Stuff a Bagel is becoming an institution in the Windermere/Winter Garden area. Since it's open the restaurant has been gaining tremendous popularity. My wife and I live 10 minutes away and I wouldn't have it any other way. The restaurant is across the street from Magic Kingdom cast member parking. So it's definitely convenient for cast members to come in and grab a bite. Stuff a Bagel is open for breakfast and lunch, hours being 5 am to 2 pm. Sunday it's 6 am to 1 pm. My wife and I had breakfast recently and she got her usual which is a pumpernickel bagel with cream cheese and bacon. It is her absolute favorite. If you want your bagel toasted, you do need to let them know, it is not automatic. I got the special that was offered which was a 3 egg omelette which was a western, also came with a bagel I chose plain. This omelette simply perfect... truly perfectly made. The bagel was delicious of course. No matter the flavor all true New York bagels. I want to talk about the breakfast menu itself. They offer a lot of variety. My wife and I have had a lot of items for breakfast. Here is what they have to choose from: -Bagels: Plain, Blueberry, Egg, Garlic, Onion, Salt, Sesame, Poppy. Whole Wheat, Everything, Egg Everything, Pumpernickel, Cinnamon Raisin, Asiago Cheese, Jalapeño Cheddar (My wife and I's absolute favorite bagels are the Everything, Pumpernickel, Jalapeño Cheddar and Asiago Cheese) -Bagels with toppings: Plain Cream Cheese, Butter and Cream Cheese, Flavored Cream Cheese, Flavored Cream Cheese and Butter, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Lox Spread, Fresh Lox and Cream Cheese, La Guardia Fresh Whitefish(My wife sticks with Plain, I like the plain too but I also get the Fresh Whitefish and Fresh Lox and Cream Cheese) -Stuff Breakfast Bagels: Long Island Expressway (L.I.E.): 2 Eggs, Steak and Cheese; Brooklyn Queens Expressway: 2 Eggs, Potatoes and Cheese; Jersey Turnpike: Taylor Ham, 2 Eggs and Cheese; Southern State: 2 Eggs, Turkey and Cheese; Frank the Tank: 2 Eggs, Ham, Bacon, Sausage and Cheese; Breakfast Burrito: 2 Eggs Scrambled, with Sausage, Peppers, Onions, and Cheese; 2 Eggs with Lox, 2 Eggs, 2 Eggs with Swiss, Cheddar, American, Provolone, or Pepper Jack Cheese; 2 Eggs with Cheese, Bacon, Ham or Sausage (I love Frank the Tank the best. My wife sticks to a bagel and cream cheese) -Cream Cheese: Plain, Low Fat Plain, Veggie, Scallion, Maple Walnut, Strawberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Jalapeño, Olive Lox Spread (we've had all but Olive Lox Spread and Strawberry) -Healthy Options: Veggie Omelette- 3 Eggs Scrambled Whites, Assorted Veggies, Swiss Cheese, Buttered Whole Wheat Bagel; Lean Burrito- 2 Egg Whites, Turkey, Peppers, Onions and Cheese ( I prefer the Veggie Omelette) -Bakery: Danish, Turnovers, Flavored Crumble Cake, Black and White Cookie, Assorted Muffins, Cinnamon Bun, Chocolate Croissant, Cannoli, Italian Cookies( Rainbow, Linzer Tarte, Pink and Green Leaf) We love a classic black and white Overall, this is a great place for a quick breakfast or even a lunch. We will be trying some lunch items next time we come here. The line is usually long, especially on the weekends, but the staff is so great, they are quick, and you never end up waiting long to order or to get your food. Their coffee is great, continuingly making fresh coffee. I highly reccomend stopping by. Aces! read more

See all

It's a small place away from the tourist areas. It's got all kinds of NY memorabilia on the walls. And they do deli style food. But the also do really good bagels! Get them with cream cheese. Or stuffed with something you like. The guy at the counter was great, answering questions and making suggestions. Totally enjoyed the experience and the bagels. read more

See all

Got bagels again recently from here and really disappointed this time. Unlike first time, were bagels with pillowy, light, and full of seeds. These bagels were pretty doughy. Bagels were dense, and not fluffy at all. They are generous with putting seeds on them as I get everything and sesame. But my bagels looked like they were plain. The service was fantastic, people and ambiance is cool. read more

Tiny little shop! Got a dozen bagels, fair price great flavors! Everything bagel was good amount of salt. Soft chewy bagel kept wanting more! Server was friendly wealth of info. Would be back. read more

