Amazing experience…read more Food was really good. I'd recommend for two sharing a combo boil. It's a lot of food. If you've never been to a seafood boil before, please ask your server any questions you have. Extremely helpful. We had Amy as our server. She was the best!! Lisa as the owner was an amazing support to tables around us. Definitely a team effort. Really good coordination between management, kitchen, and servers. We had the Utica Bag with all sauces. Definitely worth it. We used Uber and it tried to take us to the back of the building. The driver was kind to listen to our "no it had to be the other side of the building." Extremely clean. So many places don't wipe things down anymore. We'll be back!

Food was fantastic and service was exceptional. Started out with the raw oysters which were clean…read moreand delicious. Then had the lobster, snow crabs, shrimp and clams in a steamed pot. The seasoning was amazing as was the seafood. Will definitely be coming back.

The seafood was excellent and seasoned very well. I ordered take out, the man didn't give me a time…read moreto be there but I arrived about 20 min after I ordered and only had to wait another 3-5 min for them to finish. Totally worth it! The service was great, the inside was clean and decorated in seaside/coastal decor. I would dine in next time. The atmosphere and music were good. Can't wait to try another seasoning for my seafood!

This was a fun experience to try overall. There's not many seafood boil places around here. It is a…read morelot of work to get to the actual meat. It's also quite messy, but that's expected. The food was good however it was slightly overcooked. It could've been a bit more tender and easier to pull out. The seasoning was delicious. Service was great.

We ordered the Haddock fish-fry Combo, the Lobster roll Combo, and a side of Calamari. It was not…read morebusy; the food took 15minutes. Unfortunately I was expecting the lobster roll to look like the sign, but got a totally different "hot" roll. It was scant shredded meat fried with celery salt and heavy black pepper, with bits of raw celery. It weighed next to nothing and was greasy. Despite being a combo, it did Not come with a drink like the other combos! It did come with good fries. We paid an extra $2.99 for the drink. The fried Haddock Combo came with fries and a drink but no tartar sauce ($1 extra). The fish was a good size with no fishy taste. Otherwise ,the place discourages eat-ins. The seating area was FREEZING cold; I needed to wear my hood and gloves. The bathrooms were BOTH blocked with a ladder and a sign saying "closed sorry ," so we couldn't wash our hands. Thankfully the lady at the counter let us use her hand sanitizer. The garbage can was full when we went to throw out the packaging. All-in-all, the ordering and eating experiences were unpleasant for a cost of $54.

Paid 60+ for three small pieces of fish . 7 a container of slaw and got a lot of fries . I like the…read moreplace but I think the prices are too much . I think I could do better elsewhere . Too bad . Prices are way too high

This was awesome, so flavorful, great price, so sooo to be able to bring home to eat.read more

I am so glad I decided to stop here on the 28th! I was craving crab legs and this place went above…read moreand beyond. Huge portion size and amazing flavor! Im also not used to finding actual spicy foods so I was very pleased! Highly recommend!!

Wow I am so excited to share this review! What an amazing experience we had at this restaurant…read more Welcomed with a friendly greeting & beautiful smile, Chase offered us a comfy booth. Then greeted by Kyle our waiter who was awesome! So classy, and so prompt, great service, suggestions, check backs, fantastic! Now the food! The bang bang cauliflower was delicious. Crispy outside, tasty seasoning, tender cauliflower. Outstanding salads with tender chicken on the Caesar salad and the shrimp was perfectly cooked on the Asian salad with crisp mixed lettuce and a sweet savory dressing. Kudos to the chef or chefs. One of the best restaurants! We will be back! Hoping to sit on the outdoor patio that I am sure is wonderful in a nice day. They also have a private room for special events. A fantastic drink menu is a bonus.

