We have been weekly regulars at Carmine's for several years. No more! The recent inconsistency with quality is disappointing. 3 examples: 1 - The meatball sauce is extremely salty. 2. - We ordered Minestrone soup that was literally tomato water. 3 - We always order our pizza well done as the crust tends to be soggy. The last few times the crust wss still undercooked and soggy. (Awful actually) We like to support small businesses but Carmines is off our list now. By the way a large pizza and 4 meatballs is close to $50. Unacceptable! Plenty of other options including one right across Lincoln read more

Not worth a visit. Mediocre garlic knots, defrosted and reheated, lukewarm pizza with limited sauce and generic toppings. Dessert was tasty but sourced elsewhere. Entire restaurant has the bathroom disinfectant smell. read more

$18 for a SMALL cheese pizza. Want toppings? That's going to run you another $5-$8. Want a medium pizza? That'll cost you your first born. Stop patronizing places that charge $20 for $3 worth of ingredients. They'll never stop scamming you until you do. read more

LOVED the food, giant portion sizes and so good! The Penne Gorgonzola was outstanding.

We have been ordering food from Carmines located in Lone Tree for years now. Tonight one very bad manager just lost a very good customer. I don't think the restaurant owner is going to be happy with that. Carmines made our food and over cooked mine and didn't fill my wife's order correctly. When we called the female on the phone said she was the manager and she would not be making our order correctly for us. Instead she just canceled our order! We had to go somewhere else for dinner! WE WILL NOT BE ORDERING FROM carmines EVER AGAIN. Instead we will find a friendly restaurant who WELCOMES customers instead of turning them away! I urge you to think about what would happen to you at Carmines the unfriendly restaurant should an issue come up! read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - No cheese in the calzone! - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

See all

I'm not one to leave reviews, but I normally order a pizza from Carmine's a couple of times a month. The last two times there was hardly any cheese on the pizza and I ordered a sausage pizza and there was enough sausage on the entire pizza for maybe one slice. And for the price I paid well I don't think I'll be going back there again. They have really gone downhill. read more

We just moved back to Lone Tree/Highlands Ranch a couple weeks ago and came back to our favorite Italian Restaurant!! It is kid friend which is good because we have 2 grandson's 6 &8! And they have a great kids menu! (We did not have them with us today! Also we love their outdoor patio but today was raining! Ask for for Devon because it was the best and he really likes his job. read more

See all

Food was ok for the price. I was expecting more for what we paid for. Generic. Not the homemade I thought we were getting

Carmines is our go-to for Friday night pizza delivery or pickup. You can set a time which is great and they're always on time or early. Very good pizza too that's consistent and easy to customize online. read more

I got a food borne illness from this place. Had a fever of 100.2 and felt like i was dying for a day. The next day it was gone. All my symptoms lined up with food borne illness especially how it only lasted 24 hours. Even when i ate the pizza - i was questioning it. Plus the wedge salad was in a weird metal bowl - felt like a dog bowl. read more

Stephanie is amazing. She's usually our server when we visit & we love her. This is our favorite spot to eat when we're craving Italian. We've been here several times. We try to make it in biweekly. They're always ON POINT. The food, the vibe of the place, is chill. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Picked up dinner this weekend. It smelled absolutely amazing inside. It is too cute inside. The owner was super friendly and very helpful. The pizza was beyond delicious. Highly recommend. Can't wait to go back and try more! read more

A true NY pizza place has slices available daily. Carmine's has different daily specials also. read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - Front page menu - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

My boyfriend and I ordered for takeout today and we were a little underwhelmed... The stuffed shells were a bit flavorless, and so was the meatball we added on the side. The works pizza was delicious! The Italian salad was as well. I just hoped for a little more flavor. read more

Haven't been to Carmines in a while but visited a few nights ago. Food is still amazing like always. I know most people go for the pizza, but their pasta dishes are delicious as well. My favorite is Penne Gorgonzola and the Alla Vodka is a spicy (literally) runner up. Love their bread too. So good! Food still gets a 5/5. Like many places these days, they seemed short staffed with just one waiter taking care of all the tables, which is rough and I'm not unsympathetic to their plight. However, due to this, the service wasn't as good as its been in the past. Sometimes you just need a refill on water when you're eating spicy pasta. The place has never been sparkling clean, but seemed less clean than usual. So for these two reasons, I have to take away a star - 4/5. read more

