Friendly atmosphere. Waitress was great. Food was delicious! We ate in, but food was so good we…read moreeven took food to go. It was a drive for us, but absolutely worth it. Will definitely go back!

The operating hours stink! Who closes a pizza place on weekends? Out of town visitors get cheatedread more

Went at 5:30 and doors were locked on a weekend. Asked workers walking out if they were open, they…read moresaid they were getting ready to close. Website says they are open until 7. Will not be returning.

Thanks for being in Salem County! Staff is always friendly and beet cold. Casual atmosphere for a…read morequick bite n Beer or hang and the friendly people.

Very skimpy on food and overpriced and it was not welcoming at all. Do not recommend.read more

Came here with the hubby for some lunch on our way towards the shore. We sat for a bit when someone…read morefinally brought us menus. The server was friendly, although overwhelmed. There was no direction of whether to order at the counter or be seated. Hubby ordered a salad that he asked for with chicken but when it came out about 45 minutes later, there was no chicken. I ordered a salad and a mini hamburger- it was advertised on a Kaiser roll, but came out on two slices of bread. When I ordered it, I asked for it medium rare, but it was well done when it finally appeared. Disappointing. The food tasted fine although my hubby's chicken tasted like charcoal. About a half hour after waiting, the people next to us were told there was no roast beef. They adjusted their order and got their food before us, although we ordered before them. A bit strange. While I was waiting for our food, I walked inside to see what kind of things were for sale. They had balsamic vinegar and olive oil which were nice. The vinaigrette was really good and we were told they used the balsamic from it. However, on the shelves in the back, there was a cruddy jar of something that no one would buy. I picked it up not realizing it but put it back. I am adding a picture of the flowers. They were very nice. They should put some work into fixing the signs around that were peeling.

Stopped by on the way back from Cape May - worth the trip! Great Lake front location. We sat…read moreoutdoors but there are lots of inside seating and bar areas. We had a steak salad and prime rib sandwich. Both very good. Service was also excellent. One comment - the steak salad was served in a huge deep bowl. We had to ask for another plate so you could get to all the ingredients and slice the steak. Prices were reasonable for the quality. Surely worth a visit.

Went there on a Thursday night. Second time here. Very cute and cozy place. They still have…read moreChristina's decorations which was nice! We sat at the patio and while it was "heated" my friend's and my feet were FROZEN! The flounder on the specials was soooooo good!!! And so was the crab dip!!!

Easily one of the best diners in Elmer, NJ!…read more Whenever I visit NJ, I like to have at least one meal at a diner. Not one of those silly chain diners like Silver Diner, but an authentic place with authentic food. The Elmer Diner is one of those places. It ticked all the Diner boxes. It offers everything from huge portions of tasty foods and friendly service to menus the size of Russian novels and placemats that advertise local businesses. I decided to go simple and ordered a BLT. Even that came with soup and fries. The sandwich was perfectly made with plenty of bacon. The fries were crispy, and the soup was delicious. My only suggestion was about the soup choice. They offer a rotating selection of five or six soups, included. They also offer their French Onion soup for an additional $3. I sprang for that upsell and love it. If you like French Onion soup, I'm sure you'll like it too.

Great breakfast. Tasty burgers. Old school shakes. Wide variety of daily specials. Friendly staff.read more

These folks never fail in delivering great food and service. Last I was there I had the cream of…read morebeef and also the cream of asparagus... Excellence on a plate! Their steaks are amazing to the point you need no steak sauce. Their steaks steak sauce doesn't do it credit. I love that it's a historical place and you can see it through the building. Perfect for that romantic dinner with your significant other. The only downside I see, but not their fault, is that booking a reservation can be a bit of work. They book out quick and weeks out. Once see come visit them, you will understand why they book out rapidly. I'm looking forward to coming around soon.

Local gem! So pleased to have finally snagged my long awaited reservation. Which I highly recommend…read morefor special occasions to avoid not being accommodated. The food was great and had wonderful fresh ingredients. The bread was warm and fresh. The French onion soup was superb and flavorful. The chicken piccata and crab au gratin were prepared well. Service was exceptional. It was perfect for a date, anniversary, or any celebration. I will return for sure.

Papa Luigi's is more or less my go-to whenever I'm in the area. Part of that is because it's one of…read morethe only places around that feels like a real restaurant, not just a quick stop or an afterthought. You can sit down, take your time, and actually enjoy a proper meal. The food is consistently solid, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere feels comfortable and familiar. It's the kind of place you end up coming back to without really thinking about it, because you know what you're getting and it never disappoints. If you're nearby and want an actual sit-down meal instead of fast or forgettable food, Papa Luigi's is the easy choice.

The food is always good. I love the bruschetta and marg pizzas as well as the garlic or cinnamon…read moreknots. However every time I go to the restaurant the staff is always unpleasant. Unfriendly and borderline rude. I wish the staff were more pleasant so I wouldn't feel uncomfortable ordering here!

I wrote about my experience here under the previous ownership name. Didn't know there was an…read moreupdated listing. Nice place, good food and good people. Check it out!!'

Stopped by with our 6 year old granddaughter- she had a lot of fun playing with all the kids and…read morethe personal pan pizzas were really good- we would definitely come back if we were in the area!

Well, if you follow me, you notice I very seldom eat at any restaurant that's not a chain. Well, I…read morehad a meeting today and I was told to meet here for lunch. It was very nice and clean, and we both enjoyed our meals. I had a large Cobb salad with extra grilled chicken. The other guy ordered some scrambled eggs, gravy, and a side of bacon. We both got a unsweet tea to drink. I thought the food was excellent, the other guy said he lives close and eats here all the time. The bill for our lunch was $47 and some change. I thought it was sort of high, but there's no bargain anywhere. Maybe that's the going rate not a huge issue, I just thought it was high.

Made a spot here on our way home from AC and it sure hit the spot. The service was fast and very…read morefriendly. Our waitress checked up on us often and the food was your typical diner foods. The quesadilla stood out the most of what we got but nothing was terrible.

Good food reasonable prices and friendly staff Been coming…read morehere for about 10 years and never had a problem

Fun place to come hang out and watch the game. Food was av, drinks are drinks lol. I will say,…read morethey may just have older equipment, but the water and both sodas tasted funny. Didn't drink them because of it. Hopefully it doesn't have anything to do with cleanliness. Otherwise service is great. Just a typical down-home local bar that's a fun place to hang with friends