Ate here twice today. Bagels were fresh and delicious. Had a muffin and a black and white and it's just like what I grew up with in NYC. The coffee was also fresh and tasty. Different kinds of milk and raw sugar. Friendly service and very clean restaurant. read more

Brooklyn Water Bagel - Bakery case - Bagels Near Me - Clermont, Florida

See all

I'm not sure why this place gets so many bad reviews. I did notice that my sesame bagel was a little stale compared to my wife's Everything sourdough bagel which was very good. I haven't been here enough to know if there's some inconsistencies. Service was fast and the place was clean. read more

See all

Newly open Fall of 2025. They offer a mix of breakfast and lunch options until 3pm. Choose from sandwiches, bagels and bagel sandwiches. We tried a bagel breakfast sandwich (egg, bacon and cheese) and the turkey wrap (turkey, bacon and avocado) but I choose to sub out the wrap for a bagel. Bagels are made in house and show with the flavor and size. Asiago was light on cheese and the everything bagel was heavy on flavors, as it should be. Tried the apple cinnamon muffin which was delicious! Iced Coffee is a little strong so you may need to opt for cream. Great move for Clermont to get these Opition! read more

See all

Staff was super helpful and friendly! Even though I was the very first customer on a Friday morning they were attentive and energetic in getting me my bagel sandwhich and coffee. Unfortunately, it might just be myself but brooklyn water bagel doesn't hit like it used to in college! The coffee was good and the water is amazing as always but my sandwhich was just okay! Also they don't have vegan cream cheese so that was a bummer. We would visit again though! read more

See all

Very cool little bagel shop. They were listed on Too Good To Go with a surprise bag valued at $15 for just $5. I got 8 different flavors of bagels and they were still very fresh! We made sandwiches with cream cheese and bacon as soon as we got home with the Cherry, the Cheddar and the pumpernickel. All three were excellent and I'm already planning egg sandwiches for breakfast tomorrow with the everything and everything wheat. The space was really nice and the staff very friendly. I can't wait to go back and get one of their breakfast sandwiches, which the sign said they were voted #1 - so that's cool. read more

See all

CAVEAT EMPTOR: Pro tip... always check your order before leaving. This was my third strike here. I asked for a tuna salad on an onion bagel, plain and simple, just tuna, no extras. Somehow, it arrived with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, which I didn't ask for. No big deal, I removed them. Then came the real surprise: the tuna. Dry as dust, overpowered with so much pepper it felt like someone lost control of the shaker, and so heavy on celery that I started wondering if they'd forgotten the tuna entirely. Easily THE WORST "tuna salad" I've ever had. On the bright side, the bagel was fantastic and the place was nice and clean with seating on the side. So yes, I'll be back for bagels. But the tuna sandwich? Let's just say it's officially retired from my menu. You're better off making it at home. read more

Brooklyn Water Bagel - The WORST Tuna Salad on a Bagel! Bagel itself was good! - Bagels Near Me - Clermont, Florida

We usually go to another location. We found this one whilst running errands in the area. Basic inside. Clean and organized. Sadly, this experience was terrible. The service was slow and the bagels were stale. Our order wasn't correct. We were given the wrong cream cheese. read more

See all

We were excited to try this new local bagel spot for breakfast. We ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel and a sausage, egg, and cheese bagel. Unfortunately, the sandwiches were a bit bland and the bagels themselves were tough. Overall, it didn't quite meet our expectations, so we're not sure we'd return. read more

Brooklyn Water Bagel - Sausage, egg, and cheese bagel - Bagels Near Me - Clermont, Florida

See all

I walked into this location on a Saturday morning at about 7:30am and there were a few others already in the store. The store was clean and workers were happy to greet me. There is a self service computer to order from at the front which is great so you can see pictures of all the food, however you can go to the counter too. The family next to me ordered the bagel bites and I will try those next time. During this visit, I ordered an egg and cheese on an everything bagel, a coffee and another everything bagel sliced to go. Although they forgot to put the everything bagel in the bag to go, they were happy to fix the order. The flavors were great. I sip definitely visit again. It's very easy to get to off of Highway 27. read more

