Generally speaking, we get to go. Best pizza in Harrisburg, in my opinion! Love love love!

A convenient and friendly pizza option if you're in the neighborhood. My wife and I stopped in for lunch as we were passing through town. Service was fast and efficient. Our pizza was good, but a bit on the soggy side for my taste. The dining room was basic, but clean. However, it was a bit warm in there. Some more A/C would have helped. read more

Grew up going here and still go back. At this point I will ONLY go to this location though because it's never quite right at the progress location. Love their margarita pizza, strombolis, salads, and their chicken cheesesteak hoagies. The same guys have been working there forever and know what they're doing. read more

Tonino's Pizza - Chicken cheesesteak hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Got a meat lovers pizza, absolutely delicious. Price is a bit higher than most but I think you pay for what you get.

I waited longer than I expected and it wasn't my favorite pizza but it did have plenty of toppings.

Having traveled and ate pizza in many different states and countries, this pizza is 100% worth stopping for. Omw back to pgh I grabbed buf,chic slices and some pep and plain tg. My son crushed it day later and on reheat still above just good. Service was great, good crust, perfect undercarriage and a slightly sweet sauce which I like and is unique to few. (Fioris pgh area compared) 100% stop here. A Lil $$ but quality comes w a price sometimes. I will definitely grab more back in this area. Place was clean and staff on point as well. Solid 7.8 on my diverse pallet. read more

One of the best margaritas pizzas around. Good group of guys. Highly recommend for anyone looking for quality!

We have this pizza every time we come to Harrisburg and the margherita is our go to! The service is quick and we keep coming back. Thanks, Tonino's! read more

We used to enjoy the pizza from Toninos but not anymore. This has to be the worst pizza in Harrisburg. I order it with light sauce but they put extra sauce and hardly any cheese. $25 dollar pizza and it really will give you indigestion . We ate 2 pieces and threw out the rest of the pizza. I ordered 6 pepperoni rolls and they had hardly any pepperoni in them. Save your money and buy a frozen pizza ..... read more

First time ordering pizza from this location. Took it home and, WOW! I was amazed how good this pizza was! It was cooked perfectly as well. Reading previous reviews, I am shocked, but glad I had a very good experience. read more

I've eat here many times and ordered out a few times over the years. We've also have had a great experience with customer service, wait time, and the food itself is amazing! read more

Use to be our go place for pizza but no longer! Their prices are crazy high and the quality is not what it use to be. When I told the guy waiting on me about their sky rocket pricing, he told me "you pay extra for the quality". Well not me anymore- they lost a longtime customer for good! Two stars. read more

Our favorite pizza in the area. Large cheese pizza mmm mmm good. Everything they make here is delicious . read more

Tonino's Pizza - Large Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

I stopped going to Tonino's in June of 2024. I spent my youth going to Italian Delight in the Colonial Park Mall in the early 80s. Tonino makes the best pizza, always has, no matter what the place is called. I asked him why the pizzas are $25 now, he said they never bounced back after Covid and had to raise the prices. He then said that Joe Biden is a Fascist and bitched up a storm. Now that seems odd as a man of that age from Italy, surely remembers Mussolini, and how a Fascist actually behaves. Right, nOt Joe Biden. So it seems to me that four years is plenty of time to bounce back from covid, but perhaps a business owner shouldn't be spewing ignorant hateful Bullshit right before the most important election in history, as one of the candidates is, you know, a dumb rapist racist narcissist who is elderly and senile. Maybe that's why people don't go to Tonino's anymore. So if you have zero integrity, and want a great pizza, Tonino's is your place. Good people who care about other good people, leave there and take a left on 22, go about three miles, by far the best alternative. "Your" welcome read more

Toninos has always been a go to place for me for pizza or subs. However, tonight's experience made me rethink that and I may have to start exclusively using their progress Avenue shop. I should've known something was up when I called and placed my order and the first thing he said was it will be 10 minutes and we're closing in 15 minutes. Mind you this was a hot sub so it did require cooking. when I got the sub home. It was lukewarm. It was an eggplant Parmesan sub and it had no cheese on it at all and very little sauce, none to speak of, the sandwich tasted a little bit off to me and I ended up not eating it, but that could've been because of the lack of warmth, cheese, and sauce read more

No stars. Rude. Hung up on me once. The second time I called they were rude. I had gift certificates and they can shove those where the sun doesn't shine. read more

