Cancel

Open app

Search

Christine’s Creative Cookie

5.0 (1 review)

Christine’s Creative Cookie Photos

You might also consider

More like Christine’s Creative Cookie

Recommended Reviews - Christine’s Creative Cookie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Weenee World

Weenee World

3.9
(44 reviews)
1.6 mi
$

I wasn't sure what to expect but this wasn't it. This place is wild! The decor is very wacky but…read moresometimes that's a clear indicator that it will be good. The menu is huge! And a little overwhelming. I assumed everything would be processed but I'm pretty sure the coney sauce was house made. Footlong coney day was always one of my favorite lunch days in high school so I opted for the footlong coney. It was pretty good. A regular size one would have been plenty since apparently my adult stomach is smaller than my high school stomach. The strawberry soft serve was good too. It was more tangy than sweet. My brother had the carrot cake ice cream. While it wasn't as carrot cake-y as he expected, he still liked it. The employees were friendly and we got our food fairly quick. There were several other people walking up/dining in and the drive-thru was busy the whole time we were eating.

There are no lists of flavors for ice cream when you face the windows where you place the orders…read more There are all kinds of menu items listed there but NOTHING tells you the list of ice cream flavors are along the side of the building by one of the parking lots. If you park on the other side of the building you completely miss out on the list. It would have been nice to have a sign POINTING to where the flavors are. Instead you just think you can get soft serve cones or sundaes. Speaking of which, by husband ordered a large brownie sundae with hot fudge sauce and they didn't put on the fudge sauce. The lines were long so he didn't go back to correct it. But quite disappointed. Also the "large" was like a kiddie cup size. I ordered a medium twist in a cup and it was twice the size of his "large" sundae.

Photos
Menu
Menu
Footlong Coney
Footlong Coney
Strawberry Soft Serve

See all

Strawberry Soft Serve
Whitetail Sweet Shop

Whitetail Sweet Shop

4.7
(6 reviews)
0.0 mi

I am giving my 3 stars on my memories of great ice cream and service, otherwise tonight would get…read moreless than 3. A gorgeous Friday Summer night so I decided to stop for a treat after work. I thought the place would be packed but oddly it was not. There was a line of cars in the drive thru, but inside it was only one large group ahead of me. I knew almost immediately something was off this visit. I soon realized there was only one young employee working all alone. One person on a Friday night on one of the first 80 degree days makes no sense. Later, he had to come around the front of the case yo find a flavor. He stated he was new and did not have the placement memorized yet. A new employee alone on a Friday night?!?!?! I asked if someone had called in and he said yes, but elaborated the staff is allowed to pick shifts. If true it is not working and will have a bad long term effect on the sales. I gave the lone employee great credit for sticking out the shift and continuing to slug through. However, it does not inspire confidence in returning soon. Next issue was the lack of my flavor. I loved the first two seasons when they had Turkish Coffee. The last couple of years they carried a much less coffee"y" flavor, but at least they had something coffee. Tonight no coffee anything. My second go to is banana pie which had a chocolate where the tag was placed. I waited 15ish minutes for my turn to ask if they had coffee and when I was told no I thanked the dedicated employee and left. I love supporting local businesses, and I am a huge ice cream lover so I hated seeing such a favorite in times past have such an off night. I hope the management steps up if they have call offs to pick up the slack and work or they find a new better scheduling plan. Next Summer they won't be here if this continues all Summer.

First time trying out The Sweet Shop in New Castle! This drink is so good and will be coming out…read moreSOON. Loved the afternoon pick me up. The owner was great and service was amazing.

Photos
Dining area
Dining area
Whitetail Sweet Shop
Ice cream sampler or flight

See all

Ice cream sampler or flight

Christine’s Creative Cookie - desserts - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...