Brother Joe&#x27;s Pizza

Came initially because the kids won a gift certificate for this place, so we thought we would try…read moreit out. Came back again because everything from the service to the cute eating area to the Detroit style pizza was exceptional! Definitely recommend trying it out!

My partner and I were in town to go to Hershey park. I wanted a good sandwich, my go to an Italian…read moreSub. We saw this restaurant on the map and we had to try it out. When I say this sandwich was good. No complaints. It was a nice mom and pop shop. They can never go wrong! The lady who took our orders was sweet and patient with us :). We took our food to go but you can smell the food being cooked. *chefs kiss* My boyfriend got the Bacon cheesesteak (he said it needed a lil more cheese, other then that he ate the whole thing), my sandwich was the Italian sub, lettuce pickles, mayo, banana peppers, pepper, that was the best sub everrrrrr.

Palermo's Pizzeria & Italian Family Restaurant

Italian Sub

See all

Outdoor seating

Piazza Sorrento

4.0(430 reviews)

3.3 mi

Roma was our server. She was so friendly, and perfectly attentive…read more Complementary bread 10/10 Really good bread, and came out nice and warm! Caprese 10/10 I got the side portion, which was three huge slices of tomato and mozzarella. The tomato was super fresh and perfectly ripe- not too hard and not too soft. The mozzarella was fresh and delicious. The amount of oil and balsamic was perfect. Even though it was a side portion, it was definitely something that could be shared between two people, if you're trying to save room for your meal! Chicken parm 8/10 Chicken was tender and juicy. The breading had a good flavor and was fried super crunchy. Pasta was cooked perfectly, my coworker just wasn't a huge fan of the flavor of the red sauce, and how overly crunch the breading was, which is why he gave it an 8. Chicken piccata 9/10 Sauce was yummy. Risotto was delicious! Stuffed shells (Tuesday special) 9/10 Shells were cooked great. The sauce had a good flavor. The cheese was also a good flavored blend and kept its shape even when you cut the shell, I just personally would have liked it to be a touch more melty and gooey. I loved all the cheese on top too! Absolutely love that the entrees come with a glass of wine and a side salad.

Ordered take out so we could take to Hershey Park before a concert. 2 of 3 of the things ordered…read morewere incorrect. Ordered a cheesesteak...received with no cheese. Just a steak sandwich with sauce. Ordered a chicken bacon ranch wrap...there was no ranch. Bacon was overcooked, chicken was dry. Luckily the cheese pizza was made correctly. This used to be a favorite spot to go in Hershey but the last few visits have been disappointments.

Complementary bread and butter

See all

Walk up/ Take Out Counter

Palermo's Pizza of Hershey

4.2(86 reviews)

4.5 mi

My parents had lived in Mt Joy for years and had their favorite pizza shop. Nowhere else compared…read more They have since moved to Hershey. When I brought them pizza, it was always from their old fave. But since I have to drive 30 minutes, the pizza was always tepid by the time we ate. They are not ones to embrace change but today was going to be the day. Palermos's had great ratings and was only 3 miles from them. I ordered directly on the website - they advertise that it's cheaper that way - they're absolutely right. Waze bushwhacked me there and back - traffic was horrendous with families trying to get into the park. Even though I ordered with a specific pick up time, I still had a short wait. I people watched as they came in and out buying individual slices. And the pizza here? Whoa! Amazing! My new fave! I ordered a large Sicilian with mushrooms, onions and pepperoni and a side of fried zucchini. The pizza was absolutely loaded with toppings. I ordered it baked well expecting the crusty burnt cheese on the sides. There was none of that but I would definitely order it that way again. The pizza had 12 large square slices. I struggled to eat 1 1/2 slices. I think I'll order it cut into 16 slices next time. The zucchini was meh at best. It's probably not fair this far east, but I rate all fried zucchini to Pittsburgh style zucchini. This was not it. I wouldn't waste my time on it again. I can't even remember the last time I've had Sicilian pizza this good. I don't know when I'll be back in the area but next time I'm definitely ordering pizza from Palermo's.