First time at this location and I must say that everything was great. Pizzas were fantastic. I purchased three different styles and everyone loved them. Cheese & onion calzone was one of the best that I have encountered. Greek salad was huge, quality and dressing was exceptional. Really really good pizza. You can tell that high end ingredients are used. Right down to the olives in the salads. Keep up the great service! read more

Just gross. Got home with the worst stomach pain ever. Service was decent when busy. Background was very busy and had to use my outdoor voice. read more

Not based on food but management. Very rude I spent about $40 on food I tried to split a drink with my two kids and the owner rudely try's to charge me a dollar for a cup. Not getting my money again much better places with less rude owners. I feel bad for the people that work here the workers are really nice but with an owner like that I could only imagine. read more

Best pizza in the greater Harrisburg area. The Della Nonna Pizza is fantastic. Any pizza you get here would be awesome. Excellent salads as well. We love to get the Chicken Balsamic Salad. Order one of those and two Nonna slices and you've got a super tasty meal for two. (The pizza slices are huge). Any of Tonino's locations provide the same high quality and delicious food. read more

I give this place an FIVE star BUT read on for an big pitfall which happened Oct. 05,2023 - #2 below. Coming from New York where from place to place you can not find better pizza. This place, Tonino's - Harrisburg off route 22, if you miss N.Y. pizza will make you happy. Often - I go into Toninos order two slices - after half an slice I ask them to make me an large pie to go. We also enjoy the pizza rolls and other foods like the calzone, stromboli, etc. It is an 35 minute one way drive to get to Toninos. There are two issues though: 1 - I have yet to identify and I will - there is an day of the week where someone there does NOT know how to make pizza and the way delicious pizza is always found there. I've been forgetting to watch - but I find it dismaying because IF you use the same ingredients - how can this be ? 2 - Now this is bad, real BAD. I ordered an Margherita pizza and an large cheese pizza. And after paying I decided I could not leave without two orders of the delicious pizza rolls. I noticed the Margherita pizza was removed from the oven given to the young lady. She went into the kitchen to add atop the tomato chunks and the basil - then returned it to the pizza guy to enter to the oven for finishing/baking. When I got home my Wife, waiting for this delicious pizza, and I both grabbed an slice of Margherita pizza and took an large bite. I then bent over nearly vomiting. Now I read people [here] commenting about SALTY - and I have experienced people being heavy handed with salt seasoning but the amount of salt on this pizza was incredible. There was no way anyone would be able to eat this pizza. At my age ... It would be 'deadly'. We examined the pizza topping to discover - the tomato chunks - were as if an entire shaker of salt was used to 'season' those tomato's. The man managing there knows I like the food there, I do feed the tip jar ..... so it was not an malicious act. The same advice on Food shows - when in the food business - taste it once in a while. And many have realized - REMOVE the SALT containers. If people want SALT they should salt it themselves. read more

I grabbed two subs at Subway and came in to get pizza for the rest of my crew. One of the guys came flying at me that we could only eat pizza in because the subs might have COVID?!? Really? I had 3 kids with me and they needed to eat. He was very rude and was apparently disgruntled that we got subs. We ended up eating in the car. He was on the phone while we waited complaining about something else to someone. Just very rude and disgruntled. I should note that we are all vaccinated and had masks on. Apparently he has no clue how COVID is spread if he thought our subs were carrying the virus! read more

Pizza is top notch! So are salads when they give you the right items you ordered. Constantly trying to up charge with chicken on your salad. Pretty sure I just got ripped off tonight as when I do the math it doesn't add up what I was charged. They never give itemized receipts which is quite fishy. Order very slow and watch them ring in the amounts and verify they are correct..... just saying. They speak gibberish back to you on the phone to confuse you so you're never quite sure if they got it right. Such a shame people have to be like this. read more

