Carolina style grilled cheese is amazing! Go it to go. My wife tried this place with the kids while I was golfing. So I tried it myself today, and it was awesome. read more

I am a regular of this place when it's open. It's a neat place to get a quick meal. It's a very casual restaurant with a variety of good grilled cheese sandwiches. I've tried many of their sandwiches and nothing has disappointed so far. Highly recommend it if you want quick and easy meal. Also, I LOVE the pictures they have on the walls. It's fun looking at where they inserted a grilled cheese into the picture. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - Pork Roll Grilled Cheese Sandwich - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

This place is a MUST visit for vacation! It's so cute inside they have a bunch of famous paintings with grilled cheese in them and it's so funny! The food is amazing, like A M A Z I N G. I don't even know how to describe it besides amazing it's just too good, best grilled cheese place I've ever been to and everyone should definitely give this place a try!!!! read more

See all

Carolina Style Grilled Cheese was exceptional!!!!! We have come to Cape May for years and this is the first time here.... We will be back a lot now!! read more

Grabbed a quick lunch here during a recent Cape May trip. Decor is a cool selection of grilled cheese themed art. The gentleman working the counter was friendly and gave good recommendations. I enjoyed the pulled pork grilled cheese sandwich, served with some tasty fries. The salad option aka "Da Bowl" fell a bit short for my wife. It doesn't match up to the quality of other salad bowls at a similar price point. That said, the grilled cheese sandwich certainly delivered. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - Pulled pork grilled cheese sandwich and crispy fries! - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Felt like I paid $14 for two slices of bread and chips. I had a grilled chicken grilled cheese and there was hardly any meat or any cheese on it. I had been here the previous summer and had a very different experience. I make much better grilled cheese with Kraft singles in my own kitchen. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Cape May Grilled Cheese is a small place with a pretty distinct menu, so I thought we'd try it out. There is obviously regular grilled cheese, but there are so many options and grilled cheese combinations that it gets crazy. The crab cake grilled cheese was like a crab cake sandwich. The Nashville chicken was pretty messy. The regular grilled cheese was real good. If you are interested in some wild grilled cheese combinations, try Cape May Grilled Cheese out. But for me, there really is no reason to overthink grilled cheese unless it's with bacon or something like ham. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - More Grilled Cheese inventions than I could image - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

The Cape May Grilled Cheese Company opened almost a week ago and the food is full of flavor! My Carolina Grilled cheese was packed with tender pulled bbq pork which mixed with the cheese was delicious. The Original Grilled cheese is also tasty. Their menu features more than grilled cheese, and has a fun vibe to the names including the Jawn. Their location is perfect, located in Ocean St, but really in the north end of the Washington Street Mall. They feature six tables and chairs inside, and then there are plenty of places to sit outside on the mall. Parking is available behind the mall shops, on the street, or in the Acme lot (which is free if you are under 30 minutes). The Cape May Grilled Cheese Company features a variety of drinks including canned soda and canned water, this was my only concern that $2.75 is a bit high for a can of soda, but it is Cape May! Go and enjoy!!! read more

See all

Wandered in and was surprised to see it not be very crowded. Our first visit , so not sure what to try. Went with the Pork Roll Grilled Cheese and it was delicious! The honey chipotle sriracha was amazing with just hint of heat. Didn't see all sandwiches come with chips, so I wish substituting fries was suggested. I see it on the menu now, but overlooked in the store. The lobby was visually appealing and interesting and made us want to sit and enjoy our food. Can't wait to return and try something new! read more

See all

This places takes grilled cheese to a whole new level. I got the Carolina grilled cheese and I was surprised. It is pulled pork, coleslaw on a grilled cheese. It's one of the best grilled cheese sandwiches I have ever had. The pull pork is well seasoned and the coleslaw adds a nice crunch to the sandwich. The service was quick and you can tell the employee love their jobs. It's a little small but it has enough space to do a good job. If you can stop by and grab a grilled cheese you won't regret it. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - Menu - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Came here on a Thursday night around 630 and the restaurant was empty. This had me a little concerned but we got the pulled pork grilled cheese, some chicken tenders and the bacon ranch fries. All were really good the food came out quickly and the food was hot. The stuff on the walls is quirky but neat for the space. Didn't seem overly expensive for the share. Blows my mind that it was empty. I hope they don't close. Give this place a try people! read more

The best food I had during my visit to Cape May! Recommend the lobster fries. Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, a great meal! read more

