I Love NY Pizza

Committed to satisfaction

Family-owned & operated

Great service, good food and coffee and wonderful atmosphere. Thank you all for making me feel…read morecomfortable and making me feel I belong. It's like stepping into a little bistro in Italy.

Fresh baked focaccia, thin-cut manchego, peppery arugula, delicious sauces, a hint of guava paste,…read moreand that perfect tomato tanginess... this sandwich was an instant I'm-coming-back-for-this moment And the fact that it comes with a handful of chips instead of fries? Exactly how I like my sandwiches served This cute authentic café/store in Halcyon is serving some seriously flavorful paninis that make the perfect lunch spot. Pair them with one of their flavored sodas, grab a seat outdoors, and you've got yourself the sweetest little lunch date Already planning my next visit for the pastas and desserts because they looked too good to skip. If you haven't tried this hidden gem at Halcyon yet... you're definitely missing out

Carpaccio di Manzo

See all

Mocaccino

Casa Nuova Italian Restaurant

4.3(758 reviews)

4.8 mi

My wife and I have been to Casa Nuova a few times now, and every visit has been amazing. The first…read morewaiter we had was full of personality, very nice, and very Italiano. Everyone we've had since has been just as good. They're friendly, knowledgeable, attentive, and somehow able to memorize a huge list of specials. They really make us feel like part of the family. The Escargots Casa Nuova is our favorite appetizer. The garlic butter is delicious and perfect for dipping the bread in. I had never had anything like the Cannelloni Florentina before, but it was very tasty. It's a smaller dish, but it packs a punch! The Tortellini in Champagne Sauce was so good that I cleaned the plate. I also really like the decor. It has an Italian home feel, with paintings, flowers, wine, and knickknacks everywhere (and apparently a lot of local history). Casa Nuova is a little further of a drive for us, but it's one of the best Italian places I've found in the area. I'm looking forward to bringing more family here.

Three of us visited Casa Nuova on a Friday night--my wife, daughter, and me…read more I don't typically write glowing reviews, nor is this my first visit to a good Italian restaurant. But this experience was genuinely special. From the service to the food to the atmosphere, everything exceeded expectations. Despite a packed dining room, the staff delivered a level of attentiveness that felt effortless. Our server had an incredible command of the menu, rattling off a lengthy list of specials from memory with impressive detail. The entire team worked in sync--bringing bread, refilling drinks, offering fresh grated cheese, clearing plates without rushing us, and striking just the right balance of friendliness and professionalism. What really set the evening apart were the personal touches. The matriarch of the restaurant (or at least who I assume was the matriarch) circulated through the dining room making sure guests were enjoying themselves. At one point she proudly announced that the osso buco was ready--a charming moment that felt less like a sales pitch and more like someone sharing something they genuinely loved. Before we left, she gave my wife and daughter sunflowers from her garden, carefully prepared with the leaves removed and stems wrapped in foil. Then she sent us home with fresh zucchini. Along with everything else, these folks have figured out how to make dining personal. It felt less like eating in a restaurant and more like being welcomed into someone's lovely home--where there is genuine pride and gratitude that you've joined them for dinner. That's a rare feeling today, and Casa Nuova delivers it naturally. And then there's the food. The Oysters Rockefeller were outstanding. The fried mozzarella was exceptional. The Pesce Fra Diavola--with clams, mussels, calamari, and scallops--was perfectly prepared and served in a sauce that complemented rather than overwhelmed the seafood. The veal scallopini was tender, beautifully seasoned, and expertly sauced. Even our daughter's simple pasta dish was cooked and seasoned perfectly. Honestly, I'm almost afraid to go back because I don't know how they could possibly do better. Casa Nuova delivered one of the most memorable restaurant experiences I've had in a very long time. My sincere thanks to everyone at Casa Nuova for such a lovely evening. You made my wife, daughter, and me feel genuinely welcome, and we left with full stomachs, smiles on our faces, and an experience we'll remember for a long time.

