Did not feel welcome, at all. I had just spent a miserable hour at AT&T, correcting a problem they created. When I finally walked out, I decided that a cold beer or two might cheer me up. Lo and behold, there's a Brooklyn Joe's a few doors down. I figured, let's go to a local pizza joint...maybe I will leave in a slightly better mood than I entered with. Maybe they'll actually cheer me up with drink and good service. Wrong. I walked in, deflated and frustrated after my ordeal, but still mustered a smile to the staff at the register. I sat at the bar and was greeted with no zeal by the high school server (though, I don't expect great service from teenagers). I requested a beer and asked the gal (clearly a manager of sorts) what the two pizzas on the right of a display were. She answered matter of factly, with no follow up. Mind you, the veggie pizza was hanging off the metal serving plate and touching the display glass under it (eww). The look on her face communicated no friendliness or presence. I watched the high schoolers banter. I sat unengaged. I should have resorted to ear buds--like the cook--to tune out my environment. I ordered a slice of Sicilian because of the price. You get what you pay for. Finished my first beer and slid it to the edge of the counter. The manager overlooked the gesture to perform accounting, and the two high schoolers were oblivious. Finally, I was distractedly served another beer. Meanwhile, I watched a young gal innocently inform the manager lady of something (I couldn't hear), and the older of the two rebuffed the information. It seems neither customers nor employees deserve much attention from her. I ate my slice in great solitude and much hot sauce. I finished my second beer, requested the check, and eventually received a receipt. I paid, tipping exactly 20% (which was 20% more than necessary). I give this venue two stars. I left even more unhappy than I came...but they're no AT&T! Could have been worse. They had an opportunity to convert a loyal customer. Instead, I felt worthless to them. Will not return, ever. read more

The crust was thin, The heel was crispy! The slice was LOADED! OMG, delicious!! Will definitely go back!!! Got two slices of The New Yorker and could only eat one! The Yuengling on tap was nice and cold! Thanks Easter Bunny! read more

"Like a lemon to a lime A lime to a lemon I sip the def ale with all the fly women... No sleep till Brooklyn!" Beastie Boys While I can't say they carry the def ale, Brooklyn Joes is a good option for pizza, pasta and other types of beer. I wasn't the biggest fan on my first couple of visits, but being close to my crib, I gave Brooklyn Joes enough chances that it grew on me. The pizza is good, not one to drive across town for, but a good pizza. The entrees are consistently good. My kids love the fries here. The large salad can feed four. While missing the def ale, they do have a good rotating draft beer selection at reasonable prices. Service is usually friendly and fast. Brooklyn Joes is a-ok, and because I frequent it, I'd have to say I'm a fan, and bump up to four stars. read more

You what to expect. It's solid and predictable. Maybe they could cook meals a little longer, more thoroughly. The pizza is good but on the greasy side. We've eaten in and had pick up several times. It's always consistently good and fresh. This is diner-level quality: not bad but not exceptional, either. We'll definitely repeat order. read more

The family wanted pizza and we hadn't been to Brooklyn Joe's in a few months. We won't EVER be going back. Tie for the best part of the meal between the service and the fountain drinks. The food was AWFUL. We're gluten free. The pizza crust was burnt. The toppings were minimal at best. At least 2" of bare crust all around. If it wasn't for the salad, the meal would have been a total loss. read more

Sooo good and authentic. If you like authentic N.Y.C Italian cuisine, You must try. Good service and family quick to table orders. Ask for Jenn, she's awesome. read more

No skimping on the toppings here. It's quick, clean, reasonable, friendly, the food is good, and close to home. What more can I ask for? read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I ordered delivery and the gentleman who took my order was really kind and helpful. I wish I had went with all the reviews and ordered a pizza (it is just me, and they don't offer personal pan sized pizzas). Instead I ordered the chicken and shrimp penne pasta and it was meh. No real flavor and pretty oily. The shrimp was flavored and cooked well so I ended up eating just that. I had also ordered garlic knots but if I had got those in person, i would have sent them back. They were greasy and tasted like they had been out sitting for quite some time. I also ordered the cannoli, with fingers crossed I bit in, the cream was perfect, so I took another bite and the cream was gone. The middle was left completely empty (like void I was now feeling from ordering from here). If I was to ever try this place again I would definitely go for pizza since that's what is recommended all over their site. Personally, I would not choose this place again next time I am in Georgia. read more

The food is great here as it is in canton, ga's brooklyn joe. for service, and generally just being Nice...go to Canton, avoid this location. Next door also has some negative info as well with the staff, but worth the drive all the way to Canton. We live in Roswell, and during the pandemic, you would think they would try harder. This Restaurant is King and the people are peasants... good luck. read more

