After hearing Jeresy Mike's has dethroned Chick Fil A as the nation's top fast food joint, I had to come check them out. After trying the club (a TikTok recommendation) with the peppers, oil, etc...I can see why there's competition! The staff was also friendly. I enjoyed it so much I went twice in one week lol. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #9 Club Supreme - Delis Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Jersey Mike's is my favorite of the huge chains. They've been advertising a "hot Italian" sub, and I was over this way, so I tried it out. Busy at 1:15 on a weekday, end of the lunch rush, apparently. Multiple people behind the counter, working hard. Slicing the meat seems to be what takes the most time. They were professional, but not wordy. Took my order, got it going since it has to be grilled, and kept working on the rest of the orders. Counter, phone, pick up, etc. The sub came out in about 10 minutes. Fresh and hot. Loads of meats (ham, salami, pepp,) grilled onions, fresh lettuce, and tomatoes. All on good bread. Oh, and provolone cheese, nicely melted. All the flavors and textures work together really well. It's a little spicy, really not much, but enough to add some flavor. The 8 inch was enough for a light lunch for me. I would definitely get another one. I hope it sticks around and is not just limited time. Prices are decent for the quality and quality. The place was a little dirty, again after the lunch rush, they just hadn't had a chance to wipe the tables. Parking is street only and somewhat scarce, I'm sure especially at peak times. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Mike's Hot Italian - Delis Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I'm a regular at Jersey Mike's but not a this particular location. Having been out of town, we were on our way home from the airport knowing the frig was empty. So, when I spotted Jersye Mike's - I heard dinner calling. Much as my regular Jersey Mike's location, the staff at this store were friendly and efficent - and - of course the subs were excellent. We were there around 6:30-7:00 and they were actually quite busy - there were 6 or 7 subs ahead of mine, but I was still served promptly and with a smile. Food and service were excellent - consistent with other Jersey Mike's locations. read more

I love Jersey Mike's but this location... don't order delivery. I gave it one more shot because I am home sick today and, of course, my order was screwed up. How do you forget the relish on a sub in which that is your main thing? The appropriate box is checked on my order, I've checked my receipt and it does ask for the relish. I got the giant sub too. So I'd have a couple meals. All with no relish or extra pickles per my request. (Last time they didn't give me the extra pepperoni I paid for.) read more

Was out of the bread i usually like but hand wrote an apology note!.. however made our sandwhiches SOO good! We were worried about not getting our food.. however we called and they made sure to give our order to the driver even after they closed ! thank you so much read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - ##13 The Original Italian - Delis Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Customer service here sucks. I asked for toppings on my sub and get yelled at by cashier. Then she walked away and left me to bag my own stuff. Service here has gone wayyyy down hill. Recommend eating anywhere else but here. read more

Disappointing. I ordered a tuna, but should have saved the aggravation and just ordered a veggie. Tuna was a distant afterthought on this skimpy sandwich... read more

Despite being understaffed, the two gentlemen provided exceptional service, ensuring that all guests were well taken care of during a busy period. Additionally, the cook with dreadlocks prepared our food to perfection. Great job! read more

I have eaten at many different Jersey Mike's locations if you cannot already tell. The staff all get to know me as a regular at each. My order varies based on the day. What brought me to this location today was it was close to my previous meeting I had and I needed something quick before the next meeting. Therefore I went for a sub because I needed something to sustain me for that hour meeting. The #7 turkey sub is great at doing just that. #7 Turkey sub comes with turkey, provolone cheese and any toppings you choose. I usually go with lettuce, tomato, and Mike's Way which is just oil and vinegar. Along with some sprinkled oregano. The staff here put everything I like on that sub and were nice and friendly at the same time. I ate my sub in half an hour and proceeded to my next destination and yes I ran into the bat mobile like my check in said. If you need a good sub that will sustain your taste buds Main Street, Bexley has got it for you at Jersey Mike's. read more

I ordered a meatball sub and what i got was a disgusting black sauce and hard meatball sub. Ill never recommend this place to my worst enemy. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Meatball sub - Delis Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

