Great ice cream great spot great prices Joe and his staff are amazing huge milkshakes

Quality of the ice cream is great. The lines get ridiculous during the summer but I think its worth the wait. Some outdoor seating/picnic tables. The ice cream with waffle is a good choice. Haven;t tried the milkshakes, but they look nuts. read more

What a place. If you can wait in the line, you will enjoy the results. Whether you try the Sideshow shake or just a simple cone. It's some fresh and tasty ice cream Definitely will be back read more

Coney Waffle - Wonder wheel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Tried it for the first time today. We liked the ice cream but my son was disappointed that the waffle was cold and hard. Hoping we came at a bad time and this isn't the norm. We'd give it another try. read more

One of the best local spots to get icecream. Great views, the staff is also always so nice. I love the quality and flavors of the icecream; as well as the waffle combination. Would like better cleaner seating though. read more

I've been dying to try this place a couple years now and finally had the chance. Although I really wanted to try their amazing looking shakes, I decided to start off slow and do a waffle ice cream. I'm glad I did! We showed up at around 12:15 on Fri, probably about 5 min later the place started filling up. There were a ton of flavors to choose from, I got Java Chip, Strawberry donut and birthday cake(you get three scoops) with whipped cream, the ONLY thing I was disappointed with, which isn't horrible, is they didn't have any marshmallow topping, it's my favorite!! My friend had Butter Pecan, Rum Raisin, and the strawberry donut one. The waffles were fresh made and nice and warm, but not warm enough to melt the ice cream, and they were crispy. The scoops of ice cream area a bit bigger than a golf ball, which was fine, and 2 came to 13 dollars and change. Java chip was my hands down winner! Creamy, fresh coffee flavor with delicious java chips! If you love a good coffee ice cream, this is it! Coming in second for me and first for him was the strawberry donut, straight forward.. strawberry ice cream with strawberry donut pieces and frosting with sprinkles. Not overly sweet like you would think, and totally delicious. The birthday cake was good, but the other two outshined it, again...not overly sweet and was creamy! The rum raisin and butter pecan were good as well, it's just that the custom flavors took center stage. I'd definitely give this a try if you're in or near Belmar, the address on Yelp has 803 Ocean Ave Asbury, but it's 803 Ocean Ave in Belmar. They have a lot to offer flavor wise and also carry vegan and sugar free flavors so there's something for everyone!!! The photo I took was of my ice cream. I'll be back, as they're open in the off season! read more

Coney Waffle - Ice cream waffle. Far left, birthday cake, strawberry donut in the middle and the java chip!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Never a bad experience at coney waffle especially in a hot day, a lot of your basic mixed flavors but they do them well, having some ice cream on top of their fresh warm waffle... the crunchy creamy contrast, excellent. Beautiful flavors. Beautiful atmosphere. Beautiful experience. The s'mores ice cream is a close first in my book. read more

Coney Waffle - Cotton candy, s'mores, Cookie Monster in a waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Great old school ice cream shop. Bring cash, they don't take card. Flavors were awesome. Large selection as well. read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I was loving this place* until I saw a few unsanitary mishaps worthy of a health department citation. There was a young woman who was wearing gloves to put candy on skewers. Great, right? Here's where it went left, she walked over to her phone which was appearently hooked up to the store's sound system. She handled her phone with the gloves on and went back to fixing the candy skewers! Time went by and my husband and I are outside eating with our children and the same young woman left rhe store with her gloves on, scratching her hair. She went next door to the pizzeria and came out a few minutes later with rolls of coins. I went back in the store and she was already serving people. Never washed her hands! Never changed her gloves! UNSANITARY! *I hope this is the right location I am reviewing. It's the one in Belmar. Ocean Ave/9th read more

This place showed up on my FB newsfeed & I took a drive down a couple of weeks ago to see what it was all about. It was a rainy & gloomy Sunday so none of the outside tables were being used. They have a few long picnic tables set up inside & it was pretty crowded I got a "sideshow shake" & it was amazing. Mine was a strawberry shake, sugar cone with Superman ice cream, a vanilla chipwich sandwich, tons of candy AND a mint chocolate chip Belgian waffle was hiding underneath the boatload of cotton candy. $18 is a great price for all that was included. Way too much for me to eat, but totally worth trying out Keep in mind, it is CASH ONLY read more

