Carmines is my first choice when it comes to choosing what pizzeria to have for dinner. Ever since I moved from Long Island to brooklyn almost 6 years ago when I married my queen, I just had to find the best pizza in brooklyn. Out of many pizza places that I have tried Carmines pizzeria never disappointments. I probably ordered from them 20 times or more and I have never been disappointed. Everything from the sauce to the cheese to the ingredients they use, components of a perfect pizza compliments one another and gives you the true taste of fine brooklyn pizza. Also, the pizza comes in clutch on date nights, so if you tryna do a date night at the crib, the pizza goes hand in hand with some wine and your lady will smile with approval. Do yourself a favor and order this delicious pizza. I guarantee you wont regret it. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Baby Pepperoni Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

There are many acclaimed pizzerias in Williamsburg, and then there are those working-class operations which pump out slices and pies to quell the unquenchable pizza thirst of the people of this city. Carmine's is very much a high-volume producer, and their 18" New York style is entirely adequate. I ordered online, waited a few minutes, then walked over. A bit of a line to pick up, but soon I was at the counter, receiving my box of happiness. The cold night air sapped some heat from my pizza, but it was still sufficiently hot when I made it back inside and opened the box. Can't go wrong with these big, floppy slices. The pepperoni coverage was fair, and the topping upcharge was cheap. I dabbed off some surface grease and ate to my heart's content. The slices are chewy, but not as much of a jaw workout as Smiling Pizza or Two Boots. I didn't get to try any of Carmine's specialty slices, though I did like the looks of them through the glass of the counter. If I ever return, I'd like to sample those exotic offerings; in the meantime, I feel confident knowing that Carmine's can execute a decent New York style pie. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Large pie with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Went here for the first time as I was craving vodka sauce and looked up a few spots on Yelp and found this one! It's a dive bar with lots of tvs and a pretty big space. We got bread for the table which I enjoyed and penne vodka for the meal and also a pizza. The vodka sauce was pretty delicious compared to what I was expecting since it wasn't a very traditional Italian spot. Prices were also great! read more

My honey ordered me and my son the housemade meat lasagna from here last night 2/2/2024 on Uber Eats it was pretty good. I enjoyed it,the portion was perfect. I had enough to save for today. the only thing is it was pretty dry in the middle. I love a saucy lasagna it had a good amount of sauce around the beginning parts of the dish, but once you got in the middle, it was little to no sauce. My son enjoyed his,he didn't eat all of it which was shocking he's 15 and got a big appetite but he wanted to save his for today as well it came with four pieces of soft italian bread very delicious and fresh.I would definitely order from here again I would just tell them to make sure it has alot of sauce in the middle as well read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - My Housemade meat lasagna with my two pieces of fresh Italian bread yummy -Homemade Meat Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Sweetie and I are in Brooklyn celebrating his birthday. We walked up to Carmine's from our cute little hotel, passing approximately 20 weed/smoke shops, as well as bakeries, coffee shops, and a bookstore. Have I mentioned how much i love this town? Carmine's is the pizzeria you imagine when you say, in a longing and wishful tone, "man, I want some real NY pizza." The pizza counter has a generous variety of types. I got the eggplant slice and the wood fired Grandma Tri-color, sweetie got the spinach-artichoke on a Sicilian-style crust, and a slice of caprese too. The caprese was studded with 2 types of whole olives and halved cherry tomatoes. The eggplant was practically thin as potato chips, crisp where they stuck out of the cheese. The tri-color with a big swatch of pesto was indescribably delicious. The spinach slice tasted so fresh, the flavors of the spinach and the artichoke both coming through clearly. The regular, wood fired, and Sicilian-style crusts each had their own distinctive weight, texture, each a mix of chewy and crunchy in a different way. I regret that I cannot live in this dining room for the remainder of my natural life. As for the small details: it's clean and nice. The bathroom was spotless. There are no stairs to enter, so it's as handicap-accessible as anywhere in NY. There's no parking whatsoever; just take Metro and save yourself the headache. The G and the L both would work. read more

Love this pizzeria, everything I have tried here was always fresh and delicious. Nice range and variety of slices, sandwiches, pasta, salads and dessert treats. Typically there's not much of a wait time and the price point is fair. There's also a bar and a dining room attached to the pizzeria if your in the mood to sit down or enjoy some live sports on the TVs. I have been coming here for a few years and it's one I'll be back to I'm sure. You like pizza? This is probably the best pizza on Graham Avenue! Enjoy. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

[This is for the pizzeria not the dining room or bar.] Clean, renovated, nice/fast staff. Been a while for me, was partial to Tony's after Carmine's quality lapsed several years back. But I AM THRILLED to report Carmine's is BACK. Both the plain and sopressatta woodfired rectangular slices are *k i l l e r* -- best pizza I've had in a looooong time... and the price is also very reasonable considering the quality. World-class. Really. Thank you, Carmine!!! read more

