The Pizza Beast rolled into Eddie's Gourmet Pizza and came away with a respectable 3.7-star score. The pizza is solid enough to satisfy the craving, but it doesn't quite separate itself from the crowded local pizza scene. The crust holds up well, the toppings are generous, and portions are fair. The sauce and overall flavor profile are decent, but nothing that had me planning my next visit before I finished the slice. Service was friendly and efficient, and the restaurant was clean and easy to get in and out of. No major complaints--just a spot that's good, not great. Pizza Beast Verdict: A dependable neighborhood pizza joint. Worth a visit if you're nearby, but there are stronger contenders in the area if you're chasing that elite slice. Rating: 3.7/5 Beast Slices ¾ read more

Second time ordering wings. The first time everything was perfect besides the crappy Ken's Blu cheese cup they serve with it. 12 wings one 1.5oz extra cup 75 cents for an extra one. Definitely should be a minimum of 2 cups per 12 wings. The sauce was amazing but the second time ordering wings these things are so dry they might choke me. So definitely some inconsistency in the kitchen. Plus I was charged 2.00 for a coke I never ordered. read more

Eddie's Gourmet Pizza - Eddie's Famous Wings - 12 Pieces mild - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Consistently good pizza staff is nice. The passes are good and large portions would recommend to anyone to ambience is nice clean and there's places to sit inside read more

Ordered meatball sub.with extra cheese .was toasted nicely verry generous meat balls spices but not too. Much,sauce was good but didn't soak the bread. My new favorite. read more

Came by for dinner after a long day, came here like last hour they were open, but they more then happy to take my order. I got a meatball sub and buffalo chicken sliders. My order came to me in less then 10 minutes. So the sub, the meatballs were decent size and not too big to the point I was unable to close the sub, cheese was completely melted and gooey, sauce could been less, since the bread did get soggy, and almost came apart. Now the chicken buffalo sliders , that was a experience. First the breading, looked and almost tasted like a pretzel, then the filling, plenty of chicken bits and a healthy amount of buffalo sauce. Seriously the sliders were the best, I was expecting little burger sandwiches and instead pretzel type bread with filling. Very happy with the sliders and definitely something I will get again read more

Eddie's Gourmet Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Sliders - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Eddies Pizza is not gourmet pizza. It's lackluster. They are very light on the toppings, and the crust is meh. But the price is unbeatable. Additionally, they have a pizza card that you accumulate points on. You also get a free two-liter with the purchase of a large pie. This place knows how to look after the customer in that regard. Regarding the service, the older fellow at the front counter is hit or miss. Sometimes, he's on point; other times, he's dismissive. The young kids are usually beneficial. If you're looking to get a couple of pies for the low, this is the spot; however, don't expect a trip to Flavortown read more

What was I thinking? Lived here since 2005 and never ordered from this place. My mistake. The pizza was fantastic, the ham and cheese calzone was top notch, the garlic knots were some of the best I've ever had. They said they would deliver in 40 minutes but were here in 30. The driver was not only friendly and professional he made sure everything got here super hot. I think I may have found my new pizza place. read more

Great food; locally owned and takes great pride in their food! Delivery or Take out or eat in! All good, will not disappoint!!! Best pizza in the area! read more

So it had been many years since I first tried here and never gave it another thought (as based on my last review). We were happy with the two or three other places we'd been ordering from but wanted to re-try one of the other places that were just ok to give them another shot. We called for a delivery order on a Sunday evening. The person taking the order was very friendly and easy to understand. The delivery guy was very friendly and smiling the whole time - and the food was hot which is very rare with delivery! The food was wow - we couldn't believe it! Probably some of the best garlic knots we've had in the area - soft, hot, fresh and tasty. The small calzone with ham was fantastic - good quality ingredients and good ratio of mozzarella, ricotta and ham with spices and the dough was not hard or dried out. The pizza was great - great crust, great sauce and great cheese - we couldn't believe how good it was. And we got a free two liter of soda for ordering a large pie which was awesome and it was super cold! In fact we were so happy with our order that we called them and let them know how much we enjoyed everything. Glad we gave them another chance after all this time. Can't wait to try some of their other items which will be very soon.! read more

Good pizza and sandwiches. Always hot when it arrives. Wish they had more pasta choices

This food here is absolutely awesome! Bbq chicken pizza for days too! The owner is great people too! Highly recommended!

