The staff are all professional and great personalities, the bread before dinner is hot soft and delicious, my wife had a perfectly cooked new york strip steak, and I had the best chicken fried steak I have ever had. This cottons is east of Warrensburg on hwy 50. Oh in Missouri. Great job Colton steak house read more

See all

my family and I went to Colton's in Warrensburg mo to celebrate my birthday..we arrived at 7:45. Our waiter who's name was John was the worst waiter we have ever had. First of all, we received no rolls after we received our appetizers. We put in our orders at eight pm. He never refilled our drinks. It was 9pm and STILL no dinners for any of us. We finally got up at 9:15 after the restaurant was closed and left without any of our entrees...there were ten of us and we all left without getting our dinners. The only good thing is that we actually got some appetizers, but that's all. The rolls finally came out after the restaurant was closed and they were burnt.. inedible. The night was a nightmare and my birthday dinner with my family was ruined...all because a waiter's incompetentence. I didn't even receive my free birthday dessert which was promised. The whole dinner was a complete disaster. The waiter should be trained better on how to wait on tables. If I could give zero stars I would... I'm giving one star because the appetizers were good. read more

I went here for the first time a few days ago and loved it. The service was amazing as well as the food. It gets pretty busy in the afternoon but is totally worth it. The atmosphere is clean. read more

The food was overcooked. I ordered a New York strip and it came out over well. I just ordered medium. The service was good, but the food was bad. read more

I enjoyed the atmosphere, I thought the greeter and server was really great. The food came out at a decent amount of time and the food was fresh and our food was delicious. Nothing to complain about here. read more

Arrived about 7pm Monday 3/10/25. There were probably 5 tables that had patrons. Hostess was young and seemed stressed. After we were seated, our server came by after approximately 5 minutes. She took our drink order, one cocktail from the bar and two waters. Waited about 10 min and drink from bar came. She didn't bring waters until she came around a few min later and gave a new seated table their drinks first then our water. Water tasted like dirty tap water. She took our appetizer order. We waited about 15 min to get the wings. Wings were decent. We placed our order, I ordered sirloin and rib combo, husband ordered ribeye. I asked for mine to be medium well and his medium rare. We waited about 25 min and our order arrived. Server set plates down and walked away. She never asked us to check our steaks like she did the other tables. I cut my steak open and it was rare. Like the middle was cold rare. It was so rare and tough I couldn't eat it. Just ate my baked potato. She finally came by to check on us and I showed her my steak. Never asked if I wanted another one just said she would take some off our check. I would have liked my steak but whatever I was ready to go. She took off $10 from a $100+ ticket. We will not return. Felt like we were bothering our server and they had the doors open so the 60 degree air made it almost unbearable. read more

Amazing atmosphere! Location was awesome, host looked very joyful and waiters were very nice. The food was great. The 6 oz. Sirloin is a must!!! read more

Though it used to be a good place and still makes AWESOME rolls, that's about all I can say for a positive. We dined there every weekend of a home football game for UCM- usually a group of 7-10, but now go elsewhere. Sirloin tips cooked medium came out well done... and absolutely cold. Most members of the group get burgers but no matter what anyone ever asks for , they'll bring them out well- done. The tipping point for me was our waitress letting us know if bought desserts, she could skip closing chores!! This happened on our last visit and convinced us it should be our LAST visit. read more

This place was the worse place to go for a big group I called and had reservations for 630 pm got there it's took 2 hours to get set down and another hour to get food and half of it was cold didn't taste good all in all it was the worst birthday meals I've ever had to go thru Would not ever recommend this place to anyone and when we talked to the manager that was there they acted like it was no big deal we had to go thru this Which was not cool at all felt very disrespected I will never go back to this place the only reason I put one star is because they make you put one on here to do this review read more

We loved eating at Colton's in Warrensburg! Most often we get take out as we have 3 small children and it's easier for us to eat at home. Our pickup always goes smoothly and we are always impressed with the portion sizes when we get home. Many times with take-out you get skimped on food but not here. Treated the same as if we were dining in. Quality of food is always amazing as well. Love this place! read more

My husband and I have been to this restaurant many times & we really enjoy it! The place is always clean & the staff work together to provide good service. The food is very good & we like that they have a very good selection. No, things aren't always perfect but overall this is a very good restaurant!! I also really like that you can go through google and get on their waitlist! read more

Food is decent. A bit pricey for what you get. Staff is running around like crazy. Peanuts everywhere, so don't go if you have an allergy to them. However, the lake a patio are amazing. read more

We are in the most weeks about once a week and I always have 6 ounce sirloin steak normally is pretty good but lunch time today. I ordered it and I found it pretty dry. Really enjoy it. The salad was excellent. The fries were excellent, but the state was not very good Staff was friendly enough pretty well clean the place was clean yeah that's why I've only given it three stars this time read more

Very disappointed Very unprofessional to clean up your food before you close Mashed potatoes were super cold 2nd time I came in ordered no gravy Steak was horrible read more

The food it's ok now the drinks are very good , beautiful place nice staff nice atmosphere,

The food came out quickly, and was very good. The entire staff seems to work as a team and were awesome!!