The baby pepperoni Sicilian is incredible!! Good portion and absolutely delicious. Perfect pepperoni curl

White slice Spinach Roll Vodka slice MVP slice Grandma slice The list goes on, anything I get here is great. A staple in the neighborhood, great pizza. Anytime I'm in this area it's a must I come here for lunch or dinner. read more

Carmine's is the real deal. Their toppings are generous without making the pizza floppy or overly greasy and the bottom crust is always perfectly cooked. If you're not feeling pizza they also serve about every other Italian dish you could want, plus bar food. The business itself is a no-frills type of joint which is how you know it's legit. The left side is a slice shop and where you pick up to-go orders, and the right side is a sit-down restaurant/sports bar. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - The tri-color (bottom) and sausage/pepperoni (top) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Cuisine: 7 Service: 7 Decor: 6 Value: 6 Overall: 7 Random stop in for a quick bite. We ordered a regular thin slice, mixed mushroom square slice, and a Sicilian. The regular slice's crust was a bit thick but was crispy and had plenty of sauce/cheese. Mushroom slice had fresh mixed mushrooms and an excellent crust edge. Unfortunately, the bottom crust was a somewhat soggy. Lastly, not much to complain about on the Sicilian, it was very good. Bottom line, a decent pizza shop (connected to a restaurant/bar) in the East Williamsburg area. I would stop by again. read more

See all

Update: ive had 1000 vodka pizzas and penne a la karens since my last review - still delicious. Tried the chicken marsala - YUM. Picture doesn't do it justice imo. I also tried the lasagna and I didn't love it I thought it just needed something more. Overall still obsessed with this place!!! read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - chicken marsala - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Loved everything about this place, such a hip pizzeria / restaurant vibe! Takes me back to an episode of the Sopranos. The food was absolutely delicious, service was good and ambience was super chilled. read more

Carmine's just raised their prices and charge to use a credit card. We have been loyal customers for close to 20 years. Sticker shock is causing us think twice about ordering here and cook more at home. read more

I would rate Carmine's Pizzeria four and a half stars. Great selection of specialty slices. We had a pepperoni specialty slice on thinner style Sicilian crust and specialty salami slice on an ultra thin crust. Both were delicious. They were priced at $5 per slice which I suppose is reasonable for a specialty slice given most of my go to pizzerias now charge $3.75 for a regular slice. Personally, I preferred the salami one. It was a unique crust and the salami was so good. The salami flavor must have lingered in my mouth for an hour. The service was quick and hospitable. They make it a fun stop for a late night bite. read more

Ordered several large pies for a group of 24 people to be delivered to Area53 (paintball) close by. Everyone seemed to love the pizza hence the 4 stars. Def try the Tri color grandma pie! It seemed to be a hit. One star was deducted for the following reasons: 1. I requested if each pizza could be labeled and they were not (maybe too much to ask). 2. There were no lentils in my lentil soup lol. Pic of the so called "lentil soup below." It was more noddles than anything else. This was the only thing I could have that night so I ended up having nothing! I'm still hungry as I write this post. 3. Finally I also removed a star because absolutely no plates or not even ONE napkin was provided. I specifically asked if plates and napkins could be provided in the comments section. Def would have paid extra to get what I needed. Thank god I'm a planner and had napkins and plates for the large party of 24 on standby. I feel like gone are the days of good customer service. Why have a comment section if you're not going to read it ‍. Idk maybe I asked for too much given covid. When are we going to stop blaming everything on covid ? Okay rant done! Still gave a four star although I had nothing to eat cuz the pizza was on point. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Lentil Soup - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Love this place. Always so attentive. Kind. Unlimited amounts of different types of pizza. So homey. Absolutely recommend carmines to anyone. Thank you for always being grounded to any and every person who goes in. read more