Best NY style cheese pizza in Newburgh. Always quick, always a smile and a genuine thanks when picking up. The wings are delicious too. Just my favorite! read more

I picked up a calzone and a few subs. The food was good and still very warm by the time I got home. The price was also very reasonable. The man who rang me up was polite and even carried my food to the car! Nice service ! read more

I love their pizza.the guy who usually takes orders at the counter is nice and funny. I did get two really sucky pizzas from them friday night, but that's the only time I've been disappointed. They do take checks, but no credit cards. read more

I love this pizza place! I always order from here their fast, NICE and the pizza 9 out of 10 Is really good! Plus, they have awesome coupons which makes it inexpensive. Nothing taste better than eating a lot of food for a great price! read more

Awesome food. Especially the entrees and 1 of the few places that's open every day, long hours, and deliver. Pizza specials, wings, entrees, and great service read more

Honestly my favorite place every for honey bbq Wings, my bf & I go here 1-2 times a week for them and all we gotta do is walk in and they know what we want. They're the best I've ever had especially with extra sauce to dip in. read more

These guys make a great pie! I tried their plain pizza as I always do when tasting new pizza. They use good fresh cheese, and their sauce is well seasoned. Even after being re-heated, the crust was crispy on the outside, and fluffy on the inside. It doesn't look as appetizing as some pizzas I've seen when they have it sitting at their counter, but believe me it's worth the taste. I also ordered their lasagna. For $8.50 I had enough lasagna to feed me for the rest of the day, and boy was it tasty. Tons of ricotta cheese, beef, and mozzarella on top. The place was nice and clean, and the employees were friendly. read more

Called at 11:37 didn't get my order until an hour and a half later for delivery. Unbelievable. Fries are soggy and cold and my wrap is falling apart. read more

Food poisoning . This is the second time in a month that we ordered Pizza and ended up with food poisoning. We will never eat from this location again. read more

Our favorite local pizza! Not as greasy as other pizza places around the area and the sauce and crust have a more gourmet taste. We've never had issues with service or pick up. Wings are ok...not as meaty as other places. read more

Love Eddies. Pizza is always yummy and their garlic knots are the best around. My co-workers and I get take out and delivery often from Eddies and its always great. They are very consistent and their Wappingers location is always just as awesome. read more

Good pizza and service was friendly. Kyle went out of his way to recommend some local places to checkout since I'm new in town. Awesome! I'm looking forward to returning to try more stuff! read more

So we ordered again today, i am a firm believer in second chances... OMG, I am so glad we did... Pizza was cooked perfectly!! We got a plain cheese for the kids, and a pepperoni and mushrooms for the adults and wow were we all thrilled!! The Wings and Garlic knots were delicious. We are EGP for life!! Thanks Eddies!! read more

Best pizza and meatball subs in the Newburgh area, in my opinion. After trying out a couple of other pizza joints in the Newburgh area ( Leo's and pizza Mia), Eddies is the only place we frequent. Delivery is usually quick and the employees are friendly. They only have a few tables ( 3-4) so I usually just get delivery or order to pick up. read more

I was so impressed by the guy Jon (i think) who answered the phone. He was very helpful and professional. I complimented the guy when I hung up on how helpful he was. I ordered a bunch of pies, then the not so smart driver delivered pizzas to a local business for a kids event and a few of the pies were folded over. There was no wax paper down to keep the pizza in place and im sure the guy was speeding. He attempts to fix the pizza with his bare HANDS and my husband catches this, and calls him on it. The guy stares my husband down like he wants to fight him and gives him major attitude. I go to attempt to talk to the driver and he leaves SLAMMING two car doors ignoring me . My pizzas were brought back but 20-25 minutes delayed while my other pizza got cold. NO apology NOTHING! Definitely put a damper in my daughters birthday party. The pizza wasn't that great after all too. My husband was a pizza delivery guy for a few years in his late teens and he knows a good amount about how to handle deliveries. Its a shame that this guy is giving this place a bad name. read more

Called the place at 11:25pm on a Saturday night..... suppose to close at midnight. Kid on the phone told me they were not serving anymore...delivery or pick up... no bueno! read more