We were on a trip to PEI, and stumbled across this place. What a great view, the location is…read morestunning. The place is clean and the staff are amazingly friendly. I had the lobster roll with chives and dill with mayo, unfortunately the lobster was not fresh. This was a little sad for me as we really are right on the water. But the fries are delicious, and so is the coleslaw.

We each had a cup of the seafood chowder. We shared 1 ounc of mussels and the grilled cheese and…read morelobster sandwich. Way too much food but it was all delicious and we don't regret having all three. The service was prompt and friendly. One of our favorite meals so far on our 3 week trip through Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and PEI.

Stopped for lunch here at the Cavendish Boardwalk after seeing the AoGG Heritage site. This place…read morewas *hopping* for lunch, which is always a good sign. Our family has to navigate life with a severe nut allergy, so we were impressed when the staff took the time to discuss with us exactly which menu items were made in-house and safe. It's a mom and pop operation, they talked about how hard it was to find consistency and quality from the suppliers during -and after- the pandemic. We were able to find several food options for my son, and for him we ordered fried fish with a side of poutine. He was in heaven. Well, we all were, actually, because the seafood was delish. We even returned later for soft serve ice cream because they guaranteed it was nut-free. My kid has only had ice cream from a commercial restaurant maybe 2 or 3 times in his life, so it was a very rare and welcome treat. We definitely recommend Captain Scott's - both for their food and also for their family's friendliness and service. We love this place. Thank you!

The food was terrible and most likely frozen beforehand. The staff were unfriendly and the prices…read morewere high for such small portions/servings. The place was kind of depressing it was empty and staff were on their phones the whole time. Multiple people came in and left because of the ridiculous prices. The staff weren't doing their jobs as they were sit around and not doing anything while on their phones. Overall do NOT come to this restaurant it was my worst part of my trip to Canada.

Service was excellent and quick. However, the food is…read morepretty expensive for what it is. For 2 meals it was just about $50. The food was mediocre and really not worth the cost. It was good but not $50 for 2 meals good.

Affordable chip stand fare. Had a fish sandwich, scallop burger and club sandwich. Club and fish…read morewere very good the scallop burger not so much - dry and chewy. Served with huge amounts of the sides - onion rings and sweet potato fries. All the food seems to be pre-made, frozen food that is fried/cooked on site. The staff are very young - so please be patient.

We stayed at the Stanley Bridge Resort this past weekend for my husband's best friend's wedding and…read moredecided to check out Sutherland's, since it was on-site. We didn't have time for lunch or dinner but we popped in for their breakfast on Monday morning. The first thing we noticed was that the place was pretty much empty. Now, this is probably because we're getting to the end of the season and it was a Monday, but it really didn't bother us. Our server was sweet, and actually one of the same servers that was at the wedding on the Saturday before. The breakfast menu was small but it had something for everyone. They were even able to substitute something for my non-egg-eating husband. We both got their breakfast with bacon, eggs (not for him, he got more bacon), toast and hasbrowns. It was great!! Bacon was cooked perfectly, eggs were awesome and the hashbrowns weren't deep or pan fried, they were more like a hodge podge potato - tender, skins still on, and moist - they were FANTASTIC! Overall, a great breakfast . We can't wait to check out lunch and dinner next year!

Absolutely love this place! The food is excellent and the service is great. The Seafood chowder and…read moreseafood linguine are a one-two punch that you need to try at least once!

Excellent service! We ordered ahead of time and they cooked our lobster the day of our departure…read moreand packed it on ice in our cooler! Impressed with how they accommodated our needs! Happy customer from Ontario!

Same price as restaurant n not friendly service idk why the reviews have high rates…read more I just went to a restaurant and groceries in Charlotte Town also steams lobster for u

Food and service is second to none. Their beet salad with Shrimp is delicious and all ingredients…read moreso fresh.

Food took some time to get served. Otherwise, fizzy lemonade was good. Tried their fish and chips…read moreand seafood chowder, and mac and cheese for kids.

We visited on a warm and humid August evening. The sign read "Island's longest salad bar" and while…read morewe could not independently verify that assertion, we can confirm it was one of the longest we have seen. The food was great and service was very friendly. We had a wonderful time cracking the lobster and enjoying it hot with butter. Lots to choose from for an after dinner treat -. The strawberry shortcake was particularly delicious while the kids enjoyed the ice cream. A great experience and wonderful time!

I have been going here for years and I grew up in Sherwood PEI. Tonight I had the worst lobster I…read morehave ever had in my life. I explained to the server it was horrible and they apologized and offered another one, but I explained I was full and could not do it. She was kind and apologetic but said it's not your fault. The lobster was soo cooked there was very little meat in the claws and what was there was stuck to the side of the shell and had to be somewhat scraped from the shell which really was not enough meat to make it worth it. I complained Ed in the way out and one of the managers said if it was over cooked they all would have been. I have been eating and cooking lobster since I was in my teens. He looked at me and said so what do you want me to do. Lots of people try this to get a meal. I said obviously you are not going to do anything and I left saying we would not be back. As a Veteran, I will pass this on to other Veterans and let them know they are probably better off to go to New Glasgow lobster suppers.

What a beautiful spot for a sunny afternoon! We sat right on the dock overlooking the bay, enjoying…read morethe gorgeous scenery and friendly service. The oysters were some of the best and freshest we've ever had, right from the bay! We also enjoyed fresh lobster rolls, a beet salad, and flavorful chowder. Everything was fresh, delicious, and full of flavor. We would absolutely come back!

Nice place right on the water with seating either outside, outside with wind protection and inside…read more Very friendly and attentive wait staff. Beer was cold and oysters were yummy but small and a bit pricey, 12 dz for $36 CA. No happy hour specials.

Wonderfully friendly service, a charming atmosphere, and the most creatively delicious food!…read more The Blue Muscle is a must when visiting PEI

The food was amazing. Looking forward to trying the spot again before we leave the island.read more