We were on a trip to PEI, and stumbled across this place. What a great view, the location is stunning. The place is clean and the staff are amazingly friendly. I had the lobster roll with chives and dill with mayo, unfortunately the lobster was not fresh. This was a little sad for me as we really are right on the water. But the fries are delicious, and so is the coleslaw. read more

Island Favorites - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Cavendish, Prince Edward Island

See all

We each had a cup of the seafood chowder. We shared 1 ounc of mussels and the grilled cheese and lobster sandwich. Way too much food but it was all delicious and we don't regret having all three. The service was prompt and friendly. One of our favorite meals so far on our 3 week trip through Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and PEI. read more

See all

We arrived in town today and started looking for a restaurant. This was a great find. As others have said, it is a family owned business. Our server Brooklyn was wonderful. The food was delicious esp the chowder, lobster rolls, coleslaw, potato salad - wait- that's everything we ate. All wonderful! We are looking forward to returning! read more

Chose the place based on average reviews. I was not overly impressed. The service seemed to care more about their convenience than serving the customer. Our group ended up having to sit separately because the waitress was concerned about not being able to walk around a larger table, which seemed unfounded and a concern that was waitress centered rather than customer centered. When asked about closing a window because cold air was affecting some in our party, same waitress said it was not possible because the kitchen needed the air... Well... five minutes later, the customers that took the table near the window simply closed the window to avoid the cold wind... Two for two! Not a great beginning. Ordered seafood chowder and fish and chips. What would you expect? Yes... seafood chowder is served first and once customers are done with it ... you bring the fish and chips. Logical, right? Not here. They brought everything together, which meant the fish and chips got cold while we had the chowder. Third strike... Anything else? Let me say this, the fried fish, in my opinion, was not great. First, you could taste "stale" oil (old oil). This alone turned me off. Second, there was little fish and a lot of breading, I'd say 70% breading 30% fish. So, if you combine oil taste with very thick breading you get what I got. To eat the fish I had to take the breading apart. On a positive note, the seafood chowder was excellent. As Luc B. review pointed out, it is a very basic family and kid friendly setting. read more

Awesome family owned restaurant. The food is amazing and the service is exceptional. Really chill environment with not too many people. I would definitely come back. read more

Island Favorites - Lobster roll (greenhorn) - Seafood Near Me - Cavendish, Prince Edward Island

See all

Excellent meal! The lobster club and the chowder were both outstanding!! Service was great too.

Friendly staff with excellent Seafood Chowder and the Lobster Roll was amazing! Very basic family and kid friendly setting! read more

Just stumbled on this great place. The staff is super friendly; the service is wonderful. I had the BEST clam chowder I have ever had (and I have tried a lot). It was full of seafood; great consistency- not too thick, not too thin; absolutely fantastic. Prices are reasonable. Great place for lunch! read more

ISLAND FAVORITES RESTAURANT - A Quality multi generational family restaurant with fantastic, delicious and freshly cooked family meals. Originally went in as they are a Gluten friendly restaurant! But we were quick to realize that all of their food is delicious, flavourful very realistically priced. They have gluten and non gluten options. My daughter is celiac, and we have eaten twice there and she has not had a single issue!!! We are on vacation here in the Cavendish area for 6 nights, we have eaten there twice!! FIVE STARS . There were six of us, including 3 generations of our family, and there was food that appealed to all of us. I would be remiss if I did not give FIVE STARS to the staff, we met Sandra, David and Stacie, all of them went out of their way to make us very welcome! We did not meet "Mom" who is the chef magnificent!! Another FIVE STARS I hope you will stop by and check them out if you find yourself in PEI, they are 100% worth the travel to CAVENDISH, PEI! Oh, the seafood chowder, lobster rolls & lobster clubhouse are the BEST! Best regards, Maureen read more

Very friendly service and excellent food. My friend got the lobster club and I was jealous! That is my order next time.

Happened upon this restaurant by word of mouth, and the recommendation was bang on...the chowder and the lobster roll were amazing. It's such a neat little place....Dad fishing the lobster, Mom cooking in the back and daughter serving out front! A wonderful place for a lovely lunch! read more

Decided to stop here based on all positive reviews, so glad we did. Great service and amazing food!!! Well worth it!! Hope to make it here again before we leave read more

See all

Outstanding food and service! Everything was top-notch, delicious, and cooked to perfection.

We ordered Captain Lobster Roll and Lobster Club Panini. The food was fantastic including all the sides! The coleslaw, potato salad and fries were top-notch. The fries were a bit salty for our taste but the crispiness made us empty the whole basket. We were sad we couldnt try the Sailors sampler but maybe next time! read more

Island Favorites - Lobster Club Panini - Seafood Near Me - Cavendish, Prince Edward Island

See all

Had the Greenhorn Roll and potato salad, both were excellent. The lobster was fresh and tasty and not overpowered by the mayo and dill. The bun was perfectly prepared, crispy without losing the soft chewy texture. read more

Island Favorites - Seafood Near Me - Cavendish, Prince Edward Island

See all

Amazing food and amazing service!!! The chowder was delicious and the lobster rolls was fantastic! Lots of gluten free options! Sandra and Rhonda do an amazing job! Stop in and support this lovely business! read more

We had, of course, the lobster roll, which was fine, although not as transportive as the reviews lead us to believe. We tried three different lobster rolls and could barely tell the difference between them - perhaps too subtle for the likes of us.Quick and simple, and a bit overpriced at that, nothing to complain about per se. The restaurant was boiling hot the day we were there, though (no AC) and the odd split half-wall with the pub restaurant adjacent was very very odd. Kids menu uninspiring; fish and chips. read more

Ordered the lobster rolls. They were acceptable. A little too much mayo for our taste.

