We stopped this past Saturday for an early dinner. The service was friendly; we got an immediate welcome when we stepped inside. I also noticed the workers were enjoying themselves making for a positive culture. The pizza was good, especially the crust. I expected more cheese so the toppings seemed flat. We ordered a combo and a veggie. My husband felt the toppings were a bit skimpy. My rating is a 5 for the service and clean environment and a 3 for the pizza, thus an overall 4 rating. read more

See all

We had a bit of a wait but it was so worth it. The pizza was hot out of the oven, delicious and well made and the place smelled really good. The guys working that night worked so hard to make sure everyone got their orders filled. I appreciated they had a gluten free crust also. We also saw the large and giant pizzas they made. They REALLY were LARGE and GIANT not like chain pizza places. We loved it and I highly recommend going there. read more

Got DoorDash to Five Pines Lodge and we loved the Texas BBQ pizza. My daughters loved pepperoni and the cheese. My Mom and youngest daughter shared the Cesar Salad and they both really enjoyed it. Sisters had a gem of a pizza place! Hope to try it in store next time: read more

Cibelli's - Texas BBQ pizza -so good! - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

We love stopping at this place every time we come through! The pizza is delicious (and enormous if you'd like lol), the staff is so incredibly kind and hardworking!! Tonight (12/30/30) was packed, order tickets out the door and with only 3 of their young Male employees working every aspect of the restaurant and you'd never be able to tell because of their amazing attitudes and dedication, they definitely deserve a raise after tonight!!! read more

Cibelli's - The Giant pepperoni pizza 24" - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

We stopped by for an early dinner on our way back home from Bend. We did pass the Bend location while trying to get here but I think this location has better outdoor seating with picnic table benches. It also shares the parking lot with a Dutch Bros FYI. The inside had some table seating with iconic checkered plastic tablecloths and there were various black and white photos on the walls. Bathrooms were clean. We walked in and ordered at the counter for their special bundle including a XL Pepperoni pizza, Caesar salad, 2L Pepsi for a very reasonable price for the amount you get. Service was quick and friendly. They were not kidding about it being XL! Wowza, the box barely fit through the door on our way out haha. Aside from the size, the pizza was hot and fresh, sour the right amount of pepperoni, and the dough and crust were the perfect balance of chewy and crunchy. They also had your typical toppings: Parmesan, crushed red pepper, garlic salt (powder?), but I really liked the Italian seasoning Parmesan - it really added to the flavor. I was very impressed! I was full after just one slice. Definitely stop by and grab some great pizza here! read more

See all

For the first time we tried this pizza place for take-out. At first we were amazed at how giant their giant size really is, you could feed an army! The slices were so big they didn't fit on a plate. However, we found the crust was thin and floppy, and the consistency made it very hard to eat. The pieces were too large to hold, and even a fork or knife wouldn't cut it, due to the rubbery texture. More importantly we found their Hawaiian pizza to be flavorless. I'm sorry to say we won't be back. read more

They were open on Monday night when most everything else was closed!!! Service was fast, although I did expect the veggies to be cooked a little more. I don't think it was really intended as a full blown dine-in place, but was a much better option than a food truck and outdoor picnic table on a cool windy night. There was a continuous parade of customers read more

I was ording and the guy rushed me then I processed to tip and he didn't put jalpenos on my pizza that I payed for and put some weird stuff on grandmas slice this is L btw read more

Great and friendly service from David and Tristan! The food was exceptional and we we're shocked by how much we received for what we paid. Highly recommend! Plus - the only pizza place as far as I could see that is opened past 8! 10/10 would come again the next time I am in Sisters! read more

Mad disrespectful to my family. Rude worker and manager wouldn't listen to loyal and respectful customers zero star for service, 1 star for decent pizza read more

Staff was nice and place was clean. However, the toppings were lacking. Ordered a sausage and olive giant pizza and most bites were like eating a plain cheese pizza the toppings were so lacking and spread out. $75 for 2 giant pizzas with barely any toppings is kinda ridiculous. Cheese was also lacking on both pizzas. read more

Cibelli's of Bend just opened here in Sisters - their 6th store regionally. I hadn't been to the others so I had to check it out and glad I did. This is the genuine article. I watched it made from start to finish including the tossing. The crust was perfectly cooked, neither chewy from undercooking or too crispy. I liked the thickness, about 1/8th inch. I am not a fan of the puffy edges but in this case it worked. The tomato sauce was spread to the edge, something I demand in my pizzas. The toppings were generous and properly proportioned, not heaped together haphazardly so the presentation was nice. They were busy but could not have been more friendly. Only take out now due to Mr. Covid but I will no doubt be back for table service although there is nothing of ambience. Just good pizza. In fact we have a lot of good pizza in Sisters for a town our size. read more