Coney Waffle - Sideshow Shake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Business is clean and bright. Worker very friendly. Ice cream was delicious; I had a 2 scoop waffle cone (Batman chocolate and an M&M caramel). Definitely recommend this place. Fun, safe place to sit outside and enjoy the activities along the boardwalk. Thanks. read more

Amazing fudge & service at the Belmar location!!! The manager was so friendly & helpful - 10/10 recommend

We decided to try this place based on the ads that kept popping up on Facebook. These ice cream cone concoctions are HUGE. The employees find ways to make the presentation of your order impressive. But, that's really all it is. It's all aesthetics/presentation. It's "for the 'gram." Nothing gets someone all gassed up than coming out of the store and having everyone stare at the tower of ice cream and treats and yell "Daaaaaaamn!" We ordered the $16.00 Liberty Cone with Cookies 'n Creme ice cream. The ice cream tasted like any other Cookies 'n Creme ice cream would. The employee that made our cone gave us a rock candy, 2 rice-crispy-esque bars made out of fruit loops, and topped it with cotton candy and whipped cream. Don't get me wrong. We love ice cream and sweets. We definitely enjoyed the Liberty Cone. It wasn't bad at all, but it wasn't mind-blowing either. The Fruit Loops bar things were delicious and I wish we could just buy those by themselves. Not sure if you can, though. The reason I gave this place only 2 stars: Hygiene. I am a nurse and I am all about hygiene and infection control... I always look forward to eating the waffle cone of my ice cream meal. The employee who was making our Liberty Cone asked another employee, let's call her Employee #2, to hold our waffle cone while she anchors everything so nothing falls. However, Employee #2 was not wearing gloves like everyone else behind the counter. Before she was asked to help, she was wiping the tables outside with a dirty rag and picking everyone's scraps off tables. So, minus 3 stars for that. read more

Coney Waffle - Liberty Cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

We got the side show cookies and cream milkshake, and it was definitely a treat! We couldn't finish one between 4 of us, and brought most of the candy add-ons home with us...Great place for some ice cream creations with pizzaz!! read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Saw this place on Instagram and absolutely had to come experience it for myself. The day we came here it was rainy so there was no line which is always great. My boyfriend and I ordered the orange cream freak shake. I thought it was orange ice cream but that refers to the sugared rim on the cup. Nonetheless, it was so good! She didn't have the fruity pebble rice crispy treat sandwich (bummer) but she did have a coco puff version which was amazing. The overall experience of eating this thing was awesome. It's so much fun taking it apart and sharing it with someone (or you could just stuff your face by yourself lol). In NYC there is a similar place called Black Tap Burger which serves shakes for $15 and they are half the size of the ones here. The cost is $18 but it's totally worth it. I'll def be back with friends. read more

Coney Waffle - Freak shake! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

One of my favorite ice cream places. A definite cute place to take the kids. They're sitting outside it's located right on the The boardwalk. All the ice cream is definitely selfie worthy. read more

See all

Who doesn't love waffles and ice cream?! I came here with friends during a beach weekend and this was our pre dinner snack lol I got the mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream with waffle. Yum! The warm waffle tastes so good with the cold minty cookie ice cream. read more

Coney Waffle - Waffles and ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I don't even know where to begin... that's what you'll think when they hand you the biggest milkshake of your life! The employees were super friendly and seem to genuinely enjoy making these crazy over the top fancy shakes... each one truly is a piece of art. The quality of the ice cream in the shake is also wonderful... I'd definitely stop back by Coney Waffle just for a cone if I'm ever passing through Belmar solo but I really hope I get to bring back all of my friends to see these masterpieces! I shared the mint chocolate chip shake with 2 of my friends and we hardly made a dent. A little strategy we came up with was to take off all the candy that wouldn't melt so we could take that with us and then proceeded to do our best at drinking the shake and eating the cone, waffle and ice cream sandwiches that were on top. You HAVE to try this place! read more