Love their Pizza. The dough is flavorful, sauce is perfect, they dont overload the cheese.read more

Interior

Old world pizza

Palermo's Pizza of Hershey - Delicious bacon cheeseburger sub...simple yet spot on what I was looking for from a pizza shop. In house made sub rolls, are delicious!

See all

Delicious bacon cheeseburger sub...simple yet spot on what I was looking for from a pizza shop. In house made sub rolls, are delicious!

Jo Jo's Pizza and Restaurant

3.4(134 reviews)

3.2 mi

Great pizza by the slice, ready in minutes. Bonus: they make celiac-friendly pizzas too (dedicated…read moretin, knowledgeable staff). Very tasty, def worth a stop.

I'm really disappointed with the wings I ordered today. I've ordered from here many times before,…read moreand the food has always been good, so I was not expecting this. Unfortunately, the wings I received today tasted old and were burnt. I understand that mistakes can happen, but this order was very disappointing, especially since I've been a returning customer. I hope this can be addressed because I would like to continue ordering from here.

Sm Margherita Pizza

See all

Amico’s Pizza

5.0(7 reviews)

4.4 mi

Ordered pizza for delivery and it was fast, convenient and accurate! Not to mention yummy! The…read moretoppings-bacon and green peppers-were handled without a problem!

Fast and Friendly. Is not far from our hotel and picked up a couple of large pizza for my hockey…read moreguys. Good size and reasonable price. It was ready right on time and they made sure we had the plates etc since we were travelling. Staff is very friendly and you can tell they like their work. Will use them again when we are in town for another hockey tournament.

Cheese pizza

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Wings

Angelo's Pizza and Subs

3.9(46 reviews)

2.1 mi

Well, here I am again. Instead of hitting golf balls over 300 yards on average at the range, I'm…read moreriding my Harley, feeling the horses beneath me. There's nothing better than being on a real American Harley with that patented V-twin sound, riding through the countryside--wind blowing through your hair, sun beating on your skin, blue skies all around, and tunes playing while soaking in that freedom. All that riding worked up an appetite. I was driving down Route 22, coming from Indiantown Gap. Although I didn't see any Native Americans, I did happen to see two taco flags along the side of the road. Now, this was a Monday, so it wasn't Taco Tuesday--but I decided to break the rules and make it Taco Monday! I walked inside this pizzeria, only to realize I didn't see any tacos anywhere. So, I asked, "Where are the tacos, and are they actually any good?" Of course, the owner was honest and said, "I think my tacos are the best." My eyes lit up because I was eager to try them. Now, even though I'm on a pescatarian diet and don't really eat meat, I had to indulge in some lengua (and if you don't know what that is, just try it before you look it up!). He also gave me a birria taco without the dip, which was pretty much shredded beef--and well, I do not regret the decision. I also got a slice of pizza--well done, of course. Although it was a little over-burnt, the pizza sauce definitely made up for it. But bouncing back to the tacos: the corn tortilla wasn't my favorite. I normally prefer a traditional double tortilla, whereas this one only had one. However, the flavorful seasonings from the meat, the juices, and the nice sauce on the side made up for it. I washed it all down with a root beer so the heartburn wouldn't hit so hard. Do I highly recommend this place? It's a little far out of the way from Harrisburg, but it's definitely worth the drive. They have a beautiful view and plenty of seating inside. As for the bathroom... well, let's just say they are stocking the toiletries in there and it's a bit tight. But then again, the food settles well, so you don't even have to use it, if you catch my drift! That means they are washing their hands and wearing gloves while preparing the food, so you know it's safe and clean. They also have imported sodas, which is really nice for a change of pace. I definitely recommend this place for a good slice of pizza and some great tacos. I hope my review helps you figure out where you want to eat next! If you want to see more food reviews, check out my YouTube channel, B L E E.

