Just moved back to the area and trying a bunch of places in the Charlotte area. Won't be trying this one again - you would think that a place like this that's been around for 30+ years would be better - but flavor was bland, too much cheese (that tasted like it had been frozen) and actually threw away over half of it rather than save for leftovers. Customer service wasn't great either - owner acted like he was god's gift to pizza shop owners and was trashing customer calls while I was in the shop waiting for pickup. read more

3.5 if i could do halfsies fiancée & i usually just get wings n pizza from here which is above average. if u like crispy wings ask for them xtra crispy! small pizza is fairly large, the 2 of us cant finish it in one sitting also would not recommend the garbage plate... i guess theres a reason that ppl havent posted a pic of it on google reviews or yelp....... if u order from here make sure to check out their website bcos they always have coupons nd deals. they used to have a free order of fried dough for orders above $20 but that deal is $1 now its a small pizza place so not much room to sit & eat inside...maybe just one table with 2 chairs- idr we never eat there. conveniently, hermas is right nxt door & u can grab some drinks & a fresh crunchy green stalk of celery, yum read more

Cordello's Pizzeria - red hot garbage plate w everything on the side , 6pc garlic parm tranditional wings, small bacon ham mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

We like it. Everything is made to order. Service is friendly. We have never had a bad meal. Nice neighborhood establishment. Try it. You'll like it. read more

Probably some of the best "hot" buffalo wings in the city. The best prices on them as well. Their customer service is top notch. I once ordered from them and they brought me boneless wings instead of traditional Bone-In...I called to tell them the mix up..they came right back promptly with my original order..and let me keep the boneless..Folks THAT'S A THROWBACK TO WHEN CUSTOMER SERVICE MEANT SOMETHING. It was Superbowl Sunday as well...but it might as well have been christmas...and extra 50 wings! yeah boiiiiii The reason i gave this 4 stars instead of 5..Their "killer" wing sauce is pretty gross...Taste more like chili powder than wing sauce. Stay away. I am not a fan of their mild wings as well...Way too mild in my opinion, although my brother really enjoys them. But yeah..Those Hot Buffalo wings...On point. Their pizza is pretty good but i think where they really shine is the offerings on their "full menu" actually are really good.. Fish Fry- one of the best ive had. and they do it every night. G-plates- One of the better Plates ive had. I like that they offer potato salad. I can't vouch for the subs because it's been a while since i had one from here... All in all if you want really good tasting food that won't break the bank like that other local chain that delivers everything but babies...Try Cordello's read more

This is some of the best pizza in this area. I'm a regular here.. and that's okay! We ordered a medium pepperoni and meatball pizza which was awesome, and then two different kinds of wings country sweet and mild. (Bomb) Also their steak subs are very good, calzones, and even their regular subs. One of my favorite pizzas is the meat lovers. Never had one like it, I recommend it. Overall this is a great pizzeria in a nice little plaza. I love it. read more

See all

Pizza was pretty good and reasonably priced. Something was missing tho. A tastier sauce!

1st time customers, ordered a white pizza but none of us could even get through 1 slice because it was completely dry and tasted like cardboard. Waste of money! read more

Food has decreased in quality for the past few years ! And their customer service is nothing to brag about ! If I could I would give it 0 Stars ! read more

Great find in our new neighborhood. The service was great and the pizza was yummy. We will definitely be back again. read more

Cordello's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

My husband and I stopped here on our way out of town and ordered 2 large cold subs. They were both huge and had a LOT of meat in them. We seriously could have shared one! Good value and service was quick. Will stop again next time we're in the area! read more

Cordello's has the best pizza they have great service your food is always ready when you pick it up they are number 1 my whole family loves it if anyone asks where to get great pizza I tell them cordello's on Pattonwood dr read more

