First time here. This is good food. Nothing great but good food at a fair price. I really enjoyed the pie. Reminds me of the pizza I ate as a child. The meatballs were good and the sauce was nice. The cannoli were not too great. Kind of soggy and not real flavorful. read more

See all

INCREDIBLE FUSION!!! Not only is it the best pizza on 9W for several reasons including: large slices, creative gourmet slices, fresh ingredients BUT ...TACOS?! Under new ownership and the owner knows what hes doing! You gotta try the GODFATHER slice and STEAK TACOS!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Really great service here, the women at the counter was so nice and made the trip here just interesting itself while i wanted for my food and was sure get my order down perfectly and made sure my large order was packed up for easy transport and made me feel valued as a customer. Buffalo garlic knots were great, never had a spicy buffalo sauce on knots, but I have said it was pretty good and the knots themselves, sightly doughy, but not too tough to chew. spaghetti with meat sauce, now that was something, usually it's just a plain tomato sauce, but here it's a cream tomato sauce with plenty of parmesan cheese as well, and pasta was very al Dante, my favorite, also plenty of ground beef mixed in, not just handful dropped on top. Scillian slice had plenty of tomato sauce was great and crust was just right, not burnt or undercooked, plus a nice touch I noticed was minced garlic on top of fresh melted mozzarella, always appreciated with little extras added for flavor. Very welcomed herb focaccia bread given with dinner which way better than just a simple bread roll with garlic butter toasted, like other places, the bread was very good. Now last the zeppole's brought back all great memories of fried dough from the fair, lightly sweetened and sightly chewy. wish had a chocolate dipping sauce them though, since it would put it over the top. Overall, well done, with my two-day feast I got here. Great food and Service. read more

See all

Ordered from them the first time today, the delivery came quickly and the driver was polite. I ordered chicken parm which was great and mozzarella sticks which were lack luster and the salad was kind of sparse. For quick order on a job site it I'd order again maybe just sub next time, the service was quick and efficient but expect a bit better for having spent $31 on the meal read more

See all

Pizza is Excellent!!!! The Best around! Perfect crust done every time! If you haven't tried it your missing out!

Food is great but as of the two times we've ordered the wrong pizza has come, twice. We were still charged even though last week we got the wrong pizza aswell, we still tried to tip the guy and my grandma told him to wait and he drove off.. read more

My favorite restaurant without question! The food is consistently awesome! Make sure you get the garlic knots!!! read more

great food, workers are very kind, fast delivery. The owner is very kind and thoughtful and is a very good cook. I am very happy how the food always turns out. I recommend there heroes 100% the best around here and for how much you get, the pricing is very reasonable. When you come in person there is basically a secret menu because they have so much more than what is on there website. read more

AMAZING!! Great pizza, Great Sauce, Great pepperoni rolls, perfectly made cold subs, and above all Great Customer Services!! They are so kind, so pleasant, super polite, and generous. I couldn't be happier with the gentleman who run this place, their services, and their food. Well done! read more

The pizza is the best but today I ordered hot wings with extra ranch and cheese fries. The wings looked like fried rat turds and the cheese fries sucked and were bland. What really sucked was that they gave me two spoiled ranches. I didn't know this and tasted it and immediately had to run to bathroom to vomit. Fucking disgusting. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Spoiled ranch (it's not even white ) and fried fat turds. I mean wings. Gross. Threw up and threw away. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I hate to be the first to write a bad review but somebody has to do it. So, I ordered sausage calzone, chicken calzone, pepperoni slice and a plain cheese slice. Everything else was absolutely terrible besides the chicken calzone. Both slices had weak sauce, thin saggy crust and not enough cheese. The sausage calzone fell apart. The chicken calzone was a surprising 4/5, considering everything else sucked. I don't recommend this place! read more

My husband and I are here atleast once a week, Danny is wonderful and so is the rest of his crew! Even the other "regulars" we've started to know are the best. Always a fun spot to stop in quick for a slice and their bite-sized garlic knots! Feels like going to your cousins for lunch. Five stars isn't enough. read more

Awesome pizza!! Try the Brooklyn with broccoli raan and sausage one of my fav combos!!

I have to say I'm really impressed with this place. The beef patty was flaky, flavorful and had a good amount of beef. I loved how they put the fried dough in a paper bag and NOT a container. Because warm fried dough in a container causes condensation on the top of the container which turns the sugar into a paste. This is one of those places that you try and know it will become a place you will always be happy ordering from. Check this place out. read more

One of the worst pizzas I have ever tried. I would say to stay away from this place to anybody I know. Piece of cardboard. Wasn't fresh at all and pretty much tasteless. On top of that all of us ended up with upset stomach. You have been warned! read more

Just ordered a chicken wrap. Asked for sautéed onions I got raw. The chicken was dry and had a very weird texture ... the guy at the counter was rude as hell when I asked if the wrap came with fries ... which apparently it didn't .. awful experience today. read more

I worked here for about 2-3 months as a pizza maker and left because another job presented itself. I've worked in pizzerias for 7+ years and from first hand experience I can tell you that this establishment uses only top notch ingredients in their pizza. Everyone is very polite and welcoming in the store and service is excellent. As a former employee I would fully recommend stopping in and plan on doing so myself. Check em out, owner danny is a good dude. read more

Stopped in for a couple of slice while driving past on 9W. Very tasty NY styled pizza, nothing fancy but good. Sometimes you just want a solid plain slice, and they have it here, and the chicken parm slice was also quite good. Had a side of zesty tomato sauce for dipping, which was the icing on the cake. I see on their menu they do a few seafood pizzas, which nobody in Newburgh does for some reason, so I'll be coming back and ordering one of them! read more