See all

My experience at Coney Waffle was pretty good! The staff was friendly and the owner was responsive. Maria, the cake maker, was super helpful and got me just what I needed! They allowed me to change the color of the cake from blue to green, which my son was thrilled about!! The presentation was superb and everything that I hoped for. My only complaint was the ice cream was not to my liking; and just as a heads up, you can not order customize cakes at their locations (only online) but they are working on that. Otherwise, job well done!! read more

See all

Salted caramel pretzel and java chunk in a rainbow waffle cone! Delicious flavor and perfect for even a cloudy beach day. A little pricey- $7.50. You're probably better off going for one of the hot waffle sundaes with three flavor choices for $6. read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Getting one of their monstrous creations for my kids was well worth it! You can choose from the Sideshow Shake ($21 shake) or the Liberty Cup ($18 ice cream). We chose to get the liberty cup. We gave the employee our 3 flavor choices of ice cream and she went to work - carefully skewering the cotton candy, gummy works, sour worms, candy ribbon onto the ice cream, then layering it with chocolate pretzel, ice cream sandwich, ice cream cone and Hershey chocolate bar. This definitely excited the kids, visually and gastronomically! Obviously this would be tedious to eat or even just get to the ice cream, but a take out box and lots of napkins and wet wipes are provided to make life easier. The kids sure enjoyed it! They loved the cotton candy and the worms and ate some of the ice cream. The adults ate the rest! I thought the ice cream was decent. We ordered 2 scoops of Rich N' Famous and one scoop of mint chocolate chip. There were many flavors to choose from, including some novel flavors like cinnabun, birthday cake and chocolate peanut butter. Although the creation was $18, the price seemed reasonable. I won't be getting this again because it's fun just to try once, and take memorable pictures. I would just get the ice cream or even buy the cotton candy for the kids to enjoy in the future. Coney waffle also offers shakes, ice cream and waffles, and ice cream floats. There are picnic tables outside to sit on to enjoy your ice cream. read more

See all

Perfect Boardwalk style Ice cream & Sweet shop. The waffle is built like a hot dog bun ,so you can indulge while not making the normal mess a waffle requires. Great ice cream & the staff is super nice. The candy counter and cookies are pretty and I cant wait to try the cake pops next time !!. Definitely worth a visit for a old school beach treat, or two Tastes like summer !!! read more

Coney Waffle - Coney waffle & Ice Cream Sweet Shop with a ocean view. Yum !! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Great to find vegan ice cream that actually tastes good! They had about 6 vegan flavors and I was really impressed. Just take note that this is a cash only business, which sucks because it's 2019 and most people don't carry cash these days. Their ATM charges a $3.99 fee plus whatever kind of fee your bank charges, so it's not worth it if you don't have cash. However, the ice cream was very good and I'd go back for more as long as I have cash on me next time! read more

Coney Waffle - Vegan cookie dough ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This place makes my heart happy. I'm an ice cream everyday kinda person. Also I love the beach and every time I'm at Asbury Boardwalk I stop here. The waffle and ice cream is a must for me. They have a cinnamon twist ice cream that I look forward to each visit. They also have fun elaborate desserts. Cotton candy, lollipops, and candies to accentuate your ice cream fun! If you're in the area check it out! read more

This is for kids, instagram, and people who like kitschy things. If you are one of those types, you will love coney waffle! My daughter does and I will continue to take her. Ok first off all these milkshakes that you see with all the stuff in it are like $20 so if you have a couple kids it's really not that bad, they can split it. They also have waffle sundaes but the waffles in our shake were so hard that I don't think I would enjoy them. We got one of the shakes that you just pick the flavor, we picked chocolate, I didn't realize they would add another flavor, they added peanut butter to everything! Ugh. But the kids like it so whatever. Bottom line is that the ice cream isn't that great, your much better off going to The other ice cream place on 71 read more