Salad, chicken francese, lasagna, totrtellini in pink champagne sauce, and garlic bread

Zuppi di pesce & linguini in white wine sauce

See all

Gnocchi pesto and Silver Oak Cabernet

7 Acre BarnGrill

4.1(345 reviews)

0.1 mi

We've eaten here a few times and enjoyed this upscale yet casual style dining. It's a perfect…read morecountry style looking building with a menu to please everyone. Service is good. It's a small place so you might be waiting for a table if it's a busy time of day or holiday. The Buffalo Cauliflower starter was a delicious and has to be the healthiest version of Buffalo cauliflower. Nashville Hot sandwiches- well - the fries are amazing - perfect crisp but the hot is missing in the Nashville Hot and will go better with blue cheese dressing than mayonnaise. Several photos are from a previous visit I forgot to review - the menu has changes since some of the items we enjoyed. Great spot to enjoy a meal in the country side of Alpharetta / Cumming area.

New to area and first time customer. Nice little place, service ok for as many servers there were…read morefor a small place. We were there for an early dinner, not busy yet. Food, had the New York Strip blue plate special, we both did. Sauce, very good. Rest of meal just ok for me. Asparagus very skinny, lacked taste. Steak, ok. Left hungry. For the cost of the meal, I expect more than what was provided, nothing came with the dinner....no salad, no bread. Overall portion small.

Bar and tv

NC mountain trout

See all

7acre Barn Grill

Campania

4.2(728 reviews)

5.9 mi

Came here for a birthday lunch with my wife and 1 year-old. Didn't expect much, but was blown away…read moreat the quality of food and quality of service received on a random Thursday afternoon. The lunch special for $15 has to be the best deal money can buy. The Caesar salad with fresh shaved Parmesan was absolutely delicious. The pizzas are so authentic and flavorful. I am a tough critic when it comes to good Neapolitan pizza.... Campania arrivals some of the best I've ever had. Not only was the food, exceptional, but Liam delivered outstanding service. He was attentive, he was caring, and he made our visit pleasant and relaxing. I cannot say enough about how good his service was. You can tell when servers are just doing their job, versus when someone is truly passionate about serving guests. Liam is passionate, and it shows with his interactions. We will definitely be back soon, & I would recommend Campania to everyone.

We had a pretty good first time experience at Campania. The charcuterie board is top tier! It's a…read morebeautiful selection of meats and cheeses, and well worth the price! We also the Arugala and Prosciutto pizza with white sauce. The way they treat the arugula with lemon juice before applying it to the pizza really adds a whole new dimension if flavir and it's REALLY good! The location is tucked away in a strip mall, but don't let that steer you away, it's worth checking out!

Salumi E Formaggi Misti - Charcuterie Board

See all

Mondo Italian Kitchen

3.9(124 reviews)

4.7 mi

Service is terrible staff and owner act as if they are not interested in serving anyone. Waited 30…read moremin finally had to ask if someone could help us. Worst of all there was only one other couple in the restaurant who was also waiting, told us this was their second visit and has the same treatment on their first. Very strange. Food was mediocre nothing special. Will not return!

Love this place. Excellent food! The farfalle àl vodka and Wontons are the best!!…read moreMust try!!

Mondo Chicken

See all

Pies on Post

3.9(92 reviews)

6.9 mi

Nice little neighborhood spot on Drew Campground Rd. It's always busy which is a good sign. We went…read moreon a Monday night and they had Music Trivia Bingo. Lots of families were there. Service was pretty good, but the staff seemed a bit stretched thin. My sandwich, the Prosciutto Panuozzo, was HUGE and I ended up bringing half home and had it for lunch the next day. I got the chips as my side. The sandwich had a very generous amount of prosciutto which I really appreciated. We will definitely be back again soon!

$-$$ This wonderful place to eat in Cumming, Georgia had…read moregreat atmosphere, high ceilings, the beautiful smell of a wood burning pizza oven, two of my best friends in the world, good food, great conversation and an abundance of laughter! That is how I spent my very first visit To Pies on Post for Sunday brunch. Our server, Brandy, was great, and the food came out of the kitchen nice and hot. Brenda checked on us now and again, but was not a nuisance. I look forward to going back to this restaurant for lunch or dinner. The bar looked well stocked and the burger that came out for a different table looked delicious. Make great memories and safe travels

See all

Waiting on our pie!

