four stars. slice was fine , low 7s,(see below) but the chicken parm made up for it, I enjoyed both for a split meal. service was nice, no issues overall. would put them on the options list while in town. this review is like the pizzaslice : fine, gets the job done, pointy read more

After scanning through Pecorinos food photos I knew their pizza was going to be great. We only had time for a couple slices and they did not disappoint. There's personally nothing worse than overly saucy pizza with the cheese falling off. This was equal part cheese and sauce. Can't wait to go back and try their pasta. read more

Pecorinos Pizzeria & Restaurant - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Always great food and service. Owners Marco and Iris are extremely accommodating having been coming here for years. Highly recommend either to go or eating in. read more

The people were very nice and gracious. Pizza was good - thick/NY style crust that was not floppy, although I prefer it a little more "crunchy". Take out dinner for us but there were some nice tables/lighting in the dining room. Garlic knots were the smaller variety but were solid!!! Competitive prices and good pizza. read more

Pizza is the best in Middletown! I've been searching for a great pizza place since I moved here. I got pizza last week on coworkers recommendation and was so blown away! I went back again 2 days later! read more

I had the Baked Ziti Pecorinos and it was delicious! Came with warm bread. The was no shortage of sausage, mushrooms, and garlic. The flavors coalesced and can't wait to have it again. read more

Pecorinos Pizzeria & Restaurant - Baked Ziti Pecorino - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

We had the pizza half sausage/ half cheese. It was delish cooked just the way I love it. The crust was excellent. My husband likes it cooked a little more for the crispness. We also had the fried ravioli (delish) and the mild wings unfortunately they had very very little flavor. I will definitely be coming back. Thank you for your service. read more

Went to this restaurant on a recommendation from a friend. I must say if you want real family style Italian restaurant, you have found it. I prefer this restaurant over olive garden any day. Iris was very welcoming, courteous professional and respectful with her customers. Would I go back again??? Most definitely the food was phenomenal. read more

See all

Food was good. Got home and realized they left out something I ordered. Place wasn't busy so really no excuse. I live a distance so I could not return. Disappointing. read more

Nice Variety Always Fresh Great Customer service Love their Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo read more

Some of the best food in Middletown. The service is great, and the owners are very kind. A must stop place in Middletown!

recently moved to the area and was having a difficult time finding a good pizza place. this place has great pizza and food at affordable prices and the people are very friendly, read more

This was a pleasant surprise! I have been coming from Houston visiting my boyfriend in Middletown for a few months and yesterday was my first time eating here. The food was so good that I wanted to try some of everything. So I'm going to order again today. Yesterday I had the antipasta salad with the baked ziti Pecorinos. It was great. My boyfriend had the cheese garlic bread with bacon and the spaghetti with meatballs (they make the meatballs). He cleaned his plate. Not only is the food really good but the customer service is exceptional. Keep doing what you are doing cause you do it well. I'm going to get off of here now and place my order to try the pizza next!!!! read more

Excellent pizza place and Italian restaurant. We used to go weekly due to it being in the same plaza as a laundromat we used. The food and staff are always great. We love the pizza and wings. They have awesome french fries and cut them in house. Pasta, salad and bread are always delicious too. We haven't found an item we've been displeased with yet! read more

Love this spot, we get take out 1x-2x a week atleast!! The family is very polite, the restaurant is clean!

Crappy managers and crappy owners. I really don't need to say anything else at this point.

Have been getting take out here for a couple years now and always happy. We like their specialty pies the best, Chick Bacon Ranch (our fav), eggplant rollatini and Pecorinos were all good. Chicken ceasar Wraps are loaded with chicken. Pasta dinners are well priced and portions big, you get a 2nd meal out of it. We hope they eventually open their dining room back up, would like to give their dine-in a try. read more

Great Italian restaurant off the beaten path in Middletown. Authentic New York pizza. All dinners we had were very good. People who run the restaurant take pride in providing great service and good quality food. read more

Have been ordering here every Saturday for my coworkers an I the pizza is always great tasting amazingly cooked, will definitely keep ordering from here in the future read more

Got a chicken caesar salad. TONS of moist grilled chicken on top. However, know that you will get all iceberg lettuce, not romaine, which is traditional for caesar. It also came with their delicious homemade "triangle" bread. read more