We placed an order over the phone for the Spanako pizza, the Angelo sampler, and a green salad…read more First, the plating was sort of gross for the sampler. Everything was just stacked together in a takeout container with zero separation or any way to identify what was included. Zero utensils or napkins were provided either in spite of a salad in the order. The pizza was inedible. We picked this restaurant because of the good reviews but have never had a worse slice. The pizza left a burning taste in our mouths, so much so that we couldn't taste anything but the salt on the pizza. When we called the restaurant to ask if they could remake it, they told us this is what feta cheese tastes like (it most certainly isn't), they took zero accountability, fought with us over the pizza, and effectively said they wouldn't remake it because it was our taste buds and what if we didn't like it or a different pizza again. Two stars (up from one for service and the disgusting pizza) because the salad wasn't eventful or bad.

Cheese

Tacos

See all

Dining area! Gross!

My Way Pizza & Grill

3.9(55 reviews)

4.6 mi

We decided to finally try My Way Pizza & Grill. We've heard good things and now we know why…read moreeveryone likes it. My wife had a berry chicken salad that was massive as well as delicious. She says the sweetness of the berries and tanginess of the poppyseed dressing was a great combination to go along with the perfectly grilled chicken. I opted for a pepperoni and sausage pizza that was also very good. But the food is only part of the story. We chose to dine in and were really glad we did. You could tell that a lot of thought went into the interior design, and a lot of attention is given to keeping everything spotless. It's the kind of place that makes you want to linger and enjoy the ambiance along with the food.

Placed an order for pickup, and the service via phone was excellent. Prompt and delicious pizza…read more The food tastes so high quality and fresh. This is some of the best pizza i've had in the central PA area. I can't speak to the ambiance since this was a pick up order, but the food and service were great.

Decor

Pepperoni pizza with Daiya non-dairy cheese.

See all

Decor

Italian Pizza & Subs

4.0(91 reviews)

5.3 mi

We did it up between the three of us. Great fill your gut food that is fresh, tasty, generous…read moreportions and good value. We ordered enough for 4 and it was under $70 and took some home. Overall, all of their breads are great. We had chicken cheesesteak (comes with marinara on the side), pizza (2 slices - be sure to order the "salad" slice), chicken parm sandwich, chicken Caesar wrap, side salad and half dozen garlic knots (very very yummy). They have counter service that is very friendly.

I never announced myself that im here for a review! B L E E…read more Pizza again--one may ask for, wow. Once again, I feel like a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle, maybe Donatello, waiting in the subway to come out at night to fight crime. But I always have to sit down, be patient, and get my first bite of pizza during the day so I have enough fuel to fight through the night. As the sun began to set along the horizon of the Norfolk Southern railroad tracks, I found myself at Italian Pizza & Delight. I must say, I was delighted to pull into the parking lot because it brought back so many memories of going there with one of my first girlfriends and first loves--I'm just going to call her RJ. As kids, we used to go to high school events and then stop to get pizza and, of course, a cold Italian sub. But this time, I wasn't there for the sub. I was there for a regular cheese pizza. Of course, I asked for it well done. Let me tell you, if you've never asked for your pizza well done, you should start. I challenge you to eat it with a fork and knife--I swear it does some type of magic. With the heart of New York City in my blood, soul, sweat, and tears, maybe that's why I'm so used to the hustle and bustle, always eager to ride my bike around whenever there's no weight holding down my ankles. But let me get into this pizza. It was definitely cooked just a little below the well-done mark. However, I was still satisfied by the taste of the sauce, and the cheese was good. It's all about how it settles, and while it settled pretty well, it made me feel a bit fat, sluggish, and slow. I guess it did its job, though other pizzas I've had in the past always gave me more energy. I like pizza that gives me energy like Pac-Man eating those little monsters. The crust was pretty good, I must say. Overall, the pizza was a bit bland and I've definitely had better, but the size of the pie was big, just like a New York-style pizza. Though the sauce was bland, the nostalgia of being back there with memories of my first love, RJ, definitely made up for it. Maybe next time I want to think of her, I'll just pull right into that parking lot. I hope my review helps you make a decision on where to get your food next. If you want to find out more about me and my reviews, please search my YouTube channel: @brandenleebutler

Chocolate chip cannoli

See all

Bruschetta and garlic bread

Tonino's Pizza

3.5(102 reviews)

5.4 mi

A convenient and friendly pizza option if you're in the neighborhood. My wife and I stopped in for…read morelunch as we were passing through town. Service was fast and efficient. Our pizza was good, but a bit on the soggy side for my taste. The dining room was basic, but clean. However, it was a bit warm in there. Some more A/C would have helped.