Amazing clam chowder! The lobster rolls were extremely generous and perfectly prepared served with those wonderful new PEI potatoes and red cabbage cole slaw. Bright, immaculately clean and comfortable. Excellent and prompt service. Pretty close to Cavendish beach. read more

Very good lobster roll, potato salad was different than I've ever had and delicious. Very friendly staff read more

Island Favorites - Seafood Near Me - Cavendish, Prince Edward Island

Best lobster roll in the island! They have 4 different rolls and I was too greedy to order the sampler plate which came with 4. Hurray! One roll one bite. Lol handmade lemonade was a great pairing read more

See all

Many others have written truthfully about the excellence of the chowders and lobster rolls. I would point out that the interior of the establishmen has been remodeled since the website photo was taken. There's now a combination of bench seating as well as new tables and chairs. The "sides" of potato salad and coleslaw were very tasty as were the generous portions of homemade iced tea and lemonade. If you desire a meal of exceptional quality in an attractive informal environment in the heart of Cavendish, you will not be disappointed. The Island owners could not be more friendly. read more

So good! Literally the best lobster rolls I've ever had!! The chowder is great too! I personally like the lobster grilled cheese or the first mate's roll! If you're anywhere on Prince Edward Island you must come here! read more

As of the time of this writing, Island Favorites "PEI's BEST Lobster Roll" is ranked number 1 on TripAdvisor for best place to eat in Cavendish. This ranking is not unwarranted. We tried the Greenhorn roll and the lobster grilled cheese sandwich. While somewhat pricey (to be expected in a touristy area like Green Gables), the food was dynamite. The lobster grilled cheese was extremely flavorful, and the Greenhorn roll had a great blend of spices that amplified the experience. Ambiance is extremely low key - I'm talking plastic tables and chairs. The set up looks more like an ice cream shop than a lobster-roll restaurant, but make no mistake: this place is a must visit. Definitely stop in and tell Danielle, "hello!" She was extremely friendly and helpful. read more

I had the Captain's Roll (largest lobster roll on the menu) and the price was around $16, but with the amount of fresh lobster on the roll it was well worth it. The flavor was explosive, so good it'll blow your head clean off. My wife had a gluten free option, which was great, and they take credit cards, which is somewhat of a rarity at some establishments. It seems like most places have gluten free options. read more

Amazing food in a quaint place...a must try...don't fall for tourist trap restaurant, come here for some hardy seafood chowder with bread and butter and an awesome assortment of lobster rolls including just lobster and butter! wonderful family business and great service. ..sorry no pictures, we were too hungry! I hope I can go back some day! read more

The lobster roll was good. But I would say - basic/standard and a bit over priced. I doubt this is the best on the Island. Hard to find decent food in Cavendish tho- so I guess that in comparison to fried stuff people felt compelled to rave. Service was fine - you order at a counter though so not like it makes much difference. We liked it but it's served with chips only- all sides are ala carte so I think they are pricey considering they are very small and the sides are separate. read more

Chowder is fantastic. It is how you expect chowder from any other restaurant should end up tasting but always end up failing you like your family or grand kids. Lobster panini was awesome. Sure they ran out of bacon and the service was good and apologetic when things didn't turn out. Freshest eats thus far and will be going back. read more

I am looking for the perfect lobster roll - generous amounts of lobster with light mayo, good seasoning and perfect bun. I tried the Greenhorn lobster roll and it was pretty close. Toasted bun was good and it had a fair amount of lobster. It was seasoned well with chive and dill. The regular was medium sized. Also tried the lobster chowder which was really good, but I wish it had more lobster. Potato salad was a little above average. I would stop by again if in the neighborhood. You should as well. read more

Lobster rolls here were amazing. I had the Captain lobster roll with potato salad. Everything is made in site and tasted great! Nicely renovated too! read more

A great little find. We all really enjoyed our meals - lobster roll, chicken wrap, grilled chicken panini and grilled cheese. A simple menu really well done. read more

Awesome tasting lobster roll but overpriced, after reading reviews and looking at pictures I was disappointed when I saw my lobster roll. Do not order kids meals - chicken roll had cold bland chicken strips and chips were stale. My husband ordered the chicken panini it was very good. read more

Amazing lobster roll and probably the best potato salad I have ever had. I was only on PEI for 2 days and I ate here twice.

Amazing restaurant!! Me and my daughter had the lobster roll and it was simply amazing and I loved the environment of the restaurant all the employs were so happy and nice.the melted butter was great on the lobster roll.!! read more

good tasting lobster rolls. we tried the dill green horn and the classic versions. the dill version is unique and worth driving over by itself. the potato salad and wedges that were included as sides were both excellent. considering the entire package it was also very good value ($16). read more