Just moved to the neighborhood and already found my favorite ice cream spot on the Cape! Buffy's Ice Cream in Chatham is absolutely fantastic. The homemade ice cream is delicious -- rich, creamy, and full of flavor. And don't miss their Chatham ice cream bars... they're incredible! Huge shoutout to Jayden, who was super informative and incredibly nice. Also, Nolan, the assistant general manager, made us feel so welcome -- both were amazing and really added to the experience. The points system is a great bonus too -- earn rewards just for indulging in great ice cream! Buffy's is a gem. We're lucky to have it in the neighborhood! read more

Huge fan of this place! My friends and I went with the Ice Cream Sampler, which I would totally recommend for a group, since you can try six different flavors. The staff was super nice and helped us out with finding flavors that were gluten-free. All the flavors were great, especially the more unique ones. I'd happily come back again and try the Ice Cream Bars! Big fan of the outdoor patio area for the summer months. If you're lucky, you might catch some live music. read more

See all

Hot summer day screaming for ice cream? Look for Buffy's. I'm not picky about my ice cream flavors, simple strawberry and I'm good. The heat did make the ice cream a tad soft but the freshness shone through, a little bit if a wait, not to worry, you'll get served quickly, three cone sizes, I chose the cone I was used as a kid and I was ok with that. Line quickly disappeared and got to sit outside and enjoy the ice cream. read more

What a cute ice cream shop on the main street in Chatham. I tried the Diesel ice cream sandwich at the guy's recommendation (I forgot to ask his name). My husband had a cup of peanut butter heath bar crunch. Both were delicious and it's homemade ice cream. There's seating outside. read more

See all

We stopped in here for a quick ice cream! The team behind the counter was super nice and kind and helpful about the options! They also liked to have a little fun which made it entertaining! The dairy free chocolate chip ice cream was made with a coconut base and for the first time the coconut DID NOT over power the ice cream! It was smooth and creamy and the vanilla and coconut and chocolate chips worked great together! read more

See all

Stopped in for ice cream after dinner. Service is super friendly. They have gluten free and dairy free options! The coconut base with chocolate chips tasted amazing! read more

Buffy's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Cute ice cream store in cape cod and great coffee! Will def be back one day! Highly recommend read more

See all

The service is great! They were friendly & made great suggestions. The cookie dough was delicious & the affogato is yummy! read more

See all

The coffee, chai lattes, and ice cream are all amazing. We tried almost every coffee place on the strip and Buffy's was the best by a landslide. Not only was it delicious they also had amazing customer service and was super super cute inside. Every worker was so kind and helpful every time we went in. I believe it is a family owned business as it looked like a father and his sons working. I would recommend this place a thousand times over, we will definitely be coming back next trip. read more

Great ice cream spot as you might expect in the wonderful Cape Cod town of Chatham. I overindulged with the banana boat. Well executed!

first time here while visiting for the 4th! Came close to closing and the general manager was phenomena! His vibe and energy made the whole experience amazing. 10/10 would come back even just to see him read more

Cutest ice cream shop, service was amazing, ice cream is amazing, and the Buffychino was the best! We definitely appreciate the time they took the explain the menu and give suggestions. read more

The coffee oreo on a waffle cone was AMAZING! Home made ice cream at its finest and the guys working was so kind and informative.

Attentive staff, wicked generous portions, artisanal bars (dangerously delicious), fantastic ice cream (made on premises), espresso drinks, baked goods, and smoothies. Adjacent to shoppe is a great outdoor reTreat w/ dappled PM light and sturdy benches for eating & idling. Open year-round ! furkrissakez; what's not to love. read more

See all

Some of the best ice cream on Cape, period! The owners are extremely caring and go out of their way for their customers! Very much appreciate them read more

Can't rate the ice cream but my pistachio iced latte was WONDERFUL and the gentleman behind the counter was absolutely wonderful, so kind, polite and friendly! Their ice cream cookie sandwiches looked amazing! read more

I have been doing my own lower cape ice cream tour and Buffy's is my top so far! Great quality ice cream with excellent service. I will definitely be back! The shop has a great vibe right on the adorable Chatham Main Street. read more

The Cappuccino (coffee not ice cream) is the best in Chatham! The ice cream is very good too!

came in to grab an ice cream treat the man working was so friendly. cut our ice cream in half since my husband & I were sharing, he took his time explaining each item on the menu additionally gave us some tips for touring the town! read more

This was one of the best ice creams I have had on the cape! The pistachio is absolute perfection- it's loaded with real pistachios! However, they were not generous with the toppings. That's too bad - but I'm going back for sure! Super kind staff too - just give a girl more toppings! :) read more

I had a dirty chai that was amazing. Owner was awesome. It's worth the walk up Main Street.