Although I'll admit that all of the components of this pizza were good, it really didn't satisfy me in the way I was hoping for. I usually order a cheese pizza the first time that I dine at an establishment. For some reason, this time I went with pepperoni. As with all my reviews of pizza, it is just a fact that how good a pizza is depends on the sum of its parts. It's how everything melds together in cheesy, saucy, and doughy goodness that determines how good a pizza is. Finding the right combination of components is far more important than just finding the best components. Dough: one of the best I've had in the area. Cooked perfectly on the bottom so that it still had a nice crispness; but not to the point that it was as dry as a cracker. The interior of the dough was denser than most, but had a great 'chew' to it. The flavor of the dough is where it was at though! Excellent dough all around! 5/5 Sauce: for me, this was a little lacking. I don't want a candy sweet sauce, but i am looking for something that highlights the natural flavors and sweetness of the tomato. Something that pops with fresh basil, and lightly accentuated with oregano. This sauce seemed to get lost amidst the flavorful dough and gratuitous amount of toppings. Sauce 3/5 Cheese: I'm almost certain they use grande,a curse standard in many pizzerias across the country. I like grande when paired with the right components. A better sauce would have made the flavor of this cheese stand out more, but it was still great. Cheese 4/5 Toppings: this is going to sound weird. The pepperoni was good. Definitely high quality pepperoni! But it completely overshadowed the whole pie. Now, maybe i dont get pepperoni pies enough, but I felt like it was too bold of a meat for the other delicate flavors. If you love pepperoni, this will be your jam. If not, this might be overboard. Overall Pizza: 4/5 Service: quick, efficient, and expedient. No frills. Placed the order, took my money, called my name. Service: 3/5 Atmosphere: a small, quaint shop that seemed clean and highlighted all the reasons people love pizza shops. Atmosphere: 4/5 Price: i believe that this pizza is made with high quality ingredients, as evidenced by its flavor. That said, the price was in line with other area pizza places. But, because the quality did seem higher than some others I've been to, I felt like the value was above average. Price 4/5 Final Thoughts: this is a solid pie. Next time i go back, i will get a plain cheese and avoid the pepperoni. The other bummer of Tonino's, is they don't have wings! That seems like blasphemy to me. As pizza place that doesn't serve wings!? Just an fyi. If you're looking for a solid pizza eating experience, this will deliver! Anthony read more

Tonino's Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Good pizza ... crazy parking lot over the holidays. Yes, the Sicilian was good and I am looking forward to getting a special Sicilian (5 toppings). I also like the Marguerita pizza with fresh tomato and basil .... so good! The only questionable thing I had on the menu was the roast beef and provolone sandwich. The meats, cheese and bread were delicious but the tomatoes were a little funky as if they had been out too long and definitely not fresh. No matter .... I picked them off and finished off the sandwich .... hopefully just an off day. Service is very friendly and I will be back. read more

Stopped for some pie, decor is that of your traditional NY Pizza house right down to the red and white checkered table clothes.cool 80s music playing in background. At lunch they have a nice selection of pizza you can get by the the slice. Speed of service is on point if your one who has a short lunch break. The pizza crust was yeasty and crisp the way I like it. Food was served piping hot. The guys behind the counter were pleasant and lunch for 5 was only $26.00. Overall great spot. read more

Tonino's Pizza - Lunch with mom - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Absolutely the best pizza in town. Margarita and grandmas lizza are delicious and our "go to" when we cant make up our mind. Great variety with pizza, Stromboli, entrees and salads. Cheesesteaks are good and the greek salad is phenomenal. Always friendly and quick service! read more

The bread they use for their subs is the greasy pizza dough kind that doesn't hold your food well. I paid $11 for an Italian with just normal stuff on it. That kind of money I'd expect a good sandwich. read more

Great individual pie!! Thin, tasty,sliced cheese so no added preserves..My husband and Dad made pizza pie in Jersey and this reminds me of Jersey! read more

Geez.... I was excited to see that this place delivered to local hotels. But the guy on the phone....wow. He kept on asking if I wanted chicken on the salad. Mind you never said the word chicken but that did not slow him down. You want chicken? I was also excited to order Veal Parmigiana but guess what... the non-english speaking dude sent me a Veal Parmigiana SANDWICH...another word I never said. Then he said they can't deliver for less than $20. I asked him to total the order and then he said ... ok. Food was not awful which explains the two stars. But then wrong stuff delivered. What a loser establishment. Now I now why the lady at the front desk recommended Bei Jing Chinese Food. Duh... read more

this place gets no stars, i got a chicken caesar salad and i got home and omg they must have poured the entire caesar dressing on the salad, it was saturated with salad dressing, way too much so i called the owner and he definitely should not be in business, he stated that is how we make them, a normal, good business man would have given my money back as i was dissatisfied. read more

I refuse to go to a place that disrespects special needs people. I witnessed this happen and I don't care if the food is wonderful, anyone who is not going to act or treat special needs adults with compassion and kindness is not worth it. Go to Subway next door. They are kind, respectful and nice. read more

