Having heard really good things about this place, I was excited to finally get to experience it. I loved the atmosphere and had a great time at the bar while waiting for the rest of our party to arrive. The bartender and drinks were amazing, and the bacon appetizer was incredible! We enjoyed the Pearberry which was light and delicious, as well as the Japanese Old Fashioned which my partner thoroughly enjoyed. Although the price for bacon seemed hefty, it's almost a slab instead of slice of bacon. It's a solid portion and very thick and deliciously coated in a sticky sweet sauce that we enjoyed. We were having a great time and were in great spirits but it took a turn once we were seated for the dining portion of the experience.. I think our experience came from the person manning the meats, who in our opinion doesn't know proper temp checks. We ordered multiple filets, ribeyes, and a tomahawk at our table of 5 and every single one was under. We asked for medium and medium rare throughout our table, but they all arrived severely underdone. The tomahawk was the biggest disappointment, when you pay a hefty price, you expect better results.. but it was raw, because rare doesn't even really describe it. We are not the type to make a fuss, so we just ate our steaks and asked for sauce to make them palatable. The flavor was there but it was very subtle, it could used a bit more seasoning. We relied heavily on the sides and our prior experience at the bar to keep spirits up. The reason this review isn't worse is because regardless of our dining experience, our bar experience was superior and I'd go back strictly for that. I would try it again to see if the cook has gotten better but not for a while. read more

Wow!!! This place absolutely blows so many steak houses out of the water!!! This is now my top 3 best steak places I've ever had! Not only is the steak amazing but the sides are outstanding as well. It's hard to find both good meats and great sides, however Cotton Calf over delivered on both. I was sad when I took my last bite, that's how good and flavorful everything was. Mannnnnnn Ordered the Cajun ribeye medium and sliced!! Mushroom risotto was incredible and the roasted broccoli! My goodness what a meal. The Cajun Ribeye should go in the hall of fame! read more

Cotton Calf Kitchen - Cajun Ribeye Sliced - New American Near Me - Braselton, Georgia

We loved the historic brick look and the overall vibe -- it's a beautiful space with great energy. We ended up at a high‑top in the bar area since we made reservations late, and the table was definitely small, but our waitress was wonderful and explained everything really well. My husband enjoyed his steak (Kansas City style), and I had the Wagyu, which was my favorite part of the meal. The fries were just okay -- nothing special, pretty average. The bakery items were delicious, but the cake wasn't homemade, which was disappointing. My husband liked the bread pudding. We didn't order cocktails or wine, just water. For the price, the overall experience didn't fully meet expectations. After reading other reviews, I see we're not the only ones who feel the taste and experience don't quite match the higher price point, so I stand by my review. There are other steakhouses in Buford and the surrounding area where you can get a great steak, apps, and dessert without spending as much. All in all, it was a decent experience, and I'd try it again in the main dining area for a more elevated feel -- but we're not rushing back. read more

See all

Came here with a group of 11 ladies and we were seated at a table in the bar. We were celebrating a birthday. The waitress was good dealing with 11 older ladies. Well the food, I was her 4/5 times in the last 4 years. They were very inconsistent and that sucks if you can't depend on what you're getting. The food took a bit but the food was better than I had remembered. Service was understandable, it was very crowded. read more

See all

My first time dining here for a work dinner and presentation. This is such a hidden upscale gem in downtown Braselton. The decor was very nice. We had a private event fixed menu with filet , salmon, and chicken options. The steak was perfectly cooked along with the salmon that I had a taste of. Our servers were excellent in timing of our food. All the appetizers were tasty and the drinks as well. There are 2 private event dining areas. We had the front of the house area which was perfect for up to 30 people. I would definitely return on my own and recommend to give this a try if you want to get a way from the hustle and bustle. Packed house so make a reservation. read more

See all

This is an amazinggg restaurant! The ambiance is amazing. Perfect for date night or a special occasion. Our server also gave us a detailed overview of the menu which was helpful since it was our first time. The drink menu is expansive. We split the Delmonico and it was wonderful. We had oysters, southwestern creamed corn and the truffle fries. We did not have a single bad dish. This is the kind of restaurant that makes you keep coming back because you want to try everything! read more