Grew up going here and still go back. At this point I will ONLY go to this location though because…read moreit's never quite right at the progress location. Love their margarita pizza, strombolis, salads, and their chicken cheesesteak hoagies. The same guys have been working there forever and know what they're doing.

Chicken cheesesteak hoagie

See all

Large calzone.

Papa Johns Pizza

2.7(31 reviews)

3.0 mi

I need to update my review of Papa John's - because it has changed drastically! I am always greeted…read morewhen I walk in, my pizza is usually ready when they say it is (however one worker will put it ready on the tracker and when I get there, it's not ready at all), and they thank me for the tips I leave. I always order a pepperoni pizza and it's always consistently good. They're on point with the sauces ordered as well. So, thank you papa John's for improving your restaurant!!

I've been a longtime contributor to this particular pizzeria for over ten years, and not until…read morerecently, I've felt a lot has changed from the quality of the food to the service behind the counter. I'm not quite sure how the politics of the Papa John's franchise works, but it seems that there is a lot of tension and stress behind the scenes. I've never worked in a fast food environment before, but I can't imagine that it's easy to handle on a day-to-day basis. In this particular location, I used to enjoy going there on a weekly basis, but have since pulled out when I noticed the attitudes of the people working there became downright ugly to their customers. Luckily, there are two alternate locations nearby, so I've been able to get my fix from these places instead. I'm not mad at Papa John's pizza. But I am disappointed in the staff at this location.

Extra topping reveal

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

MaryAnn P.

0

1

0

11 years ago

Rude and nasty owners. They swear and yell at customers. Mediocre food at best. Don't even bother...there are so many nearby excellent pizza shops that I can't believe this place is still in business. Only after we went, someone told me they saw the cook peeing in the kitchen sink! Wouldn't surprise me. read more

Stacey C.

0

1

0

9 years ago

This place is under new management. The previous managers were terrible. The new crew is awesome. Best pizza and the menu has expanded. Highly recommend. read more

Extin L.

0

1

0

2 years ago

food is amazing very kind staff and fast great tasting food would 100% eat here again not from this area but would get from here anytime I'm in the area! read more

Michelle S.

0

31

43

6 years ago

Increasingly dissatisfied with this place. Two times in a row our order was messed up. Food is good but messing up our orders is getting old. read more

Rich B.

1

34

6

2 years ago

Great subs!!! People have complained about the service, but it's always been great for me!

Richard J.

0

3

0

12 years ago

Tried them again a yr later....Still terrible!

Brother Joe's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Brother Joe's Pizza also viewed

Gennaro Pizza

3.9

(14 reviews)

Undercooked pizza, no buona! The lady at the register comes off as mean, but that's just an Italian…read morebeing direct. No warmth there, so don't take it personally! The specials are a great price and the cheesesteak and pizza were decent for the money, just not excellent. I'll probably be back and see if we can raise the score one star.

I am so glad I stumbled upon this place, especially since it is so close to work. The subs I had…read moreare awesome, the fresh baked rolls are amazing and the owners are very friendly. I can't wait to keep trying new dishes here.

Palumbo Pizza

3.8

(27 reviews)

It's been awhile since I had pizza, I ordered online easy process. Pizza was hot and ready after…read morework to pick up. Pizza tased amazing.

Ordered cheesesteaks, a cheeseburger sub, and a pepperoni pizza. All were excellent. Called in the…read moreorder. It was accurate and made quickly.

Brad's Pizza

3.7

(23 reviews)

In my opinion the very best pizza in the area! Brad's sauce and crust are delicious, and he is…read morevery generous with the toppings. His food offerings are many and the restaurant always clean and tidy the many times I have been there for lunch.

Called in to Philly cheesesteaks and they were ready in 15 minutes. For a weekday, it was pretty…read morebusy and the ambiance seemed very chill and clean. Food tasted good, but a bit heavy on the grease.