The food wasn't ready when we arrived and the people working there were completely disinterested in anything. Had ordered a giant Gluten Free Italian on the app and instead got a regular and an upset stomach. When I got home I called to let them know about the wrong size and they wouldn't answer the phone. Won't be back. read more

I came in today (08/17/23) around noon so during the lunch rush. They were very busy but the whole team was so kind and patient and helpful. They treated every customer with care and never made them feel rushed. They were all very knowledgable and answered any question a customer asked while helping others or working on an order. Great team! Made the difference of bad and good experience. Keep it up! (And my sandwich was delicious!) read more

Awesome subs. Top quality ingredients, and well prepared. Everything was fresh. If I lived in Columbus this would be my favorite stop. It seems to me this store lives up to the Jersey Mike stance. If the measure of a sub should be a measure of the people who made it, this store must have some great employees. read more

The staff is always so friendly and they make great subs! I love how Jersey Mike's slices the meat for my sub in front of me. And I especially love getting my sub "Mike's way, no onion." The vinegar, oil and spices add great flavors to the cold subs. My only complaint is that it is often slow, especially if you get a sub that requires the grill. But it's usually worth the wait!! read more

I was on my way to pick up some wrapping paper and cards for my lovely bride's birthday today. I was wondering what to have for lunch and passing by the local Jersey Mike's, I made my choice. I don't get to have a Jersey Mike's sub very often and when I do, I tend to get a Club Supreme. I just like the way good roast beef and turkey blend. I do like one other sub place, but for differnet reason's and besides, today I was in the mood for Mike's When I discovered Jersey Mike's a few years back, I tried it "Mike's Way" and have never looked back. Jersey Mike's makes their sub's the way they advertise them. The picture on the advertisement and the way it looks when they serve it are the same. I don't know of any other sub shop where this is also true. The food today was excellent. The same way it is every time I go to this location in Bexley. I highly recommend Jersey Mike's. Service is fast. and they make it the way I like it. Extra Mayo and Mike's Way. read more

I happened upon this Jersey Mike's while at an event on Capital University's campus. I was in need of a quick bite to eat and was about to get a burrito at first but then I saw Jersey Mike's and was like shoot let me go here instead. I was not disappointed. The customer service was pretty good. They had a huge call ahead order that they needed to fulfill and while they were doing that, they worked 2 other customers and myself in and expedited our orders very quickly. They greeted us and with a smile and helped us make a decision in terms of what to get. I got a simple sandwich. A mini turkey, bacon, lettuce sandwich with oil oregano, salt and pepper on it. Let me tell you that when I say that this sandwich was freaking delicious, I am not pulling your leg. The freshness of the bread and the cold cut itself was majestic. This is the thing that I have come to love about Jersey Mike's. It reminds me of going to the bodegas back home in New York and grabbing a hero. read more

I ordered 3 subs and they got one wrong. I tried to call but they wouldn't answer and than toke phone off hook. I suggest going in and not placing any orders online. If they get your order wrong you will have to go way back over there and see if they will correct it. I dont live close so this was a big disappointment. As you know this sub joint is spread out and not in abundance like subway is. read more

Paid $10 for 1/2 of a sub. It wasn't anything special. The sub I chose came with bacon and cheese on it, but I had to tell them to put both on the sub. They did not include cheese. I get that the employees are not paid much, but they resembled zombies (resembling Joe versus the Volcano). I will not go back. read more

I work in Bexley and have no idea why I haven't eaten here before. I used to visit other locations years ago because they'll make any of their subs in a tub (basically a salad), so my bread-fearing self can eat a full meal here. Only downside is that parking is basically on the street unless you park illegally in another merchant's lot. I either go early or late during lunchtime when visiting to guarantee I can find parking. Nice people, quick service, clean interior, food is sliced/carved to order and they have a rewards program. I'm a sucker for a loyalty program! Only downside - make sure you tell them if you want a little or a lot of something. I asked for some of their cherry pepper relish on my sub in a tub and they PILED it on. I unfortunately was paying when they were putting in on there or I could've asked them to maybe take some off. My mouth was on fire the entire lunch. read more

