Fun place to get a sandwich. Food is delicious. Always had a pleasant experience each time.

First time at the Brooklyn Pickle in my home town! Went with the fam and the 4 of us ate sandwiches, had 4 drinks, a bag of chips, and two desserts for $50 (with military discount). I got a half sandwich which was huge - but decently messy with the bread falling apart. BUT the ingredients all tasted great (I got turkey/roast beef, lettuce, tomato, and pickles) and it was super filling. The cheesecake was delicious! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

Food is ok. Service is what this place is lacking. Staff is largely unhelpful and to be honest a bit rude. They do nothing to help you order by asking what you want on your sandwich etc. idk just seems like customer service is lacking read more

Had a half Reuben and chicken soup - both were delicious! The selection of chips is overwhelming and bags are bigger than you would expect. Service was fast and everyone was super friendly! No pictures as I ate everything so quickly, sorry. I'll be back! read more

Hours on Google, their website and everywhere else is wrong. It said they closed at 8pm, however we got there at 6:59pm and they were closed. We drove 45 minutes to get my Father with cancer his favorite sandwich. Very disappointing. read more

Huge sandwiches and fantastic service will always have us coming back for more. This is a great place to get a fantastic meal and the value is outstanding! read more

Great food, generous portions, attentive service and different homemade specials every day.

Finally a place for some good Pastrami. It did not disappoint. I may be back this week for a full sub, though the half was plenty, but why skimp when I can splurge. Did I mention Dr. Brown cream soda!!! So good. read more

First timer...started off with Turkey Sub. Generous turkey. Sub bread was just okay. Not crusty or crunchy on outside to add texture so was just 'bready'. Lettuce ordered on sandwich was missing and Kraut ordered (dont judge) was more like creamy slaw. Not bad but interesting...maybe NY thing. Definitely not German kraut. Cheesecake brownie was literally cheesecake and soft creamy fudge. Delicious and super rich. Ordered to go. Unfortunately, the steering wheel on my car has more "personality" than the dude that handed me my bag. Good help defines a business and good bread defines a sandwich shop. These weren't great but filled my belly so not an entire loss. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Turkey Sub (with lettuce??) - Sandwiches Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

All the taste of Subway with the inconvenience of total chaos. Literally have no idea how people can suggest this place. The Food was...quite simply...terrible. Bacon straight out of the steam tray, lettuce straight out of the old McDonald's lettuce shredder. Somehow the Bread is overwhelming and underwhelming all at once. Bummer. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - A "BLT" is what they called it but dear god. - Sandwiches Near Me - Southern Pines, North Carolina

I ordered a Brooklyn Pickle special sandwich to be delivered along with potato salad. Much to my surprise, there was hardly any meat. It was a small amount of corned beef and no pastrami as described. One piece of cheese and nothing else. Never again!! read more

GREAT FOOD. yes it is a bit on the pricey side but you get what you pay for. I am not a fan of their sides, but who cares.... yummmm.. they make an out of this world Rueben, that with a bag of chips and a soda , for a little while, my world is put right. read more

First time trying Brooklyn Pickle and I was not impressed! The meat and toppings (I ordered the Brooklyn Pickle Special sub) were good, but the sub roll was terrible, it was stale and dry and ruined what could have been a good sandwich. I took two bites and had to eat the rest of my sandwich with a fork, skipping the roll. They say it's the bread/roll that makes a good sandwich, but here the terrible roll ruined it. Maybe I should tried a sandwich on rye bread, but can't recommend their subs, sorry. read more

Food is always good and the staff is great prices a little high but what isn't now a days lol overall it's a great place to eat

This restaurant serves their food and drink on paper & plastic only. I hate to think about all that trash when real plates & cups & glasses would be reusable and so much more in tune with sustainable business practices. They don't even have a recycling container for patrons to throw recyclables in. read more

Being new in town, my wife and I are eager to try as many new restaurants as we can. We went around 1pm on a Monday and were the only customers. The place is big, but the booths were not very comfortable, so we sat at a table. My wife had a 1/2 turkey sandwich with cheese on whatever their house bread is. She said it was very good. I'm always on the lookout for a great Reuben. Unfortunately, this one was very disappointing. In their defense, most are. Being from north Jersey/NY I've had many true pastrami or corned beef sandwiches. It's all about the brine so, if you've never had a genuine one, you may not know the difference. The corned beef they used seemed straight out of a supermarket deli. It had no trace of what good, corned beef should be. They also used their house bread, and not rye, which is a no-no. Also, they represent Brooklyn in name only. You will not find a generic sandwich shop like this in Brooklyn. The search continues... read more

Love love love the sandwiches! The staff is super friendly and the restaurant is so clean. Frequent flyer

Pretty much the only thing that is "Brooklyn" is the name. Adequate amount of cold cuts on the sandwich , but the bread was soft and mushy.....even Subways rolls have more substance. The "pickle" part is pure deception.....they will give you three dill chips wrapped in the sandwich. I would have expected a selection of some sort. If you are expecting a NY style hero , you will be disappointed ......it's just another Subway , just more expensive . read more

The title of this sandwich shop is a total misconception. The sandwiches are the furthest thing from a Brooklyn style hero and only came with 2 pickle chips. The service was horribly chaotic and extremely sloppy. Over-priced food. There were no packages when it came to food. Everything was sold separately. Sandwich- drink- and chips. First time and last. Save yourself some money and head to subway or mcalister's deli. read more

Fast service sandwich was amazing, soup and chocolate chip cookie was hand made and delicious. Friendly and fast service would definitely come back! read more

I love this place! Clean and delicious. We love their toasted pastrami on rye, and the salads are fresh.

Excellent sandwiches! The Brooklyn special wrap is my favorite! Definitely worth a visit!

Below average sandwich shop. Throwing subs and sandwiches together with a cpl. Pickles in the wrapping. Personal believe you get a better sandwich at most subways. My wife's had a hair in her sub. Wouldn't recommend this business. read more

Love it! The sandwiches are insanely delicious! So many to choose from or create your own! The staff could not be friendlier.

Absolutely love the turkey breast sandwich only need a half very big with lots or turkey

Absolutely love this deli from my hometown and was so happy to see it here in Southern Pines. Everything that I have had there has been great! Pasta salad, macaroni salad, any type of sandwich, cheesecake. It's all amazing! The staff is wonderful and the facility is always spotless. read more

Good place to get a sandwich and good soup. Ingredients are fresh, and they give you a good portion. The staff has been friendly each time I have visited. read more

We saw the great positive article in PineStraw so thought we'd give it a try. Wondered in at 4:30 Sat afternoon. Place was quiet so we thought it'd be a quick in and out as there were 6 folks behind the counter. We stood around for about 10 mins, no one said boo, so we decided to move on. That high dollar rent will catch up to them soon if they can't figure out customer service. read more

I have always had a good experience here with the staff. Love all the options for sandwiches, salads, etc.

service great, personnel fabulous...ask for Aidan , sandwiches outstanding .tnice new sandwich place in Pinehurst area