Spicybeans87 B. Loves the energy of the woman who is sometimes behind the counter. She is always so lovely. Huge fan of the Italian Sausage sandwich which came smothered in sauce. Wish there were spicy beans somewhere on the menu but ce la vie. Yours always, Spicybeans87 B. P.s. If you sold a combo of the cactus cooler and say maybe some spicy beans.. I think it'd be a huge hit. Think on it, don't stink on it. Yours always again, Spicybeans87 B. read more

Eating in and enjoying a game of cards while pizza is being made. Look at this salad! Cannot wait to dive into this salad before our pizza arrives. Pizza was delicious and quick service out of the kitchen. read more

Chicago Pizza - Huge salad enough for 3 to share - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

See all

Worst pizza all five of my family members have ever had. Also, it was $100 for a large cheese pizza, a large pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza sticks and a container of ranch plus delivery. The dough was the worst ever, like it was premade. Horrid, please stay away! read more

Ordered pizza late one evening. Customer service was really great and order was accurate. I do wish they had online ordering though! Pizza was good and we will likely order more on our next trip to Vail. read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

See all

This place is so fun! They have board games you can play and the pizza is delicious!! Definitely coming back to try more. Thank you for the great service! read more

You can't get any worse than this. From customer service to actual product. The Pizza is terrible, no effort or flavor. I asked for extra crispy wings and they sent me burnt and soggy wings. I don't even know how that is possible. I called in to let them know respectfully but the owner felt the need to curse at me because they sent burnt wings to my residence. Not only did I tipped $10, the 16" pizza and wings , 2 ginger ales was $71. Outrageous. Not only my wings were burnt, they were spoiled. I recommend Alphine Pizza. Better customer service and way better food. I'll also select the local McDonald's over this. I own a food business myself that sells chicken wings and no employee/business owner should curse at the customer. You never know who you are talking to. Please do better. Upcoming customers don't waste your time. Look at the wings attached and tell me you eat this? read more

Chicago Pizza - Would you eat this? - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

See all

What a delight to find authentic Chicago pizza with its cracker-thin crust cut into squares here in Vail, Colorado. The hostess was cordial and the pizza was just what we wanted. read more

I actually threw the so called Pizza out Don't waste your time or money sorry to say this place was convenient so after many years of passing it by I thought why not try it Well I did and I will keep passing by the employee was pleasant But the pizza was horrible read more

Fantastic pizza, great service by the owners and a very reasonable price. Highly recommend!

Always a treat. Calzones are fantastic. Great place with limited seating, but it's never been a problem. Fantastic service.

A great small-town pizza parlor. The staff is super friendly and humorous. Family friend place with activities for the rnthe kids. The pizzas are delicious and full of toppings. The presentation of the cheesecake is incredible. A great hometown vibe. read more

Chicago Pizza - Humorous sign - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

See all

My recommendation, and keep in mind this is without having even tried the pizza, would be to stick to the pizza options on the menu. We were not very impressed with the non-pizza menu items; they seem to be made mostly with pizza ingredients. For example, the lasagna's "meat" was pizza sausage and pizza pepperoni slices, add pizza sauce, and I ended up with something that tasted kind of like a pasta-based pizza rather than lasagna. The chicken parm was made from the same chicken strips you'd find on a chicken pizza, and the sauce was what you'd find on the pizza, so there you go, same concept as the lasagna applied to chicken parm. I will say they offer great prices and handle delivery themselves, all the way to our room at the Hyatt at least, where most of the local restaurants route you through a delivery service that tacks on 20% before tip, which adds up very fast. read more

Gluten free pizza was on point!! Highly recommend! My friend had the pepperoni pizza which he loved as well.. read more

Chicago Pizza - Was so good ..I had a gluten free crust/vegetarian my friend had a regular pepperoni . Was ON POINT!! - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

The business mandates you say "hello, how are you doing?" ... before taking any orders on the phone. ... yes they will stop and correct you and make sure you say "hello how are you doing" back to them doesn't matter if you have a question on or off menu.... . Many people have said this is a restaurant that is a drug front... I don't know what else to be true besides that. They have the weirdest hours and are very unprofessional with customers. The environment or ambiance is very much "what do you want? Ok great get out! " aka Ed diveics from Chicago... a business that isn't around anymore. I literally just wanted a deep dish and or slice of pizza... They don't do deep dish and they make it impossible for a slice. Dogs in the parking lot that may or may not bite. You have been warned Best luck is to Go to alpine pizza or vendettas. read more