Our waiter was fantastic , but as for the foodI - first off it took an hour for us to get it , then my friend and I specifically ask for it well done both were still pink in the middle my friends was really raw . The fries were a little cool not hot , Then we had to ask for our appetizer the rolls and hon cause it was not brought to our table . Needless to say I will not be going back there . read more

Very nice place to get a great steak! They provide peanuts for free, like other steak houses, so beware if you have any nut allergies! Quick service, very clean, even with the peanut buckets! Great steak, reasonable priced meal overall! read more

I'm so glad this place is here!! Went to phantom V when it was just a shed!! Also, Coltons in Sedalia was probably the first restaurant I visited when moving to Missouri. So Phantom V and a Coltons combination so close to my home! Is wonderful!! But I think the air-conditioning was not working right while there, so a little warm to eat! read more

See all

Ive never had bad catfish till I ate it here, Not Joking. Coleslaw wasnt good either. NO REDHOT hotsauce. There was only tabasco. WTExtraH?!! The Queso Cheese appetizer was not just cold, It Was Chilled tasting! Felt more like a cafeteria at this Warrensburg Coltons with the loudness and brightness. Service was decent, unsweetened raspberry tea was Really good. Husband had dry salmon. His baked potato was fine. Im SO Bummed, it is our 25th wedding Anniversary. It seems no one cared what we thought. I will only go to Coltons in Sedalia from now on. It's all around great in Sedalia. Waitresses, lighting, quietness, music, food is all Top-Notch! SO DISAPPOINTING IN WARRENSBURG COLTONS! !!!!! read more

Visited for a second time when we came to town. The atmosphere is great..cool country vibe with good music playing. The menu has a large variety of bbq/southern food. We had a party of five and everyone enjoyed their meals. They give fresh bread with your meal that is hot and delicious. It's served with butter and honey..yum! If your a fan of fried foods, the chicken fried chicken is a winner. The Del rio ribeye was seasoned well and cooked correctly. Very much enjoyed. Our waitress was attentive and had a fun personality making the over all experience very enjoyable. read more

It was my husband and I's first time there and we were not disappointed. I did the Brandy flight of 11 because one flavor. I was all allergic to. Everything was really well. Service was spot on. We would definitely go back. read more

This was our 1st time here and the food was amazing! The chicken fried chicken was the best I have ever had! Everything came out nice and hot, exactly how we ordered it. The waitress Alexis was very attentive and made sure we had what we need! We will be back! read more

The brandy flight was a fun experience. We had so much food. I enjoyed the okra. Love that they give a military discount.

We had an excellent dinner last night, the food was great and the waitstaff was superb Our waitress Mary Kate was so attentive. We never had to wait for a drink to be refilled, she was on the top of her game. We have eaten here several times since it opened and I would have left great reviews before but I am just figuring out how to use yelp. Keep up the great work read more

The last time we stopped in Sedalia, we didn't have a good experience. To start, the seating was confusing. Awe asked if we could sit in the bar, and we set in a booth only to be told oh we thought you were going to sit at the bar." We had to wait an additional ten minutes only to be set 1 booth back behind the one we were at. The food was horrible! Baked potato was as hard as a rock. The waitress we had started off good but then disappeared or moved to another area. We will just find another restaurant next time. read more

We stopped here for dinner expecting a pleasant dining experience. And it was not . 1 steak dinner was barely warm, the other steak was ordered medium rare snd it was hard and over cooked and the okra was cold. Next the burger was cold and over cooked and did not have cheddar cheese on it but some other orange cheese. The sweet potato was supposed to be Loaded (extra $) and was barely warm and not cooked with a few marshmallows on it. They offered to recook 1 steak and it took 25 minutes to get another while everyone waited. Asked if we wanted to take a sweet potato home ??? No one offered any compensation in the bill. Waitress was not attentive and had an attitude. Won't be going back. read more

First off this place is not very handicap friendly for the entire parking lot is gravel. This means a person nearly has to drive over customers in order to get on some semblance of concrete to let a person out. Next let's talk about the food. About the only thing this place can get right is the rolls and the . We order the serlion tips which were well done and chewy, then we ordered a chicken frid chicken and a chicken fried steak which we so overcooked that a steak knife could vearly do damage. Oh and did i mention at these dishes were frozen meat deep-fried. Lastly we ordered a chicken breast covered in mushrooms and bacon and cheese. The dish was served with grease from the grill oozing off the plate to the point of almost got on one of our guest. The side for this dish was fried okra that took so long to get out to the table that the main portion of the dish was already eaten. I can't blame the service here for the problems cause the servers are only as good as the kitchen producing the food. So in the end, customers pay premium prices for mediocre frozen food in a restaurant that tries to copy the success of other franchise steak restaurants such as Texas Roadhouse and Longhorn with no ordinal idea of its own. P.s. Oh by the way if your traveling west on 50 and your trying to reach this restaurant you better pray you don't get plowed over by another vehicle for there is no turn/slow down lane to allow vechiles to get out of the passing lane safely when turning left into the medium. read more