This was our second visit. Not sure we'll go back. While food was good service was horrible. Several people at several tables had meals that were totally forgotten about and it left people sitting there with nothing to eat while others in party had dinner. Cooks were more concerned with take out orders than in house diners. Need to get act together. read more

First experience, bad experience. The little gal who was taking to-go orders was not customer service friendly . I had asked for my debit card back after she gave me my receipt to sign and she was walking away from the register , and she looked at me as if I was speaking a foregin language , kept walking to get my drank came back and was very adamant that she gave my card back only to find she left it on the counter no where near where I was standing . And says " Oh **hee hee*" here it is " no apology at all. Ordered the Pesto Crustines - not recommend however it was excatly what the menu described. Not a fan.. Meatball Sandwich, very good , side of pasta ?? Mushy, drowning in balsamic dressing . Pizza? Pretty good . But customer service... Well enough said. read more

I'm from Baltimore, Md. where we have a Little Italy. I've had pizza pie all over NY and NJ. The best pizza in Georgia is down on the coast on St. Simons Island. There is a little Italian place called Sal's Neighborhood Pizzeria and Sal's place has excellent pizza pie. Brooklyn Joes reminded me of Sal's and it is the best around Alpharetta for sure. read more

Really good pizza, nice causal atmosphere. The prices are very reasonable too. Reminds me of places up north.

Excellent pizza. Closest to real Brooklyn pizza. The sauce is perfect. Always good service. Can't speak to anything other than their pizza but it's become our go to pizza place. read more

I have ordered for Brooklyn Joe's 3 time and it's always delicious! I'm never disappointed! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pepperoni pizza w/ extra cheese and pepperoni . I love this place - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Stayed open during the entire COVID-19 outbreak and the employees are always nice. Great pizza though they should make the crust a tab bit thinner. Excellent tomato basil soup and the baked ziti is the best in the state. All around great menu and great experience every time. So many other businesses were scared off by the virus and now we are all suffering the economic consequences and food shortage consequences. Other restaurants could learn a lot from Brooklyn Joe's. read more

Kids love the pizza and they are pizza snobs. Staff is friendly. Have only gotten pickup but always timely and fresh.

I went in looking forward to a good sausage and peppers sandwich, what I got was burnt sausage and cold sauce and peppers.

I have been working here since four months..... I must say it is an excellent restaurant to visit....... I eat here everyday......Calzones and Stromboli's are awesome..... Also try the Manhattan meat Pizza.......Its delicious...... read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Unfortunately, we got our meals/entrees and no garlic knots? Tortellini Cardinal, Spaghetti with meatballs and Ravioli not a garlic knot with them. Everything else was excellent. read more

I am a transplant from the North East (New York/Philadelphia) and can say it was a struggle to find New York style pizza that was just acceptable. Brooklyn Joe's filled the void for me read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

We just moved to this side of town and were worried we wouldn't be able to find as good of a place as our old one. Thank goodness we were wrong and came across Brooklyn Joe's. We ordered to go and it was ready right on time. The staff was very friendly and most important the pizza was phenomenal! We will definitely be back, and next time dine in. Great find!!!!! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

Let me begin by saying that the 2 stars I've given Brooklyn Joes is not because the food is not good. I truly enjoy the quality of the food I had there. The rating is because of their lack of commitment to keep a paying customer happy. I have been to this restaurant 4 times and on three of those occasions requested to sit outside and was informed that I could not because they were not doing outside seating. Now this restaurant is not large and I saw three servers standing behind the bar and one standing by the door. Not serving...just standing. So what in the world could be the reason they are not allowing outside seating I asked myself....as I called and asked to speak to the manager. And the reason I was given (paraphrasing) was we do not alllow outside seating on Friday and Saturday nights because we are a small restaurant and we use the outside seating for overflow when people are waiting to be seated. But you are more than welcome to order your food to go and sit outside at the tables to eat it. WTF!?!? First of all...there was no one waiting to be seated......inside or out. Second of all...if I get there before all the hypothetical abundance of customers arrive and I'm outside eating because that's where I want to sit then they have to find somewhere else to wait. First come first serve...no? The lame justification came across to me as nothing more than its easier for us to not have to service outside tables. And let me state I could accept this if they were packed and servers were not standing around. So off to Rays pizza around the corner we went where we sat outside and enjoyed our pizza and the cool evening breeze. Brooklyn Joes I realize that I'm just one customer but I am one customer who will never return and spend my money there. read more

