The food is delicious The service is amazing The new location has great ambience I love this place and my daughter has an excellent experience with the staff read more

Had low expectations for a Mexican spot in Tomah , WI but this place was actually pretty good. Had some tasty green enchiladas along with a Mandarin Jarrito and the service was friendly. Packed mom and pop venue with some great daily specials. Would return again if I was in the area. Seems very popular with the locals and law enforcement/military as well. If you like my reviews, consider "following" my profile for reviews all across the SF Bay Area . Why "follow" someone? It causes the person you follow's reviews to tier to top when you pull up a business. I find this very handy when researching venues. Rod's Review grading scale explained. Essentially I personally base it on the likelihood of a return visit and I try to be stingy with 5 star reviews since they should be "special" in my eyes. Price/Value also play a role obviously but there are $ and $$$$ littered across my grading scale. 5 stars - "I'll go out of my way" (approx 6 % of my reviews) 4 stars- "If I was in the area I'd go here and would recommend", (approx 38% of my reviews) 3 stars "Maybe if was nearby", (approx 37% of my reviews) 2 stars -"Would likely not return, Only if you want to go", (approx 16% of my reviews) 1 star -"No thanks, even if I was hungry", (approx. 3 % of my reviews) read more

We found this restaurant from their billboard over highway 94. It surely did not disappoint. The location is tucked behind a gas station and for the first time it may seem underrated. But once we stepped into the restaurant, we were transported into somewhere resembling a theme park and were greeted by a friendly staff who took us to our table right away. The food portion is HUGE and the salsa was amazing (ask for the spicy version!). We have gone back twice already. read more

We went here on a busy Friday evening as a large group of 15. We called ahead and they put together some tables for us to all sit together to enjoy our meal. Cancun Bay recently moved to a much larger location, and it's amazing. I love how it looks like a little city in here. The prices are great, and the food is delicious! One of the best seafood chimichangas that I've had. The mixed berry margarita was a nice treat as well. The service was wonderful for a busy Friday. We'd definitely stop here again while visiting in Tomah. read more

See all

Wow! I was concerned about finding healthy, gluten-free, vegan food options in this small Midwestern town while on a business trip. Fortunately, I found this Mexican place that had a vegetarian option with rice, corn tortillas and chips. And wow is that a lot of food! Didn't even come close to finishing it for dinner. It was tasty, flavorful and hit the spot. The service was incredibly fast, especially given that the restaurant was fairly full even for an early dinner. The locals must know what is good! read more

See all

We love the new location and the look inside. It reminds me of a restaurant in Disney World but not with the high prices. The service is still the best around, no waiting long for your food. Cheers to the new location with the same great food. read more

See all

We had a group of 12. We went to the brand new location. Had it reserved for a week. When we got there they acted surprised. I look at the calendar behind the counter and had to point it out that it was on the calendar. We were seated in a table area that had food scraps on the floor and chairs. Some chicken,some limes,napkins, other smashed up unidentified foods. We ask to be seated at the cleaner area 5 feet away. That lady walked away and never came back just totally ignored. The server came and we asked if they normally seat people in dirty areas with food waste all over,napkins and greasy prints on tables and chairs....the server looked me right in the eye and said "yes,it's normal.What do you want to drink". At least he was honest I guess. That's the last money they will get from the people in the group. If they are not ashamed to sit customers in a dirty area in the dining room.....what does it look like behind those kitchen doors. Avoid this place if you like to eat in a clean environment. read more

See all

This place is the best! My husband ordered the Burrito Jarocho and said it was the best seafood burrito he's ever had!! They recently moved to a different, larger location and the atmosphere is great! Highly recommend stopping here if in Tomah..or if you're just passing by..it's worth the short drive off the interstate toward town. read more

Have been doing eat in and carry out from this place for 5 or 6 years now, and have NEVER had even ONE negative experience. The food and service are top notch! read more

An absolute hidden gem in the small town of Tomah! This Mexican restaurant on Main Street delivers fast, friendly service with some of the best authentic flavors I've experienced--and I've traveled a lot. The margaritas are incredible (and you can even order them to-go!), and their lunch deals are a fantastic value. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and every dish is packed with authentic flavor. Truly one of the best Mexican spots I've ever come across. A must-visit if you're in town! read more

See all

Great service, food & the new location is festive & more spacious! We love Cancun Bay!

