Yesterday night my friends and I came here for karaoke, the food was ok and the drinks were pretty good!! Everyone there was fantastic employees and customers. Everyone had a blast when karaoke started! They would have got 5 stars but due to some accessibility issues they get 4. I use an electric wheelchair and I have a service dog (German shepherd for preference) who was thankfully not with me when we went because of the fact there wasn't a lot of room, I felt bad asking people to move their chairs so I could get past. My Sd wouldn't have fit in the bathroom because I couldn't shut the bathroom door, I had to pull up completely next to the toilet to fit, a normal wheelchair would have had a very difficult time getting on the toilet with that set up. I have medical tubes and bags that I empty hence why I said normal users. I felt bad because I had a hard time turning, their bathroom is small. read more

See all

We shared a cracked bacon burger. Juicy and delicious. Together with the fries it's more than enough for lunch. The burger had lettuce, tomato, a generous serving of bacon and American cheese. The fries were okay, they could have been hotter and crispier. They were short staffed, the bar tender, taking over the waiter job and did a good job. Our group of 6 were the only ones there, so it worked out just fine. read more

My husband and I shared the cracked bacon burger. It was juicy and delicious and 1/2 of it was more than sufficient for each of us. The large burger had a nice amount of bacon, some lettuce, tomato and a slice of American cheese. I took off a star because the fries, while generous, were not crisp or hot. Our waiter said they were short-staffed, but our party of 6 was the only party there, so our service was just fine. read more

Looked promising from the outside. The closer we got, the more I doubted my decision. No accessible ramp visible at the front door. Upon entering, hit with the stink of cigarettes and mold. We made our way past the front bar to another bar further back and finally the "dining" area. The limited menu had several items struck through with marker. The food was not too bad, but the place needs a lot of work. read more

Came for a dinner with mom the other day and it was pretty good. The food was just okay just bland it needs more spice or flavor or something. Drinks were cheap enough and have a decent selection. Their out door patio is pretty cool a nice place to hang out and watch sports or relax a bit. Service was surprisingly slow for how busy they weren't but we had the time so it's okay. Overall it was pretty good nothing special read more

Buffalo Creek Bar & Grill - Bars Near Me - West Seneca, New York

We happened to come across this place, a little weird when we arrived because you walk into the bar with the locals so everyone stares at you as you don't know where to go. Walked around the bar to the back dining area, they usually have music but this day it poured so the music was cancelled which was fine by us but good to know for future visits. Food was great, service from Darian was great, we definitely will come back again to try other options. read more

See all

Definitely upgraded since Nickel Creek. It's newly opened, so they are still getting their footing on things. Food was ok, will get better with time. The presentation was nice. Seems roomier inside now that the bar area goes on both sides. I probably won't be back for a while, but I will go back for sure. Service was ok. read more

See all

Wow! What a gem place with delicious food!! We had the lunch special large- Beef sandwich and wings!! The horseradish and blue cheese were homemade and excellent! We finished with the cheesecake Sunday!! Oh my! We hope to return! read more

Buffalo Creek Bar & Grill - Cheesecake sundae - Bars Near Me - West Seneca, New York

The girl owner really can have an attitude at times I would never go back there food was OK nothing to brag about. Never had any paper towels in the bathroom to dry your hands either. read more

Incredible food and service! We all ordered something different and we all very happy! Great giant pretzels! Great beef on weck, hangover burger and panko chicken sandwich. Highly recommend! Sat on the patio and loved it. read more

My wife and I stopped in to try it out. We always order a burger when trying out a new bar. They failed the our "Burger Test." Both ordered medium rare, both came out well done. Seems to happen a lot. Cooks today must have something against at least a little pink. Seasoned fries were ok. Slaw was in a tiny plastic cup. Beer was cold though...along with the ladies room according to the wife and the dining room floor. The dining room was really dark. I had to use the light on my cell phone to read the bill. Lol. The server was nice, but we could tell she is fairly new at it. We still tipped her well though. There is nothing there that stood out to make us want to go back. It was just...meh... read more

We had very poor service. In all fairness , there was one person working. She was tending bar and serving both inside and outside. She was pleasant but left us unattended for long periods of time and forgot items we requested Food was just ok. Not up to their usual good standard. All in all, it was enough to not make us want to return Very disappointing read more

First time here ,and I thought that it was pretty good. We had a couple of drinks at the crowded bar, and they had about 5 different draft beers ranging in price from $5 to $8. a pint. I also had a small shot of Regular Jim Beam on the rocks for like $10. ( a bit high). Another person ordered a double Patron Tequila on the rocks and it came in a pint glass with water added? We took a table with 4 other folks, and had a fine server that was friendly and knowledgeable. The food is of high quality, creative and served perfectly done. I did not think that the food portion of our meals was overly expensive, but rather reasonable! The only thing that was missed was that the specialty salad was supposed to have Parmesan fries on it and it was omitted when served. Our server was told and brought the ladies some fries promptly. We will definitely go back, but I will only drink beer! read more

Very limited menu. Liked it for my first 5 ish visits but it has not been good lately.. wings today seemed liked they were re heated and very dry and some extremely small.. I will be back but In Buffalo you better have a decent wing..consistently read more

Oh, boy. Please hire more wait staff. One waitress was in charge of the entire patio on a Thursday night, and not only was it slow service, it was inaccurate. And why is the wine not cold!? (But the food WAS?) If you want decent service with timely drink refills, sit at the bar. We won't be returning any time soon, sadly. read more