First order and it is fantastic. Fried calamari pizza very tender and tasty. The buffalo knots are also a nice take on an old favorite! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Fried calamari pizza and buffalo knots! - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Atleast it wasn't burnt. I forgot why I haven't ordered from here in over a year. Like one other review said, the sauce tastes like absolutely nothing. read more

Love this place! We're regulars.. great pizza & absolutely love the buffalo knots! Delivery time is always reasonable too. Definitely one of the better pizzerias in the area! read more

The owner n staff are very friendly n accomidating!! Always a good experience with a delicious variety of food!! I live close by this is my go to spot n 1st choice!! His brooklyn sandwich is to die for!!! check them out, they are good people running a clean establishment!! read more

I'm now halfway done with the taco pizza, which I got at the Newburgh location. Quite disappointing, and a waste of money. It doesn't taste like taco; it doesn't taste like pizza; it doesn't taste like anything in between. It seems to lack any seasoning at all, is very soggy, and there's nothing to hold the ingredients on the pizza. Barely a dribbling of cheese. It is the sloppiest pizza I've ever tried to eat. Is the Newburgh restaurant under new management? Doesn't seem as friendly as the last time (which was my first time) I was there. The pizza I got here about a year ago was quite good. read more

If you like pizza and you like to taste buds and please don't order from Brooklyn's pizza. I tried it once before I had a regular slice of cheese and I was like this is kind of basic I could make this at home. I decided to brush it off and didn't think about it too hard and I recently ordered it from there again and this time I got a whole pie and it was absolutely terrible I cannot believe I spent my money on this I will never be buying pizza from there again I mean the service is decent. And the people are decent but the quality of food is just not there taste like nothing in my mouth taste like the most basic ass pizza I ever had in my life even the school lunch pizzas was better than this oh my gosh I'm sorry but you know you get one star. You guys better step up your game even though you're right down the street for me LOL I'll travel very far to get a decent slice of pizza you guys are in a prime location you should make use of it if you're reading this you should really make use of that prime location no wonder why if I was empty when I pass read more

Stopped here between wineries. Good sized slices at reasonable prices. Good soda selection for an old place. Service was quick and friendly. read more

My family orders from here on a regular basis, the seafood pizza and margarita pizza are delicious, the service is good, the staff are always friendly. Give it a try you won't be disappointed. read more

We stopped for pizza while driving from Jersey to upstate New York and it hit the spot. The crust was thin and perfectly cooked and the ingredients seemed very fresh. If we lived in the area this would probably be a frequent pizza spot for us! The owner (I imagine) gave us a container of buffalo knots on the house for having waited a few minutes extra (no biggie at all) to get our pizza. They were delicious, we would have placed an order for them had we known how delicious they were! read more

I order from here frequently. Definitely some of the best pizza in our area and they have great calzones as well. Only ordered dinners to go twice. One time it was good. One time it was just ok. Always friendly when at the restaurant and keep coming back for the pizza! Definitely must try! read more

I really like the food and pizza at this establishment. Food always consistent and fresh. The people and owner always welcome me. Never had a bad meal and look forward to eating there again. Check this place out read more

I'm always in this spot for some chicken rice soup. They're never short of my lemons. My favorite pizza is the taco pizza, it's to die for! The key with this lovely creation is the crispy crust... Yuuummm! One more key item, the buffalo garlic knots are necessary! If you're in the neighborhood give it a try, you don't regret it! read more

My son can only eat at a few pizza shops because of his allergies. Brooklyn Pizza owner Danny has good "big pizza", as my son calls it and the best garlic knots in the area. The service is speedy, they deliver and there's no shortage of laughter inside the shop. read more

Excellent food. We order all the time for delivery. Fast, friendly and very good serice. Pizza is great. Don't hesitate!!

Incredibly rude. I placed an order through Grub Hub last night, while the restaurant was still accepting Grub Hub Orders( I checked) . We ordered a fried calamari appetizer and a mixed cold cut hero. We knew the transaction was pending on my husbands account, because he checked. Needless to say, the order did not arrive. After I placed the order, a severe storm blew through and I figured they were running late. We never got the order. I called today, figuring there'd been a mix up, maybe because of the weather. I was willing to take the order today, because it was paid for. The young man behind the counter insisted he hadn't received the order, I didn't see how that was possible, because we could see the transaction on our end. He said he had to call his boss. A few minutes later, his boss called me, incredibly, loud, rude, and on the defensive. I told him I didn't like his tone, he told me he didn't appreciate the way I was "coming at him" (his words", and how I "came at" his employee. I told him I understand people are stressed right now. He told me he didn't need my $24.81, and take it up with Grub Hub, and before he hung up I could hear another male in the background telling him to hang up on me. I swear, I wasn't looking for special treatment. All I wanted was either our order or a refund. Grub Hub took care of me, cancelled the order which was still active, and refunded the pending transaction. We were good customers there, we've been trying to do our part to help small businesses, I enjoyed their food, but I'll never do business with them again. All for a sandwich and an appetizer sized order of calamari. I wish I hadn't given it the one star I gave it. read more

This place has always given me a welcoming feel and the workers have always been so sweet they have the best customer service that i have ever had read more

This place is a joke. They deliver your food and the delivery kid ads on to bill to pocket the money besides tip. When you call to complain they laugh. read more

Been looking for a #1 pizza joint lately and think I found it close to home. We stopped in this past weekend to give it a try. Ordered it to go and waited while it was made. Ordered a simple large cheese pie, personal Stromboli and a canolli. The stromboli was excellent, large, meat and cheese filled... nice! Good NY style pizza that can't be beat and the canolli was good as well. Very unassuming location but the food was good so don't let looks deceive you. read more