Atik is a cute location for its ambiance and live shows…read more Food: the food is good, tasteful to the pallet and good portion. The food to me is a little above average where it's eatable and will satisfy your appetite. The drinks are really good! Service: the service is top notch. The waiters consistently come around check for needs and refills of drinks. The waiter provide great inside on menu options. Ambiance: the ambiance is open seating on the inside and outside. Great for intimate seating as well as group dinners. My overall scoring is 4.4/5.0

Overpriced and overhyped in my opinion. We came here for my sisters birthday and despite having a…read morereservation we still had to wait about 20-30mins to get seated bc our table "wasn't ready" once we were sat the service was super slow and all over the place. We were a table of 8 and drinks came out at random times despite all of us ordering together as well as the appetizers. For my meal I ordered the salmon and it was undercooked and extremely oily, so much so that the skin was soggy and just a mess. Then they try to upsell on everything, coming around the tables asking us if we wanted to pay $10 to break a plate, there was supposed to be a show and that didn't happen, overall, it was overpriced bad food, so much so, I ended up stopping at McDonald's on the way home bc there was no way I was eating that salmon. As for the vibe, everyone was dressed up as if they were going to a super fancy place. I didn't dress up because LOL, it's city island yall....

Filet Mignon & Lobster Tail father's day menu. Very delicious and the food at atmosphere is top…read moretier.

Best burger on the planet. Launch guys are on it. Friendly folks. Everyone seems willing to help.read more

We visited this place when it was The Icehouse it was nice. I enjoyed the new place, the appetizers…read morewere really good, the mussels were great and the chicken wings were great as well. Drinks were good. Service was a little slow. Ambiance was quiet, nice seating areas, I think they have a outside area. I would definitely return.

I was really looking forward to trying this place. I was underwhelmed with the food and drink…read moreoptions and the service experience. There are some dedicated parking spaces that have a three hour limit if dining. Upon arrival, I entered the inside restaurant space for Dakota's on the Grove. It was aesthetically pleasing. I should have sat inside here instead of in their outdoor space which they call The Grove at Dakota's. I was able to choose where I wanted to sit, so I chose a table near this shed where the bartender/waiter was. I noticed they were setting up for the Knicks Game 3 final and there were two large TVs and a projection screen. I overheard the waiter state that the area would be packed for the game tonight. There was also good music playing throughout. They had a large connect four, which would be nice to play. They are family friendly and had high chairs for babies and toddlers. When sitting outside they state that they have to preauthorize your card. Now getting onto the food. I was seated and provided with two menus. I immediately asked for a happy hour menu and then I waited for about 15 minutes, until I followed up with another waiter who brought out the menu for me. For the happy hour menu before I received my food I initially thought the prices were good, but upon receiving my food it was evident that the prices are off in terms of the portion size of the food. I ordered a $5 slider. I thought it would be a decent size. It was incredibly small. For the $5 price they should give at minimum 2 sliders but ideally 3. This would incentivize people to buy more. The slider was the best thing I tasted while there and I would have liked more but I couldn't justify spending another $5 when it was so tiny. The tiny slider appeared to be the portion size for a toddler. I ordered calamari which was $9. I was initially disappointed that there was such a small amount. I was even more disappointed when I tasted them. They tasted very "fishy." They absolutely needed a squeeze of lemon and fresh cracked black pepper to try and balance and mask the taste. I believe the portion size for the fries was also off for $5. The fries came in a teacup. Fries are something that people tend to order to have something to pick at while dining and it would make sense I think to provide more fries for the same price. I also could not justify getting another set of fries in a small teacup for $5. I did not like the taste of the fries. When the sparse calamari, tiny beef slider, and small teacup of fries came out, I realized I would not be full and ordered chicken wings from the happy hour menu. You have to get a minimum of 6. You cannot mix the flavors. They were out of the dockside fire sauce so I went with the garlic parm. These wings did not taste like garlic parm. The garlic parm seemed like an afterthought, which was just sprinkled on the wings at the very end. The chicken itself did not have much flavor. They did not mention providing any dipping sauce. I asked for blue cheese and I had to wait for about ten minutes and then remind another waiter that I was still waiting for my blue cheese. They were out of the mozzarella sticks. Moving onto the drinks. While I get being outside and maybe wanting to serve drinks in plastic to minimize glassware breaking, I did not enjoy being served Pinot Noir in a plastic cup or the white cranberry lemon drop in a plastic cup. Each time I was taken aback that they weren't offered in glassware. I got the $7 Pinot Noir from the happy hour menu. A regular glass of Pinot Noir is $9. I also ordered the white cranberry lemon drop which is priced at $12 and is not included on the happy hour menu. The drink came out in the same sized small plastic cup as the Pinot Noir. I think once again that glassware should be used. When ordering a lemon drop you tend to expect a chilled frosty glass with a sugar rim, and that was not what I received here. I think the sugar rim would have elevated the taste profile of the drink. All in all, I really liked the outdoor area. I would probably only return to get a canned beer in the outside section. I hope they start to carry some sour beer options. I do not see myself trying the food again, with the exception of a burger (since the burger was really good.) I did have an inquiry regarding the pre-authorization charge and the final charge that I saw on my credit card. I called and left a message and the restaurant got back to me quickly, which I really appreciated.

