I've never had a sandwich this good before, every bite was absolutely incredible! Service was excellent and on time for pickup. I think the faux newspaper wrapping cool, too! I'll be back for more sandwiches, because they have got so many great reviews from all my friends. read more

Came here twice on my trip to Columbus. Got the MA Kimchi Reuben and the Yo Adrian. Both were delicious and very filling. Took my order immediately and got my sandwich in less than 10 minutes. No real seating directly at the stall but there is plenty of seating upstairs on the 2nd floor of the market. All sandwiches come with a bag of chips. A little on the pricy side but good portion and good quality ingredients . Check them out! read more

I have been wanting to try this place and finally got a chance. A steady stream of people were ordering but I saw the team turning tickets quickly. Bodega Chopped cheese is the way to go. The ratio from cheese to Wagyu beef was perfect! Keep in mind it does get messy. The soup of the day was brisket chili was great just wished it had a kick and no beans. The bread is done in house which makes the sandwich 10x better! My friend saw how much I liked the sandwich she ended up ordering Paulies Pastrami. Team was super friendly to all of the guest. Even chatted us up while we were eating since we were able to snag the table right next to the stall. I suggest everyone come visit this place when they are at East Market! read more

See all

I ordered a to-go meal from Buck City Sammies and the sandwich was very good. Better than katzingers for sure. I ordered the Paulie pastrami and it rivals the quality of a traditional Cleveland style sandwich. The breaded is buttered and grilled (nice crunch) and the meat is shaved thin and has flavor. I also appreciate that they did not put too much sauce or toppings on....i am truly impressed. 5/5 will order again. read more

Buck City Sammies - Paulie's Pastrami - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The sandwiches here are huge, and even though the price point is high, they can easily be two meals. Each sandwich has very generous fillings and comes with a bag of chips. I enjoyed my pastrami sandwich sandwich - it's one of the better pastramis I have had in Columbus. We also tried the bodega chopped cheese (it was just ok) and the smoked turkey (I liked it more than I thought I would). read more

See all

Review by :Avila.Eats on TikTok, insta, YouTube Service: staff was friendly regardless of getting slammed during lunch hour rush. Wait time was quite long I can't blame them for only having two workers for such a popular spot. Ambiance/Atmosphere: being inside east market it's quite cramped in the "waiting" area. The kitchen itself seems to be clean and well taken care of. Food: Pauline's pastrami was great. Well seasoned tender and juicy pastrami Rueben with a pleasant rye bread and not overly sauced. The mountain of meat inside is a nice surprise. I'd recommend. Wagyu chop cheese was good. Juicy, flavorful, and tender the meat melted away. Perfectly chopped with the cheeses and the fresh tomatoes with the secret sauce paired amazingly. It is quite greasy and very messy but as long as that doesn't bother you it's worth a try if you're in the area. I'd recommend. read more

Love their sandwiches. Every bite, I say mmmmm! The bread is sooooo good. Premium toppings, tons of toppings. Comes with kettle chips. Great service, good food at a decent price. What more can you ask for? read more

Buck City Sammies - Carmela - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Ordered for delivery via postmates, got the Yo Adrian with salt & vinegar chips, and housemade pimento cheese & chips. Had no problems receiving the correct order in a timely manner. All of the items were so yummy. It's hard to find places serving good pimento cheese near where I live, so I was excited to see it on the menu at Buck City, and I really enjoyed this. The sandwich was tasty too, a thick layer of italian meats, tasty pesto, fresh mozzarella, the arugula adding an herby flavor not too intense, all of the ingredients just came together so well, sandwiched between those crisp and airy sourdough slices. I was pleased with my meal from this awesome eatery. read more

See all

Buck City is a solid sandwich shop located in East Market. Service is good as the guys taking my order both times were friendly and helpful. All of their sandwiches come with a bag of chips, and the ones on a baguette are definitely large enough for two people to share. I could tell that they use good quality ingredients like fresh mozzarella and better deli meats like capicola. I tried two different sandwiches, the Carmella and the Karen, and while both were good and satisfying, I wouldn't say they really hit the spot. I'm a self-professed condiment queen, so I like my sandwiches to have an ample amount of sauce, dressing, mayo, etc. and theirs seem to be lacking. I'd return but ask them to go heavier on these to suit my liking. read more