Where O Where have you been ?? All this time it was just around the corner from my home away from home Disney!! Tucked in a little plaza is this true gem of a Bagel/ Breakfast NY style spot that you don't want to miss. Super Cool Ambiance filled I mean filled with all the true NY nostalgic moments in Sports. The tables and walls are covered with so much to look at and read. Very neat! But the main star of the show here is the bagels and cream cheese! Delicious! Everything a bagel should be plus the cream cheese! The hubs ordered a Bacon, Egg and Bagel on an Everything Bagel with a side of home potatoes. He hasn't stopped talking about it - that's how good it was! Everything Bagel Toasted- w/ cream cheese on the side 10/10 - perfectly toasted! The seasoning on the exterior of the bagel was amazing! And the cream cheese was absolutely perfect in consistency- not too thick just right. Bacon, egg on an Everything Bagel- 10-10 he can't stop chattin about it! Lol Enjoy and thank me later! read more

See all

Great tiny New York style bagel shop that has a bigger than bagels menu! Friendly staff- quick service but quality food. I had a whole wheat bagel with Olive cream cheese- creamy creamy cream cheese with a great olive taste with chunks of olives. Reasonably priced for the current economy. My husband ordered a bagel sandwich- raved about the taste stating he loved that they fried the egg. Can't wait to go back. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Specialty Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

A lady at the dog park brought a whole variety bag for all of us this morning and a tub of cream cheese and then am not a fan of bagels but this was really good. Outshines other bagel spots for sure! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I've ordered from this place a couple times and OMG SO GOOD! We got a couple random dozens, veggie schmear, salmon schmear & one other kind, maybe fruit? They lasted in the fridge & were very soft & chewy, perfect texture. It (to me) was a very reasonable price given the quality of the food. I don't have much to say about the service or atmosphere as it was uber eats, but I'm sure they're great! read more

Great bagel shop behind Disney. All sorts of bagels, all of them pretty good. I do have to say, they do add a fee for any payment via credit card. The breakfast burrito is incredible! They have some tables inside and some outside. Depending on the time of the year, it is nice to be outside, since inside it is always packed. read more

The variety of bagels is amazing. They clearly are from New York and the bagels, don't disappoint. They are so fresh, that even without toasting, they are soft to chew into. Ahhhhhh! The location is quite quaint (small) so it does get packed, as just a skip and a hop from Magic Kingdom's cast parking lot. They service is quick, however, and the wait - minimal. I had to have the rainbow bagel - and the maple walnut cream cheese - DREAMYYY! Perfect spot for a great NY sandwich and bagels to go! Loved it and will return! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Rainbow bagel! When you say "cream cheese," they mean it!! - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I live in Tampa and we came to Disney so I Finally was close enough to try them . Boy do I feel like I'm back in Brooklyn eating these bagels . They have to be the most delicious bagels I have tried in Florida that taste like home . Everything was delicious. Love they have rainbow cookies and the black and white cookie if you know you know . The cold brew was also delicious. It was so good that we are going back the next morning to take bagels back to Tampa . If you're in the area and looking for delicious NY Bagels this is the place . We also got the crumb cake so yummy . The staff were also great and soo friendly read more

See all

Located about as close as you can possibly get to Magic Kingdom, this New York bagel spot has actually good bagels. No thin, not weak on cream cheese. This are good sized bagels with solid flavor. The loaded fries were good, we might not get them again but they were worth a try. There is ample seating indoors and out and nice, quick service. read more

See all

Ordered from here while visiting Orlando via Uber Eats for breakfast-solid bagel spot. The bacon, egg and cheese bagel was the standout favorite and very tasty! The sausage, egg and cheese bagel as well as the coffee were also good. Ordering and delivery process was super easy. Nice option to have when traveling! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Sausage, Egg, & Cheese Bagel, Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Bagel and coffee - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

The inside is quite small and cramped, so I wouldn't recommend eating in. We went on a Saturday morning around 9:30 and there were only a few other people in line. The lady at the counter was very friendly, and our food came out quick and piping hot. We both tried an egg and cheese sandwich, one with bacon and one with sausage, on an egg everything bagel. I had never had an egg bagel before. I was told it would be softer and a bit sweeter than a regular bagel, but honestly I found no difference in the flavor and was slightly disappointed since it was so talked up. The sandwich was good and the bagel was good, but I've had better bagels and better sandwiches elsewhere. read more

