We absolutely love Cafe L'Amore!!! feels like home:) Food is always AMAZING! Everything is always great, especially the desserts. read more

I ordered a Marcontonio (Italian sub). On the website, it is listed at $13.00. When I went to pay, it was $20.00. I got it home. There were two slices of salami, two slices of provolone, a ton of lettuce and a ton of mayo. Not an "Italian" sub at all. No ham, and almost no filling except for lettuce and mayo. Even when I called to order the sandwich, which is on their website, they did not know what I was talking about. They had never heard of this sandwich. This is the second time this happened. $20.00 for a sandwich that must have costed them under a dollar to make and was not very good. One star out of five. read more

We return regularly with friends and family when in the area. Warm, friendly and attentive service. Like to order off the Specials Menu. Consistently good food. No liquor license so most people BYOB. Favorite is clams over linguine in white sauce when available. We typically spend $50/person with tax and tip. Accept reservations with a phone call. Pizza takeout is popular front of store. Gripe remains: tight parking and valet usually necessary read more

See all

We recently celebrated a colleague's retirement at Cafe Amore, and I cannot say enough wonderful things about the experience! From the very beginning, Michael was an absolute pleasure to work with. I shared my vision for the event, and he made it happen seamlessly. Every detail was handled perfectly, allowing us to simply enjoy the celebration. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the staff was attentive and friendly, and the food was outstanding. Everything tasted incredibly fresh...from the salads and appetizers to the delicious pizzas. Every dish was prepared to perfection and enjoyed by all of our guests. The BYOB option was a bonus and made the event even more enjoyable and affordable for our group. Thank you, Michael, and everyone at Cafe Amore, for helping make our colleague's retirement celebration one that we will remember forever. We truly appreciate the exceptional service, delicious food, and wonderful hospitality. Highly recommended! WE WILL BE BACK!!!! read more

Parking is a little tight but the food and service are great. Left with enough in our doggie bags for two more nights. We will return.

Good food great service and a clean roomie feel at home type of restaurant. The food was delicious and a great place to bring your own bottle or bottles. read more

Wonderful food and wonderful service! This place is a hidden gem and one of the best and coziest Italian spots around. Highly recommend!

The food was very good and service was excellent and very friendly environment. Pizza and the bread was very very good!!!!! read more

Cafe L'Amore - Pizza Near Me - Oakland, New Jersey

Cafe L'Amore: Food - Excellent, Service - Great, - Everything-Wonderful. Great choices of food and services. What a great place!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Another review described Cafe L'Amore as a hidden gem, and it really is. The location is nondescript, but the food is anything but. We had soup (chicken barley, Stracciatella), fresh bread right out of the oven, the stuffed artichoke appetizer (not to be missed!), lamb shank risotto (which I had on pappardelle instead, and would highly recommend), short rib ragu, and tiramisu were all homemade, and so fresh and flavorful. This was my first visit. I live 40 mins away and will now make the trip regularly, I'm sure. :-) read more

Great experience amazing staff delicious food. Amazing atmosphere with great ambiance

Ambiance: (4/5) I got great family restaurant vibes. Parking is a bit annoying. Price: (3/5) Prices are average for the area, but I felt like the portions were small. I only got 5 pieces of ravioli when I order the mushroom ravioli. Food: (4/5) the bread was really good. It was warm and came with salted butter. I really enjoyed the mushroom ravioli. It was creamy and had a few veggies. I just wish there was more ravioli. The pizza crust was perfect. I really enjoyed the margarita pizza. Service: (5/5) Great staff! Very welcoming. read more

Cafe L'Amore - Pizza Near Me - Oakland, New Jersey

See all

I am a little late on my review but this place the pizza was amazing. I would highly recommend take a road trip to this location. I give it a 10 out of 10 read more

Moved up to North Jersey a few years ago and this is by far the best restaurant up here! Amazing staff and every item on the menu is delicious! Can't recommend this place enough! Ambience is spectacular! read more

Amazing restaurant with fantastic service. Also lots of gluten free options with both gluten free pasta and pizza! Can't wait to come back soon! read more