Big Easy BBQ

4.3(88 reviews)

5.0 mi

Big Easy BBQ - Do Not Waste Your Money or Time Eating Here A…read morefew days ago, I watched a well-known BBQ show that offered a simple rule: if there's no smoke coming from a BBQ restaurant, keep driving. Today, I ignored that advice and regretted it. A friend and I decided to try Big Easy BBQ for lunch instead of visiting one of our usual favorites. After reading positive reviews, we drove more than 30 minutes to see what the hype was about. The first warning sign was the nearly empty dining room at lunchtime. The second was the complete lack of that unmistakable BBQ aroma. Despite both red flags, we stayed. My friend ordered the St. Louis ribs with sides, and I ordered the half chicken with two sides. When I noticed he had barely touched his ribs, he handed me a piece to try. The meat was tough, dry, and tasted as though it had been cooked well in advance and reheated. Unfortunately, my chicken was no better. It also seemed old and reheated rather than freshly prepared. For sides, I chose dirty rice and Cajun BBQ beans. Neither tasted particularly fresh. The dirty rice was acceptable at first but quickly lost its appeal, while the beans were merely average. Having lived in New Orleans for five years, I know what good Cajun and BBQ-inspired food should taste like. This wasn't it. The highlights of the meal were my iced tea and my friend's French fries. Service was equally disappointing. The server checked on us only in passing and showed little interest in our experience. When we requested takeout boxes for the food we barely ate, there was no inquiry about why our meals were largely untouched. We both took our leftovers home, though neither of us was enthusiastic about them. The lesson here is simple: online reviews should never outweigh what your eyes, nose, and instincts are telling you. A busy dining room, the smell of smoke, and trusted recommendations are often better indicators than a collection of glowing ratings. As a final note, my friend and I normally pay separately, but I felt responsible for suggesting this restaurant and paid for both meals. If paying for two disappointing lunches taught me anything, it's this: save your time and money, and eat somewhere else.

First time in Georgia decided to stop at this cute restaurant. We were BLOWN AWAY - the service was…read moreamazing, thank you Michelle!!! Fried alligator was tender and juicy, brisket was phenomenal. I would 100% make the 3hr drive back down just for the food!

Open clean seating, they also have outside seating.

Shrimp and Chicken Gumbo

See all

Business logo.

Union Hill Grill

4.2(214 reviews)

3.3 mi

We were regulars at UHG for many years and then after several ownership changes we stopped going…read more I am so glad we decided to try again this last week with a group of friends which were trying for the first time. Ian has brought what we missed so much about this special neighborhood spot back. He stopped by our table to introduce himself and were impressed with his commitment to use as many local sources in creating his menu options. We loved to hear that the desserts and pasta were all made in house. Service was great, food was awesome. The menu has changed a bit, and in all in the right places. Madeline was our server and she did a great job offering suggestions. Everyone was happy with their meal and if you go and it is on the menu, highly recommend the farmers cheesecake. Outstanding!

We had a Friday night reservation at 5:30 and were promptly seated upon arrival. There is a variety…read moreof seating including booths, table, half-booths, bar, and communal table near the bar. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. Her visits were spaced out a bit longer due to it being an extremely busy night. And we never waited long for a drink refill. Our food came out quicker than I expected. We started with the giant pretzel, and next time I will order double cheese sauce. It also came with whole grain mustard and cinnamon sugar sauce (the latter was surprisingly good paring). For entrees my wife had the vegetable plate which differed from the menu description (no sweet potato or whipped feta), but she enjoyed it. And I shared all the vegetables that came with my entree, which was the braised short rib. It was fork tender and served atop rich and creamy risotto. The green beans on the side were cooked perfectly and lightly seasoned. I also added a side of the mushrooms and onions (with predominant item being mushrooms), and it was a generous portion. We enjoyed all the flavors in our meals and appreciated the quality ingredients.

Entrance

Redfish

See all

Dinner menu

B & B Tavern Free Home

4.3(80 reviews)

5.4 mi

Another yummy lunch at B&B Tavern. They Monday special - Burger of the Week is a good deal at $12…read morefor a burger and fries. It's hard to beat that deal! Service was great - love the casual atmosphere.