Brooklyn Water Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Clermont, Florida

Really wanted to love this place.. very disappointed. Tried this place on few times. Every time the bagels were hard and cold not even close to warm.I feel like they are serving bagels baked the day before. Don't waste your money. read more

First time i went and ordered an asiago bagel it was ok, not the freshest but maybe a day old. Today I ordered one and it was very stale at least 3 days old. Not good for repeat business. I will not be back read more

As soon as you walk in it smells wonderful, Phenomenal bagels , service was good. My children and I loved it. I'll be back! read more

The bagels are ok for the area. I ordered the Taylor ham, egg and cheese. The order came out quick but really no flavor too it. To have a name like Brooklyn water you think it the bagel would have more flavor like getting a bagel in Brooklyn. I understand the water is not the same but other places bring down the water system from the north. I was pretty let down when I stop in. Mostly likely won't be back. read more

The bagels are not good and definitely not worthy of being called Brooklyn Water. The cream cheese was off and they got my order wrong too. There are much better options in town. read more

The bagels here are awesome. Staff is friendly and attentive. Restaurant is clean and good seating even outside. Deserves to have better reviews on its bagels alone. Love this place. read more

Food was very good. The wait staff was very helpful and pleasant. I would recommend the dark bagel any time.

Not enough staff, one person taking orders and making coffee. The bagels are not good at all. The taste of the bagels is strange.

They do not make fresh cream cheese at this location. Manager informed me that they make fresh cream cheese daily but could not explain why the cream cheese on my plain bagel with cream cheese tasted like refrigerator. Yes, you read correctly! My daughter and I both ordered bagel with cream cheese and the cream cheese tasted as if was left in the fridge uncovered for days. O could not post without leaving a star but personally I rather not leave any!! As a Brooklynite, born and raised I will definitely refrain from ever returning!! You are not properly representing the name Brooklyn well at all!!! read more

You know i was so excited when i saw this open because I loved it when i was back home, however every time i have gone i have been disappointed. The bagels themselves are fine but my god why is it so hard to get cream cheese on a bagel?? I ordered a normal bagel and cream cheese last month only to find my bagel with the equivalent of a teaspoon of cream cheese across the ENTIRE bagel. So this time i say look last time there was literally none can i please get extra to ensure there's an appropriate amount? So they charge $3 THREE DOLLARS??? And i get this?? WTF? This should be the standard amount of what is considered for cream cheese on a bagel but you had the audacity to charge an additional $3 to an already pricey bagel. Get out of here with that. Jeffs Bagel Run is so far superior, i have tried but Brooklyn, you clearly cant get it together. A true shame for real bagel lovers. I will be driving double the distance to Jeffs and thoroughly enjoying my bagel experience there. read more

Brooklyn Water Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Clermont, Florida

By far the best bagels in the area which includes Horizon West, etc. We are from Jersey and these are the closest to NJ/NY bagels and no one else comes close. We used to travel to the location on Goldenrod just for these and now no longer have to. We only get the bagels and have never tried the sandwiches so we can't speak to them. A good variety and a efficient staff. The price is reasonable considering all the bagel pretenders in this area. My only issue is the location which is really hidden and not at all easy to get to or find. It looks like the area is developing so maybe more stores will open and make it a more accessible location. Go for the bagels! read more

ordered bagels to be picked up the next morning at 9AM. when i ate the first bagel, it was very hard. i tried the second with same results. The store claims that the bagels were made that morning, but it is hard to believe they would be that hard so early. Even after microwaving it, it still was a little hard. I find it hard to believe they were made that morning. read more

Bagels are not fresh like Jeff's Bagel run or even Panera. Someone's review of being like NY/NJ bagels totally misleading. Jeff's is very good, Einstein not bad, Panera barely acceptable. read more

Bagels were good, but the order was wrong. Went to get it corrected and treated as if it is the customers' fault the order was wrong. Service staff were very rude when it was pointed out. Orders for seated guests sat in the window waiting to be delivered while staff walked around leaving the orders standing. read more

BEST bagels in Florida! Service was amazing and the store was very clean and easy to get to.