Used to be a really great place when they first opened. My husband and I made a new quick habit of frequenting every Sunday as soon as they opened the doors. I think others thought the same because there was always a line outside the door waiting for it to open. We kept coming back for the steaks and salads. Salmon dip and cheese sticks are really good, but they are the only appetizers we would recommend out of a lot of various options. The steaks used to be amazing. Tonight was terrible. The last few times we have gone our steaks are almost raw or almost burnt. No consistency. My filet mignon was supposed to be medium rare. It was well done. When I cut into it I noticed that it started unfolding once the bacon was cut away from the outside. It was more than one piece of meat folded together and hidden by being wrapped in bacon. I've worked in enough restaurants to see this truck before. It's sucks. It's not a good quality piece of meat if your piecing it together. My husbands steak was charred black around the edges and well well done inside. This was it for me. We won't be back. Can't keep driving 40 minutes hoping it will get back to what it once was. Our server Alexis was super kind and very attentive. No complaints there. I can appreciate that this restaurant is always clean and offers peanuts at the door. read more

Food was cold and it was uncooked and it was super salty never again will I eat here ...

Literally the nastiest place I've ever been to. The ribeye was horrendous, it was medium rare but it tasted like burnt cooking oil. Never will I ever return. read more

Wife ordered Steak n Shrimp, the steak was about the size of a dollar bill. she asked for it to be cooked "medium".. and it was medium well. that was returned and the second one was under cooked to "rare" I ordered Catfish & Ribs ( half-rack ) the Catfish batter was heavy with corn meal and dry though the fish was cooked properly the ribs, were one of the worst I've ever had. there was NO Smokey taste, apparently no salt & pepper in the least and was dry and overcooked on the outside. the inside was somewhat tender, but overall flavorless and was provided with some BBQ sauce, but tasked like Sweet Baby Rays, or KC or Bulls Eye.. definitely did not taste unique. We wont be going back. read more

Waited 45 min at 5pm on Friday asked twice when we were next!!! They said soon! All the people that came in before and after us were seated. I went back in waited to talk to them a party of 2 (same as us walked up and they immediately got seated) I asked what about our table and we were told we were NOT on the list!!! After asking 2 times!!!! What BS read more

Can't judge a book by it cover. Place looks good. Staff is polite and were very helpful. That's where it ended. My medium rare Ribey was over cooked and lacked flavor of any kind. Sorry stake Gods but had to add stake sauce. Oh but the okra was good. read more

When they get my steak cooked right it's awesome. But 5 out of 9 times the steak is over cooked. I ask for medium rare and get medium or medium well. That's my only complaint. read more

I would NOT recommend here to no one. first thing hot rolls was brought to the table. we ask for more butter. It never came. Our food came out ask for some hot rolls and BUTTER since the others had got cold. We got them. I had a mushroom Swiss burger and no type of sauce to go on it. I ask if I could have some mayo. Again, I waited finally ask where my mayo was, I was told they were out. My burger was cold by then I just ask for a ticket and a to go box, It was brought to me with a pkg of mayo. I was very upset. Paid my bill and I will never return. read more

Second time we have dined there. Drinks are reasonable and very good and large! Staff is excellent! Food is excellent as well! Great selection! Worth the wait not bad, 45 min last time on a Friday evening. Try a flight of Phantom V liquor! read more

Nice location, good food and friendly staff. I just wish they built double door for entrance to keep the cold/heat in inside the restaurant. Everytime someone walks in or out of the restaurant, the heat from the outside comes in and people sitting in the waiting area are being exposed to the hot temperature outside. read more

My first time here, but my husband's 3rd, so I knew it would be good...we're from another state, but we came to the area for a weekend event. Our server was Melanie, and she was fantastic! So friendly, attentive, and helpful, and she did not leave us waiting for literally anything. It was pretty busy, but no delays once we were seated. We joined the waitlist on our way to the restaurant and they were ready to seat us as soon as we got there. We both had NY Strips and they were cooked to our liking. The Mac & Cheese was delicious with a perfect blend of light & creamy sauce and shredded cheese sprinkled around within. We also ordered a flight of Phantom V brandy flavors. Wow--so good!! The Old Fashioned Oatmeal Cookie one goes well with just about any of the other ones. We also had Butterscotch, Spirited Apple Orchard, Cran-Raz, and Cherry--every single one of them was super tasty! Overall, it was a very pleasant experience with scrumptious food, amazing brandy, and top-notch service. Will definitely be back whenever we're in the area. read more

The food is so so. I was not impressed with there steak. Potato bake need to be cook more. Service was not that good. Took for every to get drinks. read more