Finally stopped in to try a couple desserts. We took home a slice of NY Cheesecake and Peanut Butter Pie. Both were delicious and the service was super friendly. We will definitely be back to try a few other flavors. read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - NY (slice) and Peanut Butter Pie (slice) - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Great tasting cheesecake. Variety varies but they don't hold on to their specials for long.

Grabbed dessert from here recently and enjoyed it! There were a lot of tasty options so we struggled choosing just one, but the guy behind the counter was super helpful. I ended up getting the red velvet cheesecake, while my wife got the peanut butter pie. Importantly, the two bottom shelves of desserts are all different types of cheesecake, which was not obvious to me but maybe that's on me :) We took our food outside to the solitary table in front of the store and dug in. Very tasty! Not the absolute best I've ever had, but not bad at all. After we were finished, I looked around for a trash can but eventually realized that I had to take my trash back inside to throw it away. I think it'd be nice if they had a trash can outside since there's a table out there, but no big deal. Overall, I'd definitely consider coming back here to order some cheesecake. read more

The selection of cheese cakes in the store is amazing. The cheesecakes are delicious as well. We got 2 pieces, Tiramisu cheesecake and the other one had a chocolate chip cookie crust. They were both very, very good. The cheesecake is thick and mildly sweet, perfect density and flavor. The store front is small but they have two big cases full of cheesecakes and other desserts. The young lady that served us cut our pieces off the main slab of cheesecake and slid them nicely into 2 to-go boxes. If we lived closer, we might be in trouble because I know we would go more often. read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - Tiramisu Cheesecake and Cheesecake Cookie Dough - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

What isn't to love about cheesecake and chocolate! There are other selections as well! Cheesecake can be a gluten free dessert! These cheesecakes rock! The staff has been delightful as well! read more

Everything here is AMAZING!!!! Peanut butter pie was my absolute favorite. So good, will definitely be back! read more

See all

The business is a small, quaint shop and the owner's passion for flavor and making awesome cheesecakes including gluten free hands up 5 stars! A few times I have gone during business hours only to find out the business is closed due to staffing issues, very disappointed. Realize that for quality the prices have gone up, so only special occasions for a treat. However, the last few times, the server is either unskilled or does not care when placing in container and providing a tip for service that seems below standard as I will include a recent pic. The server even knows it will be smooshed, when trying to give an alternative suggestion to someone who seems to have a "know it attitude" and really doesn't want to work or be there as the customer is inconveniencing them ~ sorry if you are unaware but these are recent photos of a visit. Additionally, the website mentioned 20% discount for in person order and I asked and server told me that is for GrubHub even as I showed the screen on phone. Overall, 3.5 stars but based on recent disappointment visit 3 stars appropriate for the recent visit. read more

See all

Have passed by this place so many times but never went in until now, and I'm glad I finally did. The cheesecake selection is extensive, and while I only tried the plain NY cheesecake (which was great and light) I am certain the others are also good. In addition to the cheesecake, they do offer a selection of other treats as well. The cheesecake is absolutely amazing, definitely amongst the best in this area. Other goodies from the lemon bars, turtle bar, cannoli and more are all also extremely flavorful and fresh with great textures. I am fairly certain this is primarily a takeout place as there wasn't any seating, or for that matter any decor inside or outside. Also, while I didn't have any issues with the service it wasn't very friendly which added to it not being super inviting. Lastly, I wish the boxes they gave the items in were a bit nicer instead of the standard takeout boxes, just to kind of match the delicious treats inside. Would definitely recommend, especially if you are a fan of cheesecake and will likely grab more stuff from them in the future. read more

Great selection of treats! Very fresh and reasonably priced. How did I not know about this place before?! Very easy to find. The business is very clean and inviting. I was greeted upon entry with a friendly staff member. Made my selection and left with a smile on my face. Me and my sister enjoyed it greatly! I will be back. read more