See all

Used to be my fave wing spot when I was in the neighborhood... ordered 16 wings and asked for flats... they charged me 6 bucks for flats and didn't tell me. 16 wings were 29 bucks then 38 bucks with the flats charge.... That's over 3 bucks a wing save your money at that price read more

Solid NY-style pizza. Good garlic knots. Great salads. Their pastas usually leave a little to be desired and are usually watery if sauce is tomato-based. It's not a big deal-- we come here for pizza, not pasta, and there are Italian restaurants nearby if we're in the mood for higher quality pasta. We usually order for delivery but occasionally come in with our two young kiddos. Deliveries are usually always on time and almost always accurate. Sign up for their email list for a monthly promo code. read more

The food exceeded my expectations. I will make this a favorite. So fresh, piping hot and made the delivery home still delicious. I ordered for my wife who was working nearby and she loved her dish. Also some unique deserts that were amazing. Sorry I only took one picture but you can see my Calzone had it all. No skimping here. read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - Ultimate Combo Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

Service was awful! They stand around and talk about nothing in their phones! I walk in to get my order after just placing it, I saw my pizza sit in the counter ready to be handed to me for 8 minutes while nobody was working just talking, not pleased !! Food is good when fresh, employees just need to pay more attention and act professional, would not come back read more

I would give them a zero if I could. I placed an order through DoorDash, they couldn't find the order on their end. No big deal, it was just for garlic knots. I asked how I could get refunded since I already paid and the gentleman at the front (who I have come to learn is the OWNER) attacked me verbally. Like the rudest person I have ever met. I was being so calm and respectful and he was raising his voice with a nasty tone and getting all worked up. All they had to do was say sorry they didn't get it, DoorDash will refund you, and we'd be happy to place another order now for you and have that right up. Instead this man was extremely rude. I walked out and will never and I mean never support their business again and I'm a regular customer. Great job guys! As someone who works in customer service this experience was deplorable! And don't blame DoorDash for your terrible lack of customer service. Don't team up with 3rd party vendors if you can't figure it out. I would have ordered directly but on your website it makes you choose a third party site for ordering. *And not this was NOT a scam as the owner claims...maybe he should do some research before he makes that claim. Here is DoorDash with the pricing...see pic below of $6.50. I had to call DoorDash to cancel and they had the order so clearly it wasn't a "scam" and that's a disgrace that you would accuse me of that! read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

Welp back again for Christmas and they did not disappoint! The food was hot and delicious . I got a salad and they do NOT give you just lettuce! This thing was loaded with chicken, avocado, egg, bacon, blue cheese crumble, and tomatoes. Since we are traveling I asked for dressing on the side. They were awesome about making sure we got things wrapped to go so I could enjoy the rest today. We also got a pizza with sausage pepperoni and light mushrooms (kids don't notice if it's not too much). The pizza was delicious. We have pizza at home but they have a great amount of toppings and the sauce is delicious. My daughter got spaghetti and again a generous amount of food. My son loves desserts so of course he ordered a cannoli which also did not disappoint. The staff were amazing and I chatted with the owner. It's lovely to support a local small business and I'm glad we were able to come back! The building is in a strip mall near chipotle, and I think the noodle company. They have great staff who are friendly and it's a good place to take the family. read more

See all

Staff was great, service was great food was delicious! I would definitely recommend the calzone and zepole! Restaurant was clean and had a relaxed atmosphere. read more

Ordered $200 worth of food. 1 out 3 pizzas were delivered. Restaurant would do nothing. Garbage place. Don't order.

Always great food. Just had the stuffed rolled pasta. Will definitely order again. Whenever my grandson spends the night, he asks if we can order from Carmines. He loves the BBQ chicken pizza. read more

Exemplary family style service; social seating, well lit and comfortable. Feels like you belong here... Had a bite after work, was happy to be sat down immediately. Server was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable of the menu; didn't go with the old "everything is good" line. Wine selection hits the mark, moderately priced and diverse... Wine selection 4.25/5. Was recommended a few items; arancini, meatballs and a few pasta dishes. Ultimately tried the arancini; crispy but relatively flavorless; 2.9/5. Tried a pizza for the main dish, a Margherita. Cracker thin crust, virtually no flavor. It was covered in raw diced tomato and had just a touch of basil. It was recommended to add the basil pesto and balsamic reduction as dips; that definitely changed the game. They could make it a fun, bar-style meets flatbread pizza if they used the pesto for the base sauce, and both limited and cooked the tomatoes on the pie. 2.75/5. *note, pizza wasn't recommended, but when I chose it, server highly recommended the pesto for dipping. Those garlic knots though - Dear Lord! Easily some of the best things I've eaten in a while. Beautifully balanced between crunchy and chewy, fantastic flavor development and a mellow marinara for dipping. 5+/5 -- seriously worth ordering!! Loved the atmosphere, loved the service and community within...wanted to love the food, but will no doubt double up the garlic knots and ask if they can customize a pizza..... Enjoyed, you will too. read more

