I'm giving this place the 5 star treatment mostly for the ice cream and milkshake quality. With all these spots trying to create the bigger, badder shake, the toppings become the star but I'm bringing it back to the milkshake. Went with a Cookie Monster ice cream after an employee recommended it and was not disappointed! It's like a blue cookies and cream with marshmallow and a little more chocolate. And the shake was perfect consistency. As for the toppings, they definitely do not cheap out and you can probably have a sufficient dessert just by picking at those read more

Coney Waffle - Cookie Monster ice cream shake- took 5 people to finish this - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Yo this shit was maadd good. So fat but that's why you end up here. Had the cookies and cream shake with like a million pounds of candy in it and the waffle sanny with cannoli cream. Yooooo that shit is BANGIN!!! Hit that up fooooo shoooo!! Def gotta go back and try every single thing on the menu. They were out of the brownie waffle which had me sad as hell but gives me a reason to go back! read more

Absolutely love this place. We've been taking our son up to Belmar to walk on the boardwalk basically since he was born so we love stopping into Coney Waffle. Ice cream is always delicious and high quality and you cannot beat ice cream on a waffle. Topping selection is ENDLESS. We haven't been brave enough to try any of their shakes yet but we've seen a lot of people walk out with them and they look incredible. Love Coney Waffle, can't wait to go back. read more

The freak shake may be a little pricy but it was worth it ! They layer a bunch of ice cream scoops and candies in it so when you consider the price consider how much each of those candies would cost you individually. There's certainly no skimpiness in this place! I got the mint chocolate chip freak shake, and even with two people we couldn't finish it.(Believe me we tried) Overall Coney Waffle is a fun place to go with friends and share a GIANT milkshake :) read more

Coney Waffle - Mermaid Freak Shake -Mint Chocolate Chip Freak Shake (I opted for the rainbow cup normally it has a chocolate border around the cup.) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Not only did their staff not wear gloves while handling cooked food but they are cash only and their atm fee is $4. Waffle was small and sub par read more

The workers handmade this beautiful creation! About $23 for the large one. Pricey but worth it. Good to the last drop! read more

Coney Waffle - Totally devoured in less than 15 minutes. Delicious!!!!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Great new addition to the shore. If you're looking for a good desert with a lot of creativity, this is your place. Crazy ice cream concoctions like ice cream and waffles and their crazzzyyy shakes which have things like cotton candy, chocolate covered pretzels and ring pops sticking out of them . However, the ice cream itself is good but nothing great. It gets the job done and they have some good flavors to chose from . Perhaps my next visit will give it a 5th star. read more

See all

The ice cream I had was awesome! The ice cream my girlfriend has set her off in a severe allergic reaction. She was told by the staff that she could eat what she asked for and twice they were wrong! Not cool! The staff really needs to be educated and management really needs to put up definitive signage! read more

Really great waffles and the ice cream is delicious! Happy staff and owners always there:)! Great fun festive spot! They have candy and various sweets for everyone in your family! Right across from the boardwalk and open during the winter! YAY:)! read more

Got the overpriced overhyped milkshake which was so milky it barely tasted like cotton candy and it tasted artificial. Came with not enough candy for the price. The lady in charge was rude and yelling at the young girl cleaning. (Belmar location) This is a tourist trap that locals should not support. Go to strollos if you are in the area it is so much better. read more

I saw this on a food network show and could not wait to try one of the fancy milkshakes. What a disappointment. When you take away all the candy trimmings the milkshake was watery and lacking in taste. read more

Clean and friendly staff plus the boardwalk is a nice place to hang out at after your done eating your sweet treats. I brought my sister visiting from out of town because she didn't believe they make the biggest milkshakes in NJ here. read more

Coney Waffle - Hand for comparison - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Lots of sweets to choose from. They have ice cream to chocolate covered pretzels to Cannolis. Yummm read more