Jake S. made me Listen here pal, the jukebox system is rigged. I paid $5 for Taylor swift and country nonsense was played for hours before my song. I will dismantle this oppressive establishment board by board! I will saw the tables of tyranny in half. Gnaw at the ankles of big business! Security did let us borrow their hat which was a plus. read more

Our first time did not disappoint! Food was food, and the service was AWSOME! For a busy Friday night our server was friendly and efficient. She made sure we were well taken care of, stopping back at our table to check on us often. The bonus was there was great entertainment as well. The only criticism I have is there was a table next to us in the back corner with olde adults who were obviously " regulars" and their language was offensive dropping "f" bombs as their adjective of choice in every sentence. Unfortunately they gave up the table a bit later but stood behind us the rest of the evening. read more

Nice remodeling job inside since I was last in there some 5 or so years ago, large wrap around bar, brighter in there. Nice heated patio outside in back, great food, drinks. EBC beer with blueberries, fried banana pepper logs were delish, beautiful burger varieties served with pickle and fresh cut fries that reminded me of homemade fries I made at home as a kid. Server, Jen, was very attentive and pleasant, even the cook, Mike, came out to see if we enjoyed the food. It was 7 pm, on a tuesday night, so not too busy in the dining room, but bar was full, hockey on the big screens. I'll be back, felt comfortable in there. read more

Had high hopes for a fish fry. Was let down. Service was meh; the batter on the fish was as thick as the fish. Side salads also lacking. I'll stick to my tried and true fish fry places from now on. read more

Very uninviting for lunch. Wouldn't recommend. Bar was open but nobody seemed to want to address people coming it. Walked right out.

We thought we would try this new place for lunch today. The interior was very welcoming. All started out real well with quick service when taking our order and bringing our drinks. 35 minutes later our food arrived. The roast beef, for the beef on weck, was just deli sliced and put into hot au jus for way too long. Fries were bagged frozen fries and nothing special. Pork sandwich was supposed to have cheese on it and that was missing. Cold slaw was too "milky" for my taste. The food was good. It just was lacking when it came to preparation and slow to arrive. Service by the server was very good! read more

Had a great first time fish fry experience. Was told try Monday wing night, waitress and their family member raved about it? Only Two waitresses on and took two hours for wings . No one to clean up dirty tables including ours when sitting down . Sorry but will not return for this ! Needs a lot of improvement! read more

Had some family in town and have been out to eat several times this week. Never been here before but was pleasantly surprised. Service was excellent. Food was good and cooked to order (nothing had to go back) which is surprising because our group has a couple very picky people and almost always have to recook something. read more

Hayley is the best, fridays are great, love this bar. Alicia and hayley serve well, would recommend

Came in there about 2am got served a drink by the bartender with my friend next thing I know the "security" Is staring at me so I try and look away for about 2 mins but he keep staring at me so I start to stair back at him he asks me to finish my drink and I tell him that staring at me makes me feel uncomfortable and I cannot finish my drink with him still staring at me and my friend. Then he gets real aggressive and and asks me if he should throw me out of the bar which I was just trying to finish my drink at that point I calmly say "if you feel that kicking me out of the bar is necessary the do it" then he goes back behind the bar for about 3 minutes while I am finishing my drink and walks back out to me ripping my drink from my hand and dumping it out and says to me "you have to leave which I comply with him and start to exit the bar and on the way out he tells me to go fuck myself now I am furious and reply " no go fuck yourself" and slam the door and leave. All in all this is a terrible bar no respect for its customers and will do anything to kick you out even if you are doing nothing wrong read more

Waitress was very nice. Fish fry was very very greasy. The oil ran out of the fish ruined the fries, and left a pool of oil below. The broiled fish was very very salty. Tried scrapping topping off. Didn't work. Dirty sticky floors your feet stuck to. Only good point is the place is so bad it should close in a few months. Avoid so as not to ruin your dining experience read more

First time here since Nickel Creek. Meh. Plenty of bar space, mostly filled on Friday. Promptly seated for dinner. Food may have taken an unreasonable time, even for a Friday during lent. Food, meh. French fries had an unusual flavor, maybe tossed in rosemary, again meh. Service a little slow but I think it was more kitchen and bar than waitress. Didn't hate it but not hurrying back. Meh. read more

We had a fish fry last night. Beware it is not haddock , it's cod. The batter was soggy, not crisp which made the fish quite mushy. Sides were really good but the fish kind of ruined it. Service was great. The dining room is quite noisy but the outside patio area looks really nice. All in all we wouldn't go back for fish but the wings and everything else we saw go by looked really good read more

A fledgling bar and grill business. Was totally impressed with the cleanliness and attentiveness of the waitress. It took a while for the food to hit the table, but then obviously extra attention was taken upon preparedness. It was good. The location can only enhance the success of this business. It is charming with outside seats overlooking the creek. read more

Went there late evening for a quick beer and roast beef sandwich. The place was painted a dark grey and seemed rather dark for a dining room. To start off, my beer was flat as soon as I poured it in my glass. You can't use beer glasses for pop which I know was the case because I've owned bars. The glass was clean so obviously it's being used for both beverages. My kimmelweck was toasted and mushy. That tells me it was not fresh so they toasted it. The beef was full of stringy fat and had no flavor. The frys were limp. The oil was old. My companion ordered the chicken fingers, and they had no flavor and were overcooked. The patio outside looked very nice and there was also a bar. Hopefully they'll get the food right. From the looks of the full parking lot, it looks like it may be a great place to drink and listen to music outside. I know the owners never owned a business before. I wish them luck and hope they take these reviews to heart to improve their business. read more