Chicago Pizza and Vicky really delivered when a group of 20+ kids and parents wanted a place to have good food, service, and fun. We loved the games that were available to take to your table. The pizza was delicious with fresh ingredients, including Gluten free options. Parking right out front in Vail a plus too, but also walkable to many properties. Hope to return next year. read more

We bought a mushroom, pepperoni and sausage pizza on June 5th. It was so delicious because the flavors were fresh, cooked to perfection and the lady that owns the place is super sweet and friendly! We wanted to take her dog Rafa home with us, because he is so big and friendly. Extraordinary food and service. Will order here again next time we visit Vail. read more

This place is straight trash first I would like to start with the chick on the phone pressing me for my credit card before I even order to then follow up by rushing me through my ordering process. I then become bombarded by knocks followed by rings and more knocks at my door/doorbell as people are trying to sleep across the hall as we're in a condominium building. This is all before tasting the fu king trash food. Please I have never once seen a place mess up pasta with gravy but this joint sure did. Along with the bottom of the pizza having the same undercarriage of Ted Cruz The only decent thing outa this spot was the mini bag of some Cheetos outa some Walmart value pack they through in probably knowing all the other food wouldn't get eaten. Thank god they didn't grab the plain lays chips when they sent this order out or I'd be going to bed hungry read more

Chicago Pizza - Undercarriage - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

Awesome! Came in when I70 was closed and had a great time and marvelous pizza! I will be back! The staff are great!

10/10 for us. Very friendly and polite employees working when we came in. Pizza was good as well as the customer service.

After a 6 hour drive, we were exhausted and hungry! And that combination with 2 toddlers was not a good combo. Thankfully while we waited for our food there were some games to district the kids with. We had 9 total In our party, and the biggest table was a table of 6, but it wasn't that big a deal as a table of 4 was very close by. It was quiet and cozy. I loved the homely feel of the place. The pizza was AMAZING! Super cheesy and a perfectly crisp crust. read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

See all

Cozy little pizza spot nestled roughly 10-15 minutes away from vail resort. When you walk in the place gave a very welcoming feel as if you were at home with amazing attentive service. And the pizza was delicious and filling just the thing to look for after a long day of skiing. Would recommend to anyone who visits vail read more

A great mountain pizza place dripping with local charm, great food and a very friendly owner. Pizza is delicious and their Cesar Salad was really memorable. Decent prices too. Kid friendly and chill. read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

I visited 11/14, had the 8" sausage pizza. Fantastic! Nice crispy crust, served at the perfect temp. This approaches the homemade pizza my mom makes. Great value, would strongly recommend! read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

We live in the area but had not tried Chicago Pizza. Called on a rainy Friday night and got a friendly lady that said we could pickup in 15-20 minutes. Arrived and the vegetable pizza was ready. I was really hoping this was going to be great pizza, close by, quick and nice friendly staff. Then I tasted the pizza. The crust was a commercial pre-baked pizza! The crust was tough, flavorless and basically inedible. The vegetable toppings were fresh and crisp. Obviously it doesn't take long to bake a pre-baked crust. So we ate the toppings and threw the crust away. Too bad that a pizza shop calling itself Chicago Pizza would not make their own fresh crust. So, back to our old favorites or a frozen pizza. BTW I have been baking industry for many years, I know a pre-baked crust when I chew on it. In read more

The pizza and calzone I ordered were both really good. The owner is so nice and was teaching me Afrikaans. She was so nice she even rescued me from doing something really embarrassing, she ran outside and stopped me from driving off with a fresh pizza on the roof of my vehicle! And that I'll never forget! my only caution is that the pizza and calzone crust is very thick and filling, which I myself don't dislike. But for those of you who like thin crust... read more

Amazing food and great service. They always go outbof their way to feed the crazy Cubans read more