Cotton Calf Kitchen - New American Near Me - Braselton, Georgia

Terrible experience. Terrible over Priced food. Don't waist your money. Burnt bacon on over cooked Scallops.watery side dishes and over cooked steak. Just a horrible experience. read more

Friends of ours have raved about Cotton Calf, so we decided to check it out for my husband's birthday. I'm glad we did. What made this visit stand out for us was the service. It was exemplary! A special shout out to Lauren for making our experience top notch. My husband and I split the Cajun ribeye, which came highly recommended. Delicious!!! We also had the mashed potatoes and lobster mac n cheese. We finished the evening with a complimentary birthday pastry. 10 out of 10 experience! read more

The ambiance at the Cotton Calf is very sleek , modern and beautiful. With the kitchen being centered right in the middle surrounded by glass for onlookers to see all the action!! Very cool!! Service was par and solid and on point. The food was highly recommended to us by neighbors and friends, it is the best known restaurant on the high end$$$ in downtown located in Hoschton GA. The Filet mignon steak was full of flavor and delightful! As well as the "twice baked" sweet potato which was covered in cinnamon,butter and bacon. Mmmmm The asparagus was a little bit on the mushy side, but definitely had good flavor and the lamb chops looked and seemed to be absolutely elegant and delicious but slightly charred a bit too much for our taste. That seems to be the theme of this restaurant with the little extra char and love that is put into their cooking . I would recommend trying this place if you're in the area and looking for a special event and or special night out with your loved one. Highly recommend making reservations as walk-ins are very slim . Enjoy read more

See all

This place is wildly expensive but the food is definitely worth it. Everything I've ever had there was incredible. The Cajun Ribeye was the best steak I've ever had. The gumbo is amazing too. It's also the only truly elevated dining experience in the area. You really feel like you're having dinner in a Michelin Guide restaurant. Everyone working there is extremely kind and competent, which is a breath of fresh air in recent years. Best restaurant around and it's not close! read more

Perfect spot for a special occasion or celebration. Came here for a birthday dinner and it exceeded all my expectations. The filet was wonderfully seasoned and cooked to perfection. The side dishes and drinks were excellent. As you would expect, the service was top tier and perfect for a special occasion. We had dessert given the occasion, which is rare for us, and it was out of this world. The ambiance in the restaurant is relaxing and very conducive for a nice night out with friends or for a date. The prices do match the high quality of the food and the experience, but it's certainly worth it if you're prepared and have proper expectations. read more

See all

My daughter and I went with friends before a concert last Friday night. We split one burger for $36!!! and got the chopped salad to share as well. I ordered one cocktail. $99 before tip! The burger was very dry even though I asked for medium. It had 2 thick pieces of bacon that were so fatty that we had to remove. The chopped salad was so chopped that it looked like coleslaw and that was $22! I will never go back. We tried Brussel sprouts that our friends ordered and they were terrible. The calamari another friend ordered was ok. Their steak prices are outrageous. My hubby and I ate at nacoochee grill in Helen last night and I had one of the best filets I've ever had for $42 with 2 sides. Salad for 2 was $11. CC charges $62 for same 8 oz filet and all sides are al a carte and very expensive. Totally not worth the hype and food was a big disappointment! read more

Every year's wedding anniversary has a 'theme'; year two is Cotton. So, my punny husband made reservations for us at the Cotton Calf Kitchen for our cotton anniversary. It was incredible. Nicole is very friendly and knowledgeable, it's obvious she takes great pride in her work and making sure every guest has a great experience. We had the oysters Rockefeller for an appetizer. They were the perfect temperature and the ingredients were balanced perfectly (garlic, cheese, spinach, and prosciutto complemented each other splendidly). For main courses, my husband had the Wagyu hanger steak and I had the lamb rack. Both were just *chef's kiss*. The lamb in particular was amazing. Perfectly cooked, and the sauce was just heavenly. My husband even dipped a few pieces of his steak in it! I will say (and this is a nit pick only because of how pricey it is and I know many of us are careful with our budgets), if you're deciding between the steak or another main (like lamb or sea bass, etc) and you prefer a more medium or under steak I'd advise going with the lamb or seafood. We've been here before (and had the filet and ribeye, in addition to the hanger this time) and the steaks both times had a few places where the outside was charred beyond chewable (and the steak was medium rare). Again, that is just a nit pick because of the price of the steak. Because it was our anniversary, a complimentary crème brûlée cheesecake was brought out to us with "happy anniversary" written on it. A very sweet and nice touch. We'll definitely be back! Thank you for a great wedding anniversary read more