First visit since they have changed hands and renamed the restaurant. Came here for dinner,…read morerestaurant was very dimly lit; it was a stormy night and too dark inside - I had to use my phone's flashlight in order to read the menu. Chairs seats were worn and uncomfortably hard. Had the meatloaf dinner and upgraded to a side of brussels sprouts. The meatloaf and mashed potatoes were very good, but the brussels sprouts were not as they were overcooked and flavorless. They have a handful of craft drafts along with a full bar. Service was excellent.

Butter Toffee Cake

See all

New name/ new sign!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rodney W.

0

1

0

7 years ago

"DO NOT ORDER FOOD " from this place. The staff is very nasty and unprofessional, and knows nothing about customer service. You tell them something, and they do the complete opposite. If they get a order wrong, staff gets mad at you because, you want the order corrected. If you get on there bad side , they will spit in your food, talk nasty to you, as if you're bothering them. They come to work with a chip on their shoulder, and should not be working around food .Staff that work here are scum bags and have no people skills. Need to take a lesson on what customer service is all about. You order a salad, or anything, Common Sense would tell you to put utensils in the bag, to have something to eat your food with, these idiots forget them each time i order from them. Terrible ! Terrible! Word of advice Stay Away From This Place!!! Nasty attitudes , followed by Nasty Food, and you're food getting spat on. These people should be reported to the board of health! They have the absolute wrong people in position dealing with food and the public. The owner bought these trashy people from New York, Whom dumb and oblivious on how to deal with the public. Has no telephone Etiquette at all. Terrible stay away read more

James R.

0

3

0

10 years ago

I have tried many others, but I Love NY Pizza is the best! I love the authenticity of the this place with pizza by the slice. If you like old school pizzerias then this is your spot. it is by no means a "fine dinner". However, that is the charm. You don't wear a tuxedo to a pizza joint. My personal favorites are the NY White and the Pepperoni. Also, their garlic rolls don't just have the smell of heaven... they taste like it too. If Pizza isn't your thing then they also have pasta dishes, Strombolis or Calzones as well. Plus the ownership is courteous, and really places the effort on food quality - rather than ambiance - which as a foodie - isn't that were the emphasis should be? If they had 6 stars they would get my vote. read more

Andrew A.

0

4

0

12 years ago

I'm a total NY pizza snob and I love this place.The crust is tops, yet it's distinctly a "N.Y." pizza. When folks visit from out of town, this is where I take them for good pizza. Love this neighborhood pizza place. Small with great food and staff. Just wished they delivered to my house. read more

Al F.

0

45

0

6 years ago

This place has average pizza and the worst customer service of any restaurant. My opinion from a person that's been in the restaurant business for over 30 years these people don't know how to run a restaurant. Stay away! read more

Snake P.

0

3

0

11 years ago

This place is awesome. Slices here are where it's at - thin NY style. On par with some of the better slices downtown. Alpharetta is lucky to have a pizza shop like this. read more

carin b.

7

167

0

12 years ago

We love the pizza, fresh salads, everything is fresh and delicious!!!!! And they're close by!!! A great local find and great pizza, even by the slice :) thanks!!!! :) read more

Yavuz G.

0

4

9

8 years ago

Mamma Mia! Yummy pizza. Hands down Best pizza in Georgia. Try grilled chicken salad and calzones too

Xing L.

2

5

26

3 years ago

Burnt food Don't waste money I'll throw the rest in the trash box!!!!!! Will not go again

Zoo M.

1

5

0

15 years ago

A good ny style pizza as good as you can get in alpharetta, gyros are pretty good as well.

JJ P.

14

109

41

1 year ago

My school ordered food from here They were amazing. I will be coming here to eat pizza read more

Elizabeth S.

39

27

3

16 years ago

Pretty good Stromboli. My boyfriend loves, loves, loves their sausage pizza.

J M.

78

35

1

8 years ago

Hands down one of the best pizza's we have eaten. Perfect every time!

Daniel L.

0

9

0

9 years ago

Really good pizza and the garlic knots are awesome!

Sue N.

6

18

59

16 years ago

Fantastic Italian food. Pizza, pasta and entrees.

Ngta C.

0

2

9 years ago

Excellent food and service. Thank you so much.