Thank you again Mark....25+ years and everything has been perfection. Pretty good odds. We will go with the sure thing and continue to come back. Great dinner. Thank you. Keith and Donna read more

See all

I love it here, really nice people and really beautiful place! The food is amazing and make with care

Cafe lamour is a wonderful restaurant. From great food and a friendly staff, cafe lamour makes you feel right at home with their extensive hospitality. The owners are wonderful people, making you feel on top of the world while you eat their amazing food. read more

OMG What excellent food at this cozy restaurant. You can tell when someone takes pride in the taste, preparation and presentation of a dish! The short ribs and risotto are excellent. The seafood dishes were fresh and delicious. You also get good portions so you feel good about the moderate prices. The carrot cake is sooo good. And don't forget the brick oven pizzas! This will be your new favorite spot! read more

Amazing authentic taste of Italy! Fresh ingredients and generous portions! My favorite spot by far!​ read more

Cafe L'Amore - Meat lovers pizza is insane! - Pizza Near Me - Oakland, New Jersey

My partner and I came to Cafe L'Amore for our anniversary this week. We had been here a few years ago with his parents and remembered how great the food was. Well, the restaurant has stayed consistent because we had a fantastic dinner. Everything we ordered was from the specials menu. We started with a shrimp appetizer. It was deliciously spiced with the perfect amount of heat that didn't overwhelm the flavor. He had a lamb osso buco tossed with pappardelle; I ordered veal scaloppini with asparagus. The chef and/or owner was very hospitable and genuinely friendly, which made us feel at home. Incredible food with really friendly staff. What more could anyone want? read more

What a great time we had at Cafe L'Amore! They are so accommodating and welcoming. All six of us agreed that the food was delicious, as was the service. They aim to please, it's BYOB, and it's consistently excellent. Well be back! My wife is still raving about Chicken Francese! Nice job, Mark and your whole team! A perfect evening! read more

Delicious food, big portions, great service! Every time we come it is always fantastic. Authentic Italian!

Great food, great service, wonderful experience. Would absolutely come back over and over.

So good! Michael is such a kind soul and treated us like family. He encouraged me to try the duck special and it was delicious!! I highly recommend trying it if it is available. read more

Delicious! Great food, parking in front, friendly staff. Love the Veal Francaise with roasted vegetables.

I am not a local, but I am in the area regularly and always order from Cafe L'Amore. My daughter can't get enough of the Chicken Parmesan, and this is what she wants for her birthday dinner. As a salad person the fresh homemade Caesars salad is wonderful! So when I was planning a surprise party there was only one place to go. They helped me choose a balanced menu with something for everyone. The guest of honor loves the veal saltimbocca and now so does everyone else who attended. But it is not just the food and delicious bread it is the people and the owner. He is always busy but never to busy to say "hi". Thanks for making us feel like family! read more

We pulled up for a 7:30 reservation, and a nice young man was there to valet our car. We were warmly greeted. This is a BYB, so we had Compari spritzs, the waiter supplied seltzer and lemons. Appetizers consisted of stuffed hot peppers. They were fantastic if you like a little heat. The house salds were perfectly dressed and very tasty! ( they are huge get one for two people) we ordered Papardelle with Bolognese sauce and Tagliatelle & White clam sauce . Both were extremely flavorful and excellent. The pasta were perfectly cooked al dente. The White Clams sauce pasta was one of the best I've ever had. Fresh small clams! Garlic and white wine! Everything went excellent with a bottle of Tuscan whine brought back from San Germiano. No desert this time, we wrre stuffed! Although it looked great! The owner was super friendly and gracious. A most go. We will be back. read more

So very very good. I've only ever ordered the chicken l'amore from here and it never gets old. I love the owners - they always great you like family. This place is a true gem. read more

Cafe La More is one of those spots that makes you want to come back after the first visit. It has a cozy, romantic vibe without feeling too formal, the kind of place that works just as well for a date night as it does for catching up with friends. The food is the real star. Their pasta tastes fresh and homemade, and the sauces actually have depth (not the bland, watered-down kind you get at a lot of places). I tried the penne vodka, and it was creamy, rich, and perfectly seasoned. The pizza is another must thin, crispy crust with just the right chew, and toppings that feel thoughtfully put together rather than piled on. Service was warm and attentive, and the staff actually seem to care about making sure you're happy with your meal. Portions are generous without being over the top, and prices are fair for the quality you're getting. read more

Excellent! Very friendly atmosphere and attentive service. Food is authentic and delicious. The best bread in Bergen county!