See all

Facebook recommendations are correct - this is the place for a wonderful meal. Great Service (Servers are very well trained and confident, friendly) Fun atmosphere, tasty cocktails & sharp decor. We had both steak and seafood and both were excellent - sides were very well done with the right time and flavors. They brought me a complimentary birthday dessert and it was a scrumptious chocolate mousse cake - just the right small size after that meal. Portions are very generous. Make Reservations - great for couples or special occasions. I would not take kids there but one family we were seated next to did. Their one child was very well behaved with some screen help. read more

This is supposedly a $$$$ restaurant in the small town of Braselton Ga, that has no competitors. I have been coming here since they opened! They have been experiencing growing pains and they lack the $$$$ service that is expected by patrons! They seem to be overly busy in the kitchen which is fun to watch them say "ok chef"every second, but leads to mediocre plates! This place has grown to existence because there's nothing else to compare in this simple town. They closed their patio service for some reason which was once a great place to have dinner outside! Prices here have escalated but the atmosphere hasn't! Somebody needs to make some changes! It's a big time restaurant in a small town community that needs reviving! read more

This has got to be one of the best steaks that I have had. The waitress was great and very attentive.

Another outstanding dinner. From the shrimp cocktail to the espresso martini, everything was spot on, the steak was cooked to perfection, and the service was top notch. Cotton Calf delivers excellence every time. read more

Great steak delicious salad and bread. Good coffee but they couldn't keep my cup filled.

I am a regular at Cotton Calf. I bring family, friends, and business colleagues to dine there. Great menu, some of the best steak you'll find anywhere, and a friend/knowledgeable staff. Enjoyable all 'round! read more

Ugh, I had been wanting to check this out for years. I really wanted to like it. Hubby and I decided to try it out for our anniversary dinner. Ambiance...lovely. Seating in some areas is a wee bit tight but overall I liked the vibe. I loved the open kitchen you could see into and there were a few booth seats right in front of the expo area. Service...great. Server was really nice. Manager stopped by to see how our meal was. Our leftovers were boxed properly and everything was timely. Food...ehh. It just wasn't great! Honestly wasn't even that good at all. It lacked flavor and for the price point...I mean c'mon. We ordered the Delmonico ribeye and the Cajun ribeye. Split a chopped salad and also got the brussel sprouts. I didn't finish any of it...and even though I got my leftovers boxed to go...I never ate it. It's sad but honestly I would have preferred a steak from Longhorn My hubby did eat all of his steak, but he doesn't believe in things going to waste. He said it was an average steak, but he did really enjoy the brussel sprouts. Perhaps I'd give it another go. But not if I was footing the bill. I won't make that mistake again. read more

See all

First off we'd like to say service from the beginning was great! Attentive waitress by the name of Cheyenne! She deserves all the praise. Not even a few minutes sitting down and settling we've ordered drinks and it came out with some bread in less than 10 mins maybe even 5 mins honestly. (That's how quick it was) She gave us all the awesome update and run down of some of the menu items. We ended up ordering raw blue point oysters for a light appetizer -10/10 so clean and tasty! We also got the Chilean sea bass, which was flaky and so buttery that's a 10/10 in our books. Del Marco dry aged steak 16oz, fantastic and perfectly cooked (medium). Well seasoned and natural flavor of the beef. Our sides were prosciutto green beans & asparagus- both 10/10, cooked perfectly and delicious! We had reservation for the lounge side and it was just right with great ambiance! We'll be back! read more

See all

Expensive but sooooooo good. I've had a few different dishes every time I've gone and all were delicious. Highly recommend. If I lived closer I would go more often. Service is impeccable as well. read more

The food is just ok, nothing special but the price. Nice atmosphere and service. Right in downtown.