See all

I have to give Buck City Sammie's 5 stars for how amazingly they handled a mix-up. I stopped by on a Sunday around lunch before football started to grab a sandwich to go. My boyfriend was also picking up three carryout orders for his friends at the same time, so looking back, I can see how things might've gotten hectic. I ordered a chopped beef with the tomatoes on the side. When my order was ready, I happily grabbed it and drove home. To my surprise, when I opened the box, it was a completely different sandwich. I was super annoyed -- I'd been having a rough day, and this felt like the icing on the cake. It was my first time there, and I had been really looking forward to it. I drove back to East Market (about 15 minutes) in a pretty bad mood. As soon as I walked in, the two men working knew exactly what had happened before I even said a word. They immediately apologized, told me they'd make the correct sandwich right away, and insisted I pick another sandwich free of charge. I was shocked and told them they didn't need to do that, but they insisted. While waiting, I realized I'd be happy to just take the one that was made by mistake -- it would be easier for them -- and they told me to take that one too! So now they were sending me home with three sandwiches. Before I left, I apologized if I came off upset earlier and explained I'd been having a rough day. They were incredibly kind and reassured me they didn't think that at all. They were just happy I came back so they could make it right. I could've left a bad review right away, but I really encourage others to give a business the chance to fix things first. The way Buck City Sammie's handled this situation was top-notch, and because of that, I'll 1000% be back. I've already told several people how impressed I was with their customer service. Oh -- and the sandwiches? AMAZING. Super flavorful, made with quality ingredients, and huge portions. I had lunch set for the rest of the week! Can't wait to go back. read more

Stopped back at Buck City Dec 29th with some friends. Decided to try the fried green tomato sandwich with bacon. It was good. Huge. Bug enough for two people. Came with chips. As good as it was, I still think the Carmella is better. I will be back to challenge another menu item against your perfectly created Carmella sandwich. read more

See all

We had a hard time figuring out what to order because all the options looked delicious. We decided on the pimento grilled cheese because I can't say no to pimento. We ordered a side of the pasta salad which had a little kick and was really nice. Would order from here again in a heartbeat. read more

Buck City Sammies - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Huge Sandwiches with lots of fixens! The service is fast and efficient. Located in The East Market.

Let me lead with you need their 'Yo Adrian sandwich in your life. And you need Isiah to make it for you. This guy is a magician and crafted an exceptional combination of fresh cheeses, vegetables, quality meats and date I say it truffle butter for our lunch this morning. Take a look at the menu and you dimply can't go wrong down there in East Market. The venue has this awesome industrial hawker stall vibe and I'm going to return tomorrow because it was simply delicious. Give it a go! read more

Buck City Sammies - Let's do lunch! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

They know what they're doing here. There was some cheesesteak pop up that opened next to them and it just looked like an overpriced waste of time. Instead I went to Buck City Sammie's with unique flavor profiles, not your run of the mill tasting breads from Krogers or Giant Eagle but fresh bakery level breads and girthy, meaty, thick sandwiches. Prices and quality here are on par with Brown Bag Deli and it's well worth the price for the high superior quality and flavors. On the other hand if you want a cheap sandwich, with cheap quality and meats like it came from a government food pantry then go to Subway or wack ass Jimmy John's where the bread overpowers the meat. read more

See all

The sandwich is here or the Sammy if you prefer to call them that (I called them hoagies for years back in PA) are built nicely and very well handcrafted with care. It is probably one the better shops in the city at this moment when you have a craving for filling appetite. read more

Buck City Sammies - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If your a sandwich person you will need to put this spot on your list. Great local vendor located inside the East Market (the historic old trolley building). We ordered and split The Carmella for lunch. Yes half was enough for one person and it was delicious. I was sad when it was gone. Yes, the sandwiches are a little pricey, but they are worth it with all fresh ingredients and they are big. Service is spot on and the attention they make to prepare your sandwich shows. The is one both in their location but there is plenty of seating around the market. They have a large lot adjacent to the building so parking isn't a problem. I can't wait to go back to try one of their other creations. Stop by and give them a try...I promise you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Best sandwich I've had in Columbus. It was fresh and very filling. Will definitely be back.

A delicious deli choice near me? Hell yes I'll be there! Every. Sandwich. Is. Amazing. The staff is awesome. Everything is great.

Tried this place out today and it was pretty good. The service was also pretty good. The guy that helped was was Isah and he was friendly. Also being that this place is in a market it was cool that they had their own seating attached to their booth. I ordered the cheese sandwich and it was a good sandwich. I'm not a fan of Swiss cheese but I was pleasantly surprised with the sandwich. Each sandwich comes with a bag of chips and that was nice too read more

Soooo good. This place serves carefully. crafted. sandwiches. Every bite is full of all the ingredients in the sandwich. They dont skimp out on the ingredients. My husband and I shared the Carmella sandwich. It was so darn good. He's a big dude and he was full after eating half, which was a shame because we wanted to try more! We will definitely be going back. read more

Soooo delicious! Great sandwich, friendly service! Can't wait to try more sandwiches. Definitely check them out at The East Market! read more