Used to be my favorite. Took help 15 minutes to acknowledge me and then food arrived without plate. WTF? The picture says it all and the lack of management response proves it read more

Brooklyn Joe's - If you have time to lean.... - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

This is our favorite pizza place when we want a real New York pizza. Smells amazing when you enter and tempts us always to get more than just pizza! They have a whole wheat crust which we always say we are going to try next time but we are afraid to mess with what we know we love. In fact we usually forgo any toppings when we eat here as it's delicious as is. read more

I went there this weekend with my girlfriend. What a giant mistake. The location and layout of the restaurant is decent. I ordered the lunch special, which was a house salad, pizza with 1 topping (I picked chicken) and a fountain drink. She ordered a calzone. The house salad was at best, mediocre. I found multiple pieces of old iceberg lettuce in it, turning a dark brown. The chicken was dry and rubbery. It tasted like high quality dog food. The cheese was terrible, especially since it was soaked in grease. She said she thought the calzone was good, but she agreed my pizza was terrible, and when a pizza joint can't do pizza right, you know you've got a problem. Terrible food not withstanding, our waitress was a total ditz. First and foremost, it took about 30 minutes for them to make a calzone and 1 slice of pizza. People who came in after us had their food before us. I saw the "chef" sprinkling the chicken on my pizza WITH HIS BARE HANDS. I should have walked out right there, but I suppose I'm a glutton for punishment. the waitress asked if we wanted refills for our empty drinks. No, I'll be happy with just the ice, thanks. She then went to fold silverware with her back turned from every customer in the restaurant, which basically meant I had to sit there waiting for her to finish since I couldn't waive to get her attention. So after waiting too long to get mediocre food served by a disgusting chef who puts his dirty hands in it, she gives us the bill and charges us extra for the drink that should have been included in the lunch special. On top of that, my girlfriends calzone was customized, so they charged her $11 for just that. The total bill was $23, but if it was correct should have been $21 plus tip. Assuming a $4 tip, that's $25 for absolute crap food with crap service. No thanks. Since she slid the card before we saw the bill, it wasn't worth fighting, so we just circled the wrong price, wrote "WRONG" next to it, and left her no tip. I've never not a left a tip, but there is a first time for everything. If you really want good pizza and good service, go to Mellow Mushroom (there are much better pizza places out there, but MM is everywhere). This place sucks, and if this is indicative of what this shopping center will be like, I hope it stays empty. read more

Best darn pizza around the area in GA. You can get slices quickly. They have a nice balance of dough, cheese and sauce - I've found most GA pizza to be all cheese and hardly any sauce, what's up with that??!! Please do yourself a favor and check this place out if you're nearby or driving through. I'm sure happy I did! Very delicious pizza. The crust has a nice crisp to it too. read more

Ever since our Beloved Eastside closed, we stumbled upon Brooklyn Joes and have been very satisfied. I absolutely love their spinach salad, with the warm bacon dressing. I usually get the calzones, which again are delicious. Or we will get a big pie and pass it around. I wasnt super impressed by the slices we got ala carte... but ive only had them once, and it didnt turn me off to where i wouldn't order them again. but i like the idea of a fresh pie being made with all the fixins ;) usually have good service, there have a been a hiccup or two along the way.. but that will be the case anywhere you go. The manager always comes out and says hey, offers to clear plates or get refills. All in all Im a fan!! ( and now hungry for pizza) read more

Very good pizza place! Has everything you'd expect: pies, subs, salads, pasta. Not sure about dinner, but at lunch they sell by the slice. They also have a good selection of specials. 2 slices and a drink for less than $8?! Not bad. Service here is always stellar. They have a great staff who is attentive and helpful. Pizza is greasy...a little too much...but nothing a few napkins can't handle...and certainly not a reason to avoid this place. Highly recommended! read more

I'm a former Ny er and we take our Pizza seriously. This places Pies are fantastic. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and the sauce actually has flavor. The crust is as close as you can get it outside of NY too. I highly recommend if your in the area. read more

Pizza is good, service on the other hand not so good. They always mess up our order, cooks not wearing masks and seem quite unhelpful with any request made. Be sure to check your pizza before you leave! read more

Fantastic food! I had the pasta Lilly, my guest had the manicotti. Both dishes were FRESH! Veggies were crisp, not soggy as if they'd been sitting in sauce. Manicotti was freshly made!!!! Flavors were fabulous! !!! I'll try the pizza next time! Great food, fantastic service, responsible pruces!!! read more