I Love NY Pizza - italian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed I Love NY Pizza also viewed

Vintage Pizzeria

3.8

(121 reviews)

I have gone three times to Vintage Pizzeria, recommended to me by a friend and the food has been…read moreamazing every time. Such yummy Italian food, great options for kids, and adults. The it can be a little pricey, but the quality of food and the size of the portion are definitely worth it. However the first time I went it was a bit busy and the service was pretty bad, we got our food at a reasonable time, but the waiter was a little rushed and antsy. Overall, very good!

My boyfriend and I always see a crowd when we drive past Vintage Pizza, so we decided to try it…read moreout. It was mediocre at best and the service was not great. They are pet friendly on the patio and I had my boyfriend waiting outside with the dogs while I waited at the hostess station. The hostess was on the phone modifying a take out order and it took over 10 minutes for me to even be greeted. From what I remember in my hostess experience, you always serve the customers in person first - turns out this to go order was calling to get double sauce on their pizza and the hostess ran to the kitchen twice while I was waiting. Eventually, someone else greeted me and took me to a table outside. Our server was prompt, but actually kind of rude, and we were not impressed. I ordered a white pizza and it grilled chicken and my boyfriend got the meat lovers pizza. The price was standard for 2 pizzas and alcoholic beverages, but we much prefer other places in the plaza.

Brooklyn Joe's

3.7

(201 reviews)

Great service. Delicious food for even the pickiest people. Could hear each other's voice.read more

A hidden gem! WOW I've missed food like this. Full of…read moreflavor and it's served hot and fresh! Staff is polite, friendly and helpful. Clean and wholesome restaurant. I tried a few random picks from the menu and it was all excellent. I was looking forward to eating there again, before even finishing my meal! Definitely a must, if you're looking around, give this place a try, it's yummy!

Vincenza's Pizzeria

(209 reviews)

•$

This is the best pizza ever! Excited to go back again soon! We had a cheese pizza and a sub. Both…read morewere amazing!

Good news the food was good not great. The bad news, this is a take out only restaurant. They do…read morenot understand the concept of dining in. There were three of us and they served each of our entrees about 10-15 minutes apart. So by time, I got my food, my son and husband had already finished. They had a big party of 8 walk out because they wanted to order and eat there but couldn't accommodate them with all the take out customers waiting at the tables and using up chairs

Alessio's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.8

(182 reviews)

Had a family dinner here tonight. I ordered the Veal Marsala. The entree came with a generous…read moreportion of veal that had a rich sauce that included mushrooms. It was accompanied with pasta and two garlic knots. This was a great value for under $20. Others in my group ordered a large New Yorker pizza which they said was fantastic. The ambiance was nice and included pictures of New York. It had an open concept where you could see the kitchen. They also had a nice patio area for dining when it's not so humid out. The service was really friendly and quick. She checked in TJ see how everyone's food was. This is a great restaurant that provides nice sized portions at a reasonable price.

Our family has been coming here for years! I never lived in GA, however when im in town, a few…read moretimes a year, I always make it a point to pop in. The staff remembers me each time. Its such a nice family environment. Ive been coming here for upwards of 15years. Many dishes later and a few kids in and we are still enjoying this place. The lemon chicken with capers has been my favorite but you cant go wrong here. My god children love the garlic knots and pizza. Perfect place with something for everyone.

Pizzeria Lucca

3.9

(396 reviews)

I visited Pizzeria Lucca near historic downtown Roswell after touring Bulloch Hall around Christmas…read moretime. The dining room is relatively small with large, long tables. You place your order at the counter, and they bring the pizza to your table. They make Neapolitan pies from three wood-fired ovens imported straight from Naples -- with dough and sauce made fresh, in-house, every single day. I waited 10 to 15 minutes for them to bring my pizza. The pizza tasted hot, fresh and flavorful. Based upon the taste and quality of the pizza, I would definitely consider returning. One thing to note about parking. They do have a small private parking lot, but be certain you are visiting the restaurant when parking there. There are "towing enforced" signs. So, if you're in the downtown Roswell area, definitely try Pizzeria Lucca. Cheers

Pizza Lucca has become one of our favorite pizza spots in Roswell. My kids and I love coming…read morehere--the pizza is consistently excellent, and you can really taste the quality of the ingredients. They use Italian double-zero flour, high-quality ingredients, and an authentic Italian oven that turns out that perfect thin, slightly charred crust you want from true Neapolitan-style pizza. Everything tastes fresh, simple, and done the right way. Another big plus is the atmosphere. There's usually plenty of room inside, so it's an easy place to bring the family, and the front porch is a great spot to sit outside, enjoy a beverage, and have a relaxed meal. For me, Pizza Lucca rivals Antico when it comes to authentic Italian pizza--and having something this good right here in Roswell makes it even better. Highly recommend.

Minnie Olivia Pizzeria

(181 reviews)

Food was all great! Our waiter was especially helpful & friendly. No one was eating inside at…read moredinnertime, everyone was outside. It looked like a nice vibe but my party chose to sit in to avoid the noise. I stupidly ordered a white pizza not knowing it was a white pizza- I don't like white pizza- no problem, just asked for some side red sauce to put on top and it was great that way. My friend had never had butternut squash soup and she gave me a look like I changed her life when she tried mine lol. Yeah, it was basically that good!

Hidden gem in downtown Alpharetta. It's a cozy little joint with some of the best pizza in town…read more Top 3 in Alpharetta. Service is excellent too. Street parking is limited but there is a parking deck just down the street.

Ippolito's Italian Restaurant

3.1

(93 reviews)

This is our go to for catering an annual event - the food is amazing!…read moreOur favorite is the Chicken parmesan. This meal is a great way to end a busy day. Thank you to Brooke and Dan!

Buyer beware! Or delivery order beware! We placed an order for chicken Parmesan and rolls and a…read moresalad through DoorDash. What we got was not chicken Parmesan. When I called, they said because we went through DoorDash they couldn't do anything about it, and DoorDash said all they did was pick up the order. And the order had our name on it. So catch 22. Just know before you go and order.

Carlisle's Pizza Tavern

3.8

(125 reviews)

one of if not my favorite pizza spot in atl as a nj native! comfortable atmosphere, friendly…read moreservice, cold beers and you have to try the spinach and artichoke dip!

I've had Carlisle's saved on my bookmarks for a while and finally decided to give it a go a few…read moreweeks ago for date night. Hubby and I are early birds, so no surprise that we were the only ones there upon arrival around 4ish. We sat down and started to look over the menu. There was only one guy working and whether intentionally or not, he definitely gave off a vibe that felt like he was annoyed we had come in, which wasn't a great first impression. He never gave us napkins or utensils, so hubby got up and got some for us after the garlic bread we ordered as a starter arrived. The garlic bread was literally just toast with some garlic spread slathered on. It wasn't great, and we would not order it again. Aside from that, I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza and hubby got his weird Hawaiian concoction that I will never understand the appeal of. My pepperoni pizza was amazing. Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and pepperoni distribution were spot on, and the best part is that the bottom was perfectly crispy but not burned. Hubby's was good too, though he is less appreciative of the crisp factor than I am, though to be fair, he is not really much of a pizza fan to begin with and was just humoring my date night pick. After our pizza was brought to the table, other employees had started to arrive. Salty dude disappeared and a much nicer lady took over for him by bringing us drink refills and later closing out our tab. We will not be returning for date night, but the pizza was definitely good enough for a repeat visit. I will most likely just order as carryout during lunchtime instead, though. I wasn't really a fan of the vibe for dining in, particularly due to the salty guy who we seemed to annoy at the beginning, but I think the pizza was definitely worth coming back for.

I Love NY Pizza

(40 reviews)

After being a regular at another pizza restaurant for years, we now have switched this restaurant…read more The pizza here is always cooked perfectly. The crust is just the right level of crispness and the bottom of the pizza is never "doughy". The sauce is not too sweet and the amount of cheese is just right. I judge this place in the perspective of being raised in New York City. There aren't many places in the area that make a pizza that reminds me of home and tastes this good. Another home run here are the cannoli. YUM!! They are made when you order them. You can tell this by the crunchy shells and delicious filling. Many places the shells are soft and soggy because they are filled hours before which leads to a yucky cannoli. NOT here! These are Great. Give this location a try. As there are several with the same name, be sure to check the addresses

This was terrible food - will never order from them again. Pizza was terrible and the chicken…read moreMarsala was awful - so bad. Not sure who cooked this (summer interns?) but this was not good.

Annunziata's Pizza & Pasta