Buck City Sammies - The Karen. Absolutely delicious! The pimento cheese and cranberry jam... yes please! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Happened to walk past this in the East Market. They have a food truck during the warmer months, and this pop-up stall through the winter (I think February.) Short menu of very intriguing sandwiches. I was interested in several, but when I saw "brisket and pimento" - oh, yeah. The Money Penny: brisket, pimento cheese, pickles, etc., on rye. Every component was good, and it came together well. Not quite five stars, because though it was a good sandwich, the size and quality weren't quite a $14 sandwich. Yummy, not amazing. And I was still a little hungry. But I'll eventually be back for other things, like their pastrami-slaw-Guinness mustard- chive cream cheese combo. read more

Super friendly. Super quick. Really tasty. BAD value. What you see in the picture was $17.00 before tip. The "Toasty Tammy" was so small... how is this "MASSIVE??" Wanted to split it... We messed up and should have gotten the flagship sandwich-- that seems to be the appropriate size. Wanted to like this place so bad. Might give it another try if I'm on the East side. But man we left hungry and broke... lunch for one is 17 dollars now? read more

Buck City Sammies - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Excellent sandwiches; a little pricey but big sized (you could split with a friend and still be satisfied!). I had the Karen (turkey, pimento cheese, cranberry jam, red onion, arugula on rye) and Yo Adrian (salami, traditional salami, capicola, house pesto, mozzarella, mayo, arugula, on sourdough) and both were so good and quite different. Service was quick and incredibly friendly. read more

Buck City Sammies - Close up of the Karen - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Should have taken a pic but I was starving! One bite and my eyes rolled up into the back of my head. Can't remember the name but it's the one at the top of the menu. BFF got the Karen. Yowza on both! Can't wait to bring my honey bunny here. read more

Wasn't expecting much from a sandwich spot but we were hungry. The sandwiches were very good. I got one of the best grilled cheese sandwiches I've ever had. Everyone else's food looked good and tasted great (according to them). Chips were very crisp, fresh, and complimented the meal perfectly. These guys have a place in the East Market as well. Looking forward to trying more menu items. read more

See all

Ordered the Carmella !!! Baguette was a 10 out of 10. Huge sandwich. A little pricey at $19 but it will feed me twice. Quality meats. Girl fixing it was very nice!!! read more

Buck City Sammies - The Carmella $19 - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've been eyeing this place up for a little while... I wish I would've tried it a lot sooner. Everyone was super friendly and the food was amazing. By far one of the best chopped cheeses I've ever had. 10/10 recommend read more

Buck City Sammies - Chopped cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I'm not the biggest sandwich gal. These Sammie's though hit the spot! I've tried them all and they've all been spectacular. Top favs. Toasty Tammy, the Karen, the Carmella, fancy gal. The special they had Kim's convenience was to die for. read more

Buck City Sammies - The Karen - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

The sandwich was really good and had high quality ingredients. The food is a little bit on the pricier side for the amount you get. Service was quick! read more

Buck City Sammies - Toasty Tammy - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time trying this sandwich vendor. Excellent! Fresh, creative ingredients make for a great sandwich. I ordered the Peggy Sue and she was very tasty! I will be back. read more

Buck City Sammies - The Peggy Sue! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Obsessed with this place! They have impeccable service and the nicest staff. The amazing food is just a plus on top everything. read more

Buck City Sammies - Paulie's Pastrami - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Super fresh, delicious, food. Kind staff. Beautiful neighborhood. Highly recommend! They have veggie options too in case that speaks to ya

$17 sandwiches- good taste and selection, though I don't think we would get it again given price for the amount of food/protein in sandwich. Waited 35 minutes for our two sandwiches. Located inside of East Market, so very cool vibe and fun place to walk around as we live around the corner. read more

Was in the mood for a sandwich. Found this place on yelp. Outside of parsons brewing. It was Tasty. Close to where I live. A little expensive but worth it. read more

Buck City Sammies - The Karen. Pretty good - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Awful. They will ONLY make the sandwiches listed on the board. Now, usually they're out of the ingredients for about 1/2 the menu. However, if there's a sandwich they make, but you don't want an ingredient (like cranberry jam), they refuse to leave it off the sandwich. Really? read more

Great sandwich spot in East Market food hall. Everything on the menu sounded good but I went with the Carmella. Shout out to whoever made my sandwich today it was 10/10, bread was toasted and tasted fresh, perfect amount of meat and toppings. It could definitely be split between two people, I couldn't finish the whole thing. First time here but will for sure be back! read more

Buck City Sammies - Carmella - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've been ordering a Yo Adrian a couple times a week for like a month now. Best sandwich ever. I ordered the sub too, but the Yo Adrian is my fave. read more

good asf honestly, scientific food engineering could not have reproduced a better sandwich ingredient ratio... perfectly toasted sourdough..... gigi approves read more

Buck City Sammies - toasty tammy - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio