I just ordered through UberEats and was charged an additional 25% tip from the restaurant. That's in addition to the other fees already added and didn't include the driver fee or driver tip. What a ripoff! I couldn't even see the charge till I went to the actual receipt. 25%?! For what? At least be honest if you're going to charge a standard tip. There are more honest pizza places than this around the area. read more

Villa Roma Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

Good chicken sorrentino (depending on who is cooking ,sometimes oily but always tasty)!

Amazing! Tasty , quick breakfast inexpensive and staff is always friendly. Breakfast lunch or dinner here is always on point read more

Villa Roma Pizzeria - Ham egg and cheese on a sub - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

You have probably passed this place a ton of times and never noticed it, as it sits off in the tuck and literally looks like a random corner store. Even walking inside, I saw no one and it looked like a big, empty space of a store that hasn't restocked in ages. I had no idea what to expect, as I came to pick up my pizza from here and assumed that Yelp set me up. The pizza here is pricey, even a small two-topping pizza ran me about $20, just as much as a Sicilian large with pepperoni ran me about $23-25, paying almost $45 for both. But, everyone that tried it loved the pizza and admitted it must be worth the price because it's pretty damn good. I recently picked up a Sicilian and it was tasty, I just wish the pizza here had a BIT more sauce and a BIT more cheese. It would've been perfect. All in all, I do like this pizza better than Tosco's and I'll be returning. I'll try to upload some pictures next time we order! read more

Villa Roma Pizzeria - Sicilian Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

came by after food shopping in the area for lunch, took me a while to order since they were bit busy with a small lunch rush. So, I ordered an Italian combo on a hard roll with no lettuce, tomato or onions, and add mayo, so basically plain. Also, a side order of meatballs and a buffalo chicken roll. I was told 5 minutes and it did take longer, am like whatever, but what got me was one of workers, not once but twice tried to give me the wrong order and am like this my order, so really a lack of Commnication, between them here. so, after the third time, the guy gives me my order. So needless to say, the service was very miss. So, the Italian combo sandwich was very good, plenty of meat, they remembered the mayo, but totally forgot I did not want lettuce, tomato and onions, but hey I should I have expected that someone would forgot to not add them. Buffalo chicken roll was great, a lot of chicken and it was moist and tender, and the bread was soft. The side of meatball, well pretty lacking in flavor and the texture was bit strange. Food was good, but service was def meh. read more

Villa Roma Pizzeria - buffalo chicken roll, side meatballs and Italian combo sandwich - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

I forgot to take pictures! We were staying at a hotel near the airport and looking for a quick dinner. This didn't disappoint. The Detroit-style pizza was thick but the crust didn't feel overly bready. The rolls were delish. The calamari was really good. It didn't keep its crunch in the to-go container but was very tasty! We would definitely come back when we're in the area! read more

This is a very good spot. I stopped in on a Saturday afternoon to get a few slices of pizza to go. As soon as I walked in the door, staff were friendly and greeted me as if I were a regular customer. Within 3 or 4 minutes, I was out the door with 2 slices and a soda for $5. That's a reasonable price. The pizza was delicious - cooked just right and not a lot of grease. This pizzeria seems more geared toward take-out. There are around a half-dozen tables with a few wooden chairs for anyone who would like to eat in. The menus are printed large and clearly above the counter and there's a TV while you wait for your order. Clean, friendly staff, fast, and good food. What more could you ask for from a pizza place? read more

I've been slacking on this review so here goes. We've been ordering from Villa Roma for over a year and we love this place. The food is really good! Not only is the pizza good, but their pasta dishes are great. We've had a number of them, but my favorite is the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Parmesan. If not in the pizza mood, they also make a good wrap, delicious burger and good caesar salad. We recently catered from them for a small gathering and everyone raved about the food. We had meatballs, lasagna, fried calamari and chicken parmesan. This is our go to spot for great food. Plus delivery is fast and the customer service is A+. read more

I'm a foodie so I'm always honest this is the first time ordering from here and I must say this pizza is so good I ordered mushrooms and pepperoni with extra sauce I had two slices and full I ordered a salad which I didn't eat yet but it looks great I'm definitely gone to order again thanks read more

Food great, asked for it extra crispy. Dining area clean. This is the place to get pizza in the area. read more

Villa Roma Pizzeria - Two slice! - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Drove past this place several times and never thought to stop in. After reading the the reviews I decided to give them a try. Pizza and wings were amazing!. The staff was very friendly and wait time for the food wasn't bad. read more

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS SPOT AND THE FOOD!! Almost every week I'm ordering from here because the pizza tastes exactly like brooklyn pizza and it makes me feel like I'm home read more

Unimpressive inside and out, until you see the menu. Very extensive Italian cuisine, and other popular food items. The prices are way more reasonable than others in the area. The only thing that surpasses the menu is the food itself. We have ordered from here many times and have never been disappointed. Not ever. From their pizza, to their appetizers, to their entrées, and desserts, as well, all excellent. They even have their own deliverers so you don't pay extra charges as with Door Dash, etc. Call them directly for that. Service is exemplary and friendly. I highly recommend this diamond-in-the-rough local restaurant. read more

First time trying this place and it was excellent. Ordered a large cheese pizza and mozzarella sticks. The pizza has the right amount of cheese and sauce. The crust was crunchy with a nice chew to it. The pizza itself was not too thin or thick. Mozzarella sticks were beer battered and fried perfectly. Prices very fair and a 20 minute wait time for pick up which was great. Was a loyal customer to Clearwaters pizza in New Windsor for years until he retired. Been tough trying to find the right place for pizza in New Windsor. Will definitely return to Villa Roma again! read more

I order from Villa Roma at least once a week. I've been getting my delicious tasting chicken wedges and cannoli for about a year since I decided to stop here. This place is an awesome spot for an italiano dinner. It's absolutely perfect for take out and also have a few tables for eating in. Staff is extremely nice, everything is really clean, and the prices are unbeatable! read more

Ordered a pizza and some wings via SLICE. This was my first time trying Villa Roma and all seemed good. Ordered a special... large pizza and 10 wings and a soda for like $20. Well worth it. Pizza was delish...never got a wing...lol (garlic parm). read more

Delicious thin crust pizza, just the way I like it. My brother lives in the area and even though I have good pizza all around me since I live in Long Island, NY, I was very impressed with their pizza. read more

See all

If you're not hungry then I recommend this place. But if you are hungry then don't order from here, they tell you 35 minutes and 2 hours later they show up with some nice nasty cold soggy food!!! I will never order from here again and I'll be sure to tell everyone in New Windsor to... read more

Hands down the best pizza in this area! I haven't ordered anything from here yet that I didn't love. Food always gets delivered quickly, hot & fresh. I order from here weekly read more

This is the best pizza in the area! The crust is so crispy, I haven't found that at any other place in the area (and I've been to just about every pizza place). They also have a wide variety of specialty pies, some of my favorites are taco and chicken francaise. I've only had one dinner (chicken parm) and it was delicious. The staff is also extremely friendly. This is now our go to pizza place! read more

I've have to give them 5 stars!! Best food around!! Best pizza I ordered. I've had pizza from other places in new Windsor this hands down the best.. Great chicken Parmesan to. They got a new regular customer. Oh and the price is great. I got s large pie, wings and a 2 liter soda for $21.with tax!!! read more

This is the closest pizzeria from where I'm working today. walk in not expecting much but they had huge selection to choose from and the price was just right walked outa there within 4 min with my hot pizza to go it was so good I'm about to go back and try a deferent slice 2 was not enough when it's that tasty read more