We all came here on a last minute change of plans. We had heard good things of Carmine's. We were all hungry and wanted to order the whole menu when arriving! "Give us everything on the menu" one of my friends said to the waiter! Btw the menu is extensive.. When arriving there are two store fronts a pizzeria and a bar/restaurant. The decor on the bar area is cute. You can tell the owner likes baseball and the Yankees to be exact! Like I said we sat down and it was difficult picking something because the menu is extensive and we were super hungry! We decided on a few things and went with it. A salad with goat cheese, pecans and apples over spinach. I heard it was tasty and good. Also, it's a very large salad so def something to share!! A personal margarita pizza from the oven that sits in the bar area. It was good not great! The sauce was somewhat bland and so was the dough. We added some grated cheese. Unfortunately coming from NY there is a lot of great pizza places. We also order chicken francese. When it arrived it looked a bit of a mess. Not plated nicely. The breading seemed to be falling off. I didn't try but just from the looks I'm glad I didn't. We also ordered clams and linguine with white sauce. The linguine was so over cooked. It was really upsetting for an Italian to even eat. The sauce was somewhat bland. Also, not much of a portion. We also order a side order of broccoli rabe with sautéed garlic and oil it had no flavor what so ever. Lastly we order a Cuban sandwich. This was more of a ham sandwich with really hot mustard. There staff here was sporadic and look annoyed when asking them for anything. Overall, maybe we came on a bad night? Maybe we ordered the wrong food? Or maybe they have such and extensive menu they should limit it to what they are good at and stick with that.. I def will not come back Parking is extremely difficult (353) read more

See all

The people and the food are top notch. Don't take my word for it. Go find out for yourself

Best pizza outside of Manhattan. Been coming here for years. Even after I left the neighborhood. Great place. Great people. This is an institution of culinary excellence. read more

This was the worst unauthentic Italian I've had in a long time. The salads were crafted from salad from a drum and the plastic cheese you get from a bag. The straight-up canned sauce tasted like tomato acid and water had a baby. The cheap wholesale calamari was dumped right from the bag to fryer, with no pepper or spice, with the watery pizza sauce accompanying it. The only reason I think people come here is to watch the games and drink, because it can't be the good . read more

Pizza here is pretty excellent and it's easy to grab on the way home. Their tomato sauces are homemade and tasty.

Ok so we ordered from Carmines pizzeria last week bracease I saw they had that tiny spicy pepperoni cup lol and I had to have it!!! You know how it is :) now the delivery was nice and fast so the pizza was still hot!!! Now the pizza was freaking good!!! Hahaha it's call BABY Pepperonis pizza in their menu ;) and the dough was soft and the sauce was flavorful!!! So I recommend getting this specific pie!! :) yummyyy read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Baby Pepperoni Sicilian - - AllFunNYC from Instagram - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here a few months ago great pizza, small walkway, distant neighborhood perhaps if I happen to be there again

Ordered delivery, mozzarella sticks and Carmine's favorite hero. Super disappointing and a waste of money. When I was eating the sandwich I felt like I had Covid again because I couldn't taste it anything. They didn't even salt the chicken. Mozzarella sticks are better at the bodega. Maybe I'll try the pizza here one day but delivery was a bad idea. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Carmine's Carmine's Favorite Hero - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Anytime I'm out in the Williamsburg area for work I make it a point to stop here for a slice or three haha. It's arguably one of the best slices in the queens/Brooklyn area. One of my favorites is the pepperoni cups on Sicilian or the regular Sicilian. Can't find a better pepperoni cup slice. We ordered a bunch of pies and they were fresh, hot, and delicious! Can't wait to Make it back here. May be in 6 months so I can actually stick to my diet this time. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Sicilian with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Carmine's is THE pizzeria in East Williamsburg. I miss the homemade Italian dishes they used to have up front when this place was smaller ... their expansion to the next-door sports bar changed the old-school family vibe this place had 20 years ago. I hope it's a successful biz model, because I hope Carmine's never disappears. I will always keep coming out on the L and make an excuse to stop at Graham Ave for this slice. Great brick oven, and high quality ingredients. The pepperoni, soppresatta, and sausage have personality. Great eggplant slice... "Ben Frank" slice is a perfect take on the margherita style, fresh flavorful basil. The wood-fired oven is perfect. The classic thin crispy vibe is there, but they keep their slices a little floppier than some other places. I think it really works for this style, because the dough is delicious and blends well with their sauce/cheese proportions. And Carmine's sauces can be put on the top shelf, in the conversation with all the more famous pizzerias you've heard about in Brooklyn. Great job with the pesto, the vodka sauce, and cacio pepe. They have some inventive slices too. So many different grandma's. Burrata with honey? Yes please. This place makes me want to try everything on the menu. I get the feeling they are really next-level, when it comes to the homemade sauces. NEW YORK PIZZA RAT APPROVED ! read more

Ordered delivery on a Sunday at 6:30, order arrived at 7:40. This was within the time frame indicated, but pizza arrived cold and french fries were soggy. The cheesesteak is advertised as "with Philly steak and classic cheese" but they used Cheez-whiz for mine. The bread was hard as well, not normal cheesesteak roll. Overall a pretty mediocre experience. They do have a lot of different foods available to order, so maybe some are better than others, but my choices tonight weren't great. read more

