Like Scotty's on YouTube! A genuine neighborhood auto mechanic who will not try to sell you anything beyond what you honestly need and service your broken parts at an honorable price! Caldwell Tire will Never push & urge you to buy an extra unnecessary service. At Mavis, I've been strongly recommended to order new tires and add a $90 Engine Oil Flush while brought in for a simple oil change & at Jiffy Lube; a $30 injection cleaning was strongly suggested (which was really just a small bottle of $4 fuel additive). Plus Jiffy Lube wanted to replace my wiper blades on my Brand New Honda Accord with 5000 miles on it! But Never at Caldwell Tire Auto Shop because Honesty is Best and Honestly, you just don't need new tires at every oil change like its NASCAR. read more

Got a flat less then a mile from this place parked and asked if they can fix my flat as I'm on my way to work they said I had to leave the car and it will take a few hours because they busy I said is a 10 to 15 minute job is just a flat fix they said NO so I asked if there was a never by tire place they recommen and the lady at the front says I don't know I'm not from around here. You can look it up SMH poor customer service. Don't come here for quick flat fix service read more

Mike is great having restored my faith in car mechanics. Honest, reasonable, you do yourself a favor by coming here. Avoid dealers and the chains and recognize this place is a find. Look no further. read more

The customer service here is so poor that it makes the whole experience frustrating and not worth your money. We are first time customers and dropped off the car with a list of fixes needed on Sunday night after hours per Mike's direction. On Tuesday he reached out and we agreed on what needed to be fixed. I called and spoke to a girl who said I could pick up the car after hours. My husband and I live in Queens (I grew up in Caldwell) and he works 7-7, so after he got out of work we drove to Caldwell. Our car was open, but we couldn't find the keys inside. We tried to turn the push start multiple times and the car wouldn't start, so we knew the keys were not in the car. We also checked the late night mailbox and there were no keys there either. Very frustrating so we drove back to Queens as we had work the next day. Mike called in the morning and said our keys were in the car the entire time and he left it open all night. He didn't apologize and was adamant that we were wrong - even though a car with a push start always starts when a key fob is inside of it. I have had this car since 2009, if the fob is in the car, the car will start! My husband called back later and we requested this time they lock our car and leave our keys in the mailbox for another after hours pickup. After work that day, my husband drove to Caldwell and him and my neighbor went to the lot to get our car. This time the keys were not in the mailbox and our car was locked - so we could not get in for the second night in a row. Frustrated yet again, my husband drove back to Queens. Finally this morning we called out of work and drove to Caldwell to get our car. When I got there, the girl was extremely rude and unprofessional, saying that we were adamant for the keys to be left in the mailbox vs. in the car (which is their normal process) and someone came at night and opened the mailbox and moved my keys into the key drop off slot. She fully blamed us and said "it's out of our hands". I told her the least you all could have done is apologize for the inconvenience after we had to drive 4.5 hours round trip to get our car. She was insistent it was all our fault, kept saying we were wrong and she "put the keys in our car the first night" and refused to apologize. She had a very rude attitude the entire time and Mike didn't even have the decency or professionalism to come and speak to us himself. Also, one of the issues I requested he fix (tire pressure sensor) is still broken and they didn't even tell us. Regardless of the fact that this could have been a mistake, the least they could have done is apologized for an inconvenience. It takes ZERO effort to say to someone who just spent $900 at your business, "We apologize for the inconvenience this caused you and we appreciate your business" but that was impossible for this place. On top of that, they really should not leave cars unlocked with the keys inside and random people should not be touching other people's car keys !!! During this experience we spoke to other friends who've used this place in the past and all of them said recently the customer service has gotten so bad they don't come here anymore. Just wish we knew that before this ordeal! I DO NOT recommend coming here for anyone looking for a mechanic in Caldwell. You're better off finding someone who will at least be kind and where you'll be happy with your hard money being spent. read more

Absolutely top-notch car service, not like other auto repair garages, Tony will check your car for what you bought it in for and give you honest answers and fair prices, not just look at you and see $$$$$, looking to score bucks and have you wondering why you came. Also best price on an oil change in the tri-county area. read more

And the guys at Caldwell tire are my go-to for anything with my red pickup truck Mike is always reliable very good pricing does a wonderful job keeping my little red wagon ram 1500 running like a top my brother and I are customers for life read more

Good honest folks. Family has been using them for years and have always been satisfied. I highly recommended this place.

great service, great prices, great technicians, just a great place To take your ride.

I drove up with a nail in my tire, the team there immediately found the nail and repaired it within minutes. Reasonable price and excellent service. read more

This place was highly recommend to me and I am glad I came here. They are friendly and honest. We had a great mechanic in our old neighborhood that I really trusted and I am happy to find these guys close to home. read more

There are simply not enough to stars to describe the service,expertise and kindness of Caldwell Tire. I am truly surprised that more people have not come on here to provide their positive experience. If you are a caldwell resident and a member of the Facebook page you will know that this place is the best. But if you aren't this is the best kept secret in auto repair. You will not be ripped off, you will not be mislead, you will not be disappointed. read more

The best mechanics anywhere. Honest, reasonable, top notch every single time!! I would not take my car anywhere else . Give them a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Best and most honest mechanics around. As others have said, they are completely honest. They have fixed problems for me that I expected would be hundreds more read more

This place fixed my boyfriends car for $40. He took it to another place less then a block away and they quoted him an estimate of over $500. The car is running well and I recommend them to all my friends. read more

Hands down the best place in the Caldwell . Tony is very honest and reasonably priced!

Tony is the man! very trustworthy and more than reasonably priced! this is the ONLY place i go to get my car worked on!