Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Castro's Restaurant

    3.6 (325 reviews)
    ModerateMexican
    Open 9:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Order Castro's Restaurant Takeout or Delivery

    Castro's Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    CASTRO'S RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Castro's Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Castro's Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    rachel k.

    great spot! my mom and i came for brunch and were pleasantly surprised with all the veg options. my mom was easily able to order a vegan version of the chilaquiles and we got home fries on the side. the vibe was good, and we had a great people watching table in the front. will definitely be back!

    Soft Taco Carnitas?
    Walter T.

    This place has its own special kind of food, they have a good lunch special for under $12 , w/ a drink . The service is a bit slow at times especially when there not buzy ! Unless there during togo orders, i definitely would order right away! They have a backyard here but small , definitely not a place for groups but you can sit at tables together' the thing I don't like is a got my BILL and I was hit w/ a service fee , on TOP of a credit card charge, when in fact I paid on CASH and also added gratuity on my bill on top of tax also .. BECARFUL when you get the bill , THE don't tell you ALL this till you get the check . I would use CASH here or expect hidden charges on your credit card statement next time!

    Drink menu
    Cee G.

    Good food with great deals The drinks are delicious the service is welcoming. They have lunch specials The ambiance is very cultural they are Mexican it beautiful and colorful You can sit and eat or get take out

    a woman sitting at a table
    Nakia S.

    Castro's is one of the staple restaurants in the Clinton Hills/Fort Greene area, it's been here for years and never really disappoints! Authentic eats and my favorite red sangria . Nicer weather, dine outside in the backyard. Sunday dinner choice: chicken fajita with sangria. Burrito to go. Everything was delish!

    Quesadilla Con Arroz Y Frijoles, 3 Piece Flautas, Pineapple, Strawberry and Lemon Mix
    Bea T.

    SO GOOD!!! The food here is to die for, especially the rice, chips and quesadillas. Castro's is my go-to when I'm craving a home-cooked meal, as the atmosphere is very comforting. Their hot coco and lemonade also taste amazing. What to know? You walk in, ask to be seated, take a look at their gigantic and extremely expansive menu, order, and either pay up front at their registers or ask the check be brought to you. Only one time was there any real delay in getting my order and they gave my group free chips before any of us realized more time than usual had passed.

    Quesadilla Azteca
    Taylor M.

    The perfect local restaurant. We order/go to Castro's at least once a week. My go to is the chicken quesadilla and it is flavorful, cheesy, & enough for two meals! The rice and beans are always on point and the guacamole is always fresh. They offer indoor and outdoor dining as well as take out. Give this place a chance, you won't regret it.

    Chilaquilles bistec, sopa azteca, tacos
    Pleasantries F.

    Bring your appetite!  The food is irresistible and the portions are generous!  I first came here when I was a student at Pratt about 12 years ago and fell in love. It's one of those classic establishments that I'm so grateful is still here and doing well!  Authentic mexican is hard to find in NYC.  They have a huge menu with everything you could ever want including fresh juice and smoothies. Today I had the mole chilaquilles loaded with beef, the sopa azteca, a huge orange juice, handmade chicken tacos, and flan for dessert. Everything was super tasty, warm, and pleasing to the eyes.  The staff was extra nice and the food came out quick. They give you free homemade chips and salsa too.  I sat in the outdoor, heated seating area in front.  They have a nice open air patio too and the inside is cute. I'm actually shocked that this place doesn't have five stars, but reading through some of the reviews it's clear that many who gave lower marks just don't know real mexican food. Someone gave one star because a quesadilla had "crispy edges" and "too much cheese"!?  Literally WTF? You clearly don't know what an authentic quesadilla is. The generous amounts of meat and cheese, and the perfectly crispy and soft cooked tortillas are what I love about this place. And the prices are very reasonable, and certainly just as good as other Mexican restaurants in Brooklyn. They have affordable lunch specials too. You can also blame raising rent and condos, not your local restaurant if you don't like nyc pricing.  So please eat here and leave them a good review too because they deserve it :)

    Kelly G.

    Very authentic food and drinks, and just a lot of fun! I'm new here but this is one of those restaurants that my friends frequent a lot, wether it be for dinner or a chill night out. The food is pretty cheap but you get a large portion no matter what you order. There were so many options on the menu I could hardly decide, I want to go back and try everything!

    Enchiladas de Pescado.