Really good pricing, people were nice, and the food came out so quickly! We got the taco salad bowl, and it was good! Yes, the place could've been cleaner, but that doesn't take away from the food for that price! read more

Great food and service great nice Mexican spot to enjoy lunch . They also carry's weekly deals which is absolutely amazing if you ask me !

A great spot to grab some Mexican food. It's a small place, but the service was great and the food came out super fast. They have a lunch menu we ordered from and the chicken lunch fajitas were delicious! My husband got the fajita quesadilla and really liked it as well. Very reasonably priced too. read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Lunch fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

This restaurant was recommended by a colleague and did not disappoint. The have complimentary chips and salsa. The chips were warm and the salsa was fresh and chunky. I ordered the shrimp (Large) and crab chimichanga (imitation crab). It came with refried beans, rice, pico de gallo, guac, and a little slide salad. The food came out quick and it was a nice family friendly atmosphere. I didn't order an alcoholic beverage but they did have a list and looked good on other tables. The price was good. Overall, good experience read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Chimichanga - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

We always get a variety of different food in our family and we very time it does not disappoint! There birthday tradition is amazing we go for all of our birthdays they always come over and sing and give you a dessert read more

I love when I find an unexpected jem like this. We drive through Tomah all the time and this place always has a bunch of cars, so today the timing worked out for lunch. Glad it did. Homemade chips and fresh salsa to start... chips are warm and crispy, and the salsa is chunky and flavorful. I had a lunch sized portion of steak fajitas and they were absolutely perfect. Hot, flavorful, and served as expected with rice, beans, lettuce, a little guacamole... all fresh and delicious. Wife had a beef tips burrito that was enough food for 2 or more, but also very good. Huge chunks of a very tender beef..probably chuck, and covered in a nice sauce. Remember to slow down, and hit these unexpected places in small towns all over the place. read more

See all

Great spot for a quick lunch. Service , Food were great and they have Vegetarian options . read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - We stopped in for a quick lunch, place is clean, food is so yummy, and service was friendly. - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

The service is fast and prompt. The food is good, especially with the limited options in the area.

HANDS DOWN, at loss of woods no expert in Mexican cuisine but this little gem is a little slice of Mexico, as soon as you walk in the music makes you smile..order that margarita, worth it! We did strawberry mango then you get house chips and salsa.. lord have mercy, we could of ate that only soo fresh and the flavors had my mouth dancing. We each ordered a steak entree and ooohweee AAHMAZING HANDS DOWN RECOMMEND!!! read more

My crew and I were all away from our family for the holiday so we figured we would have a fun night out for our families and decided on this restaurant. We had a party of 12 so we called earlier to get a reservation but they do not seem to take reservations so we showed up in person and they gave us a 25 minute wait. this was no issue as we were able to pregame with the gas station next door. Once they were ready to seat us, the staff wasted no time in getting out orders so the appetizers and drinks came out in fast time. The queso dip was delicious but got ran through real quick as the staff was quick to refill our chips. I ended up ordering the Steak Burrito as I needed a big portion to hold me over. The food came out and our plates were cleared within minutes. Afterward, we were able to enjoy to cool ambiance and finish our drinks when our waiter came out offering us free shots. The gesture was incredibly kind and made our experience all the much better. All in all, we all had an amazing time at the restaurant and recommend it to anyone looks for some nice vibes and decent food. read more

Authentic Mexican food! Took a shot and stopped. Was real good! Salsa was nice and spicy., you have to order the chile de árbol! Got some enchiladas! They were great and price were so good as well! Service was quick and friendly! The place has a small parking lot and the inside is decorated read more

