This is one of those no-frills, hole-in-the-wall neighborhood pizza places that are abundant in New Jersey, the kind that has been around for years and will likely outlive us all. The kind of place we take for granted as New Jersey natives until we visit family in Ohio or something and discover they have no idea what pizza can really be. Amongst fancier options in the area like Pizza Crime, Bricco, and Tacconelli's, their staying power lies in their consistency and their simple take on the classics. You know what you're getting here and can always bet on this place. It's a true mom-and-pop, independent place. The woman who takes my order and runs the front of house (the mom of the operation) is always super friendly and kind. They have a diverse menu of hot and cold subs, salads, and even burgers, but I've only ever gotten the pizza here. I live just a few blocks away so I've had their pizza plenty of times over the years, and it's always perfect. Perfect chewy crust, excellent sauce, and they don't skimp on toppings. Support local independent pizza places and order from here! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Entrance on Haddon Avenue. - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

See all

Let me start with the pizza that I purchased. It was burnt on the top and the bottom so left a very bad taste in your mouth and then the salad hardly had any lettuce. What I can tell you is the quality of the food has gone in the trash and the price is extremely high. I would not suggest that anybody gets food from this place read more

My employer orders the office lunch every Friday. Today they ordered pizza from Tony's. Most of us never heard of this restaurant and it's only a few blocks from our building. I tried a slice of the Buffalo chicken pizza as the cheesesteak pizza. Both were very good although the Buffalo chicken was my favorite!! Will definitely order from there again! read more

They messed up my order. Asked for grandma's pie with cheese but got an overly seasoned tomato pie. Cannolis we're ok. 3% surcharge for credit card. read more

See all

"Tony's! Pick-up or delivery?" That famous voice you hear every time you call! She (who is noted in several of these reviews) adds just the right touch. Oh, yes! The food! Very good...and many items are a bit more reasonably priced than other places. I've ordered 50+ times from Tony's, and never been disappointed. Special shout out for the pizza and wings. Very tasty! read more

The woman on the phone and at the counter was very nice. The pizza smelled great. However, both pizzas were severely undercooked. The ingredient quality was average at best (ham was a stack of lunch meat diced and in clumps). The amount of salt left a burning feeling in my mouth. The undercooked dough was concerning and unpleasant to eat. Edit: I just dropped my review to one star, because my son found three hairs (not his) in his pizza. read more

This is the foster child of bad pizza. Never go here it's terrible if u know what good pizza is. Worse pizza I ever had!!! Rating is -10 read more

Really love the convenience of this local pizza place. They have a pretty extensive menu if you're not in the mood for pizza, I really love their wings. The pasta, nothing special about. But a great place to get a simple pizza when you need it! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Haddonfield, New Jersey

A lovely little mom and pop pizza place. Nothing fancy. Nothing unusual. We shared a large cheesesteak and it just hit the spot. It came with potato chips and a drink. The bread was perfect, the meat juicy and flavorful, and it was served fresh and hot within minutes of sitting down. The lady who served us was very sweet and friendly. Pricing was fair. What more can you ask for? It is literally a 2 minute walk from my front door. I have a feeling that they may be seeing a lot of me on a lazy Friday night. read more

Have ordered from Tony's for years and it is always a hit in our house. Pizza, wings, cheesesteaks, hoagies are on point! Love walking in and seeing Tony & his wife. Enjoy read more

Love Tony's Pizzeria Pizza is great and everything is always fresh. My daughter favorite is the chicken parmigiana dinner! Family run business Always friendly read more

Stopped in to use the restroom and decided do get some dinner. I asked the woman what the best sandwich was and she replied, "they're all amazing." I wound up getting the Florentine. Grilled chicken, mozzarella, spinach, and roasted peppers on a garlic chibata-type bread. One of the top 5 best sandwiches I've ever had. I'd go out of my way for this. It's the best. Go there now. read more

After reading Marcello D.'s very solid review of Tony's, I swung by one day last week while running errands on my lunch break. The door was held open for me by a friendly gentleman on his way out, and I entered to hear the husband and wife duo behind the counter speaking to each other in Italian. Swoon! I ordered two slices to go, one plain and one veggie. Fifteen minutes later I was back at my desk, inhaling the pizza as fast as humanly possible. The slices were nicely sized and with a thin crust. The toppings on the veggie pizza made me feel downright healthy about my lunch choice. I felt like I gave into my pizza craving without going way overboard in the calorie department. Whether or not that was true... is irrelevant at this point. I have had better pizza, but for a quick takeout slice, Tony's wasn't a bad option. I'll check them out again sometime soon. read more