Friendly, friendly service! And very helpful. Really thin pizza crust so not sure where the Chicago comes from, but it was decent. We go buffalo chicken - definitely some kick to the hot sauce. My nose was running (but I don't really eat much spicy stuff). Also tried a meatball sub - was also good. Not sure if the Fritos that came with it were meant to be put on the sub or not, but I enjoyed the crunch! For being in Vail, definitely not a bad option of where to get your grub on. Little pricey, but again...it's Vail. read more

Chicago Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - PacMan not included :) - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

Vickie was amazing! Stumbled upon Chicago Pizza due to an I-70 closure and glad to have found this place. From the moment we walked in, Vickie was so nice, as well as cracking jokes with us! We started with the garlic pizza sticks, and the crust was nice and crispy, that made us want to order a pizza. read more

This pizza is so good! We came down from the city easily the best pizza I've had! The owners were so incredibly nice definitely gonna make this a stop every time I'm in vail! read more

Chicago Pizza - Cream cheese and pepperoni pizza! Is to die for! - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

I will be straightforward I didn't eat the pizza. I am writing this review based on observations made on other people's food. 1. Atmosphere. The lighting is as dark as the sewer drain where penny wise lives. The general shady aura is given off. The tvs are the brightest lights in the place. 2. Pizza quality. The pizza is about the same as dominos in Avon. Same cheap ingredients are used with a frozen crust. In general a sub average slice. 3. Service. The service here is indescribably terrible. The reason we didn't eat here wasn't because of the 40 minute wait, but because of the cashier was so rude about the wait. Instead of replying respectfully she gawked that the pizza would take 40 minutes and you couldn't find any other pizza place in the vicinity with less than a 1 hour wait. While we gave up on our pizza dream we did call dominos and they said that the pizza would be ready in 15 minutes. read more

They make great thin and crispy pizza. The lady took extra time to make it well done for us. The night we went, she had received order to deliver 60 pies for a wedding after-party, but she made sure that our order was made to our request. The lady said that she was from South Africa and she was very friendly. Came out to chat with us a couple of times to ensure we had everything we needed. We are vegeterians and has made some customized request for the toppings and she made it perfectly well. Thin and crispy pizza was the best. The deep dish pizza was too thick in our opinion, so pobably not our choice for the next visit. But we would definitely try the regular thin pizza. Great service overall and we used our yelp coupon as well! read more

This place is gas station sushi-level bad, don't know what Chicago did to upset them (quite a nice city actually, but I digress). Considering it only does one type of food it's staggering how bad the pizza was. The base was like carpet, the toppings looked like a 6 year olds drawing, finished off with enough salt to grit the highway in there. Still trying to get over the indigestion. read more

Nothing like Chicago pizza so dont get your hopes up. Chicago Pizza is not Chicago style pizza. Small mom and pop pizzeria. The service is wonderful. The price is decent for Vail prices. They also offer delivery which is nice. The pizza was good but again, not Chicago style, "thick crust" nah. However, it is definitely worth it to support small, family ran businesses! read more

Popped by here for lunch on my way out to the Western slope for Thanksgiving. Quick, friendly service, and a pretty reasonable price for a personal pan pizza. They even brought my pizza out to my car while I was walking my dog around the parking lot. Thanks!! read more

Not only was the pizza disgusting and the worst pizza we've ever had,(party of seven) which is hard to do the owner is the rudest person I've ever dealt with and couldn't care less what I had to say. She actually laughed at me. Who does that when owing a business? We looked at other reviews and it's astonishing the response of the owner. I hate complaining and even taking the time but be warned . Don't order this pizza read more

Friendly staff, convenient, great food, quick service. Location is good instead of going into one of the resort plazas it's off the main road. read more

Was good homemade pizza. Not Chicago deep dish by any means. Went there hoping for that, but not even a choice. Not saying pizza was bad, just that name is a little misleading. Service was great and the owners seem like great people. Will go back, just know that it is not Chicago pizza read more

Acceptable mid ski week pizza, but nothing you will be amazed by. The toppings were fine, the pizza was fully cooked, plenty of cheese, maybe could have used a bit more sauce on one of the pizzas we got, but the crust reminded me of elementary school cafeteria lunch. read more

Okay the name is a bit of a misnomer - the pizza here is not Chicago style, it's New York style. But the quality and service are both excellent. read more

Chicago Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Vail, Colorado

Really good pizza. Large caesar salad. Very prompt delivery to the hotel room. Highly recommended.