Coney Waffle - Perfect' ice cream and the beach - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Definitely a great place to stop by with friends or family.. the largest size of shake is worth the $$ price and can easily be shared by four or five people the way my friends and I did. It was an overcast day so there was no line but I can imagine on a summer day there might be. It was aesthetically pleasing but lots of the candy was uneaten... probably better for kids to share or for someone with a huge sweet tooth. Either way I would recommend it! Definitely want to go back and bring an update after trying the waffle taco-like snack with ice cream inside!! read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Love love love this place !!! my sister, Neice, and I came in here just to buy my Neice a waffle cone and we walked out with a free shake! It was marvelous! The owner was so lovely and kind and the employees were very patient(there is a GARGANTUAN amount of treats served there!) this has definitely been encrypted into one of our Belmar traditions( along with 3brothers pizza of course. Definitely a must try! read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Absolutely love Coney Waffle. I found them on Instagram over the summer and have been back many times since. I ordered a peanut butter freak shake and split it between 2 friends...We managed to eat it all! We also got a waffle cannoli, which was amazing because the homemade waffles are to die for. They're made with cinnamon and served fresh! I also recommend the Fruit Loop cereal treats and Butter Finger fudge. The staff is so friendly and helpful, and they know a thing or two about making unique desserts. It's a true experience to visit this ice cream shop and it's hard to walk away unhappy. The best part is that they're open year round. read more

Coney Waffle - Reese's peanut butter cup waffle with chocolate ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

I got the brownie waffle with scoops of pistachio, chocolate peanut butter ripple, and cookie dough. The cookie dough was my Favorite and the waffles were fresh and chocolatey. Delicious! A little expensive but you're paying for the hand made waffles! read more

WOW! MAKE THE DRIVE, STAND IN LINE, DO WHATEVER YOU NEED TO DO TO GET A SCOOP OF THIS PLACE!!! Staff was very friendly and the product is delicious! Loved the decor of the place. I recommend the Side Show. For $18 you can feed a family of 4! Very family friendly spot , perfect for a date as well ! Ps: I hope you have a sweet tooth ! read more

Coney Waffle - Cookies and Cream Side Show - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I know it's off season and the end of the night, but no need to be rude. $9 for 3 small scoops and a dry waffle. No thanks. This place won't make it. Poor attitude service dude. It's the locals coming in now. Bye. read more

My best friend and our significant others went to Belmar beach just for this specific place, and they did not disappoint. She got her huge icecream decorated with cotton candy and all other sweets and I got a cotton candy and Cookie Monster icecream. So so good! Really recommend it for a fun ice cream place. read more

i had the bday cake ice cream in a cup and it was so good! very fresh! loved the cake pieces in it! also i tasted some of the wafel my dad was having and it was very good! i have to get that next time! fresh baked and u can smell it! read more

The vegan ice cream here is AWESOME! We had the Oreo and mint chocolate chip which were both creamy. They gave us a taster of the soft serve sorbet which was watermelon and mango (I think). I was expecting the sorbet to be sweet, but it wasn't at all. It had a nice fruit flavor. I've had vegan sorbet from other places and couldn't eat them due to the sugary taste. The vegan offerings are expanding too, they will add a whole case of vegan options. So exciting! The only reason I am giving them 4 stars instead of 5 is due to the cost. We got a small and had asked to split the scoops with the two flavors so we could try them. The cost was over $8. read more

Amazing! Skip meals for a few days cause the size and calories will keep you covered for a week. Seriously, nice staff and great ice cream. The creativity is amazing. Wish they were closer. read more

Have a hidden $2 upcharge for vegan ice cream which is not on any of their signs - and is totally unfair anyway. The reason I was given, it's gonna store the ice cream in the freezer - what they aren't storing the regular ice cream in a freezer?!?! And after spending $8 on one single scoop of ice cream, I was told I could not have a cup of water. read more

Probably some of the best ice cream in the area. This location holds up to the be the best of them. If you go, get the cinnabun ice cream!

Saw pictures of this place and decided to go while at the beach. Their products that you go their for (the hugs milkshakes and ice cream bowls) are huge, which is nice if you go with a big group. I ordered one because It is very unique but wish I could get something just as cool but smaller. They have a non dairy ice cream as well. Also this place is pricey, but very unique! read more

I love this place. I never leave the beach without getting ice cream here. They have a variety of flavors, something very similar to waffle tacos and crazy shakes. I got a cookies and cream shake this past weekend and bomb.com. The large is sooooo big. I couldn't finish it alone. There's plenty of outside seating. read more

Had to try one do their giant shakes for my bday outing! And it was worth the sugar coma! Got the cookies and cream. Yum! It's huge and prob good for 4 ppl. You get so much for the money too! We even brought home all the candy on it! **cash only! read more