Outstanding! One of my favorite "white tablecloth" restaurants. The food is amazing, steaks come to hot vs warm. Favorite appetizer is oysters Rockefeller. Even though the oysters can't be local, they're good. (I retired form the seafood business after 30 years, I know seafood) The service is top notch, never had to look for our waitperson. Ambiance is very nice, I'd say dress is relaxed business casual, shirt should have a collar. A bit heavy on the budget side, but I'm a believer that you get what you pay for. In today's world that wouldn't apply to everything though, like fast food drive through! Bottom line, if you're looking for a very nice place for a special dining, I highly recommend Cotton Calf!!! read more

AMAZING!!!! The food is amazing, the smells, the flavor EXCELLENT! The service Cheyenne so attentive and Nicole -- you already know!! The atmosphere is intimate! I highly recommend the lemon drop! I shall return!!! read more

***FOOD: fresh & overall tasty food but some things were burnt. SEAFOOD TOWER - very good with jumbo jumbo (yeah double jumbo) shrimp & blue pt oysters & a little lobster; GUMBO - very very good and beautifully presented; SIRLION STEAK - good, was a little undercooked for medium; KANSAS CITY STEAK - very good cooked perfectly; SHRIMP MAC N CHEESE - gooey rich 3 cheeses but didn't seem to have a lot of shrimp; SCALLOPS - bacon wrapped around scallops was so burnt. ASPARAGUS sides - good; LAVA CAKE - didn't really ooze with chocolate; KEY LIME PIE- love ***COST (OUT OF 4$) $$$$ it's expensive; $70 alone for the seafood tower & gumbo was $24 so you have an idea. ***DÉCOR: Dark mysterious and relaxed comfortable. Great for date night or to celebrate a milestone. Special occasion dining for sure ***SERVICE: our server seemed really nervous. Otherwise they were attentive. Filled our waters, our wine came right in time for the main. The manager stopped by a couple of times and asked us how our meal was which is nice but he never really made eye contact when he asked. Minor but it sort of indicates interest or sincerity. Service was perfunctory. Lots of parking in the back. Very popular place so it was crowded. ***RECOMMEND: YES RECOMMEND and will probably go back for special occasions. read more

See all

OMG! where do I start?! This place is amazing. A very tucked away secret hide away! Our Server, Lauren, was the Absolute BEST! We made a reservation for my boyfriend's birthday and so glad we did. Reservations for 8:00p and got a text 30 mins early that our table was ready. Cool. It was only a 10 min drive. Arrived the venue is breathtakingly Beautiful. Didn't even know this place existed but it was so welcoming. the two young ladies at the door greeted us as we entered and sat us immediately. Our server was such a delight, she knew the menu front and back and even gave us some great suggestions. We started with Moscow Mules to drink and Fries Green Tomatoes for appetizers, which were both on point. We were then introduced to a medley of bread with a compound house made butter that was so good and blended so well that we tried it on the steak and OMG! It changed the game. Lauren also brought out the regular butter.. I wasn't quite sold on the corn so Lauren suggested we 'taste test' the corn so she brought it out, YESsSsS!! So I ordered the filet mignon Med Well and he ordered the lamb chops Med while we shared the creamed spinach, creamed corn and potatoes.. Everything tasted like Perfection. I can't describe in words how good each bite was. The food, service and overall experience was Amazing. Lauren went above and beyond on Customer Service and made our dinner a Joy. This restaurant was a unique great surprise and hidden gem. I told our server that it was his birthday in a message during dinner and she brought out a cheesecake slice with a candle! What a way to Top the Night! After dessert, we both ordered a coffee with side of Bailey's.. an after dinner treat if you will.. The coffee didn't disappoint, was hot, fresh and delicious! A Perfect Ending to a Grand Dinner.. So glad we decided to stop in this place. it was such a delight! Will definitely be back for Round 2! read more

See all

True, fine dining steakhouse with top-tier food, drinks, and service. We love Cotton Calf! This is fine dining, so expect to pay top dollar, but it is worth every dime. The steaks are buttery, and cooked to your liking. The sides are delicious! Ask about the Truffle fries with bacon butter ketchup. OMG. Or the charred roasted garlic broccoli. Who knew broccoli could be a star at the table! Finally, the deserts are not your basic steakhouse deserts. The bread pudding alone deserves an award. We're super lucky this is in our neighborhood but either way, make the reservation and just go! The ambiance is beautiful and you can have a romantic dinner, business meeting or solo date. read more