Best pizza in the area hands down! The crust is thin and crispy and has the perfect flavor. The cheese is hot and bubbly and the sauce has the perfect zing. It just all goes together. Another favorite of mine is their Greek salad. It's loaded with feta, olives, peppers, cucumbers, and tomatoes. You can add a protein for an extra charge. Its always fresh and crisp! The dressing is homemade and outstanding! The kicker? The "garlic bread" that comes with it is pretty much a slice of garlic pizza!!!! So if you ever can't decide between pizza and salad, you can essentially get both when you order a salad! Just add a side of sauce to dip it in and it's complete! The staff is friendly and they move you along quickly so it's great to get in for a quick lunch/dinner or takeout. Only downside (and since everything else is so good i won't remove a star) is that they don't have a fryer. So no cheese fries which is always a favorite of mine at a pizza shop and oh I bet they'd make them good... read more

See all

Really bad communications with customers. Super rude! They also wrote down everything right for my sub but ended up giving everything wrong ! If you have any food allergies stay away from here!! They do not pay attention!! read more

Terrible pizza place. I don't normally write reviews, but I had to alert the masses on this one. I'd give less stars if I could. Rude service. Bad food. Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else. They don't even let you get a cup of tap water. You have to buy a bottle. Ok, fine. But then I received my chicken parm sub, and it was nearly completely inedible. Most of the chicken was chewy and tough (like those gross little pieces that are sometimes in general's chicken). I posted some pictures of it if you'd like to see for yourself. I had to throw most of it out and am still hungry after spending $8 on what I thought would be dinner. read more

See all

I have lived in New York City for years. I move to Harrisburg in search of a tasty pizza. I have found that place at Tonino's. Seriously some of the best pizza I have had in my life. Plain cheese-- great, Sicilian-- so good especially reheated in your toaster oven at home. Also spectacular is their original cheese steak (with sauce on the side). I did have their cheese steak with the works and it was just ok. For me, there was too much going on in the sandwich. Other great items is their stuffed pizza (ham, pepperoni, Italian salami, ricotta and mozzarella served with sauce) Although it is a tad greasy it is a nice treat occasionally. I also love their regular Stromboli. Their fresh baked breads are excellent as well. I think the reason why I love this place so much besides the fresh ingredients is the use of their tomatoes-- the San Marzano tomato. This tomato gives the food an extra zest (not spicy) to it that is uniquely delicious. The staff is really friendly with me as well. I recommend eating here wholeheartedly. For the first timers: try the sicilian slice, original cheese steak with sauce on the side (you have to ask for it on the side or it is put into the sandwich), or the regular Stromboli. You cannot go wrong. Enjoy! read more

I stopped at this place. Based on the overall good reviews. I've never left a review. But need to know. These people are NOT CLEAN. I'm big on cleanliness when I eat out. That's why I don't do it often. When they prepare the food. They use their bare hands. No gloves nothing. The bad thing is I watched them. Touch other things. There apron the cash register the credit card machine. WHO KNOWS WHATS ELSE. If cleanliness is important to you. Please don't eat here unless there is new management. The manager did the same thing. The health department needs to be notified!!! 1 star is to high. I just don't know how to remove it. This. Is. Not. A. Joke read more

This is by far our favorite pizza place in the area, and we have tried practically all of them. The Della Nonna pizza is so delicious and unique, and tonight we tried the margarita pizza which was equally as delicious! If I could eat here every day of my life I'd be completely happy. The staff is incredibly friendly and the environment makes you feel at home. Love, love, LOVE Toninos! read more

Tonino's Pizza - Della Nonna! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Forget pizza. This little secret pizza place holds the secret to world peace. This restaurant makes what may well be the best cheesesteak on the planet. Another review mentioned the fresh-baked bread, which is also used for the cheesesteaks. This bread is perfectly crispy on the outside and dense/chewy on the inside. It's hearty enough to stand up to the juicy steak, but not so much that it will eject the sandwich innards upon your first attempt to pierce it (as is the plight of the bagel sandwich). The standard cheesesteak parts are all of pretty much perfect construction, with the meat that has a good spring to it, and the same sauce that makes the remainder of the reviewers happy. Now... the something special that makes this place so awesome is that they offer this perfect cheesesteak in an even more perfect version. They call it cheesesteak with "The Works", which effectively makes it in to a supreme pizza. Specifically, they add sausage, bell peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, and onions to the mix, which makes the whole thing mind-blowingly good. I've been all over the country and have not found an equal. Honestly, I haven't even found a close second. Go try it... NOW. read more

I started coming here while working part time at Color Me Mine in the same plaza. The owner, Antonio, is fantastic and always greets customers with a smile. My three favorite menu items in order are the Regular Stromboli, the cheese steak hoagie and just a regular slice of plain pizza. Everything is fresh and so tasty! I go out of my way to visit Tonino's now because it's worth it! Also, their bruschetta is awesome, and worth a try! read more