Good service can enhance the way you perceive any business. Tony's, a mom and pop pizza shop, works this angle very well. It's always a pleasure to walk in here and be greeted with a "Ciao, Marcello," no matter how long it has been since my last visit. The owners seem happy to see me and genuinely interested in hearing about my children. They respond by telling me stories about their family. It's a small detail that makes a big impact. Their delivery service is also very good. They come quickly and the food is reasonably priced. It's also a great spot to run in and grab a quick cannolo, if you're sweet tooth is aching. read more

BEST MARGHERITA PIZZA EVER!!!!!!!! this stuff is unbelieveable. also, their "normal" pizza is great too. everything i've had there is great, but seriously, the margherita pizza is so good that you literally cannot stop yelling about how good it is that whole time you're eating it. but beware - it has very little cheese on it... i usually ask for extra cheese, which still leaves it mostly cheese-less. great for pick-up or eat-in, friendly service, parking is a little tough. read more

My most favorite pizza...probably ever. The crust is so delicious, I could eat it plain! The sauce is just how I like it- simple without s tin of seasonings. The cheesesteaks are great, my only complaint is they are big and I end up eating it all this is always my go to, they started closing sundays which makes my hangovers sad read more

Tony's is a solid pizzeria for take out or delivery. The crust is nice and thin, cooked perfectly, with the right amount of cheese and sauce. They charge $1 for delivery and their overall prices are good. Whether you're looking for a quick slice (or two) or ordering a whole pie for a night in, Tony's is a solid and dependable choice. I recommend it. read more

I haven't given a bad review yet, but here is my first. This is my second time ordering from Tony's and it leaves a lot to be desired. The first time, my order was messed up to the point where the pizza was barely even close to what I wanted. The second time, both pizzas and onion rings were so burnt that my family couldn't taste anything but charcoal. They say that the third time is the charm, but I won't ever know because I certainly won't be back. Highly recommend all others find another pizza place to go to, like Pietro's on South Street. Worth the distance or train ride over. read more

Haddonfield, you're fortunate to have Tony's in your neighborhood! Every year I call from 1100 miles away in Tampa Bay to order one of Tony's best hoagies for my cousin's birthday in August. Their food is consistently good and delivery service is always right on time! My cousin would rather have one of their hoagies than any other birthday gift.I think that speaks for itself. Since the owners speak Italian it gives me a chance to parli Italiano as I did back in the day when I studied at Temple University's campus in Rome. I miss living in South Jersey but when I order from Tony's Pizzeria all the good aroma's flavors and memories return. Gratzie per tutti! Michael M. read more

We've been regulars for the 6 yeas we've lived in Haddonfield and of course that means we think it's the best pizza in town. The owners are great and know their customers. They often bring garlic knots for the kids and always fawn over the little ones. Pizza ranges from solid/good to occasionally great. It's a friendly cool scene and I have to admit the soccer on the TV ( in Italian) and kitchen chatter ( Italian ) influences my judgement - but what can I say - there is nothing phony about this place and they put out a pretty good pie. read more

Only tried the pizza but it wasn't that great. Well, it may have been good if it wasn't severely under-cooked. The pizza slid right off the slice it was so under-cooked. Might give it another try to see if it was an anomaly but wasn't thrilled with what I got. Prices were fair, slices were standard size and the atmosphere is what you would expect of a small pizza joint. Some locals were hanging out taking up a few tables, you can tell they frequent the place a lot. Not a lot of traffic for the lunchtime which can be telling for some places. read more

Had a chicken parm dinner while the wife got 2 slices of veggie pie. The chicken parm was ok...the ziti accompanying it were aldenti as I prefer. The tomato sauce tasted just ok. Portion was average. My wife said the pizza was just ok. Good , friendly service . read more

Stopped in after browsing at Haddonfield Record Exchange to enjoy one of their specials (two slices and a soda.) The pizza was great, and the slices were a very generous size. Will definitely be back. read more