Usually I go for plain flavors, but when I saw that this place had a "Superman" flavor I knew what I had to do. It was actually really good (mix of berry and vanilla ice cream), but it's not something I'd get every time. My mom got coffee and was pleased. $9 for two smalls, cash only. read more

Coney Waffle - Superman - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Yes, I came here and got a crazy milkshake. I just couldn't resist. There's apparently an even bigger size than the one I got, which has double the amount of everything. I decided that the regular great shake was enough diabetes for one day. My sister really wanted cookie dough so we shared that. If you haven't heard of the great shake, it is basically a massive milkshake with an ice cream cone, ice cream sandwich, ice cream waffle sandwich and a bunch of candy held together with cotton candy in the back. It was a complete sugar rush, but it was so worth it. The ice cream waffle was delicious and so was the ice cream sandwich. My sister ended up having the cone. The candy was fantastic, but since I had so much ice cream already, I saved the candy for later. They give you a to-go box for you to take your leftovers home, which is really nice. Honestly, between three people, we were only able to finish 50% of this. It would take about 5-6 people to really finish the whole thing. So worth it though! read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

I love this place so much. SO SO DELICIOUS. The quality of their ice cream is amazing. So creamy, rich, indulgent, and not icy and freezer-burny like some ice cream parlors. So freaking good!!! Been coming here for years. The one in Asbury is by far my favorite location. I'm on weight watchers and willing to break my point bank for this stuff everytime we come to the beach. You really can't go wrong with any of their flavors. My favorites are Batman Fudge, Monster Cookie Blue (though you'll be a sight to see if it melts all over you), and Java Chunk. I've had their sideshow shakes, they definitely go all out. And they're great for large groups. But they're just too sugary in my opinion, even though that's the point. I've had their waffle and ice cream, ehh nothing special and the portions aren't as generous. Stick with a classic waffle cone. You won't be sorry. read more

Coney Waffle - Monster cookie blue - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

My family and I were looking forward to trying this place. I had seen it on a food bloggers Instagram page. But it was not as good as it looked in the pictures. We were all disappointed! The ice cream was good, not great. The waffles were not made fresh when you ordered them, they were already made and then used in the waffle sundaes, so they were cold and rubbery. The only reason I'm giving them two stars is because they had a few great flavor combinations for the ice cream. read more

My girlfriend and I have been wanting to go to this place since they opened. Finally the heavens aligned and we made it our mission to go there as part of our 3 year anniversary celebration. We went in May so I can't use the off season as an excuse. To start, we were turned off my the dirty appearance of the store, but we figured maybe it was the rustic look they were going for. I will however compliment the staff on being very friendly, but that's about where the ball stops rolling. We ordered 2 ice creams, 1 brownie waffle and a regular waffle. Both items were sitting out for a long time because they were just next to the waffle irons and thrown into the paper bowl thing. They were cold, hard, and borderline inedible. The ice cream was definitely missing something and the size of the scoops they give you compares to the size of a golf ball. So for 2 ice creams we spent 20 including tip and got half a sundae. We go over to the tables they have and are instantly disgusted by the horrendous nature of the condition they are in. I would be very surprised if they have ever been cleaned. Dirt and grime covered them to the point where we couldn't even sit on them. They use a park bench type table so the dirt was so embedded into it, you wouldn't be able to wipe it off if you wanted to. The inside leaves a lot to he desired and mixed with the filth, we couldn't wait to get out of there. The ice creams were in your standard freezer, but probably didn't need to he because the place had the ac set to about 40. A group of kids in winter jackets next to us had to get up and go outside in a 55 degree day because it was so cold. We look through the window to see the ice cream, but nothing was labeled so you have no idea what flavor you're actually thinking about getting. All in all it was a very bad experience and we were severely disappointed. Maybe they had an off day, but it would be a long shot if I ever gave them another chance to prove that it was. read more

We stopped here after eating dinner next-door and watching someone eat a huge sundae with cotton candy. It looked so fun and we planned on getting it but decided not to when we saw that they offered waffles filled with ice cream. The price is just right, you can get a waffle with three scoops of ice cream for only six dollars! Can't beat that! They have so many flavors to choose from. They are so offer a couple different kinds of waffle cones and of course ice cream in a cup. read more

