I had a hunger for Fish and Chips, so I went to Captain Arthur's. The interior has been redecorated nicely since the last time I was in. They were having a Crab Cake and Fries special, I got that and then added two pieces of fish to my order. The owner, Denise, provided vinegar, tartar sauce, and cocktail sauce. The crab cakes were good, but there's nothing like biting into their fish and getting that distinctive crunch! I splashed some vinegar on my chips, and they were so tasty. I love this place... and I'm already thinking about going back again soon to get some of their great fried clams! read more

See all

Food tasted rancid. My visit was such a disappointment after getting excited this place even existed.

A fitting tribute to the original AT. Our meal was delicious and the place was very clean. The staff was very pleasant.

5/5 - Taste - Delicious fish, chips and slaw! Cooked fresh to order and served HOT! They even have malt vinegar. 5/5 Service - The woman who works the drive thru was super helpful. She didn't rush the ordering process and more importantly, got the order right! She even gave us some coupons for future visits once all was paid for. Nice read more

Drive thru only, but time it right during lunch and the food will be hot. Got the clam and fish combo. Not that salty greasy stuff like at Long John Silvers. Hot. Thin crispy coating (unlike Ling John's, which is more salty batter than fish, blech!) hot chips (I mean proper English style chips) fish, hush puppies, even the clams were hot. Easy four for the food. read more

Captain Arthur's - Nice piece of fish, HOT chips, and clams on the bottom. - Fish & Chips Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Same great taste . And the Ladies that own it are awesome. Very good environment and staff.

Fast and friendly service! The food is always HOT and fresh! The same old recipe from Arthur Treacher's. Consistent great quality food!

We stumbled across this location yesterday and just had to stop (the ones in our area closed 30+ years ago). Although it looked kinda desolate and run down from the outside we still went in and were very pleasantly surprised! Inside was clean and adorably decorated for fall. Husband reported the restroom was spotless. The service was pleasant and the food was hot, well cooked, and delicious!! The lemon pie is still made the tasty way (fried). We absolutely enjoyed this and also made sure to do a Facebook check-in; all our friends were jealous and now want to go too read more

Captain Arthur's - Fish & Chips Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

On June 15, 2019 my fiancé and I were in West Mifflin, PA. My parents had mentioned to me weeks prior about Arthur Treacher's and said we'd have to check it out! We found this location because it was little over an hour away and we knew we would make it before they closed for the night. Boy, were we wrong about that.... After leaving West Mifflin and driving an hour in the rain, we made it to Youngstown, Ohio at 8:25pm. I checked my phone and saw Arthur Treacher's was to close at 9:00 pm. We were glad we made it with half hour to spare. As we drive closer, we can see Arthur Treacher's with their "open" sign on the windows. But, we also see a woman vacuuming the carpet. We figure, it's 8:30, I'm sure she'll stop vacuuming. We park the car outside and gathered our stuff to head in for dinner. As we were standing in the rain, we heard this old lady yell and say: "we close! We close!" And a door slams. We look and the woman who was yelling "we close" was the woman vacuuming. We couldn't believe how they decided to close 30 mins early. As we left, we drove back to Pennsylvania because our hotel was in West Middlesex. We eventually got dinner at Red Lobster. No wonder these Arthur Treacher's locations are dropping like flies off the face of the earth. Need better employees who will keep the restaurant open for their desired times... not close early because they felt like it. read more

As a SoCal "foodie" transplant to OH, I'm always seeking the best hole-in-the-wall, re-opening, or small family run joints. Formerly, Arthur Treacher's, one sample of their rib night special, has me yearning for more on the menu. I always walk in, order and watch. I walked in, ordered a full slab of ribs dinner and took advantage of the Thurs & Sat, "Buy 1 rib dinner, get another, 1/2 off" deal. Of course! Quite pleasantly surprised! While about a 15 min wait (I was a walk-in, expected it) watched fish & chips, chix coming out and looked great. My turn! Gathered my bags of goodies. I'd NEVER had a hushpuppy (other than shoes, when I was a kid). My brother had and stated he wasn't fond. Next morning - "OMG! Those are THE BEST HUSHPUPPIES I'VE EVER HAD!" I don't do chicken but can't wait to go back and try the fish & chips dinner. Sides of clams and more Hushies! And, shrimp. And, they actually have cocktail sauce to dip your shrimp. NOT, just tarter sauce, but cocktail sauce. Granted, it's not my own homemade,cuz, I'm on the flyby, BUT, the fact they offer/have (even in the packet) is a miracle. Will update soon. Cheers, Austin/Youngstown. Go grab some great eats. Cheers! read more

Captain Arthur's - ...then, the other! - Fish & Chips Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

Get it while you can! This restaurant chain has largely gone out of business. 850 locations in the 1980's. Fewer than 20 now. This one is still in business for obvious reasons. I just had fish, clams, shrimp, hush puppies, fries and a lemon pie. Everything was perfection. I mean...perfect. Quick service, fresh, hot, clean, friendly, etc. 5 stars without hesitation. read more

Captain Arthur's - the front of a restaurant - Fish & Chips Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Always liked their fish, but got their ribs the other day for a change of pace. They melt in your mouth!

So the hours on line on several different sights say close at 9 pm! Pulled through drive through at 8:15 lights on and employee is standing at counter starring at me she stares at me for 5 min with headset on! When I proceeded to drive around drive through to check hours and leave she took headset off and turned her back to me! Hours say 9 pm! I called and asked when the closed and the girl said 8 pm and proceeded to get rude and give excuses when I said on line it says 9! I love arthurvtreachers and am there 3 times a week but never again.! read more

While the food is still reasonably good, the staff leave a lot to be desired. They are not friendly, they refuse to give a phone number where complaints can be given ( we were told that corporate doesn't care about complaints anyway) and they refuse to give the condiments asked for. We were told that we could only have the cups of tartar sauce and not the packets. If this is the new policy then they have just lost a long time customer. While this sounds like a petty complaint it could be a big deal in the future. If I pick up a family pack to take to an outdoor picnic in the summer, the last thing I want on my fish is tartar sauce out of a cup that has been out in 90 degree weather for a few how's. The packets aren't going to go bad, the cups will. I will be going back to Long John Silvers, they have no problem giving me packets. If this is how all Arthur Treachers treat their customers then I can see why they are going out of business. read more