The grilled cheeses here were amazing! I got the chicken bacon ranch one and the chicken was so moist and the bacon was perfect. Comes with chips. Good portion for most of the grilled cheeses costing around $10-12 except for the lobster one which costs more. Would definitely go again! read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - Chicken Bacon Ranch Grilled Cheese Sandwich Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwich - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

They do beach delivery which is great, and the lobster grilled cheese was yummy. However, a star was taken off for the lobster fries. The fries are advertised as having shredded lobster, but the "lobster" used was clearly imitation and kind of ruined the fries for us. If the fries had real lobster like the grilled cheese did (or if they were advertised more truthfully so we could have gotten something else) it would have been 5/5. read more

My first time here and WOW! Was looking for an affordable quick lunch and I am so glad I stumbled upon this place. The Hipster Grilled Cheese was packed with its awesome ingredients and the bread was perfectly buttered and crispy. Loved the pickles and sriracha combo! If you like a little spicy (obviously I do!), be sure and try the Fried Cauliflower Strips with the Honey Chipotle Sriracha. BOOM, I want this sauce in my fridge for everything! Definitely give this small business a shot. You won't regret it! read more

The best grilled cheese sandwich I have ever had! And the chips were amazing too. Centrally located in downtown Cape May. read more

Cape May Grilled Cheese - Original Grilled Cheese Sandwich - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Our whole family enjoyed our lunch here! My daughter is a grilled cheese connoisseur and she absolutely loved this place :)

Here's an amusing story (unless you're the customer): Going into Cape May Grilled Cheese ... asking if you want the order to stay or to go ... replying "to stay" ... and then being told, "Oh, you can't eat here today" (for some very vague reason). And then -- wait for the punchline -- being CHARGED AN EXTRA FEE FOR TAKING THE FOOD TO GO!! No, this isn't a sitcom premise. It's a real experience at Cape May Grilled Cheese. So, my friends, if you want to be asked a question that isn't really a question and then get charged for a service you didn't want, by all mean, stop on by. read more

What a hidden gem- awesome grilled cheese- our table had the OG, Mac n Cheese, and Taylor pork roll sandwiches and they were all great. Teens loved it (a plus). Great service- personable. LOVED the wall decor read more

Stopped here for dinner with my mother. I had the hot Nashville chicken grilled cheese and she had the chicken bacon ranch grilled cheese. Both sandwiches were delicious!! I highly recommend lunch or dinner at Cape May Grilled Cheese at the Washington Street mall. read more

See all

Food was okay. Got the crab cake grilled cheese. It was a fish cake. They charged an extra $3 for taking it to-go which is extremely stupid.

The food is delicious, the service is great & they were very kind. The interior design is cute & I absolutely loved the music selection.

Sandwich was good, Ambiance was good, Only complaint - Wished the chicken in the sandwich was a little more flavorful.

Went there at 6pm on a Saturday night. Sign and Yelp says they're open til 8. They weren't. Won't bother going back.

Very good pulled pork grilled cheese! Side of fries was perfectly crispy. Food came out quickly and was freshly prepared. Owner greeted us with a smile. Canned waters added a nice touch. Try out this hidden gem over by the Acme! read more

Redownload yelp just to give this place 5 stars. Food was fire. Service was amazing they were very nice. Bacon chicken ranch was crazy good. Very nice setting inside as well. read more

This place is very mid. I ordered the Nashville hot chicken grilled cheese and there were soggy chicken strips in it. The service is great though. read more

The grilled cheese sandwiches were terrific. We had the "Original", a smashburger and the tuna melt. They were full of flavor! We'd go back any time. It was nice to get a quick, easy sandwich in a city full of fancy restaurants. The service was good and the location is convenient, right on the Washingtom Mall. read more

Great service and good grub! Yelp requires 85 characters so I am just typing more to make those idiots happy. I am not like the typical Yelp wannabe business owner who just whines and complains. In summary, get a great grilled cheese here! read more

Got us a winner here. Lobster grilled cheese is one of the best lunches in Cape May. The butter of the grilled cheese goes perfectly with the Lobster. This will be a vacation staple. read more

This place is tucked in and a great find!!! Super fast service and The Carolina grilled cheese was incredible. Pork was tender and it melted in your mouth. Also had the fried cauliflower strips. They were also very good with the Siracha sauce. Great food which came out in under 5 minutes. Owner also greeted us and was very nice. Will be back! read more