My favorite meatball parm is now crap. What is with the salt??? I could not finish my sandwich. It…read morewas so very salty. The person who took my order on the phone didn't speak enough English to understand what I wanted. They had to put someone else on the phone. In 3 months the place has gone straight to hell. I won't be back

All I really wanted was a good piece of pizza so I jumped on Yelp to find what was recommended…read morenearby. I was not disappointed with the grandma slice and regular pizza at all! The grandma was definitely my favorite, so I had to go back and get a second. What really put it over the top for me was the little bit of pesto diagonally drizzled on each slice. Yes. I had three slices and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Staff is great...and its laid-back pizza joint at the end of a mostly empty shopping center. I did notice plenty of takeout orders so the locals must know it's good, too.

The food was delicious and the bagels tasted fresh. The staff were very friendly and went above and…read morebeyond to make us comfortable even though we aren't local to the area. Absolutely loved it, and will become a staple of all my future NY trips!

Well it was cozy and definitely loved by the locals vibe I got here. The staff was very friendly…read moreand when I ordered they very thorough to make sure my order was right, I do appreciate the effort, since it's value. Got the Thoho and a bagel with cream cheese with lox. For the thoho egg sandwich pretty good, melty cheese, grilled ham, fried egg and okay home fries, since crispy home fries would be better. For bagel with cream cheese and lox, the bagel was toasted just right, not burnt but not under. Plenty of cheese and the lox was plentiful. Great place for a quick breakfast.

Pretty good food but…read more.. Do we really need to have BOTH music and TVs blaring at the same time? I said something and they chose... TV. I should have been more specific: Get rid of the TV! It's not an airport! We don't need to have CNN yelling at us all the time in every public place. I realize your restaurant isn't a library, but the TVs create a terrible atmosphere. It makes me want to leave. I might have stayed longer and ordered more food except for that.

absolutely love their chicken cilantro pizza. it's my favorite from there. can't find anywhere that…read moremakes it but them. the guy who checked us out was great. even gave us free cookies.

Placed a delivery order. Driver got a "flat tire". They failed to notify me until 1 hour after the…read morefood was supposed to be delivered. Complete shit show and I highly doubt that was the real story. If I could give a half of star I would

A bit dissatisfied. I placed an order for delivery via Grubhub for a simple sandwich, which should…read morehave been super easy. It took over 1hour and 45 minutes until I called to see what is taking so long and was told "it should arrive in about 20-30 minutes! (I was only 5 minutes away) I just cancelled it and requested a refund. Never again.

Adriana was such a helpful person…read more We were two ladies not sure what to eat and she recommended food for us and made us feel so Welcomed! The food is great and the service was great! I highly recommend this place for the food and the service and I came all the way up here from NJ for their Gyros Thanks Adriana!

Grilled spicy chicken cutlet on whole wheat wrap was delicious! Go early as they get crowded. The…read morevarious sandwiches are on point!

That crust didn't just fold--it surrendered…read more From the first slice, it was clear this pizza had no structural integrity. I lifted it, and instead of that satisfying slight bend, the tip just drooped straight down like it gave up on life. The toppings slid forward, cheese threatening to make a break for it, leaving me doing that awkward two-hand maneuver just to keep everything in place. A good crust should have some backbone--crisp on the outside, a little chew inside. This one felt underbaked and soft, almost like it skipped the oven's final exam. Flavor-wise, it wasn't terrible, but texture matters, and this crust just couldn't carry its weight--literally. If you like your pizza more like a floppy flatbread, maybe this works. But if you want a slice that stands tall and holds together, this one's not it.

Came on here for the first time and I was pleasantly surprised. Got the amazing salad with a really…read morenice size proportion it was delicious. They have so many different varieties of pizzas as well as other items to eat. Reasonably priced so definitely check them out if you're in the area.

My wife and I have made Cugino's our go-to spot in Middletown, and even though it's a bit of a…read moredrive for us, it is consistently worth every mile. It's a cozy, intimate pizza shop with just a few tables, which creates a great local vibe where the focus is clearly on the quality of the food and the people. We started with the Vodka Knots and Pepperoni Knots, both of which were delicious, but the main courses really stole the show. We ordered the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Chicken Parmesan, which we paired with the Sachetti pasta. The highlight of the entire meal was definitely that pasta. I've never had Sachetti before, but they are like these perfect little "purses" stuffed with creamy ricotta cheese. The texture and flavor were incredible--a must-order if you visit. What really makes Cugino's feel special, though, is the service. Our waitress, Adrienne, always welcomes us back with such a friendly and genuine attitude. It's rare to find a place that hits the mark on both the food and the hospitality every single time. If you're looking for authentic food in a warm, small-town setting, "know before you go" that this place is a gem!

I've heard about this spot for a while, and I've had their stuffed pizza a few times before but…read morealways after it had cooled down or sat in the fridge. This was my first time actually eating at Cugino's, and spoiler alert: this is great pizza. We came as a family and decided to do it right. We started with vodka garlic knots, fried calamari, and fried mozzarella. The garlic knots with vodka sauce were a huge hit, perfect pairing. The calamari was well seasoned and fried just right, and the mozzarella was hot, crispy, and exactly what you want. For my main, I went with the meat lovers pizza and was not disappointed. It came out loaded with bacon, sausage, pepperoni, and ham, and every bite was packed with flavor. Everyone else ordered their own personal pies, and each one was a win. The biggest thing we all noticed was that everything came out fresh from the oven, and you could really taste the quality in the food. Service was friendly, helpful, and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. This turned into a great Saturday lunch, and I'm already looking forward to coming back to try more of their specialty pies. 5/5 stars.

First time order and last! Food was AWFUL! Cheesesteak had some type of chopmeat texture, there…read morewas no cheese or onions, fries w/cheese and gravy - no gravy and some type of yellowish cheese & last but not least the crispy wings - NOT CRISPY but CHEWY! This food doesn't deserve a star. I will never order from here again. I was told it was under new management and the food was good. If this is good I would hate to see what they considered bad. STAY AWAY - SAVE YOUR STOMACH!! The response from Josette at Switch Inn tells how bad things are as they got pretty defensive with their comments. I don't file false reviews!!

Absolutely unexpected gem in this establishment! We decided to do brunch in this historic building,…read moreand found a most inviting, cozy, fun place to have bottomless mimosas, and a PANCAKE BOARD! Yes, you read that correctly...a charcuterie board. Of PANCAKES. It has eggs, pancakes, sausage, bacon and bananas with an adorable little jar of orange marmalade! Oh. My. God. There's also a jukebox that you can choose songs from with the help of other patrons and if you're lucky enough, Mackayla will be behind the bar and your brunch will be that much brighter! It doesn't seem like a place that would do such a fabulous brunch but Holy Hannah get yourself over there and order that board!

Fantastic comfort food! The mac and cheese balls were unreal. We had the mushroom, American, and…read morecheesesteak. And on top, great and unique beverages.

What a wonderful surprise. We travelled to visit family and we found this place. Delicious food and…read morethe staff/owners were very friendly and welcoming. They happily answered any questions concerning the menu