They are so consistent and the best pizza around! I'm from California and they were the "first" pizza place I tried in NY! I got a slice and it was amazing! I tried other pizza places people raves about but kept coming back here. Been a fan for about a year now since I've been a "New Yorker"! Other pizza places are greasy and floppy. I started to get my "California" pizza here and it's awesome! Pepperoni, pineapple and jalapeño, don't knock it till you try it! I used to hate pineapples on pizza but this combo is life changing! My husband loves their fish fry, it's gigantic and always perfect! read more

Cordello's Pizzeria - California style pizza, pepperoni/pineapple/jalapeño. Don't knock it till you try it! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Love the pizza and wings. Yum. Local delivery with no delivery up charge. Super friendly staff and delivery people. read more

Cordello's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Cordello's has good food, I'll give them that. What's lacking is customer service. I try not to order from here very often because 1) they charge you for using a card. (Really? In this day and age?) 2) the delivery people are not in the least pleasant and 3) my order has been wrong the last 3 times. 4) they charge you more than advertised pricI actually threw out half the last order and didn't bother calling because they won't do anything. Since there are so many others that have equally good or better food, I'll spend my $ elsewhere. read more

I went here yesterday during the dinner rush. They were very busy but I was taken care of right away and got my pizza pie in about 25 minutes or so. The girls were very friendly and the piazza was delicious. Thanks Cordello's for a good experience. read more

Was actually the worst pizza, I had ever ordered. Although it arrived hot, the toppings were not the best quality, skimpy portion and OVER priced for what you get. Very very disappointed. read more

Cordello's Pizzeria - Go somewhere else. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

I have been going to this restaurant for nearly 10 years. They have the best food. Ready and willing to make it your way. Portions are large and costs are fair..the customer service is outstanding..accidents happen but they go way beyond necessary if one occurs and in 10 years we could count on one hand how many times a small mix up happened and we were more then satisfied with response..I highly recommend this place. Thank you from my me and my family..Also they are very respectful of social distancing since I have cancer..it is appreciated more then they know. read more

They have amazing coustumer service and there food tastes great

Slowest service i ever had. The lady at the counter said 15 mins. And I ended up waiting a little over half an hour when I was the only one in the restaurant. The food was not worth the wait either. read more

Best subs and garbage plates in all of rochester, especially now that harbor hots is closed. Lots of deals.

Tried something new from this place was the cheeseburger wrap got everything in it. Was so amazing. The only thing was if you get tomatoes in it it will get soggy kinda fast. But other then that I will for sure order this again! read more

Finally. ..Great pizza & Great wings. I have now ordered from here 3 times over the last few months and each time the food was awesome! They have great sauce and the crust is perfect. They don't seem to skimp on toppings like some places and at the same time the quality of the toppings seems to be pretty good. The wings are the best I Have had in a long time. They are large in size with plenty of meat, fried until nice and crispy and then covered in your favorite sauce. Prices are very good as well. Large pepperoni pizza and 20 meaty wings runs you $24. Service has been very good each I have ordered. I have only done pick up so I can't comment on delivery times, but my order has always been ready when they said it would be. read more

i found a ROACH in my calzone box i called the store to tell them what i found and the worker put on the owner, how rude he is!! the owner acted as tho i was bothering him and could care less what i found! after dealing with the owner and his "i don't give a shit attitude" i opted to get refund and take my business elsewhere! i will suggest salvatore's on lake! read more

Been ordering wings here every Sunday for the past few weeks. They are always on time, extra extra crispy, with sauce on the side. Done just perfect! They come with BC and celery unlike other places we have ordered. We'll keep coming back! read more

Really good pizza and wings are also nice. They also have great coupon deals and deliver to Greece.

