff will great you and you choose your table. The menu has plenty of Italian meals and pizza to choose from. You can also create your own pasta dish with choices for type of pasta, sauce, and protein. This is a great place for family dining. read more

I was looking for a new pizza place near my near place, and I found Brooklyn Joes. Located in the Super Target shopping center on Alpharetta Highway and Webb Rd, it is easy to spot. I had passed by it many time, but never had the chance to dine there before. Fast forward to tonight. I ordered delivery, estimated delivery time 1 hour....real life delivery time, 31 minutes. I ordered just a cheese pizza, and it looked like the NYC style pizza that I know well, and love. I was happy with my first bite. The sauce is a bit tangy, not too sweet, which I like. The cheese tasted good and I liked the perfectly cooked thin crust. I did feel like their crust was maybe lacking a little something, but it did remind me of a lot of NYC pies I have indulged in. $17 for a large pizza and delivery, sold. Now that I live down the street I will definitely be ordering from here more often. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Extra large cheese - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I must say, this place has amazing wings. I got medium and they tasted amazing, in fact I wish I had gotten milk because they were quite hot. Service was also very nice and fast. I would go again any day. read more

Great little pizza spot in Milton. My wife and I have been frequently patronizing this establishment since shortly after they opened their doors. Everything from the wings and sandwiches to pasta and pizza, Brooklyn Joe's is the best pizza joint in the area. Friendly staff, great food and they deliver! FYI... the tiramisu is amazing!!! Check these guys out if you want the best. read more

Had the spaghetti with meat sauce. Good for casual dinning. The garlic knots are the best I ever had. Certainly is a good fix for craving of Italian. read more

I love Brooklyn Joe's and I can't believe there's any negative reviews. Everyone is nice, the place always looks clean, food is always hot and delicious. Cannolis are to die for. read more

I typically stay away from chains especially for pizza but this place rocks. If you like white pizza, they offer a great option. Also their Greek salad is very fresh and tasty. read more

This little hole in the wall never disappoints. I'm a semi frequent diner here as I can order a fabulous pizza to go. Their Tortellini Cardinale is amazing and enough for three meals for me. Their soups never disappoint. Their staff has to be one of the best. ALWAYS greeted when I walk in the door by at least one (sometimes two or more) employee with a GENUINE welcome. Never had an issue with my food or the service. Dependable always. Great employees. Friendly staff. Like they have an ownership. I sat outside one time and an employee was on his break at the next table and got up, came over and opened up the umbrella. Little things make the difference. A huge difference. Now they don't know me by name, but they appear grateful when I walk in the door. I am surprised that there's never a wait list for this place. It's really that good. For as many times as I have eaten there or ordered to go, I've never been disappointed in my food. Great restaurant in Milton near Target. read more

So, I'll start by saying if you want to appreciate pizza then you better make this a stop. The people there are super cool and they do not have a bad item on the menu. Eat At Joe's!!! read more