Friendly, energetic HS/college staff. Wide variety of flavors; great shakes, creative, "exotic" combination cones for kids. Long lines, but, it's summer....so no complaints! Significant turn off....this past weekend it looked like the floor had not ever been introduced to a broom. Similar lack of cleanliness last year. With the volume of staff, would not hurt to hand one of them a mop every hour or so. Cleanliness issue kept the rating at three stars. read more

Have been dying to check this place out forevers since the cold of winter 2016! Yes those instagram photos have lured me. Yes I bought a huge ice cream cone with huge candy and cotton candy toppings. Yes it was gloppy and delicious. Whether you want delicious small cones, ice creams in cups or on waffles, this place is colorful and fun and truly fits the jersey shore atmosphere in a sunny summer! Must go! Can't wait to try a bigger ice cream concoction to share! The cone I had with two big scoops of ice cream and a big cotton candy with gummies and a ring pop coat 9 dollars. I was very happy and full of chocolate ice cream on my cheeks. read more

See all

Went to Belmar for the first time with friends and before heading down I looked up spots to visit .. this place came up so we checked it out. We went in expecting the huge ice creams and shakes advertised but not really. We showed the workers some pictures asking for suggestions and they were kinda like whaaaaaattttttttt like we were crazy. They have so much to choose from but I went basic - waffle and ice cream. You get three scoops so you can do three different flavors which is huge! The waffle is also about a 1/3 of a regular Belgium waffle so it's easy to eat the whole thing and great amount. Will be back to tackle a giant shake! read more

Coney Waffle - My friend Brynn and her fun come ($9.50) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This place is amazing!! The people that work here always get real crafty with their milkshakes! They never fail to amaze! I cant finish one by myself however I always try to! Ice cream sandwiches, candy, waffle sandwiches, cotton candy, chocolate covered pretzels and more all piled on top of an amazingly delicious shake :) Check it out, i think its cash only. You won't be unsatisfied after leaving here. They have a great Instagram and do holiday inspired shakes. read more

Must stop in here with your friends, kids , family don't worry about the line it moves pretty fast and it is def worth the wait for scrumptious ice cream and Home made waffle cones with Special New Jersey themed named cones you'll love stopping in and so will your guests.perfect spot by the beach sit outside on the picnic tables and enjoy the ocean breeze with crazy mile high ice cream sundaes with gummy shark, cotton candy swirls, peanut butter cups , m&m's , and so much more! I rate it a 10 ! This is a place where kids can smile and summer dreams come true ! best ice cream and sweet treats read more

See all

What a terrific way to end our evening, walking back tour hotel along the Asbury Park board walk we can across a terrific ice cream parlor. Once entering, I immediately was drawn to the fresh waffle machine in the corner. I had canolli cream scoops on my waffle, my wife had a mixture of canolli cream and homage mint chocolate chip scoops on a brownie waffle...I feel this speaks for itself! read more

See all

This is a great ice cream shop right on the boardwalk in Asbury Park with a bunch of great choices. There must be at least two dozen flavors and the scoops are pretty big. There's no better way to cool down on a hot day at the shore. The picnic tables out front on the boardwalk are perfect for enjoying the tasty ice cream and taking in the sights of the boardwalk. read more

The sideshow milkshake brings everybody to the yard!! Holy Moly that thing is huge! For only 18 bucks (cash only) you get a 32 oz milkshake topped with all ze candies and ice cream sandwich, waffle and ice cream , ice cream and waffle cone. Bring the village to help eat this beast! #almostdeathbyicecream read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I'm not going to knock on this spot too much, they had a line out the door and my family did enjoy their ice cream. However, I will say their topping selection is definitely barebones, as are their non hard-serve offerings. I just wanted a fruit flavored option and they acted like they had never heard of sorbet or sherbet before. It's definitely way too pricey for what they serve. I hope they start to consider all customers when they put out their flavors in the future. read more