Absolutely delicious! I had their alfredo with broccoli and mushrooms and my hubby had their gorgonzola pasta. Both were super yummy, some of the best alfredo I've had in a long time! We will definitely be eating here again. Highly recommend! read more

Good neighborhood spot for tasty Italian. Food hits the spot and the prices are reasons. Garlic knots were tasty. Pizza was solid. Salad was great. Service was excellent. They have a good kids menu. We will definitely be back. read more

Due to COVID they are doing takeout only. Sorry I forgot to take pictures before we dug in! We ordered garlic knots and a half meat lovers half cheese pizza. Pizza was very good. I was impressed it was still hot after driving home. That doesn't happen with a lot of places. Folks were friendly and working to get customers out quickly. They were manning the phones as well as helping customers. read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

See all

After a long week of travel to visit family for Christmas, my wife, kids, and I decided to order from Carmine's in Lone Tree. We wanted something easy that the kids would enjoy, and since Carmine's offers their own delivery service, we skipped the apps and ordered directly. Our food arrived hot, accurate, and delivered by a kind driver--who we made sure to tip well with the holidays around the corner. The portions were generous, and the toppings on my meat lovers pizza were plentiful. The kids loved their spaghetti, and my wife's calzone was perfectly prepared. Everything tasted fantastic, far better than the big chain options. Supporting a local business that delivers such great quality felt good, and we're already planning to stop by in person before heading home. Carmine's offers excellent value with their generous portions, and we couldn't have been happier with our meal. read more

First time trying Carmine's. We will return! Marina is delicious. Sean, our waiter, recommended Chicken Parm. This is a must order dish. Restaurant has a nice easy going vibe. read more

See all

We enjoyed the food and service so much! Ordered a pep/pineapple and some wings for delivery on New Year's Day. Pizza and wings were sooo good! This place uses high quality ingredients, good quality wings u can just taste it. Most delicious ranch! Quality + taste and service - delivered within 45 min. 5 STARS! I'll be back! read more

Terrific NY style pizza and AMAZING cannolis. Great for dine in, or takeout. Pizza done right!

I really came here because I had a hankering taste for some fettuccine Alfredo and they were literally 3 min away. I ordered the jerk chicken, which was cooked perfectly and the jerk sauce was balanced excellently. The sauce is goodadenamuhfucka! Now my pasta, the fettuccine Alfredo, very lackluster, tasteless, the noodles, the broccoli, the asparagus tasted as if it came straight out the pot, no seasoning added to the water or anything. Noodles were bland as well. I tried to spruce it up but it just was a fail! I don't know if I'll give it a second chance, maybe just come for the chicken and not the pasta cause that was damn good! So me personally, I'm from the south, the tastes are different, it could be just me but I did not like it very much. Would not recommend! read more

Carmines Pizza & Pasta - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Lone Tree, Colorado

I love Carmines! I think it is underrated. I've only ever had good service by friendly staff. Food is really good, lots of variety and plenty to share or have leftovers. I would recommend! read more

It was a nice night so we sat on the patio. Service was excellent and the food was really good.

The service was good . The menu has a variety of dishes. The food was uninspired and average. I would return to try the pizza but not the pasta dishes. read more

This place is amazing! It is now my favorite pizza in the area! Their calzones are fabulous! The service was great. We will be definitely be going back. Oh, I forgot to tell you... the sauce! Mama Mia was it delicious! I could eat it by the spoonful! read more

See all

I thought the food and the price was good value. I believe we way over tipped as we forgot they add tip to every bill. Other than that, it was good and will be coming back. Ambiance needs some work, but it was clean. read more

Mom and pop. Good service. Food is good. Nothing exceptional. Pizzas and calzones are great. Affordable. read more

Good service, nice atmosphere and amazing food. For $16.50 I got the homemade lasagna. I have been to a lot of restaurants and this is seriously the best lasagna I think I've ever had! Not a great variety of draft beers but the Bluemoon was good. We also got spaghetti, pizza the works and dessert. Do the gelato or u will miss out. See you again soon thanks for a great dinner. read more

See all