I used to like the place until I started doing a little research. When you dine in and you get your chips... You get all perfect chips that are unbroken. When you get to go orders, you get broken chips at the bottom and only a few normal chips on the top to cover it. It's like they have two separate bins of chips and the takeout one is to completely screw you! I've done this experiment three times and every single time it's happened the same way. And with the current prices of one large salsa, one large cheese dip, and one large chip bag being $25... Totally unreal! Keep your eyes out.. read more

Excellent food! Cold beer. Great service. Excellent and friendly staff. Highly recommend this place!

Great Food! Great Service! Fast Service! We stopped here at dinner time and the restaurant was full. We still got fast service! I can't wait to come back! Warm chips, good salsa. Horchata was really good. read more

See all

Very good food... and great portions, the waiters aren't that nice but other than that the place was clean and food was great... I also definitely think the side of queso should be bigger for $5 read more

Service was very fast. Portion was large. Prices very reasonable. I didn't drink but seemed the drink menu was pretty decent with lots of speciality drinks. Would eat here again. read more

The service was concerningly swift, the chips were not fresh( clearly warmed) the salsa was very mild and watery. My burrito was upsetting mainly because ALL of the lettuce was on the outside, but in total, mid af. The enchiladas were decent, as was the rice and beans, infact the rice was quite good, betrayed only by its alarmingly orange color. Throughout our experience, we struggled to tell if the music was looped. 4 stars my a$$. read more

Delish. Such a classic good quality Mexican restaurant with super nice staff!! Loved the size of the lunch fajitas and the margs were also yummy. read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Lunch fajitas! Mixed chicken and steak - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

See all

Food was actually really good! I got the fajitas Michoacán and it was really tasty. Very authentic and lots of flavor. Also had the fried cheesecake and ice cream which was delicious, and a strawberry margarita which had the right amount of liquor in it, definitely didn't skimp on the tequila lol. The place isn't much to look at from the outside but well worth the visit. read more

This place is really good. Very good service and food. Typical Mexican stuff: tacos, burritos, fajitas, etc Inexpensive and tasty. Recommend this place! read more

This place is a little gem. Everything thing we had was great. The margarita are excellent and well priced. My Girlfriend had a non-alcoholic one and it was good. I had the beef chimichangas and they were very good, the queso was excellent. My girlfriend had steak tacos and she thought they were very good. The steak may be a bit salty for some but we enjoyed it. The service was extremely fast we had our food within 5 min of sitting down. read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Beef chimichangas and 27oz strawberry margarita. - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

Every one was great and food was delicious. I had the cheese dip, carnitas tacos and margarita.

The salsa was awesome! Right amount of heat/sweet. Not too thick or soupy. Amazingly flavorful. My chicken burrito was bigger than I expected, and wonderful. Partner also was very pleased with his meal. The service was fantastic! Any time a drink went dry, service was there in seconds. This is now our go-to restaurant whenever we're close to the area. Do it!! read more

This place is delicious! I'm very critical of Mexican Food, because I grew up in a Mexican household. This place is delicious and service was great! read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Potato cheese enchiladas! - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

Had the pollo con mole. It was amazing. The place is authentic Mexican cuisine. Highly recommend.

Best food in Tomah! Carryout or dine in - consistent quality meals! Its a must try!

Food ok customer service ok we had to wave the flies away the whole meal a little concerning we asked for chips to go since the flies flew on the other ones $2.75 charge won't return read more

This Steak Consteno was one of the best Mexican meals I've had in awhile. I'm from Texas and I highly recommend a stop here. Even if you have to wait in the line that formed after we were seated. The food was well prepared, well seasoned, full of flavor, at a really good price. read more

Cancun Bay Mexican Restaurant - Steak Consteno - Mexican Near Me - Tomah, Wisconsin

This place is great! The food came out hot and tasted delicious as always. This is one of the best kept secrets if you are visiting this town! read more