From St.Louis & stopped for the meatball pizza. Wonderful interior & the pizza was amazing. Authentic NYC style pizza. Slices & not squares. I despise stl style pizza . Definitely will stop by if we are in the area again. read more

Wasn't a fan of salad dressing. Was supposed to be a sweet vinegaret but just tasted very tart, too vinegary. Then the pizza had NO flavor. Crust, sauce, and meat on pizza had no seasoning. Then my toppings were supposed to have included peppers, onions, and garlic...was confused where the flavor was. read more

The best pizza I've ever had. The service was amazing. They were so nice. The pictures were so cool. Fantastic crust. (Written by my 10 year old pizza connoisseur son) read more

We had the chance to stop by Brooklyn Pizza while visiting Fulton, a small town full of history and charm. A kind lady at the Winston Churchill Museum suggested we try it, and I'm so glad she did! She also mentioned that their Tiramisu is house made and delicious!! We started with the chicken parmigiana appetizer, which was really tasty. Chicken was fried to perfection and the tomato sauce wasn't overpowering.. just the right taste! For the main course, we went with the Missouri Pie, which had a unique blend of minced pork and beef. I'd never had a combo like that on pizza before, and I really enjoyed it. The crust was thin and flaky, baked well, and the meat gave it a rich and hearty flavor. I added Parmesan, chili flakes, and oregano, which elevated the taste of the pizza for sure. Since it was a Sunday afternoon, the place was buzzing with people and everyone seemed to be enjoying their food. It's such a fun and refreshing addition to the quiet, history-filled town of Fulton. Definitely worth a stop after visiting the nearby Berlin Wall, Museum and Christopher Wren church! read more

See all

Tried a Missouri Pie for the first time: ground pork and beef, minced green peppers, onions and garlic. It was definitely different, but not in a bad way. The pizza is thin with crispy-chewy crust, living up to its New York style reputation. The meatball sub I ordered was quite hefty and had great flavor and texture. I would have liked more cheese personally. I thought the prices were very reasonable for the amount of food you get. Would recommend to friends for sure. read more

See all

Great / friendly service, neat atmosphere and fantastic food. Pizza is very good and everything is cooked fresh to order. Can't wait to return. read more

See all

Service was good. Pizza was OK, not really anything too special, however the cheese was really good and saved the disappointment in the lackluster pizza sauce. We had the chezzy garlic bread and that was pretty good. Overall it is probably one of the better offerings for food in the downtown Fulton area, but it won't be a staple for my family unfortunately. The restaurant does fit the bill for a classic pizzeria with big windows and checkered red decor, the pizza just doesn't hit the "spot" read more

The calzone is one of the best I've ever had! Added meatballs to it with a side of delicious pizza sauce. The cheesy garlic bread was amazing! There were pieces of fresh garlic mixed in with the cheese on the bread. This wasn't our first time here. Always been great each and every time. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Meatballl Calzone either side of pizza sauce Cheesy Garlic Bread - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

This is a authentic Italian family restaurant. They are known for their pizzas but everything has been good. The inside is decorated with Pictures and memorabilia of New York. The service is always served with a friendly smile and very prompt. It's a little off the beaten path from Columbia but worth the extra 15 minute drive off highway 70. Give them a try! read more

See all

Good food, good service, friendly staff. Usually go as a church group. Pizza and pasta and salad.

We drive from Columbia to Fulton for pizza. We've tried them all and Brooklyn Pizza is the best pizza in central MO. Great pizza, service and a simple ambiance. read more

Pizza was excellent. We got the Sicilian and spicy Hawaiian. Staff was excellent. Will be back!

Service and food are excellent. Ambiance is quiet and it gives classic pizza parlor vibes. Besides Great vibes they offer excellent pizza! We ordered a specialty pizza the itlaian beef, and it was hot, fresh, and the perfect combo of spicy and cheesy. We had leftovers, and they reheated and tasted just like we ordered it, which is impressive. If you are nearby, stop here and get some yummy pizza! Will be back to try another specialty pizza soon! read more

Cheese pizza is pretty good (7.1/10). The people were nice and calm. Lasagna was great. Overall good experience, and the place is decorated nicely! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

See all

The pizza is just ok, nothing to write home about. Crust is like cardboard and the sauce wasn't flavorful. We also ordered spumoni to go and when we got home there was about a half a scoop of spumoni in there. I think they charged us $3 or $4 for a half a scoop. Pizza Hut is better. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Spumoni - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

Love Brooklyn Pizza. Hubby loves the Missouri Pie and I love the Shrimp Pizza. We've never had a meal less than great! Service rocks too.

On our way home from Saint Louis. Decided to stop here and order Togo for the ride home. Arrived at 8:41 pm. Doors clearly state they close at 9 pm. Doors are locked. I called and asked if they are closed. I was told yes, they close a "little early because no one was in the dining room. We have side work to do so we will be done around 9 pm." ummm... I responded by asking if the owner knew & was told yes. I was planning to place a fairly large order. It's obvious they do not care about customers considering they are still there, but not one time did they offer to serve us despite the fact that they were open. Don't waste your time. They might not be open during their posted business hours. read more

I love the simplicity of their dishes. I had their spaghetti with meatballs, not overly garnished with spices, just simple and good. The same with their Tiramisu, not too sweet just perfect balance and feels light. I would order from them again the future. Their price fits the serving size. Two thumbs up! read more