P & J Pizza

3.4

(50 reviews)

We love their cheesesteaks. They give you so much meat at a reasonable price. I live in Florida and…read moreI'm always disappointed in the size of their cheesesteaks here. They give you half the meat that you get at P&J's. We also like their pizza. It so hits the spot. The only downside is the parking.

I love their Italian subs! Definitely recommend. Friendly service and fast. I love the easy in…read moreeasy out.

My Way Pizza & Grill

3.9

(55 reviews)

We decided to finally try My Way Pizza & Grill. We've heard good things and now we know why…read moreeveryone likes it. My wife had a berry chicken salad that was massive as well as delicious. She says the sweetness of the berries and tanginess of the poppyseed dressing was a great combination to go along with the perfectly grilled chicken. I opted for a pepperoni and sausage pizza that was also very good. But the food is only part of the story. We chose to dine in and were really glad we did. You could tell that a lot of thought went into the interior design, and a lot of attention is given to keeping everything spotless. It's the kind of place that makes you want to linger and enjoy the ambiance along with the food.

Placed an order for pickup, and the service via phone was excellent. Prompt and delicious pizza…read more The food tastes so high quality and fresh. This is some of the best pizza i've had in the central PA area. I can't speak to the ambiance since this was a pick up order, but the food and service were great.

JoJo's on 22

3.3

(131 reviews)

It's another nice day here in Central Pennsylvania. It's not the first but the second time I rode…read moremy Harley into the sunlight. Now before the sun went down. I found myself at JoJo's pizzeria. All I wanted was a classic slice of cheese, but I ended up getting the Nona pizza and of course a beautiful Coca-Cola now I sat outside as I enjoyed the chirping of the birds. I was excited to find out that this is not just a pizza spot, but it is also an Italian restaurant so as I was waiting for my pizza. I decided to also get a nice slice of tiramisu cake! Now this tiramisu was nothing like Olive Garden. It was way beyond the perfect blend of espresso and coffee notes inside of my mouth. Its everything that it should be! I sat outside and even though it was right off the highway outside of Harrisburg I felt like I was right back in Sicily. This place is very clean. The bathrooms were utterly amazing and the staff was very nice. It's kid-friendly and there's plenty of seating also plenty of parking. I highly recommend the pizza and of course try it well done. And if you haven't yet try eating your pizza with a fork and knife. Based on the location and of course, the food I'll give this place a 4.7 out of 5.

Food is good, but is has gotten super super expensive. Won't be back. Such a shame!!!read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Italian Family Restaurant

4.5

(216 reviews)

Came initially because the kids won a gift certificate for this place, so we thought we would try…read moreit out. Came back again because everything from the service to the cute eating area to the Detroit style pizza was exceptional! Definitely recommend trying it out!

My partner and I were in town to go to Hershey park. I wanted a good sandwich, my go to an Italian…read moreSub. We saw this restaurant on the map and we had to try it out. When I say this sandwich was good. No complaints. It was a nice mom and pop shop. They can never go wrong! The lady who took our orders was sweet and patient with us :). We took our food to go but you can smell the food being cooked. *chefs kiss* My boyfriend got the Bacon cheesesteak (he said it needed a lil more cheese, other then that he ate the whole thing), my sandwich was the Italian sub, lettuce pickles, mayo, banana peppers, pepper, that was the best sub everrrrrr.

My Place Italian Restaurant

3.8

(16 reviews)

We get salads here almost every week. Serve is good and the staff is friendly . The pizza is also…read morereally good

Older pizza joint, that you can tell has been around for a good while. Inside is nothing special at…read moreall. However if your looking for just good pizza then stop here if In town. I'd say it's a top 2 pizza place in Etown and the best of your looking for thinner pizza. The rest of the food is average but let's be real the only thing that really matters in life is pizza.

USA & I

4.4

(55 reviews)

I got an Italian sub. The bread was very good. The vegetables were very fresh and we enjoyed it.read more

Umm. Pizza burnt. Black on the bottom This is a continuous…read moreissue. Something is messed up. $17 for a small 2 topping pizza and it was burned. Called shop. No response or initiative to correct. You don't burn and item and not know it. They knew and sold it anyway.

Davinci Italian Eatery

3.4

(128 reviews)