I remember when good friend of mine owned a consignment shop 3 stores down, she would go grab a margherita pizza & water. I would go visit, & I was hooked. OMG!! I would safely assume the other ones great too. I stopped here today, after running errands, got couple slices.The slices had home-made sauce, tons garlic & Basil,simply heaven!! It runned by cutest Italian couple, just adorable!! Love this little place!! If not anything else, go get Margherita Pizza!! Pizza-pizza!!! read more

If you are visiting Haddonfield, as I was, you'll immediately notice how dang cute this town is. Everything in the downtown area is adorable -- restaurants, shops, houses, business... everything. So when we walked into Tony's after reading some good reviews, we were like, "meh." Not the cute restaurant one would come to expect after driving through the quaint little streets of Haddonfield. We were skeptical. But then we ordered food from the very nice Italian woman behind the counter, and when it was brought out on actual dinner plates (not paper or styrofoam), I was very impressed. You wouldn't expect a hole-in-the-wall place like this to use real plates and silverware. We ordered some caesar salad, gluten-free cheese pizza, and one medium pizza that was half margherita, half bruschetta. The caesar salads were pretty good. The dressing was thick and creamy, and they served it on the side, which I appreciate. It also hard hardboiled egg slices, which I liked. My friend who is gluten-free said that the gluten-free pizza crust was pretty good, and she really appreciated that they gave her her own individually-wrapped pizza cutter so there was no cross-contamination. My other friend and I shared the bruschetta and margherita pizza. The margherita was really good but I wish we had gotten a whole bruschetta, because it was possibly the best pizza I've ever had. Oh my goodness, SO good. Ridiculously fresh mozzarella, delicious tomato, basil, garlic, and spring mix. Perfectly flavored. Mmmmmmm, you must try it. I'm going to be dreaming about this pizza for a long time. Anyway, do not be fooled by the un-cute exterior of the place. The people are great, service was great, and food that we tried was incredibly delicious. read more

This is a little mom and pop shop and a great place to go for a slice of pizza. The prices are reasonable and the quality is always consistent. read more

In a word; HORRIBLE! If I could award zero stars for the food I just ate, I would. I'm basing my review on the Holy Trinity of Waste; Time, Money and Food. It kills me to waste any of the three but ALL THREE really gets under my skin. My partner and I have been watching what we eat, working out nearly every day and giving a great effort at changing our lifestyle. After four weeks of being careful about the food we've been eating, we decided that tonight would be a "splurge" night. What a waste that we chose to break our good eating routine with a delivery order from Tony's Pizzeria. We called for a pizza at 540PM adding an order of calamari and some onion rings (I told you, we were splurging!). It's only been 15 minutes since I finished eating and I can't even remember what type of pizza we ordered. Nature has a way of blocking out terrible memories I guess! I'd look at the menu to find out but unfortunately my partner shredded it as soon as we cleared our plates. When we placed our delivery order we were told it would arrive in 30 minutes. Sort of hard to believe that a pizza can arrive in 30 minutes on a Friday night but hey, they know their business a lot better than I do, right? WRONG! After calling back an hour and fifteen minutes into our wait time, I was told that our order "had already gone out and should be there any minute." Another ten minutes passed before it finally arrived making our wait an hour and twenty five minutes. It was NOT worth the wait! The calamari...horrid! I know what food looks like when it has had freezer-burn and there is no doubt that this crap suffered a bad case of it! The breading had a white, freezer-burned edge and it tasted as though it had been deep-fried with everything else that had ever been deep-fried at Tony's. Being delivered cold didn't help. We attempted to rescue it by putting it in the microwave for 30 seconds but it only made the calamari flavored rubber bands a little more rubber bandier. The onion rings...horrid! Onion rings are pretty self-defining. Rings of onions. These were the same crappy onion-flavored, circular-shaped, deep-fried "things" that Burger King serves. Minced onions inside of a bad breading that were limp as a pasta noodle when they were delivered. Onto the pie...isn't pizza supposed to be hot? Seriously. If you don't have the proper equipment to deliver your product hot and fresh, don't be in the delivery business! When I opened the pizza box and reached for a slice, the crust was cold. Not just "warm". I mean COLD! The cheese on the pizza broke rather than stringing from the box to my plate like a great pizza should. It's truly unfortunate because the flavor of the pie was actually acceptable and if it would have been at least warm, I might have something good to say about it. Gotta tell you, Tony...our experience of your restaurant sucked! You can't afford to serve crap like this in today's economy...there are few of us who will give a second chance at wasting our money. And, there's way too much competition in the area to throw good money after bad. We won't be back and strongly recommend others don't waste their time or money. read more