We all opted for the ice cream "bars" (sandwiches), so can't comment fully on the ice cream here. The bars are pre-made and packaged, maybe they sell them other places too? They were sold out of a bunch, three of us opted for the Angler Brownie Bar, chocolate chip brownies with chocolate lovers fudgy ice cream between and white chocolate drizzle. This bar delivered on the chocolate and the sweet and the fudgy! It was good, but at 53 grams of sugar it certainly packs a punch for your blood sugar level. My wife got the CG, peanut butter cup cookies with peanut butter and cream cookie ice cream and milk chocolate fudge topping. Also very good, but maybe needed more chocolate in it. Either way, these small bars hit the spot if you want a quick sweet treat. out of five cones. Best paired with a stop at the Chatham Fish Pier to see the harbor seals and Jacuzzi Boys - Glazin'. read more

See all

We stopped in for their fresh squeezed lemonade and it was fantastic!! Not too sweet and perfectly tart. Perfect! We didn't try their ice cream but the menu looked great. Love the old staff pictures lining the walls. Cute place in Chatham. read more

Buffy's Ice Cream - Buffy's side yard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Ice cream was Delicious, service was friendly and quick, and it's the cutest store in a small town. Definitely recommend!

Buffy's is a little Ice Cream Shop On Main Street in Cape Cod in Chatham MA that makes Home Made Ice Cream. People love to walk up & down Main Street in Chatham because they have unique one of a kind restaurants & shops. Buffy's is one of them. They have a counter & Stools here or you can get it to go. The color scheme in here is black, white & pink. They have traditional Old School Favorites as well as newer & more popular flavors too. All of the selections are listed on the wall on a Blackboard Menu. You can ask for a sample before you buy which is always nice. Everyone thought that The Old School Rum Raisin Flavor which is very hard to find today was the Best & had lots of Raisins in it. It used to be, you had to have mega bucks & be really rich to have the Good Life, not anymore. The Game has changed. You've been Upgraded. Now You Can Live Like a King on a Limited Budget! read more

See all

We were so pleased to find this after a night in Chatham. Lots of fun flavors including some cool ice cream bars. Most importantly, some of the best ice cream we've had in Cape! read more

Wow. Really incredible ice cream. They have all the classic flavors that you might've grown up loving in the US (ex: coffee heath bar, mint Oreo, strawberry, mocha chip), but probably better quality than what you grew up having. The mint Oreo had real, full Oreos in it, which was INCREDIBLE, and the mocha chip was very generous with the chocolate! Took off one star because they wouldn't do a single scoop that's split between two flavors, so I had to get two scoops to try the flavors I wanted and ended up wasting a lot of ice cream. Otherwise, I can't wait to go back again soon I was definitely in my happy place. read more

Buffy's Ice Cream - Mint Oreo and mocha chip - both AMAZING - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

The bars are delightful and waffle cones fresh. A bit of a wait even with only 1 person ahead, but glad we stopped.

This is now open with a new owner and new name Buffy's plus Chatham Ice Cream Bars. Hope they will update their listing here. Had coffee chip and it was very good. They also make ice cream sandwiches. Look good, didn't have room to try some yet. But will be back! read more

Slayed by Salty Caramel. Resurrected by Lemonade. There's a lot of ice cream choices in Cape Cod. Perhaps too many. Please allow my humble review to solve this problem for you. My midsection can attest to decades of ice cream experience. Buffy's stands out with its friendly staff and cozy confines. As for the ice cream, in a world of prefabricated everything, being able to enjoy something homemade is refreshing and pleasantly fattening. read more

One of the best ice creams that I have ever eaten (and I've had my fair share). Worth the half hour wait. The coffee Oreo ice cream was out of this world. Creamy, filled with chunks of real Oreos, and fresh. My boyfriend also had the butter pecan and loved it. Check this place out regardless of how long the line may be. You won't regret it. read more

Meets a critical need in Chatham - yes they have great ice cream, but also the only place in downtown Chatham open for coffee all day, every day! Excellent service, excellent ice cream, excellent coffee! read more

Talk about pretentious? Now, I know it's Chatham and all the beautiful folks are shopping their way into oblivion but this is ridiculous. Two ice creams cost 13 bucks? The ice cream is good but if I closed my eyes, I couldn't distinguish it from the place on 28 in the next town. Drive to Harwich and get great homemade ice cream at nearly half the price and far less attitude. read more

Good ice cream, but really expensive. Lots of good flavors and tasty cones, but $2 extra for a waffle cone? Scoops were big, but almost $40 for four cones is the most we've paid on the Cape. read more

Cute ice cream shop on Main St. Chatham. Great flavors. A little bit on a pricey side, but will definitely go back. read more

See all

Amazing flavors of home made ice cream and staff has always been cheerful regardless of the line out the door (which is so worth the wait in the on season). The addition of the raspberry Oreo is delicious but coffee Oreo my absolute FAVORITE. read more

Buffy's Ice Cream - Coffee oreo in their home made waffle cones YUM - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Staff is friendly. Very popular place. Great homemade ice cream with lots of delicious flavors to choose from. read more

See all

Wow, this ice cream is amazing. I can't believe I am saying this but it is worth the egregious price of almost 6 bucks a cone (for a small!) We visited multiple time on our vacation this summer. I wish they had kids sizes, though. Hence four stars, and also because of the price :) read more

Buffy's Ice Cream - Yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Excellent Ice Cream--Excellent Service!!!! Nice to see locally owned business!!! Hope to visit it again!!

Ice cream is top of the line. A great place to cool off on your summer vacay.