Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Burger 25

    4.3 (122 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Order Burger 25 Takeout or Delivery

    Burger 25 Photos

    BURGER 25 ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Outdoor seating
    Dogs allowed

    Recommended Reviews - Burger 25

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Apple cider donut shake
    Shelby G.

    25 options! This became our go to while on the island this season. Burgers are cooked fresh, with several meat options. Order a half and half to have fries and rings. Don't forget o grab a shake. Order online for pick up if you're in a hurry.

    Caitlin B.

    This place was always my favorite burger place and their shakes are constantly changing. Their food is delicious and I usually end up splitting whatever I order since it's so filling. The bacon jam burger is BANGINGG! The cookie dough ball on top of my Cookie Monster shake really made it better. This place has multiple locations but of course the LBI one is my fav! TikTok Reviewer: acaicaitlin

    $1 play till you win!
    Kate Y.

    Great food - we tried the: - black bean burger - fish & chips - vanilla malt milkshake - oreo malt milkshake Big portions, and everything was delicious. Service was friendly and quick. Came to LBI during off peak, so very happy to have found this place!

    Al M.

    The shakes are really interesting and fun to try a new one every month!! Really friendly staff as well

    Decor
    Fire Hazard I.

    Food was very good and the staff were so polite the inside was well decorated but the table and seats felt a little sticky but I do recommend trying this out

    chicken ceaser salad sandwich

    Wonderful burgers, sides, salads, etc. Everything on the menu is delicious. With that being said, the parking lot is WAY too small. I've pulled up and had to leave several times because there's literally nowhere to park, and even if there is, i know it's likely someone will hit me because of how tight the parking lot is. I know it's easier said than done, but it would be great if they could somehow make an additional parking lot. I'm sure it would bring more business to this great establishment :) To add, the chicken ceaser salad sandwich of the month is incredible. It needs to be added as a permanent item!!

    #10 FRENCH ONION SOUP BURGER 9/18/2023
    Valerie R.

    Fantastic addition to LBI!! Burger 25 is a quick service restaurant where you order at the front counter and food is brought to your table. The prices are VERY reasonable in general, and much more so for the island. Burgers are large and very tasty! Fries were crispy and good with a yummy garlic dipping sauce. They have shakes, soda, and cooler drinks, but you can also BYOB. They have a special menu just for dogs, very cheap, a burger without a bun, ice cream, or a cup of whipped cream. And doggy friends are welcome in the outdoor seating area. Definitely a place to check out if you're craving a burger or a less expensive meal while on LBI!

    Disco fries

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Burger 25 Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Burger 25

    Are their fries gluten free?

    Only our sweet fries.

    Do they have gluten free?

    Yes we offer gluten free rolls

    View All 3 Questions

    Black Eyed Susans - Beet salad

    Black Eyed Susans

    4.1(298 reviews)
    5.1 mi
    $$$

    We have been going to Black Eyed Susans since it first opened on the other side of the street many…read moreyears ago. At that point it was a small restaurant, BYOB, but it was immediately apparent that real gourmet food had finally arrived on LBI. (I still remember their version of shrimp and grits from that time.) We no longer had to put up with the prevailing surf and turf that we had unfortunately become accustomed to. Since then they've moved to their current, much bigger space and have created a beautiful, vibrant, inside-ourside restaurant that still serves excellent food (their lumache is terrific--we try not to order it every time) and has expanded to include pizzas--thin crust and very tasty; every one we've tried has been delicious. So we would definitely recommend Black Eyed Susans. The staff is welcoming, friendly, well trained. This is now a big, beautiful destination restaurant. The pizzas and beer lower the price point.

    Black Eyed Susans came highly recommended to my fiancé and I so we decided to try it one summer…read morenight. We got there early so we could have a drink and enjoy the outdoor area. This was very relaxing and I truly felt like I was transported to a resort. They do a great job of creating a little outdoor oasis. Once we were seated, we literally wanted to order the entire menu. Everything sounded outstanding that it was hard to choose. We settled on the seared tuna and a pizza as our apps. We also did indulge in an order of homemade sourdough because when in Rome! The pizza was by far my favorite. The crust was so thin and so crispy. You could tell all the ingredients were very fresh and the dough was perfect. For our mains, my fiancé had the swordfish special and I went with a crab cake. I love that I was able to get a single order instead of a double. It was the perfect amount of food after all the apps. We agreed the swordfish was outstanding. So moist and not dry whatsoever like it sometimes can be. The real highlight of the meals for me was the homemade soft serve. As a huge ice cream stan, this was the perfect ending to my meal.

    Photos
    Black Eyed Susans - Dining area

    Dining area

    Black Eyed Susans - Pizza sausage

    Pizza sausage

    Black Eyed Susans - Great decorations for the holidays

    See all

    Great decorations for the holidays

    Burger 25 - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...