See all

Holy smokes. The desserts are beautiful, and also delicious. Yelp is asking me to write more, but there is nothing more to say. So freaking good. read more

Absolutely love that there is a local place open past 5pm which has really good desserts! Everything we have tried (and we have tried a lot of their desserts) has been amazing. It's our go-to spot when we are craving something sweet, and they are often open until 8pm or 9pm. read more

Everything we got, and we got a lot, was fantastic!! Will definitely be back next time we are close by

D-I-V-I-N-E ny cheesecake! What more can I say. The carrot cake had a twist in it which was a lovely mousse layer on the top, thus increasing the lightness with each bite. They have free samples of their dessert bars. Lemon bar was good. Cannolis offered. What a little gem. I definitely would return. If you need a whole cake, you need to order ahead. So worth it. They are next to Abby Road Tavern and Grill. So get your yummy large burgers there and the cheesecakes here. read more

See all

Love ordering from here if I have a sweet tooth. Their cheesecakes are so yummy. The cookie dough cheesecake can be a little mushy if you have it delivered from Doordash but im sure it's just due to the drive. Outside of that everything else has been great. For more reviews follow @raleighunlocked on Instagram. read more

See all

This is by far the best cheesecake ever! It's not overly sweet, it's just perfect. My only wish is that the slices were a little bit bigger-they are on the smaller size especially for the price. I have only been there twice but both of those times they have had someone wonderful working the front. They were knowledgeable and very sweet. Love this place! read more

Good desserts! Cheesecakes of various flavors, peanut butter pie and Nutella pie all have our approval.

The young guy that helped us was so sweet! My husband and I got some cannoli's as I was craving something sweet that's not too sweet and these were amazing!!! I also got a piece of cheesecake as I am pregnant and like sweet things! The place was so clean! Definitely will come back for some more treats! read more

We just discovered this local place tonight. The cheesecake and pie was AMAZING!! We will definitely be coming back. Give them a try. You will not be disappointed. read more

Peanut butter pie, all in my mouth! Holy hell is this tasty!!!! Found this place by accident and I've been back numerous times!!! Small place and the selection is small late in the evening, but worth the trip! read more

Extra delicious cheesecakes! We are never disappointed! We also found out that the cheesecakes we got at couple of local restaurants were made by custom confections! White chocolate raspberry and red velvet are my favorites. Gluten free chocolate torte is also in line. Can't wait to try more and more flavors. They are addictive!! read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - Chocolate torte and white chocolate raspberry cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Listen, my fiancé ordered some sweets for us from Custom Confections tonight, and all I can say is FANTASTIC. The peanut butter bar? Fudgey, rich, chocolate top layer and the bottom layer was a delightful soft, almost like a peanut butter cookie. He also got me a vanilla cupcake and the icing was phenomenal, light, something I've never tasted but in a good way. He raved about his Heath toffee cheesecake! We are definitely going to be regular customers after tonight's order! 10/10 read more

Best cheesecake in town, hands down. I don't have a favorite because they are all beyond delicious. And don't sleep on the peanut butter pie, it's light and fluffy and very tasty. read more

The cheesecake here is the best! I got 2 mini cheesecakes and devoured them. I highly recommend this place. read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - 2 Mini Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Got some slices for takeout - cookie dough cheesecake was delicious! Not sure how they bake a cheesecake with a cookie dough crust, but it's awesome! read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - Cookie dough cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Wasn't even able to find parking to go inside the store as Dominos and Abbey Road take up all the spots. The parking lot was pure hell with cars and trucks driving in and out looking for parking. Had some people with me that were able to bring out a slice of cake for me (apparently you have to order cakes 2 days in advance so we didn't get a whole cheesecake like we planned). Wasn't much of a selection from what they told me. But the NY cheesecake was really, really good - not the best I've had being from NYC, but very light, creamy and smooth. Nice, thick graham cracker crust on the bottom (not sides) so every bite was perfectly proportional. Definitely made me wish we had been able to get the whole cake. Overall, the experience was hell because of the parking lot and inability to go in and pick stuff out - let alone not being able to buy a cake. But I don't think there's much you can do about the parking (except go early in the day) and the cake was definitely worth going back for. So 5 stars for the cake, 2 stars for the experience and +1 star for being new (meaning they'll likely figure out a better way to accomodate customers at some point). I hope so! (Pic is as close as I could get to the place, which is just frustrating and sad lol) read more