This is the REAL DEAL! Some of the best homemade Italian dishes (and American dishes as well) that I have ever experienced on the east coast. I am an Italo-phile and have traveled to Italy extensively. That is (just one of) the reason(s) why I know REAL Italian cuisine (not a hodgepodge that attempts to pass as such). Food is heavenly, staff & service are impeccable, prices are very reasonable, and parking is easy. You really can't beat this place! Please believe me that I have actually considered relocating to New Jersey just so that I can frequent this cafe-restaurant on a daily basis. Whenever I am in the area this is definitely one of my very top go-to spots! Come one, or come all. You will find yourself returning again and again and again. 10 stars/ 10 stars !!! read more

Co-owner Marco greats the many repeat customers like old friends, and the other customers like new friends. We've come here twice, once during off time when we were the only table. And another time on valentines day when it was packed. On the latter occasion it took a little while to get seated, as they did what they could to seat everyone in a somewhat timely manner without rushing the other customers. Excellent pizza (nice light puffy margherita style crust, their margherita pizza is excellent, the Alla Puttanesca was also outstanding) and appetizers. Somewhat obscure location, but a real find. read more

Excellent service and food. Owner made a custom pizza pie that was perfect. Highly recommend

Great local Italian restaurant with delicious pizza. BYOB which is always helpful. Family owned and never disappoints.

I want to preface that I've ordered from here before with no issue but Sunday ( Valentine's Day) I ordered take out through Grubhub and noted that my dish needed to be gluten free. I even asked the man at the counter if they saw my note and the dish was made gluten free including the side pasta. He got snippy with me and said I would know the difference between the pastas. Well I got home started to eat my chicken dish and pasta and about 1/4 way through I found regular spaghetti noodles in my gf penne pasta. I immediately stopped eating as it was clear they reused the same pasta water they cooked their regular pasta in. It is now Thursday and I am still feeling the after effects of being glutened - I got pretty sick not long after and Monday was in so much pain and sick it was awful. I hate to write reviews like this but if I can help another GF person avoid this I feel I need to share this feedback so hopefully someone sees it and management and the chefs can fix this for the future. read more

Cafe L'Amore - Regular spaghetti in my gluten free pasta - Pizza Near Me - Oakland, New Jersey

I ate here for the first time earlier in the week. Had the pizza. Perfectly cooked, thin and full of flavor. I wanted to try something else so I went back a couple of days later and had the Penne with Vodka sauce, chicken parm and the homemade bread...AMAZING!!! Don't pass this place up. there is a reason why the Owner Mark has been here for so long. Great food, great service and a family friendly environment with good prices. We will be back. read more

Cafe L'Amore family dinner take out is the best. The staff and owner are welcoming and eager to please.

Cafe L'Amore is a gem!! We walked in for lunch and were so warmly greeted by the owner Mark. We had just come from hiking in Ramapo State Park which is only 1.5 miles away and although we were dressed in hiking clothes, he welcomed us right into the dining room. The food was outstanding as was the service. We had wood-fired pizza and clams in white wine sauce. They were both outstanding. The bread is warm and delicious. Although we do not live close by, we will be back next time we are hiking or driving by on 287. read more

Can not say enough great things about this place. Cater from them every party and it's always a hit. Their short ribs with risotto is phenomenal and one of my favorites. Chicken, calamari, Caesar salad, bread, shrimp, the list goes on and on. Owners are welcoming and the kindest people. Service is always amazing. They are truly the best Italian spot. read more

Cafe L'Amore - Fried calamari - Pizza Near Me - Oakland, New Jersey

See all