Sadly this place is one of the only open on the island after hours... for now…read more My burger and calamari were ordered over the phone. I was given a 20 min eta. It took a little longer than 20 but it was nominal. The calamari came unseasoned with tartar and not marinara sauce... im sorry did I order crab cakes? Also have you ever heard of old bay? If you're not a fan of seasoning don't serve food that demands it. My 6 year old can handle that one The burger was obviously from the freezer and not fresh. It was warmed. Not cooked. Do you know how hard it is to serve a frozen patty still raw? That takes talent. Thankfully I saw it before I got too far into it. I ordered the "Wayne" burger. I guess it was meant to come partially raw with raw accoutrements. The fries... well they're on par with the rest. Soggy, raw and... not worth the order. Maybe I'll try to feed this to my dog... Actually I won't. He deserves better.

This place is a hidden gem! Our bartender Brooklyn is the bomb.com! She had the drinks flowing and…read moreshe didnt short end us! Let's not mention how good the food was. I could barely finish my portion. Plus, the place is not mixy at all :) I would definitely go here again! Definitely worth a Saturday night visit with you and your boo, your homegirls or a man that's looking to spend money on you.

Great little local bar to enjoy a cocktail we were their first my girlfriends birthday and had a…read moregreat time ; nice bartender nice locals and very very reasonably priced drinks ... my boyfriend doesn't drink they had n/a perfect! Street parking is the only catch !

Awesome sports bar. Jen, the bartender, is a lot of fun. The best bar on City Island!read more

Great service and has all of your social media aesthetics!…read moreThe soft serve margaritas were so good; the chicken nachos were delish too! Service was great but bear in mind that they're strict with their 90 minute rule at the table.

Over exceeded my expectations, the customer service was perfection, food was worth it very…read moreaffordable, the drinks was the best in the city and I'm saying that from a person who love trying new restaurants. The music was great as well . I want to add for a Wednesday at 3 my server was so friendly, gave great recommendations you can tell she love the job because how well her customer service is. I think this is my new favorite spot

Made a reservation for brunch for 6 in early Feb for 3/16. Two weeks prior to the reservation, one…read moreperson wasn't able to come and i was able to easily edit the reservation to 5. I was sent a reminder to confirm the reservation 2 days b4 and on the day of, the owner called to let me know there were some streets blocked off due to a Saint pattys parade. My friends and i were able to plan ahead thanks to that call and parked and walked over. My brunch reservation was for 2:15pm. Now once we came in, we were seated fast. One of my friends was about 20 mins late and they didn't give us an issue about it since the rest of us were there. They took our drink order and appetizers. My friend got there after we got our drinks and appetizers and she ordered hers and we all ordered entrees. The waitress was amazing! Kept coming to fill up my mimosa. We had shots, i felt celebrated the entire time. Owner came by and checked in on us too. The DJ was a vibe! Loved him and he kept shouting out all the birthdays in the room. There are 2 bathrooms which we didn't figure out until later because there was only a sign for 1 of the 2 bathrooms but once we figured it out, we saw the cute photo op area in the back. It's literally directly behind the DJ. The place is decorated beautifully and plenty of options for pics. Food was great, drinks were great and so were the vibes. Love the way they sing happy birthday with a whole party and bubbles. Overall great experience for a bday brunch no complaints. I will def be back for brunch and dinner for sure.

Visited for friends birthdays and was disappointed. Service is lacking. We had ti ask for…read moreeverything from water to napkins. The food was just ok. The dj was great and it's very IG ready but that's where the positives ended for us. We were carded at the door but there's a few tables with kids under 10 inside. Then tables around the kids smoking hookah. Drinks could be stronger. This place had potential but won't b returning until there's major changes

10/10 Churassco and maduros as well as lettuce salad, overall great vibe, can be a bit loud but if…read morethat's the mood then is definitely time.

The food is incredible The pasta was delicious and lets…read moretalk about those colossal shrimps they were amazing and the service was spectacular