Not very pleased. Nothing special about this pizza Disappointed. Veggies were barely cooked Crust was non descript. Not much sauce. Always looking for a good pie. This was not it. read more

Cordello's is by far one of the best, if not the best, pizza joints in the Greece/Charlotte/Rochester area. You know when you walk into a pizza chain and people are in uniforms and your food is going through a warming conveyor belt and the wings look like they came off a sparrow instead of a chicken? Or when your calzone looks like it was defrosted after being shipped from China after having its toppings carefully weighed out and measured? Those places are awful. That's when you walk out and head to a pizza joint. A pizza joint is hot, sticky, and sweaty. The pizza chicks wear boxer shorts. And there is flour on every inch of the place. The pizza is fresh, the calzones are swoll, and you can pick the most random thing on the menu...and it will be the best thing you've had in months. That's a pizza joint. That's Cordello's Pizzeria. From the pizza, to subs, to wings, plates, or even the fried cauliflower...everything is top notch. An extensive menu for everyone! They are open late and deliver all over. And the area is better for them. Check them out! read more

I am always so satisfied with my food. It's always delicious, on time and hot. I highly recommend it here!!

I'm a busy guy that usually doesn't have the time to cook. Glad Cordello's is super close. I love the Eggplant parm, pasta dishes, and garbage plates. The meat hot sauce is great, and you have more than just the usual meats and sides to choose from on your plate. The wings are excellent as well as the pizza, I just don't order them as often. The staff is super cool, and nice and looks out for me being a regular and it's appreciated. Thanks guys. read more

Great pizza place for takeout. The pizza's crust is not too thick, not too thin, just right. They also have good wings, calzones (which are gigantic), and "trash" plates. (If you don't know what a trash plate is, you're probably not from Rochester.) There isn't very much room to sit down and eat, so it's really a takeout/delivery kind of place. read more

$9 delivery charge added on, really??? that's outrageous, and then i feel rude not tipping but why would i when i already paid 9 bucks just for u to bring it to me! I understand maybe i lived outside their delivery range but dont have commercials telling about how you deliver all over the Rochester area but forget to mention that it will cost you an extra 9 dollars. it took them and hour and 20 minutes to get it here and the pizza was only ok, i should have just stayed with Perri's Pizza their food is way better! read more

i've been to this location multiple times and every time I've had great service. I usually just get the lunch combo two slices and a bottled soda for seven dollars great deal, great pizza. read more

We have been ordering pizzas for a few years now from cordellows we get the sheet pizzas extra crispy and they are excellent they do a dynamite job I think it's one of the best pizzerias in the city this is the cordellows in Irondequoit read more

My go-to for delivery of garbage plates; the person on the phone is always nice, the delivery is always fast, and the food is generally consistent. It's rare to get customer service this good anywhere these days, and some of the drivers are so awesome to interact with. I've been ordering delivery from here at least once a week for 5+ years, and will continue to do so. Great job guys, please keep it up! read more

Cordello's was a great surprise... we were in a hurry and just wanted to grab a quick slice, and we discovered that their menu is ridiculously huge with great prices. Their portions are large. We ended up getting wings, the BLT pizza and a salad. all was really good and service was fast. check it out! read more

Pizza can vary from good to great, never got anything bad from them. Surprisingly their garbage plate is one of the best I ever had in the area, the hot sauce of full of meat and perfectly seasoned. read more

Uncle Ralph's sauce is phenomenal. Great food, always deliver on time. I've used them numerous times and have never had a bad experience.

Good selection, excellent wings. And fried cookie dough to finish it all off. Yum.

Never again. Terrible customer service. Had a coupon (which was theirs - taped to the pizza box from a previous order) with no expiration date and they refused to honor it. Spoke to the manager and asked if losing a long time customer was worth the $5 of the coupon. Evidently it was because they didn't care. I don't care either. There are many other pizza places around town. I'll support someone who appreciates the business. read more

First order with them tonight. Small cheese pizza, 6 garlic-parm wings and another small pizza with x-tra cheese and pepperoni. Got the owner when I called, told him I was a new customer. He gave me a new customer discount! The wings were fringin' assume! Crispy and bathed in a ton of sauce! The 2 pizza's were full of cheese and cooked to perfection! Might be my new go to place! read more