This place is AMAZING! We went for the first time. The cream puffs are divine. The peanut butter pie is to die for! We also got Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake, and the Deadly Chocolate Cheesecake. All great. Wonderful customer service too! read more

Awesome Cheesecakes and quite varied to boot . The Cannolis are great too . Highly recommend a visit to a very talented and creative Chef Shannon's Custom Confectionery! read more

See all

Absolutely amazing cheesecake... Stopped in after dinner and we got the almond joy & bananas foster cheesecake slices. It was airy and fresh. One of the best slices of cheesecake I've ever enjoyed. Def worth making a trip over to support a local bakery like this one. read more

One of my FAV places. I really have not had a bad thing here. My favorite things: peanut butter bar, turtle bar, peanut butter pie, and any cheesecakes! I think the turtle and peanut butter bars are a MUST try. Also, if you Grubhub your order, they do a really good job packaging. 10/10 read more

Love this place. Key Lime and Pumpkin are my favorite slices. Peanut butter bars are incredible. A go-to for dessert!

Amazing cheesecakes!!!! We had the white chocolate raspberry, classic, lemon and turtle and lived all of them. Dense but creamy, the way cheesecake should be. read more

I feel bad I forgot to leave a review! I originally discovered Custom Confections when trying to figure out a cake to order for my birthday. I learned that Common Grounds sold slices and figured I'd try it before I commit. The cheesecake was phenomenal! I feel like I'm pretty pretentious when it comes to baked goods because I can bake pretty well myself. I usually make my own birthday cake, but I wanted to treat myself for my 30th. I do not regret ordering a full cheeseake for my birthday from Custom Confections. I got irish cream and it was amazing. I tell everyone I know about their cheesecake now! read more

Cheesecakes By Custom Confections - Irish cream cheesecake. So delicious :) - Desserts Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

This shop has change me! I have fallen in love with their cheesecake. They have great flavors and fantastic care. I look forward to more cakes. read more

The Black and White cheesecake was delicious! My dinner guests did not stop raving about it. I've also had other cheesecakes they supplied to local restaurants and they did not disappoint. read more

We have been purchasing slices of cakes, pies, puffs and my favorite, the moon pie from this store for a few months now. Everything has been delicious. I also love how clean and organized this store is. Definitely give our local cake shop a try. My kids request this store now when they visit. read more

Visited Academy Bistro for lunch and the waiter suggested the cheesecake. We ordered it, and while cheesecake is not my number one favorite, it is now ! There Apple cheesecake was amazing. Everyone at the table loved it. The waiter informed us it was made by Cheesecakes beside Abbey Road in Cary. We are definitely going there for our next cheesecake fix!!! read more

I ordered a blueberry lemon cheesecake a few days ahead of time online. The ordering process is extremely easy. I received a confirmation email quickly. The cheesecake was the best I've ever had. It was perfectly smooth and the crust was excellent. I also really liked that it was light and creamy. Will be ordering from here again and again for birthdays and special occasions. read more

Best cupcakes in Cary! Shannon has supplied cupcakes , tea breads, cinnamon buns ( best I have ever tasted ) , and scones for numerous family and school events . All to rave reviews. I am proud to be a repeat Custom Confection customer since Shannon first served up goodies at the market. I highly recommend her. read more

This place is so delicious I've gotten the cupcakes and they are SO tasty-and well priced!!! You can tell how fresh they are. Definitely going back for more! read more

First and most certainly not the last time visiting this place. Customer service was exceptional and so was the taste of these delicious cheesecakes. read more