The food remains consistently excellent. The service continues to decline. Whether the place is…read morefull or empty, whether you have reservations for two or for 10 people, your table simply will not be ready. The average wait time is 20 minutes beyond your reservation time. Once you are finally seated, the wait staff are knowledgeable and friendly and will help you select your evening repast. And then you will wait again. Typically at least 20 minutes for your food. For your drinks, for your appetizers. It wasn't always like that. There is an internal inefficiency in their kitchen operations in recent months that results in delays. They seem to have enough staff. They just seem to have lost their rhythm. The ambience is lovely, the table settings fine. But there are little things that are slipping. As you can tell from my many reviews of this restaurant over the last several years, this beautiful establishment has achieved four stars. But today in June 2026, their beautiful cuisine is served on nice porcelain plates, but their coleslaw is served in a paper cup. The music is way too loud so you can't have a conversation at the table unless you scream. And they claim to not be allowed to turn the music down. They clearly cater to the 30 and under crowd. The 60s and older are not a priority for them. Wine is properly served, and the drinks are nicely mixed but to get a refill will take you a very long time. When the tables around you are empty, it begs the question as to what is the cause of the delay. My last two dinners here experienced these inexcusable delays. I hope they get the problem straightened out. Because this really is a destination restaurant.

A hidden gem inside of a beautiful historic hotel with incredible views of Lake Otsego!…read more Loved the salmon/ pinkish and old word interior. The brunch we ate was stellar and fabulous cocktails. Service was 5 stars plus. The pricing was competitive with places of far less quality. What a lovely lazy Sunday brunch. I shall return.

first of all let me stop by saying the service was excellent five. The view was also five star…read more However, my husband and I went to the in October 2025 this time we were there on July 4, 2026. We were very disappointed between October and July. The wine menu had been paired down, which was OK. They still offered many wonderful wines. However, my steak was so rich. I could hardly eat it. I ordered a ribeye. It had excessive butter. It was greasy. The side vegetables were very good. But our desserts were tasteless and disappointing My husband had the lamb very much. Appetizers of salad and carpaccio were wonderful Overall, I love this but I do hope that the entrées can improve

This place nails the Utica scene for Italian food…read more Meatballs, eggplant parm and chicken riggies....all were delicious, authentic, and beautifully prepared. Really great meal with kind servers.

Went in for lunch on a Friday and were promptly seated. Our server was super friendly; all the…read morestaff there seemed genuinely happy and like they enjoyed their jobs. I immediately knew I was getting the fried bologna sandwich. I was pleased with my choice, and tried some of my Dad's cranberry and turkey sandwich which was also great. My mom got the fried bologna as well but opted for sweet potato fries. She said they were some of the best she's had. It was sleek and clean in the restaurant with ample seating. They had some excellent monthly lunch specials, so I'm looking forward to another trip back!

When we lived in the area, we ate at Fat Cats a lot. Now that we're 3.5 hours away, we're missing…read morethe delicious food! There's absolutely no place in our city to get a decent fish fry, fried shrimp or clams. We were visiting family in Mohawk recently and of course we opted to have lunch at Fat Cats!! The employees are still super nice and friendly! It was just as good as we remembered! Hubby's fried haddock was on point! Perfectly crispy but still flaky and delicious! My fried shrimp and clams were amazing! Their coleslaw is the best in the area!! I'm so glad the food hasn't changed in the few years since we've moved. It's definitely worth the 3.5 hour drive!! Worthy of all five stars!

Service was very friendly. Food was well prepared, delicious and quickly served. Easy stop off the…read morethruway.

I met a friend here today and shared a few great brews and two delicious cheese and smoked fish…read moreplates. don't know anywhere in town where the appetizers are so thought out and interesting! I also asked for advice on their fresh salmon to take home for dinner. August was extremely helpful and explained the differences between the three fresh salmon choices. I choose the Scottish salmon and oh boy! it did not disappoint! Salmon was super fresh tasting, August put it on ice for the ride home! Simply seasoned with salt, pepper and paprika with a few lemon slices. Absolutely delicious. Thank you August for your expertise and kind service!

Went to Captain Cook's for the first time I'm from Long Island and was really missing seafood the…read moreseafood I got at the stores blah I got four dozen clams from him as I was baking and making linguine and white clam sauce with some friends they were a fantastic fresh sweet and now that I know I can call ahead of time and even order specialty products like super soccer on calamari with a lot of legs fresh I was very very happy what a nice gentleman also received us and while you wait you can have a nice bloody Mary really nice place to go really enjoyed the experience