I read the other reviews and I am so sorry you guys have had such a sucky experience. Even if a patron's opinion of an establishment's food is negative, with great service, it really helps the food to go down! ON TO MY REVIEW: We had it delivered, so can't comment on the wait staff, but the delivery guy was great, very polite, and all smiles. The order was placed via phone at 8 pm on Friday night (3/13) and Chris, who answered the phone, did all the right things ... he was attentive, even though I could hear the phone ringing in the background he didn't say "hold on for a minute", every question I asked he answered or immediately found out the answer. Delivery time was stated between 45 minutes to an hour, the hot food was delivered within 30 minutes!! Ok, here is the food critique: 1 small House Salad w/ extra gorgonzola and feta cheeses 1 small Greek Salad w/ extra feta cheese and dressing - WOW, Hubby's first comment was is this the small salad? Yep! We both finished our salads with absolutely nothing left but our fork!! 1 Chicken Salad Wrap 1 Mama's Lasagna - Both tasted awesome and were very delectable. I loved them. The lasagna and sauce were great, cheesy, mm-mm very very good. The chicken salad wrap was just as good too. Shredded chicken and seasonings tasted well, as did the wrap itself. Servings just as the salads were big portions, we both had ample for lunch the next day as the small salads were filling. Oh, and the lasagna came with a bread stick coated with garlic and butter that I loved, as I am such a bread girl. 4 stars up to this point but I had to give it 5 stars, rating an establishment isn't always about the taste of the food, it also includes the service, ambiance, portion size, price, and efficiency. On a Friday the 13th, 8 pm, raining, two hours into being hungry, to have some great food delivered within 30 mins, $30.00 for two people - WOW. 5 STARS BABY!!!!!! read more

We ordered two large pizzas and two Caesar salads to go last week. Everything was absolutely delicious, and we aren't easy to please-We are very picky foodies! The sauce on the pizza had a fantastic flavor, which is hard to find/not the case with most pizza establishments. The salads were also of high quality. They included a nice amount of fresh green romaine and weren't full of stems instead. Drives us nuts when you order a salad and you receive mostly lettuce stems and stalks. The Caesar dressing was the best we've had-didn't have the sour aftertaste so often associated with Caesar dressing. Will definitely order from Brooklyn Joe's again! read more

Brooklyn Joe's pizza pasta grill located in Milton Georgia with indoor and outdoor dining facilities excellent staff friendly and speedy service quality Italian food I recommend the chicken parmesan prices are very affordable fun family atmosphere read more

See all

Love this place. I work around the corner and we have lunch here. The food is fantastic. The service is great. Clean, great atmosphere. Price affordable. PLUS they deliver. They have a waitress I can't remember her name. But she excellent. Ms. Deb and I love her. read more

Expat New Yorker here. The pizza at Brooklyn Joe's is legit! I am very happy to have found this place so close to my (new) home. Their subs and pasta dishes are also very good, and it's a great spot to bring the kids and not spend an arm and a leg. Service is also excellent. read more

My fiance and I have been trying pizza for the last year here in Alpharetta. We moved from New York a year ago and sometimes crave pizza from home. We were really excited to try their pizza, however we were disappointed in our sicilian pie that we had delivered from Brooklyn Joe's. We were really rooting for your guys after hearing such good reviews. Their phone service was really great. We even got pointers on what to order from the menu that would travel well. My fiance and I promised to give them an extra star just because they informed us before hand that their fried zucchini sticks wouldn't be a good choice for takeout. Saved us $7 bucks! As for the pizza, the sauce was too acidic and the crust lacked everything. Oh no :( The cheese didn't hold together and it was impossible to eat. We only ate one slice each. read more

Hate writing this, but it appears they can't handle a heavy rush of take-out orders. We've been weekly regulars since they opened, so we know what the norm is, but carryout has been a nightmare. They've been rude, dismissive, and taken far longer than quoted. And they don't have a mask policy, which is their right obviously, but with half the folks we saw coming in with masks and half without, the whole experience isn't worth the aggravation or potential exposure. read more

This is a great little spot. They have your typical pizza, calzones, pasta and sandwiches. The pizza is really good but not great. They are always very quick with pick-up orders, however, dining in can sometimes be a pain. The restaurant is not that big and often gets crowded with large parties after sporting events at North Park and the local schools. Since there is no real entrance or waiting area the restaurant gets jam packed inside, however, they do have shops next to them so if you alright with standing outside, there is plenty of room to do that. The service has been friendly and consistently good but I just can't rate the food at anything above average. Maybe I am a pizza snob, who knows? I like Brooklyn Joe's as a close to home pizza joint. read more