See all

Stuff a Bagel is our local bagel spot for authentic NY bagels. This is family-owned location that also has another shop in Naples. This has really been where we come to get bagels or breakfast. It has been gaining more popularity, and I have heard more people talking about it. This location is in Winter Garden, very close to us. It is also directly across from the cast member parking lot for Magic Kingdom. I do think this is a great location, grab breakfast or lunch and head into work. They do offer a discount for Disney Cast Members, which is great. They are very small, with only a few tables inside and a couple outside. Most people tend to get it to go, which we always do. We did eat here once, but honestly, it is so busy, it feel very crowded if you are sitting down. They do serve breakfast and lunch. They are not open all day. Their food is very similar to a bagel shop you would find in New York. They are truly some of the best bagels I have ever had. They really do have a great variety as well including your classics, pumpernickel, salt, rainbow, everything pumpernickel, and more. I would say there are about 20 different flavors. If you are going more towards lunch time, there might not be every flavor available to you. We have been here a few times and usually come on the weekends. I do honestly forget that they have lunch and am going to try and go there when I am working at home. It is much better food options. MY husband usually orders the Lox Deluxe, which is basically a lox bagel but very good. He also enjoys the Veggie Omelet, which has 3 egg whites, assorted veggies, Swiss cheese and a whole wheat bagel or whichever bagel you want. The last item he really enjoys is the breakfast burrito which has 2 scrambled eggs with peppers, onions, sausage and cheese. I usually order the same thing - pumpernickel bagel with cream cheese and bacon. This is my favorite combination for a bagel. If you want your bagel toasted, you do need to let them know, it is not automatic. Overall, this is a great place for a quick breakfast or even a lunch. The line is usually long, especially on the weekends, but the staff is so great, they are so friendly, they are quick, and you never end up waiting long to order or to get your food. I love that it is family owned as well! Their coffee is great, continuingly making fresh coffee. I highly recommend stopping by. read more

See all

After hearing so many good things about this spot, after trying it today, I'm happy to say it did not disappoint one bit! Super friendly staff working, loved all the NY memorabilia and the bagels were absolutely amazing. After trying a few different bagel spots in the area, I can say that this is hands down our favorite. read more

I love Stuff A Bagel's New York style bagels! The photos of New York always make me feel like I'm back home. The staff is warm and friendly as well! read more

just perfect. The food, the service, and the ambiance, mind blowing. Tastes like homemade. Thank you. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Frank the Tank bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Horrible experience beyond disappointed will never be back. Do not recommend go to Jeff's Bagels you will get your moneys worth and it will be their pleasure!!! Drove out of my way for my order time to be changed and then canceled. Never again! read more

The best bagels a NY-born girl has found in the south! Perfect texture and their toaster is magic if you eat yours in store. Salt is my favorite! read more

Nothing like a morning Bagel here in Winter Garden! Really on of the best places in Orlando to get an authentic NY bagel... service is always excellent, and we love the options for bagels and cream cheese, plus any breakfast sandwiches! Our favorite definitely is the memorabilia of the NY sports teams, the posters on the wall, the cool items, and just the vibe of the place! read more

See all

So glad I found a bagel place that is almost tastes and feels like from NY! Ambience and staff are straight form NY and first place in Florida I found my favorite..egg everything. Be sure to Tell them to toast your bagel or they won't. They need to fix their menu board. Prices are all outdated. Otherwise, it's clean, and great food! On a Sunday get there early if you want the bagels you want. They were wiped out around 11 when I went. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Authentic NY bagel shop frequented by Disney cast members (it's right across the street from the cast member parking lot). I love I can get Taylor ham there (NY name is pork roll). Thumbs up read more

Flavors straight out of NY! Amazing taste and customer service! Outstanding menu options! Every taste reminds me of NYC!! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Turkey egg and cheese with extra butter and extra mayo. Asiago bagel egg and cheese with mayo and butter! - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Small location in a strip mall. Saw an online reel of their special Italian cookie cream cheese and needed to try it. Staff seemed rushed, not overly attentive and I was the only one in line. Ordered a toasted bagel with the Italian cream cheese which was about $5. The bagel wasn't toasted or even warm and the cream cheese was very basic with minimal Italian cookie flavor. We are not from the area and had driven out of way to come here, so quite disappointed. Will likely not try again. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Chocolate chip bagel with rainbow cookie cream cheese (Wasn't toasted as ordered) - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

10/10 bagel place in FL! I was recommended this place by a friend and it didn't disappoint! I ordered the Ham & Cheese Melt on an Everything Bagel and t was delicious. I asked for a cup of water and while they don't do cups of water, they gave me a water bottle instead without a charge. Staff were also super nice and the speed was efficient during my lunch break. Overall, great experience and food! Will be back! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

TL;DR As close to a New York bagel as you're going to get! Family atmosphere. My son took us here having hear how legit their bagels are, and they are legit. Freshly made daily. We all had bagels with eggs, cheese and sausage which were served quickly. They are delicious. The right taste and right amount of chew. Michelle waited on us and treated us like family. My son mentioned he was still hungry after his bagel so Michelle brought us a slice of lemon cake and a cinnamon roll, gratis. They have Coke by the can. read more

See all

Great egg sandwiches and their bagels are large and fluffy. Cannolis aren't bad either!