What do I start with.. The food is great everything that we ever ordered is delicious and big portions. The staff is wonderful very nice they know there regulars on a first name basis. They make you feel like your apart of there family. Big seating area good for large or small groups. Great place 5 STARS read more

This used to be one of my favorite favorite pizza places. I went in recently to order a pizza. I asked the owner I think it's a new owner if the chef was wearing a mask and she circled the question. Well I know it's not mandatory if you are fully vaccinated I would have no idea who's fully vaccinated in this place. For safety I would assume that they would be wearing masks rather than breathe on people's food when the pandemic is still in full effect. Maybe they don't watch the news and maybe they don't know that there are different forms of covid now which can infect you whether vaccinated or not. I won't be coming here again but you can do what you want read more

Stopped by here after work for something quick to eat but after being helped by the staff what I thought was a quick bite because such a filling meal. The environment, portions and again the staff made me feel so welcomed that Im glad I found my new favorite spot. read more

Ordered a large cheese pie. Was the best fresh pizza I've ever eaten in Middletown. Smells & tastes good, inexpensive, and quickly prepared. What more could I ask for? read more

Found this place and I'm glad I did so far the best pizza place around here. Pizza is good and the portions big.

Quaint, family style Italian restaurant/pizzeria with a nice menu. Reasonably priced, good food, huge portions (I couldn't finish my plate). I ordered the shrimp parm- it was delicious- as expected. Very attentive and friendly service.... thank you Victoria. read more

I am usually a very critical person when it comes to food. On a whim I ordered an extra cheese pizza from this restaurant. I just happened to be next door at another store and I hadn't had a pizza in a little bit. Well I finally found what I could call the absolute best pie I really ever had. I am sure you will be hearing a whole lot more about this place, it is tucked away in a strip mall off tower drive just outside Middletown NY. Give it a try you will thank me for telling you about it, I guarantee it. read more

My roommate and I used to order from here often but the last time the staff was extremely rude and hostile to us. We typically get a pizza here but made with vodka sauce instead of marinara. It isn't on the menu but typically the staff is extremely accommodating. The last time we ordered it we were told over the phone they don't make that pizza and could be fired if they did. They asked why I would ask for this pizza since it's not on their menu I told them that we have gotten it from them a few times before and there has never been an issue. They still refused to make the pizza so I told them I had to discuss with my roommate before changing the order and I will call back. After I hung up they called me back and said they "found" the recipe for my vodka sauce pizza and can now make it if I want to proceed with the order. I said that would be great and thanked them for being accommodating. When my roommate went to pick up the pizza though the staff was extremely rude to her and made some snarky comments about how difficult we were and than shoved the pizza into her hands and in an aggressive tone told her how to carry the pizza properly so she doesn't ruin the pizza after they accommodated our difficult request. I was extremely upset with how they treated us who regularly order food from them especially since I have requested the same pizza from at least a dozen pizzerias in the past and have never had this much difficulty. I suggest ordering from one of the other 10 pizzerias in the area because the quality is the same and I'm sure the service and hospitality would be better. read more

Great pizza! Crust was just right. Service was excellent & place is spotless...Following Yelp's advice & enjoyed the pizzas!

Have been to this place many times and have always had a great experience. Friendly family run business that I highly recommend with excellent service and food. Hidden away in a quiet area of Middletown it's well worth locating, I don't think you will be disappointed. read more

First off, if I could give this place no stars I would. Without having any of there food my first impression was not a very good one. First strike, the lady on the phone taking my order was incredibly rude and condescending. Not how you should treat a customer. 2nd strike looked up there menu as ive never eaten here and only heard good things. I ordered a Sicilian pie and garlic knots. There menu is deceiving, online says Sicilian pie is 15.97 and 6 garlic knots 3.45. Long story short I get there and my total is almost 30.00 I'm not a idiot I do know there's tax but its not 10.00 in tax on a 20.00 order. Third and final strike there pizza isn't even good. I dont know how they're rated so well. Barely has any sauce on the pizza. If I wanted cheese bread I would have bought dough and cheese and made it my self for easily 1/3 of the price. I will never give this place another penny. If you're into being treated like crap over the phone and eating sub par pizza this place is for you. Buyer beware read more

Good food. Not fancy but enjoyed chicken tortellini soup & chicken piccata, pasta perfect. Wine ok. Will be back.

Customer service was excellent. Pizza left a lot to be desired. Very greasy and overall bland. Crust was really good though.