This place is delicious, but be prepared for a long line to wait in. It is dangerous to handle the bigger shakes and items because they are easily tipped over and ruined. You definitely don't want to drop any toppings because their menu items are not cheap! They recently added some vegan options to the menu, which is great for anyone with allergies or specific dietary needs. I've gone twice, but I honestly can't say I will return. While their ice cream is good, it's too over-the-top for me! I feel like 99 percent of the people there only go for a cool Instagram photo, then waste two thirds of their shakes because they're gigantic cups of diabetes that shouldn't be consumed by one person alone. You CAN get a smaller portion, but at that point you're better off going somewhere with better prices. read more

My boyfriend and I came here to day to try the freak shakes. This place was packed with a line out of the door! I don't know why I thought we'd be the only people trying this shake. Anyways, we decided on the 'Parachute' freak shake which was a Chocolate & Peanut Butter shake. The girl who took our order was okay, seemed a little nasty but that's probably because it was insanely busy. The owner/manager - I'm guessing - who was at the cash register was very nice and always had a smile of his face. We waited for our shake for about 15 minutes or so... there was a HUGE line of people waiting to get the shakes. Ours was topped with lemon, orange & strawberry cotton candy, chocolate donut, ice cream sandwich, blue raspberry & strawberry sour belts, chocolate ice cream cone, waffle sandwich with chocolate/peanut butter ice cream and a ring pop. It seems like a lot and yes, it is huge but if you take off all the candy - like we did - it's really not that much. It's mostly the sticks that they use to hold everything together. The shake itself was A LOT of shake - so you definitely get your money's worth. I loved that they gave you 2 spoons, wet naps, and a little bowls to put the candy into. This all really helps and is much needed! I should also mention that a year ago I tried the waffle with cannoli cream and that was just delicious. In my opinion, as much as this shake was great, the waffle with cannoli cream was better. I will definitely be back to try other items though. read more

The brownie waffle with cookie dough and ice cream is honestly just rediculously delicious and unique. That's what I go there for. If you wanna come get the crazy $20 shakes for the picture for your Instagram that's fine too cause they're really cool. But when your done with all that just do as I do, you won't be disappointed. They do have to figure out a way to be a little quicker though. read more

The ice cream is good but the woman behind the counter was a bit rude--didn't seem that friendly. $31 for a "Big Show" milkshake--cash only--thats basically a 32oz. milkshake w candy on top of it...umm...overpriced in my mind but she said 100s of people buy them..and it's CASH ONLY! I'm sorry but I find that price insane... the ice cream is REALLY good--try the Lemon Bar. But I just find some of it VERY overpriced. read more

Come on!!! No one thought of this yet?! ice cream sandwiched on top of a warm waffle just like a hot dog on a bun. I regret not taking a photo, I ate my cannoli waffle way too fast. I would absolutely go here again! I got cannoli filling inside my waffle and it was H-E-A-V-E-N read more

Very interesting. Not bad. Very different. Would recommend trying just not waiting in line for one.

Great ice cream, a little pricey but it's a must have for people that love ice cream.

Way over priced. Got a kid size portion and while it was tasty it was $3.75 for two tiny scoops that didn't even fill the kiddie cup. Both Day's ice cream places are closed for the season so I gave it a shot. 1/2 the portion of everyone else kiddy cup. Not impressed and not worth my time. read more

Besides blowing you out of the water do to the size and crazy stuff they put on it, it's made with quality stuff. The waffles are homemade and awesome and the ice cream is some of the best around. Some of the little novelty stuff they put on it is clearly just for show but it's worth it because of the other ingredients. The only downside is be prepared to wait because they take a long time to make and there is usually a big line. read more

We saw the crazy milkshakes on instagram and had to try it. There was no wait, the employees were friendly and quick. The milkshake and all the toppings were delicious and could probably feed 4 people. My only complaint is that it is an expensive dessert. Also cash only - luckily they have an ATM read more

Coney Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Went here on out last Beach day off this year, i got the monster m&m, totally underwhelmed. The rest of the party was satisfied, by i was disappointed. read more

what a rip off waited on line forever finally got to counter and put my order in for the vegan cherry vanilla the girl told me it was too hard and she couldnt give it to me but was happy to push the orange!! I didnt want orange. I settled for cookies and cream and it sucked, My daughter got a strawberry cone also vegan and we ordered a bottle of water. We went to pay and nobody came for 5 minutes and we should have just left. The girl finally came to me and she is adding up the 3 items and there were 2 extra $2 charges. I asked and she said the vegan ice cream is $2 extra. So my daughters cone was $7.85 + 2.00!!! wow never again read more