See all

Perfect evening. We go here every year for our family birthday celebration! The atmosphere is beautifully lit and so elegant. The food is always on point. I have never ordered anything that isn't amazing. Tonight we got the 12oz filet, Salmon, and Garlic butter chicken. Our sides were ala carte. Mashed potatoes, creamy Brussel sprouts, cream spinach, root vegetables, truffle fries. And of course the rolls with herb butter that's so amazing. The waitress was so attentive and the kitchen was quick with our food and perfectly timed. To celebrate the birthdays we got the complimentary raspberry cheese cake with the cutest little candle on the side. It was a perfect birthday celebration read more

See all

Was a wonderful experience just a lot pricey for the menu. But would recommend and definitely go back again

5 Stars! Sat at the bar and had a great experience- per usual. My husband went full caveman with a bourbon, the tomahawk and sides, while I had the Wagyu burger-which was chef's kiss* excellent. The fried green tomatoes? Absolutely amazing too. The pretzel app wasn't my favorite, but if you're feeding a group, it's a solid choice. Great service, great food, and it's nice to fine dining so close to home. I've been coming here for years for a drink and appetizer and the occasional dinner, and it never disappoints. We'll be back! read more

See all

The ambiance of this place is elegant! The open space with the kitchen view is beautiful! For our appetizer, we chose the crab and artichoke served with pita. It was absolutely delicious! We also got the CCK salad! Wow! Super duper delicious! It's definitely shareable. We got the Wagyu and the Wild Alaskan Salmon. It's definitely the perfect portion! The service is super amazing! We will definitely be coming back soon! read more

See all

Easily a top 5 Steakhouse outside of Atlanta. North Gwinnett and Hall counties have 2 outstanding steakhouses being Bare Bones and Cotton Calf, and I have to say Cotton Calf is an extremely competitive choice. Having sampled their charcuterie, crème of corn, and filet, I can easily say Cotton Calf has its bearings straight. The filet was almost perfectly prepared and melted in the mouth. Its smoked accents added wonderful flavors to its core. The restaurant is gorgeous located in downtown Braselton. A great place to come for special occasions! read more

Cotton Calf Kitchen - Charcuterie - New American Near Me - Braselton, Georgia

See all

Had dinner here 15 years ago and have thought about the steak for years. Went back a couple weeks ago after moving here and was not disappointed. Had the charcuterie board and it was huge to start took half of it home. Ordered the filet which was fantastic. Great selection of wine. Nice for a special occasion. read more

The food was absolutely delicious. From the cocktails, to the appetizers, to the entrees, to the dessert...everything was impeccable. Our server Mary Katherine was so kind, knowledgeable, and made great recommendations. We did not feel rushed at all. We will definitely be back! It had an intimate atmosphere and exceeded every expectation! read more

Update: My daughter suggested we give it another try, and this time the crab cake was actually pretty good--maybe it's under new management. One of the co-owners was there, and he was warm and friendly. The kitchen even made an effort to accommodate us and came up with some tonic close when we asked for coleslaw to go with the crab cake, which we're used to having since we're from Maryland and Washington, D.C. read more

Great food, always accommodating regarding party size/seating. I prefer to eat at the bar and typically just do appetizers or split a burger with my wife while we enjoy the amazing cocktails. High-end restaurant that caters to anyone....casual attire is never a problem which is why I like this place. It's expensive but meets expectations with the quality, atmosphere, and service provided. read more

Cotton calf is so amazing!!! I def recommend! The waiters are so kind, don't even get me started on how good and flavorful the steak is! This is the best restaurant ever! I recommend! read more

Spent a delightful evening celebrating 29yr anniversary. Everything was delicious and business was decorated for holidays. Highly recommend this place for a special evening. read more

See all

This restaurant was amazing! We went out for a nice dinner and they did not disappoint. They started us off with the three varieties of bread with in-house butter mixed with some herbs and it was so so so delicious. We then got the ahi tuna poke with these super crispy chips and it was so well-seasoned. I'm usually not a fan of ahi tuna, but I really enjoyed it from here. We got some truffle fries, brussel sprouts, and crab cakes for the other appetizers and they were all delicious. Finally we got the A5 wagyu 16oz steak and it was probably the best steak I've ever had in my life. It melts just like butter in your mouth and yeah it was just amazing. Service was super nice and really enjoyed my meal here! read more

See all