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 9 of 9

    Castro's Restaurant Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Castro's Restaurant

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Mexican 73,561 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Chela Park Slope

    Chela Park Slope

    4.5(789 reviews)
    2.0 miPark Slope
    $$

    Chela is one of the best Mexican restaurants that I've been to and I'm incredibly lucky that it's…read moreclose to home and has an extremely friendly and welcoming staff. Everyone that works there is super attentive and for how busy they are they always make sure to check up on your table. Their tacos are extremely delicious, they don't hold back with make sure each taco is full of any kind of meat that you get! Full of flavor and just looking at them reminds you why they're the best. Some other notable things that you should get is the quesadillas and the nachos they have. I'll have to keep coming back to try other things. Great place for sporting events as well as I was here with a group to watch Brazil vs Morocco and stayed to watch the Knicks win right after and become champions!

    I really enjoyed my experience in this establishment. Definitely was worth the trek from Uptown…read moreManhattan. This neighborhood gem offers an industrialized minimalist form of decor with pops of color and art. Cozy but roomy, the bar area had mostly 2 seater tables and a few with high chairs. We recently went for a birthday brunch. Restaurant Week was still in effect but we decided to choose from the regular brunch menu. Place was low key and giving neighborhood vibes. The service was 10 STARS! Our waitress was extremely attentive and kind. We were also checked on by a second staff member who I think may have been a manager but cannot be certain. We started with cocktails and they serve chips and salsa gratis. I had the Jalapeno and Hibiscus Margarita and my friend ordered the Pepper Margarita with Strawberry and Chipotle. Mine was a bit on the sweet side without a hint of tequila. My friend's drink definitely was the better of the two. Not overly sweet and definitely a flavor of tequila was present. We also ordered a guacamole. I must say it was quite small and barely served 2 people. I suggest if more than 2 guests are part of the experience, order more than one. For my entree, I requested a market salad and 2 veggie tacos with a side of birria consume. Salad was very fresh and I am sure was made to order as opposed to premade a week prior and waiting in a fridge to be served. My tacos were average but satisfying. The consume was a bit disappointing as it was more of a water/broth based and not of a typical gravy consistency. It was not exciting. My friend's entree was the highlight of the experience. She had the brisket quesadilla. Never have I seen a quesadilla with a crispy outside such as this. A culinary masterpiece indeed. She consumed it all and not one complaint afterward. Delish. We did receive a complimentary Churro plate for the birthday celebration. They were drizzled with caramel and berries. Served warm, they were a dream for the palate. I did use the bathroom which was a single stall. It was clean enough but not well lit. The biggest downfall of my experience was the temperature of the restaurant. I understand it is summer, however, there was no A/C and the inside was extremely hot. I sweated through my entire experience. Even the bathroom felt like 100 degrees. We did not complain but our waitress noticed and brough a fan out to circulate the air. They do have ceiling fans but honestly I did not feel them. The management/owner should consider more temperature control methods during the hotter months as it was quite uncomfortable. To sum it up, I thought this experience was mostly positive and would patronize it again.

    Photos
    Chela Park Slope - Fresh Made Guacamole

    Fresh Made Guacamole

    Chela Park Slope - Queso Fundido

    Queso Fundido

    Chela Park Slope - Fish Tacos

    See all

    Fish Tacos

    Xixa - Charred Edamame

    Xixa

    4.4(725 reviews)
    1.2 miWilliamsburg - South Side
    $$$

    I was honestly shocked by how much I loved this place! We did the tasting menu, which was $65 per…read moreperson, and I also ordered the passion fruit cocktail. It was fab! Most of all, what I really appreciated with every bite is that I wanted more and that it was so unique compared to anything else that I had ever tried. I thought the tasting menu was a really good deal, but you should also consider booking just a la carte because everything was so solid. You can tell when the chips served alongside the guacamole are so delicious and so unique that the rest of the meal is going to be incredible. I will say that it did seem slightly understaffed. Our waiters did the best they could, but dinner took longer than expected. It was still a great experience for both those on dates and those there with friends!

    4.5 stars, 5 for food and 4 for service…read more Food was delish! My favorites were the gem salad elote and the guac. We also got the crispy snapper taco and the duck to share. I loved all the sauces that they give to each table that I couldn't decide which one I liked more. The drinks were very good as well. We got the deconstructed margarita and I really enjoyed it as well as the pina colada cocktail. Service was a bit on the slower side but to be fair, there weren't many people working the tables. Also one of our dishes got served to the wrong table and then never came :( definitely wanna come back to try the tuna tartare which was the dish that didn't get delivered.

    Photos
    Xixa - Seating inside

    Seating inside

    Xixa
    Xixa - Bar wall

    See all

    Bar wall

    Castro's Restaurant - mexican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...