Great pizza! We got off the mountain pretty late, so there wasn't much open on a Monday night. Takeout pizza seemed like the best option, as we didn't want to sit down anywhere right before closing time. We got a medium combination pizza and a large Caesar salad. Large was an understatement. The crouton to lettuce ratio was perfect. Almost 50/50! He gave us extra dressing, which we needed. The pizza itself was delicious. You can tell the crust is hand rolled. The ingredients were spread evenly, and there were enough toppings to keep us satisfied! read more

The Margherita pie was delicious. Loved the thin crust and having to do a good fold to eat a slice. Customer service was super friendly. Just a really delicious pizza! read more

Stumbled upon this place when we were getting coffee at Dutch brothers next door. We had The Caesar salad and the Greek salad. Both are fresh and wonderful. Then we ordered a 10 inch personal gluten-free pizza with just the white sauce on it. I would come back just for that. Great little find. Too bad wee live all the way in Seattle or we would come weekly! read more

Try the garlic and cheese stuffed crust in any configuration of pizza. Trust me, you will not be disappointed. We really enjoyed our pie from Cibelli's! read more

The pizza is wonderful. All of the people working there are great. They acknowledge the customers as they come in, and I appreciate that. To sum it up, we'll continue to buy their pizza.. Great job guys read more

Horrible place. Would not recommend. We called ahead of time to order the pizza and ask for when it would be ready. They told us 40 mins so we were like okay that's cool we will get there at that time. But when we got there to get our pizza it turns out they messed up our pizza. So we had to wait 20 more minutes for the pizza to be ready. It turns out they messed up our order of pizza with another customer which was very unprofessional. The least they could do was offer us some sides or something. But I think the workers were all new trainee so they didn't know what they were doing. Also they literally only give us the pizza that they fixed. There was no plates or napkins given as well. Definitely would not recommend if you are looking for a place to make you a fast pizza that you order ahead of time and even confirmed that the order was right. read more

We love it here! The employees are always kind and our order is always done right. Our weekly stop for family pizza night. Get there 24" if you're hungry and ready for leftovers! read more

I reviewed this restaurant a couple weeks ago and gladly gave it 5 stars. The combo pizza was delicious. But my assessment has changed. Last night, my wife and I ordered what we thought would be an identical pizza. It wasn't. The staff was still friendly and helpful, and the place was perfectly clean. However, the pizza was average, if that. Cibelli's was very sparing (as in "stingy") with its ingredients and the previously-fabulous taste just wasn't there. Disappointing, to say the least. I suppose we'll try it one more time based upon our first experience. But, as far as I'm concerned, they need to score big to keep our business. read more

Best pizza in Sisters. Always on time for orders. Generous servings for the price. Mostly kids working, but they do a great job.

The fact that Cibelli's reviews aren't higher is a bit mind boggling to me. Best pizza in Sister's and I don't think it's close. Have ordered three times and every time it is amazing. Oh and the 24" giant will feed an army. So glad to have Cibelli's in Sister's! read more

Tasteless pizza. We ordered a large combo, ended up throwing 5 slices away cuz no one wanted anymore. Been here 3 times and it just doesn't get any better. Pizza is limited in Sisters. read more

Ordered a large sausage/olive pizza. The pizza was ready when I came to pick it up. courteous staff. Crust and sauce were good but pizza was severely lacking in toppings. Kind of disappointing for a first time visit read more

Cibelli's - a pizza with olives and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Friday night called at 4:55 to order and the pizza wasn't ready until 6:25? Went ahead with the order as I wanted to try them out and the staff was super friendly. We all agreed that the pizzas were ok. That's it...just ok. Not worth waiting an hour and 25 minutes for. read more

This pizza was way too big! My stomach hurts... and I burned the damn christmas cookies.

Had the pizzone and a house salad as my second dinner tonight. The salad was fresh and the pizzone was delicious. This ain't no dominos shit. The crust is good!!!! And I am picky!! I don't settle for BAD/chain/beige ass food. This meal was WAY better than the shit we had at a Chops Bistro earlier. And the gal that took my order was SUPER sweet. read more

We were vacationing near Sisters. Decided to try this place. It was so good that we ordered it again the next day! Gourmet California was my favorite. read more

Unfortunately the dough was not cook through on the White Pie, Meat Lovers Pie or the Cheese Sticks. Toppings on the Pies where very sparse. read more