I've eaten at Pepe's, Sally's, and plenty of well-known Manhattan spots, and Stone's is now the…read moretop of my list. I'm a biker, and we're known for spending $25 on gas to find a great slice. Stone's is worth the ride. Outstanding food, friendly people, and a comfortable, casual atmosphere. I'm already planning my next trip for sandwiches and a pie to bring to my brother's house. If you're traveling Route 9 through Wappingers Falls, stop here.

I'm ready to make a bold declaration: Stone's is the best pizza shop…read more Not the best around. Not the best I've found in Wappingers. The best pizza shop. Period. I know. That's a ridiculous statement to make about pizza. I'm not Portnoy, and I'm not basing it on one bite and an 8.3. In fairness, I have 10+ reps here now--eating in, taking out and delivery--and at this point I'm ready to pour a little affection on this place. Stone's is just it. Want an exceptional plain slice? It's here. Want some of the best wings you've had from a pizza shop? They're here--and they're frying them in beef tallow. Want a carefully considered specialty slice that actually earns the right to be different? Pick one behind the glass. Want a sandwich? A pizza shop frankly shouldn't be making sandwiches this stupidly delicious, but apparently Stone's decided that was their lane too. The creativity isn't there for novelty. These guys clearly think about food. And that's really what separates Stone's for me: consideration. The dough gets a minimum 48-hour fermentation. The ingredients matter. The wings matter. The sandwiches matter. The sauces matter. The way a slice is constructed matters. There is a level of intention here that you can taste before you ever know any of that. But I probably wouldn't love Stone's this much if it were only about the food. I love the playful banter from behind the glass. I love asking about a slice and getting an answer from someone who is genuinely excited to tell you what they made. I love that on more than one occasion I've been sent home with a few tastes of something I hadn't ordered or hadn't gotten the chance to try. Those little interactions stick with you. The ownership loves what they're doing, they've mastered their craft, and somehow they've managed to make that enthusiasm contagious. There are plenty of places that make great pizza. Stone's feels like a great pizza shop. There's a difference. So, to the ownership of Stone's: keep going. Whatever you're trying to build here, don't stop. It feels inevitable that more people are going to discover this place. Watching that happen is going to be fun. P.S. -- Stone's may not know this yet, but they've developed a strangely loyal satellite market in Garrison, NY. It's basically two houses: mine and my neighbor's. We've figured out both how to make the Wappingers-to-Garrison run and, somehow, how to get Stone's delivered all the way down here. So if an order is making that unlikely trip south, there's a pretty safe chance it's headed to one of our houses. Consider us the unofficial Garrison chapter. Can't wait to watch this place grow. 5/5.

I had read good reviews about this place and we decided to try it! There is a small parking lot…read morearea, which is convenient if you can find a spot. Upon entering, I wasn't too thrilled with how the pizza looked from the display, but we decided to try the plain slice, grandma, and the pepperoni roll. The pepperoni roll was okay. The plain slice was HUGE. It definitely didn't look that big from the display. Flavor was okay. It was very thin. Grandma was okay also. I'd go back there if I was in the area and wanted to grab a quick slice. Service was good. Interior was homey and comfortable.

Me and my aunt were there today to get the large pizza slices, they were so delicious as usual…read moretoday makes my 2nd time going there, excellent pizza, the staff and owner are very friendly. I can't wait to come back

One of the best pizzerias in the hudson valley. The food is always great and the customer service…read morematches up to it. Btw they have the best garlic knots by far in the area. Shout out Vito!

Pizza time makes a great homemade chicken soup minestrone soup then pizzas are excellent…read moreeverybody's great. The owners are great. It's a great place to eat. They've been in business in Marlborough for many years good people.

Mexican pizza is the bomb. Get with chicken or just…read morevegetables You can't go wrong. Svs is excellent

They have the worst bitter sauce for the pizza. I couldn't get past how awful it tasted.read more

Classic NY pizza - no complaints. Perfect sauce flavor, perfect dough, perfect cheese, and perfect…read moredough-to-sauce-to-cheese ratio. Perfect for a sit down meal or take out dinner!

I grew up in cornwall, and this spot has always been a treasure for the town. NOTE* Prima does not…read morehave the best pizza in town, there's several spots I would go to before here (ie. Toscos, Mama Theresa's) but Prima has a charm that other spots simply dont have. Small, decorated with local clipping from the paper and cornwall spirit, it feels like stepping back in time when you eat here. Out service was great, the people behind the counter were every friendly. Their pizza was still good, but thats just it, good. Still, 4 stars for remaining the same since I was a kid!

Wonderful pizza, pasta and more. One of our faves! We usually pick up ourselves, but we…read moreunderstand that they do deliver as well.

This place is a major player in the pizza scene of the southern Dutchess area…read more Who knew, you could find Brooklyn pizza in Dutchess County. I don't think the owners are even aware they make good Brooklyn pizza. They're just eager to please their clientele. They offer a broad variety of pizza combinations and the talented pizza slingers will create a pie to suit your taste with any combination from their arsenal of flavorful toppings. The pizza is on point from first bite to crust, also there is nothing disappointing about their menu from appetizers to entrees... WELCOME TO FLAVORTOWN oh I meant Florina's. They put most of their effort towards the menu rather than decor. The place is a simple pizzeria decor and exceptionally clean. It's a 4 table establishment and the locals know it, so they pump out massive amounts of deliveries and pick up orders. Their pride is proven in every bite. It's road trip worthy and if passing through it's a must stop by. YUMMY TUMMY!

I love the pineapple pizza. Nice people and clean places. I remember when I was 14 coming hereread more

Heard locals raving about this place, tried it, unimpressed. As someone raised in the city, I have…read morecome to learn that pizza recommendations are to be taken lightly in dutchess. Someone told me this was the best pizza they ever had in their live, and they constantly rave about it. I was SO excited, because finding good pizza up here is hard, so I ordered pickup (they don't deliver). It was so subpar. Chewy. Too much seasoning that overpowered it. Really unimpressed. Maybe I just caught a bad day, but not what I was expecting.

Grabbed takeout while in the area. Calzone was large and tasty. Everything was prepared quickly…read moretoo. Prices were as expected for a pizza place. Would order again!

my food cost 19$ never signed a recipe when I picked it up and they charged my card for 22$…read more... they tipped themselves.