See all

FOOD- Brooklyn Pizza has a wide variety of Italian cuisine. I ordered the Chicken Parmigiana Sub Sandwich. My meal, as well as other members of my party's meals, were delicious and cooked very well. The drinks we were served were cold and full of flavor. SERVICE- The service at Brooklyn Pizza was good service. We were waited on almost as soon as we sat down, we received our drinks and started ordering our food very soon after. After ordering our food, we did not have to wait too long before our food had arrived at our table. The food also came out very warm. OVERALL- Overall I would definitely recommend you check this restaurant out. I would say that you are guaranteed good service and good food at this restaurant! Happy Eating xoxo. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Main seating area of the restaurant - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

See all

The atmosphere was classic for a Brooklyn Pizzeria! If you are in a rush I wouldn't suggest eating here. The meatballs were tasty. The full size pizza was good but a little pricey for the overall taste quality. The crust has a nice brick oven crunch. I would come back if just for the tiramisu dessert, which was said to be made by a local! read more

See all

Love this place. We always have great service and the pizzas are always fantastic. We also love their salads and they have the best house dressing. If you like New York Style Pizza, you won't be disappointed with going to Brooklyns. If I could change anything about Brooklyns, it would be to add more beer selections as they are pretty limited here but the pizza makes up for it. read more

A feel of New York in mid Missouri! Love the food and the service was great! It's definitely worth the stop.

Super cute restaurant, love the ambiance. The staff was very nice and the pizza was really good! We got the white spinach pizza and added sausage to it and it was very good! Definitely will come back here. read more

Excellent calzones ! The cheesecake was authentic Italian style and delish! Prices are also extremely reasonable. I highly recommend this restaurant. Grazie! read more

Service and ambiance are great but the best thing is the food! I didn't want to fill up on salad but my husband ordered one and we shared it. I was amazed by the sweet vinaigrette dressing, which is the best dressing I've ever had. I almost ordered another and had them hold the lettuce! I am happy I didn't because I would not have been able to eat as much of the pizza, which I believe is also the best I've ever had! I cannot have wheat and had to order the gluten free crust, which was great, but the cheese is what makes a pizza and I would swear it was fresh mozzarella!! I don't know but it was heavenly! read more

I get Brooklyn pizza in Branson, Mo. It is great went to this one and no not near as good.

I've had a lot of pizza from pretty much everywhere in the world. This is quality pizza. You can thell they care. Awesome.

Pizza was excellent. Service ok but not great (a tad slow for few there and delivered our pizza to wrong table). I would/will go again.

Great pizza and great service! Even ordered in advance and they had a table waiting for us.

Have had a few pepperoni pizzas. They make a really good pie. I'll make this a frequent stop while in Fulton.

Went on my first date with my girlfriend here. Lovely little place, the music is good and the food is tasty. The service was quick and it wasn't at all packed. Will definitely stop by here again in the future. A lot better than chain pizza! read more

Really nice owners at this place and I must admit his pizza is as good as my wife's homemade pizza. Delicious. Thx

Staff was unfriendly - food was mediocre - the calzones had mostly ricotta cheese and very little of anything else. Both my husband and I were extremely disappointed. Just because a business is located in a college town doesn't mean quality doesn't matter - sad that such a cute little place with such potential is being managed so poorly. :-( read more

This is a really good pizza joint with a NY feel here in Fulton. I would recommend the pizza and the Stromboli.

I thought the staff was not that friendly to be honest and the food was ok. It was cold in the place and waitress didn't check on us that much. Albeit, it was before the Thanksgiving Holiday, so maybe that is why not many were interested in service. I'm not sure that we will be going back when in Fulton. read more

The lunch special is just the beginning of how wonderful this pizza and Italian food is. Worth the trip.

I love small businesses and try to support them. I really wanted to love this place and I had heard good things from the people who work at the Churchill Museum. We were craving Arris' Pizza but since it was 30 miles away, we opted for this place. The service was friendly enough and the atmosphere was fine, but I found myself really wishing we could sit outside or on the patio (which was like one huge table). Their menu is very limited, and I didn't find much original. We were there on Mother's Day and there was no "Happy Mother's Day" or any real observance of it. The pizza was fine but nothing special in my book, even though I really wanted it to be because I am all about the small, independent entrepreneur. They did offer a gluten free crust. We should have gone ahead and opted for it because the regular crust didn't leave me breathless. They serve beer and wine, so I loved that about it. Many small places don't bother to apply for the liquor license so that was a pleasant surprise. They had a tannin free wine too so that is awesome. Their salad was fine but I guess I was hoping for a little originality-- like a creamy italian dressing with provel or something. It was lettuce, italian dressing, and mozzerella. Just nothing to hook me. The pizza was okay but not my favorite. I would try it again but I would love it if they offered some cheese options or a Chicago style pizza, or just something to make me choose them over a chain. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Very good pizza! Meatball, Italian sausage and Italian beef. - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

It amazes me how many more dining options Fulton has that it did just a few years ago. I was in town for Alumni Weekend, but it seemed like the staff wasn't quite prepared for the influx of customers. It didn't bother me really because I wasn't in a hurry, but the service was awfully slow. That being said I did enjoy my calzone when it finally came out. I built my own with mushrooms and spinach. I'm usually a pizza girl over calzone, but I was the only one eating and didn't need a whole pie. It is nice to see a sit down pizza joint in town that isn't a chain, and I would be willing to go back in the future perhaps with a larger group to try more of the menu. I just hope they realize when Alumni Weekend is in the future so they can staff up! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Calzone - Italian Near Me - Fulton, Missouri

See all

This was our second visit here. Everything was excellent! The pizza is absolutely amazing, and good, friendly & prompt service. We came early and had plenty of space in the dining room, so we ate in both times. Good atmosphere, and oldies playing too! Quickly becoming a favorite! read more

One of the best NY pizzas in Missouri. A must stop if you are traveling near Jefferson City and love NY Style pizza