Epic Burger.. drop... Don't even get me started with the pizza Thanks for keeping it simple Andy!

Worse pizza ever! Soggy, limp, no toppings, just a BAD pizza . They get away with it because there are NO repeat customers. Go to another place and save your money. read more

I've only had there burger and fries the burger is fresh ground beef and the fries are always fried perfectly I'd imagine everything they make is delicious and priced very well service is always friendly and on point this place is an island gem you need to try sorry no pic I devoured it. read more

During our family vacation to the Beach, we always do carryout pizza on the first night. I had looked ahead and found several options near where we were staying. But when we arrived at the house, one of the rental workers was still there, and I asked him which pizza place he would recommend, without sharing my list. He immediately said Circle Pizza, which happened to be on my list. So I went with it. Turned out to be the right choice. I ordered a lot of pizza, and even though we didn't finish it on Friday night, the rest disappeared on Saturday for lunch. It's good Pizza, and I thought it was reasonably priced. The restaurant itself didn't seem like anything fancy, but it's perfect for carry-out. Would definitely do it again on future trips to Emerald Isle. read more

Pizza delivery is a luxury that I don't indulge in enough. One night in Emerald Isle we decided we didn't want to go out so we ordered circle pizza. My friend had raved about it so I was excited to try. We ordered the veggie and added pepperoni with olives only on half and it was great. The crust is on the thin side without being thin pizza. read more

Circle Pizza - a person holding a box of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Th pizza was okay, but not outstanding. Wings were good, larger than a lot of places. I think the service was probably the best part of our visit, fast and friendly. We needed sustenance and they provided it. read more

Pizza was good, not amazing. A little pricy. Nice variety of offerings. Nothing else to add.

Pizza was delicious and at a great price to feed a group of 24 on vacation! I will definitely order from there again! My favorite was the veggie but we bought a variety and they were all fantastic! Even my picky eater ate 2 large slices of cheese pizza! This is a must for any beach trip! read more

amazing service! the lady there was awesome. super friendly. the food was great. my husband loved it

Great food. Free delivery. Only critique is the salad needed a lot more dressing than what was provided. read more

Circle Pizza - Didn't take pictures until we were half way done. Large pepperoni, small sausage pizza and 2 garden salads. - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Food delivery was fast and wonderful. The pizza and fries were amazing. They even remembered the ranch. :)

If half ratings were a thing, I'd probably review a 3.5. The pizza is good, was a little on the higher side for the price. We ordered pizzas and garlic cheese bread one night for delivery. It was about an hour and a half time for delivery. The person on the phone was nice. We were fans of the pizza - but oh wow was the garlic bread not good. It was basically a thick slab of cheese on sub rolls. There didn't taste any garlic either. Highly recommend to stick to the pizzas and playing a round of cards (or two) while you wait! read more

See all

COCKROACH FOUND IN PIZZA! This place is DISGUSTING! My wife and I ordered takeout from here last week. She had the pizza box on her lap on the way home and when we opened the box up on our kitchen counter there was a cockroach stuck to the cheese. We called and the owner (Andy?) was very rude and tried to say this was our fault and that he would not give us a refund. Stay away from this place! read more

Ordered two pizzas takeout while here on vacation. Service was polite and prompt and cheerful. The crust was the right amount of crisp without being burned. Food was great ! Will definitely go back read more

Came in a few minutes after close and they made me a pizza anyway. It looked great and tasted even better! The people were awesome. Thanks for helping me out when was in a jam. Can't wait to come back again. read more

We had a chance to eat out tonight because of the storms in the area. We had planned on cooking out at the house. Found this place. WOW, we enjoyed the vibe. Great service and super friendly. Garlic cheese bread sticks. Bacon, onion and green pepper pizza. Food was great..looking forward for a return trip. read more

Circle Pizza - Our pizza, bacon, onion with green peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

The sandwiches and burgers here are great. Ordered pizza from here for the first time, about 45 minutes before closing. Asked the crusts to be thinned out. The grilled chicken/cheese was extremely dry. The pepperoni was just ok. The veggie was the best tasting of the entire order. Will probably stick with the sandwiches and burgers in the future and get pizza from somewhere else. read more

The best pizza on Emerald Isle. We get this 1-2 times each visit. Always consistently good.

We ordered for pick up. It was not too busy - delicious, and ready when they said it would be! Fries, just how we like them, were an added bonus! read more

Circle Pizza - We loved their fries too! - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Cozy Charming small town restaurant. Men's bathroom door was broken. The food was super hot. Chicken tenders, Hawaiian pizza. Pizza was chewy and hot. Fries were crispy and they had good blue cheese. read more

Even though pizza is in the name, their burgers are wonderful as well! I ordered delivery, and the phone service was friendly and efficient. The delivery itself was quick and easy, and I'll definitely check out some more of their menu in the future. For good casual food, can't recommend Circle Pizza enough! read more

This was our first visit, but it had been recommended by our daughter and son-in-law. It did not disappoint! We had pizza and it was delicious! The crust was crispy, topping frsh, and all that cheese! We can't wait to go back! Food was tasty with big portions, staff was friendly and fast, price was good too! Great little spot to visit! read more

This has got to be one of the best hamburgers I've had in a while The lady at the front desk was the sweetest I highly recommend Is circle pizza my friend got a cheesecake and it was just as good now we've got to try the pizza read more

Circle Pizza - This has got to be one of the best hamburgers - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Pizza was not that great. Pizza sauce flavor is off and on the saltier side. Toppings are not that fresh either. They do deliver which is nice but the food is just ok. read more

This place has really good food we loved it. The service is amazing from the servers Chrissy and Jionni (not sure how to spell their names) but they great and made us feel very welcome. Recommend read more

Circle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Solid pizza for the price and location. Ordered a large pepperoni/black olive pizza for $19. They do not skimp on toppings. Was ready for pick up in 15 min. read more

Circle Pizza - Large pepperoni/black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

The food is delicious usually hot and fast delivery This time the food was stone cold has to cook it in the microwave I was shocked food an delivery always top notch read more

Pizza was sub par. It did the job but wasnt very good. Had little to no sauce on it and tasted bland.

The first time I ordered here, I ordered a cheese pizza and jalapeño poppers. When it was delivered to my condo they made a cheese pizza with jalapeños on top. I wasn't happy but chalked it up to one mistake. This time I order the same thing and received this burnt, barely edible cheese pizza. They really should be ashamed they serve this to customers. We won't be ordering from here again. read more

Circle Pizza - BURNT cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Really disappointed in this place. Food service slow then was informed that they were out of ham for my italian sub. FINALLY get out food and sub was overdone and dry! Ask why no Italian dressing on sub and THEN was informed that they were out of that too! Would have been nice to know that when order was placed! Service sucked, food sucked will NOT BE GOING BACK! OH YEAH....we weren't the only complaints. Heard 2 other tables complain and there was only 3 other tables taken! WHATS WRONG WITH THESE FOLKS??? I'll stick with Michelangelo's! read more

Friendly staff and yummy pizza. Such a cute place inside. Great fried pickles too! Great crust. Nice and thin. We would happily return!

We had 2 lg pizza, a sm white + a SuperSub. The sub was very good, white pizza was ok. The pizzas, we'll I'll just say we had flash backs to middle school. Greasy, no sauce, NO flavor, nasty pies!!!! Do yourself a favor, instead go buy a take + bake or frozen pizza at the grocery. Hands down, the worst, dare to call it, pizza I've every had read more

The two ladies there are very nice and charming, we had great service. Pizza came out hot and very tasty, burger was very delicious and the mozz sticks were crispy and not too greasy. Lemonade was cold and refreshing. Also the salad was fresh and the veg wasn't old. Very reasonably priced for food quality and quantity. I would come again! read more

Needs to update online menu. All the prices are much higher when they ring you up(2-3) dollars an item and gyros don't come with tzatziki sauce read more

I am so thankful for the people at Circle Pizza kept bringing me food when I had Covid. The food was fantastic and they would not except payment. They are fantastic. Thank you Chrissy and Art read more

WOW, this was great pizza!!! I think the greek pizza was actually the best pizza I have ever had. We have a big family, and ordered a cheese pizza, veggie pizza, and a greek pizza. All were phenomenal. Delivery took slightly over an hour and a half - yikes! It was also pretty expensive. And the fries weren't great, but you really can't expect much of fries being delivered from a pizza place. But seriously, the pizza was absolutely amazing! So I gotta give it 5 stars despite the long delivery time and price. read more

Ordered for delivery. Great service and great pizza. I will definitely eat there again!

We had take out from Circle Pizza on the Thursday evening after Labor Day. Ordered a large Supreme and a Greek salad, which were ready in 15 minutes as promised. The staff were two young women, perhaps in high school, who were both very friendly both on the phone and in person. There were several delivery drivers sitting around; I'm guessing it's getting quite slow for them as is the case for most businesses on the Island now that Summer is ending. The Greek salad was okay. Iceberg lettuce, a few slices of tomato, canned sliced black olives and a good helping of feta. The dressing was entirely oil, likely canola or plain vegetable oil. It needed to be better emulsified before being portioned into the plastic cups so that some vinegar made the trip, but we had vinegar at the cottage and were able to rescue it. I do recommend checking the dressing before you leave as lettuce with oil ain't a good salad. The pizza wasn't very good. It didn't have the thin crust like another reviewer had mentioned, but it wasn't really a thick crust, either. Not good, but not bad. Pizza had lots of toppings and looked very impressive (see photo I added), and it was cooked properly. Sauce, like the crust, was also uneventful. They use canned mushrooms, which I find slimy and unappetizing, so if there is a next time, I'll ask them to hold those. Salad and pizza ran close to $30, which seemed much higher than it should have been. Prices on the website seem to have changed, so call ahead if you are concerned with 5% swings in price. Wife and I both felt that the pizza from Michaelangelo's down the road is better, but they suffer from really bad service, so you need to pick your poison - bad pizza or infuriating service. Next time, we'll just go with frozen heated in the oven. It's a lot cheaper and at least we're pretty sure the outcome will be consistent to our expectations. Not recommended. read more

Circle Pizza - Greek salad. - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

See all

Fast and friendly service. Kids destroyed the pizza and my burger was great. Small, quiet place - just what we needed

We ordered delivery from Circle Pizza on our first night after arriving at Emerald Isle. Delivery took an hour but they told us this when we placed the order. Good pizza and their fried mushrooms/pickles were also pretty good. The pizza prices were a bit high but the food was good. read more