My first NY pizza experience visiting Brooklyn from San Francisco. Wow, delicious pizza, we ordered two grandmas one pepperoni and one with the three drizzled sauces - my mouth was rejoicing and asking for more. I couldn't stop eating, my mouth wanted more. The flavor of the sauce and the toppings and the fact that the slices are square and pack so much flavor, and the melty gooey cheese. We also ordered their house salad and wings - both did not disappoint either. Very good food and excellent service. Definitely going back on next visit. You need to try this place it will not disappoint read more

I made my order on Seamless Carmines pizza is really great. My delivery went well. I was pleased with the quality of the food and the overall taste. 1. I ordered the tuna sub which was AMAZING! Loved loved loved. The tuna tasted fresh, avocado was great, lettuce was yummy (Romane lettuce), the tomatoes were fresh, the bread wasn't dry. It was overall awesome and at 8.00 you can't beat it. It can feed two people or one hungry person lol. The bomb a definite must have. Yes I know their a pizzeria but it was great and you should give it a try. 2. I ordered a lasagna pizza. I though it was okay tasting. I didn't taste the flavor in the meat and felt it would have tasted better if it was seasoned. The sauce was great though. The dough was pretty good too. The meat wasn't great because it was bland. 3. I ordered French fries. This is what I will not order again. They were $5.00 dollars and I wasn't a fan. This part was a epic fail. Defintly don't know how they could get this wrong but it was very wrong. While the fries may look as if they were done they weren't. They were undercooked as well as for they were dry as hell! didn't like them at all. SO if your going to order them think about it first. Maybe Carmines needed to change the oil of get fresher French fries because these were horrible. Delivery= 5 Service= 5 Cleanness= 5 Food= 4 Overall= 4 stars read more

See all

Carmine's is a great neighborhood slice shop with tons of variety. You can get vodka sauce, ranch, hamburger style pizza, or classics like pepperoni and mozzarella. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars is that the pizza feels heavier than other slice shops like Best Pizza. Still delicious read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Vodka square, pepperoni square, margherita triangle - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Had my 30th birthday here and It was great! The food and the service were excellent and the room was the perfect size to have an intimate gathering. read more

Good food Excellent customer service. Wood oven pizza .....Exellent.... The ambiance very chill and good read more

Food is delish - had the Sunday gravy - nice big dish and full of love - my hubby had the chicken parm and my daughter had a chicken broccoli rabe mushroom specialty dish - was delish and very healthy. A must come too and affordable. Like the atmosphere and the people /staff super nice read more

See all

This grandma vodka slice is exactly three flavor profile I've been craving. Its by far the best pizza place in Brooklyn.. definitely my favorite it was so good.. Not getting pizza from anywhere else. Nice classy spot if you want to sit down. I ordered a to go slice, in and out. Service was fast. Friendly service. I can't wait to go back. So many tasty options read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - What's left - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Phenomenal! Like literally one of the best pizzas I've had in NYC. This is top of the charts for a cheese pizza in New York. WOW! The crust is perfect, the cheese is perfect, the sauce is perfect. Honestly that slice was unreal. read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Idk what I picked, I just pointed but f**k that's amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Solid pizzeria with a ton of options. I typically try a new slice every time I go, really can't go wrong. The bar has a bunch of TVs and typically full during big games. read more

You must stop by & grab a slice - or two! This place is a few steps away from the L line on Graham & is pretty easy to locate. I popped in for a quick dinner on the way to catch a Broadway show. I ordered the cheese pizza & one pepperoni pizza. I got my food fairly quickly & sat at the counter, enjoying the food. I didn't feel rushed to eat & give up my seat at any point. The pizza was perfection - good quality NY pizza with affordable prices. I would definitely come here often if I lived in NY! read more

Carmine's Pizzeria - Cheese & pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Carmine's! I've been going there for four years and ordering lots and lots of takeout, too! I just ate a chicken parm sandwich - seemed like it was made with chicken bacon! And I don't mean chicken and bacon, I mean chicken bacon. So thin- as if it was cut on a slicer - then dried and fried to death. Everything else is great. Please fix your chicken parm!! read more

This is an amazing Italian restaurant! Numerous different types of pizza, a brick oven, comfortable atmosphere! I walked in, saw all these different pizzas! The aroma was making me hungry! They also had chicken parm sandwiches in what looked like a large garlic knot (Gotta try it!) We sat down and saw two girls behind us eating. One had this amazing looking dish, she said it was "Chicken Bruschetta with Buratti". The bartender/waiter "Rocco" (great guy) told us it was really good - HE WAS RIGHT! Oh my goodness!!! I cleaned my plate! The girls even ordered 2 to go for dinner that night!I didn't expect this from a sports bar/restaurant!!! As far as Italian food in a sports bar goes, I give this place a 10 out of 10. See you soon Rocco!!! read more

See all