Genuinely perfect. The service was so kind, and friendly, the food was amazing, the vibes, music, etc are great, its actually perfect.

I would rate the bagels and cream cheese a 5/5. All the flavors were great and the jalapeño cream cheese was the best I ever had. The pastries were a 3/5. They tasted like pre-packaged, store bought pastries. Definitely go for the bagels though. This would be a convenient place for Disney vacationers to get breakfast before going to the park. read more

See all

This place is very trashy food is junky a lot of pest seen. I don't recommend I rather the drive to Jeff's bagel run.

This small bagel shop stuffed with NY memorabilia is located just North of the Magic Kingdom Cast parking lot. It's a popular place so expect a line depending on what time you go. There are about a dozen bagel flavors as well as a list of traditional bagels sandwiches. My son got the La Guardia which is a white fish salad on a bagel. I wanted a full breakfast so I got the Mario Special which is a bagel with butter, two eggs, cheese, breakfast meat, home fries and a coffee for $10. I got an onion bagel, toasted (you specifically have to ask if you want it toasted), scrambled eggs and sausage. I don't like coffee so I got tea. The food is really good and the bagels are crunchy on the outside and soft in the inside. It's also a filling breakfast. The reason I didn't give them 5 stars is the first time we went, it was pretty crowded, with all the tables full, so we got our breakfast to go. When we got home, my breakfast was missing. I tried to call the restaurant and a recording said the mailbox was full and no one answered. So, I had to drive all the way back and then was able to get a replacement. Also, the only tea bags available were Lipton, which aren't great but I'm pretty used to that. The second time I just brought my own tea bag and asked for hot water (yes, I am that person, LOL). read more

Stuff A Bagel - Mario Special - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Love this place. Service is fast and the bagels are real. They taste exactly like they're from the north east. The ambiance is great and they actually spread you cream cheese (unlike the inferior Jeff's bagel run). They have true bacon egg and cheese sandwiches (for some reason rare in Florida). Highly recommend and the hype is real. read more

Update! I went back for the Jersey Turnpike! I just love Taylor Ham! I will say, my Jersey-born roommate makes the Taylor Ham a little crispier than they do here on this sandwich, which I think is my preference. But I got it on an everything bagel, and you bet I'll be back for more sandwiches here! read more

See all

I was impressed how cozy this place was. I was expecting just another strip mall counter place, but the decor and vibe is great. I just had an everything bagel and coffee, and both were excellent, and inexpensive. There are a wide variety of bagel sandwiches and other creations, plus house-baked pastries. I'll go back for lunch and check them out. Kudos for offering good coffee in three varieties (Colombian, world blend, and decaf) and providing add-ons for free at the coffee counter, rather than creating a bunch of milk and sugar-infused concoctions and charging three times as much! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Exterior - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Honestly, one of the best places I've been to here in Orlando. I have been craving an egg everything bagel and a really solid bacon, egg, and cheese since I moved here. I'm born and raised in NY. I loved the decoration and the vibe this place gives off and the staff service is amazing as well!!! The staff go out of their way to make you feel welcome and are so incredibly sweet. 100000% if you get the chance please go here. read more

See all

Quick friendly service. Bagels were fresh and NY style as advertised. Lot of NY memorabilia around AJ it's very inviting.

We originally hail from Bayonne, NJ, super close to NYC. We haven't even attempted a bagel yet in the seven months we've been local to the area now, not til I came across this store in passing somewhere online. This place is so NY Metro area, they have Taylor Ham. If you don't know what that is, it's a Jersey thing, and the superior breakfast meat. Look it up and if you come here, give it a try. I got an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, it was so, so good. The team was friendly and very helpful. We will return many times! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Chill out with the cream cheese it's actually insane. Maybe buy the chef a knife instead of an ice cream scooper for the cream cheese

After supporting this establishment since the first day they opened, I regretfully, have to leave this review. From what I understand, they are under new management and have charged me a fee for requesting EGG WHITES ONLY! I can't imagine why I would be charged additionally for OMITTING something. I am not adding anything. I calculated my expenses for this year alone and have spent over $700 at Stuff-a-bagel this year 2025 and they charged me $2.79 to request egg whites. When I called, I was told the store is under new management and this was the store's choice. We have met the previous owners many times and they are from the same town on Long Island that we were from. Just for the principle, I will need to find another breakfast spot. Sorry Stuff-a-Bagel. I am more hurt than you know. read more