Margarita pizza heaven! If you like lots of fab tomato sauce in comparison to just enough cheese to make it seem not completely unhealthy, you'll love this pizza. The crust is the right kind of thin and crispy, and not crunchy like a cracker. read more

I've given this place some business, but the guy they have answering the phone is the grumpiest prick I've ever encountered. He can barely speak English and he gets highly annoyed when he doesn't comprehend what you're saying and he rudely cuts you off constantly. The food is average at best, so I'm out. read more

An awesome ol' fashioned mom & pop italian restaurant. Great food, have yet to disappoint! If you want a home made meal but dont feel like cooking, tony's is the place! read more

Food is hot and prices reasonable. Pizza is great, steak sandwiches are hardy and yummy.

Tonys margarita pizza and wings are the best in town (as for hot). You can tell everything is made fresh in house. This is a gem of a place for authentic italian food! read more

Love Tony's pizzas. Sauce is the best: Fresh, tomatoey. Not the thick over spicey stuff commonly found. Cheese is delicious and toppings generous. The other stuff is very good too. Delivery is prompt. ( one time the pie had the toppings slide to one side and they offered to replace it.) read more

The food is ok. .Had better pizza. But the most important is they have mice infestation in the building. read more

A solid neighborhood restaurant. Reliable, inexpensive, pleasant, accommodating ... Not high cuisine. Nothing gourmet, but good ... what I'd call soul food, the food of my childhood growing up in an Italian neighborhood, that I could eat dinner after dinner if I had to, and never tire of. read more

Very mediocre pizza. Ordered wings and unfortunately they were breaded wings. Yuck. Come on south jersey! Much better pizza places. Nothing negative to say about the place but the food was just very, very average. read more

I've been going to Tony's Pizza for 15 years. It's my go-to place for pizza. Not the best ever but pretty darn good. My husband requests long hots on the pizza and they are happy to oblige. The owners are an Italian couple named Jerry and Connie and are very nice. They are funny to watch interact especially when they get in an argument. My mother-in-law from Pittsburgh says she craves Tony's Pizza when she's in for a visit so we always order it when she's in town. They also have a loyalty card and you get a free pizza after 10. They also offer an awesome special on Mondays: $7.99 for a large pie. read more

Went here for the first time today. The lady working the front was so sweet. She wouldn't let us pay until we got our food because she wanted to make sure it was satisfactory. My husband and I got two appetizers and a large pizza. All of which exceeded our expectations. It's hard to come by good food accompanied by good service anymore but this place has it. I definitely recommend it! We will be back. read more

I am generally an adventurous person when it comes to food and trying new places but this is one place i regret ever visiting. I was recommended this place by a coworker, who raved about their pizza. I thought, why not. As soon as I got in, the husband and wife who are the owners/cooks were in the middle of an argument. It was all in Italian so I did not understand but I would not be surprised if it was full of curse words judging from the tone of voice. When they noticed I was there, they immediately stopped and started taking my owner as if nothing happened. I ordered a fountain drink and 2 slices of sausage pizza and sat down while I was waiting for it to be cooked. When I started eating, I realized that I made a mistake. The pizza was the same quality as an overcooked Red Baron pizza and the sausage reminded me of partially frozen jimmy deans sausage patties. I immediately went to the bathroom as soon as i was done as i have the tendency to vomit when i eat peasant quality food. I couldn't even relieve myself because there was one of those 14 inch, solid perfectly formed turds that curled perfectly around the toilet bowl in there. I was so horrified i bolted out of the restaurant as if i was doing the 40 yard dash for the eagles try outs. Im having ptsd every night. I awake in cold sweats and i no longer feel safe using any restroom including my own for fear that i will encounter that henious site again. I don't know what to do. HELP ME read more

Really the worst pizza place around haddonfield. Many others have opened and this place is usually empty so I can't tell why theY can stay open for so many years. No flavor or passion in the food. Or atmosphere. A stale recipe with nothing innovative. My kids won't eat here even if really hungry, kids who don't like the pizza? .Sorry but I hope they improve the food or allow some other business to prosper in this location. read more