Stay away from this location. They will mess up your order and then never answer the phone. They have often in the past ignored giving extra toppings for extra money. They forgot to deliver us an expensive sub and refused to even acknowledge us; even corporate ignored our pleas for recompense. Worst experience ever with a restaurant. They need a competent manager. read more

Advised staff vegetarian order which usually means the staff will clean the slicer. The woman was dumbfounded and said "ok". I said you need to clean the slicer(which had a lump of turkey sitting out and in it). She was annoyed and said she didn't understand, then the manager swooped in and said I'll do it! He said let me get a towel and proceeded to clean the slicer with just a dry towel. Bits of turkey was still on parts the cheese. Look I get it, the meat eaters have their cheese so the cheese still gets dem meaty chunks but at least try to fool my "I got to get food in my belly that doesn't have meat" brain. Soooo I ate my sandwich, it was late (15 minutes before they closed) but if you don't eat meat, avoid this location! Gahanna and Pickerington go out of their way to satisfy the veggie eaters!! read more

I was so excited when this Jersey Mike's opened because it was so close to home. Now I'm bummed because since it opened (2 years ago) I have either gotten an attitude when I've been in store, have had missing drinks on ALL Uber orders and missing or wrong items on all take out orders. I will return to Jersey Mike's but never to this location again. read more

Love their sandwiches! Fresh baked bread, sliced meat and veggies make for a terrific sandwich no matter what you order.

I love jersey mikes... usually. Ordered a chx parm sandwich like i get at other locations. I was dumbfounded to watch the manager put the chicken ina microwave (store was empty so they weren't busy) throws the microwaved chicken on cold bread sprinkled some cheese and wrapped it. As he handed the sandwich to me, i asked if the grill was broken, he replied "no, that will be $12.24" totally oblivious to the idea that he should have cooked it on the grill and melted the provolone, and maybe asked me what toppings i might want. Sandwich tasted like rubber flavorless chicken on stale bread. Never going back to this location since they cant bother to actually cooked the food read more

Great subs, but pretty expensive. Look up coupons online before going, you can probably find some good deals. But one get one half off etc.

Finally a genuine "Jersey Sub"! As a born and bred Jersey girl I was so sick of so-called sub shops. The breads were awful and overall so we're the sandwichs in general. I recently tried Jersey Mike's and such a pleasant surprise! Memories of home...made just right with those thin sliced sweet onions. It's the best!!! Sorry subway you don't even compare! read more

They manager is super nice and always remembers me. They all work pretty fast and efficiently. I eat there way too much but the service is always great. read more

If you place your order online and it is made wrong please do not expect them to give you your money back and if you push for them to remake it correctly it will not be done without the police having to come and make them remake it. Horrible experience and most of all Horrible customer service. read more

I went in yesterday and the customer service was terrible I walked in the cashier says shit cause she was in mid way of walking away I get to the counter to place my order the young man did not acknowledge me he continued cleaning condiment droppings from in front of him... I began to speak my order no sooner than I could catch my breath that cashiers was asking was that all I began to look at the chips for original Doritos she snappingly said we ain't got them!! She asked again is that all I said just a second I would like to watch my sandwich being prepared and the grill man turned around mumbling a few choice words at me and she the cashier rolling her eyes and smacking her lips this was a total nightmare I respectfully declined my order and left the premises in disbelief like did this just happen or was I dreaming this I called back asking for corporates number the young man began to chuckle stating 740 and then the phone hung up... Today I called again asking for cooperates number and I was told that there was no cooperate number they couldn't give me a mangers number but they could give me an email... customer service was appalling I will continue to tell my story the service was absolutely outrageous read more

It seems like there are always new people in there that have never made a sandwich in their lives. The sweet/unsweet tea canisters are never full past like 4pm and the selection of chips is awful. I find myself disappointed nearly every time I leave. It's just something about this location I guess because the Reynoldsburg and Polaris locations never disappoint. read more