It was my first time here. What a great place! I got the chicken, Parm wedge, a grilled chicken,…read moremozzarella cheese and roasted red pepper wedge and some fried chicken. All the food was outstanding! Everyone there is so super nice and really fast and efficient. I love the guy behind the counter who jokes around with all the customers. He is hilarious! I brought the sandwiches home and everyone raved about them. I especially love the basil sauce that was on the chicken sandwich. I will Definitely be back soon!

Deli is great, and their chili is amazing. I always get compliments when I use it to make a dip…read more But lately there are lots of tomato chunks in it and would love to see it go back to just chili.

food: 50/50 service: 25/25…read more ambience: 25/25 total: 100/100 Stopped at Paulies Deli because 1. my husbands name 2. Deli in NY is always a yes. Food was delish, I ordered a BEC on a roll and was veryyyyyy happy with it. Paul got a philly cheese steak but regrets not ordering the chopped cheese. We met Paulie and he was quite nice. Overall service great. Ambience on point, standard deli aesthetics and it was very clean. Bathroom very clean! Overall would absolutely return to this establishment :)

Originally, this place wasn't on my map. However, it quickly came into consideration once I had…read moreconsidered taking the train from Katonah instead of driving all the way to Long Island from Waterbury, CT and looked at Katonah's parking situations. As you can tell by the existence of this review, I had decided to get to Bellmore I would park in the parking lot next to this business until I got back. This place does kind of give me a Rocky Balboa vibe upon entering, which isn't a bad thing at all. Some of the names of the menu items are even inspired from the movies such as The Balboa and The Italian Stallion. Beyond that, this place does take a little learning, but ordering is pretty simple once you know what you're doing. You don't pay for the order until you get your food, and you pay right by the front door. This is something I could see going awry if the wrong kind of people were to come here and requires an amount of trust in the customers that can make some nervous people uncomfortable. Really though, beyond that the service here is really good. I did have to remind the cashier to get my bill right when it was my turn to pay, so there is also that to consider. I did The Spartan Stack and some Mac and cheese bites because when I was returning to Katonah, I NEEDED something to eat right there and then. The Spartan Stack let me tell you got the spot just right, and I did appreciate some healthier ingredients such as cucumber in there. The Mac and cheese bites are a newer item as was The Spartan Stack, and those were pretty tasty. You get a chipotle sauce to dip them in, and let me just say that it does actually pack a punch of heat! All in all, a really satisfying lunch and I'm glad I came here. It's actually a great spot if you're commuting from the Katonah Station and it's very convenient. A good place indeed.

Great chicken cutlet sandwich really tasty and fresh! I got a number 1 Staff were friendly. Just a…read moreheads up: the website still shows an old price ($11), but in-store it's actually $13 plus tax on a roll , so make sure to check before ordering. Overall, solid food and service, just a bit of a pricing confusion and i wish they would've honored the $11 listed price as it was on the website even though it's not much, it's just the principal.

Had nothing in my house for lunch. My choices were limited. I could have gone food shopping and…read morethen made lunch or just bite the bullet and buy something. Since A&S is close I went in. I usually buy my mozzarella and dry sweet sausage from there but this time it was time for a sandwich. They have a list of about 20 different sandwiches. While standing on line it seemed everyone was ordering one particular sandwich Chicken cutlet, Pepper Colby jack cheese Bacon, lettuce , tomato, & chipotle mayo. Yeah a heart attack waiting to happen! So I figured why not try it. Yeah it was worth it! The sandwich was available on a roll or wedge. I smartly went for the roll it was huge! Now I know why everyone was ordering it.

For the Italian combo. Portion was good, cold cuts were fresh. Service is ok. Honestly, felt like a…read morenice bodega in the burbs. The exterior is nice. Place had a koi pond and table. For context, 2 heros and 1 roll was $30

Been going here for years. It's a great sandwich, shop and BECs. Posting a menu to help anybody…read morethat's curious.

This deli os spacious and has tables for people to sit and eat at. I did not see any outdoor tables…read morebut maybe there are in the warmer months? Not sure. I am never in this area and was hungry so we came here. I was actually shocked at how tasty the bagel I got was. I got a sesame toasted bagel with scallion cream cheese. The bagel was very fluffy, doughy which I like and the scallion cream cheese was good. I was shocked since I know NYC is known for their bagels and this place is not in NYC. I will be keeping this deli in mind for the next time I am in the area. The staff is also very nice and this deli looks to be clean. They also have deli meats, sandwiches and more.

Nice neighborhood deli with tasty sandwiches. I had the DJ, hubby had one with roast beef, smoked…read morecheese and both were great. Two warnings: 1) there are only a couple of street parking spaces that aren't 15 minutes M-Sat and there are threats of towing if you part in the very large and mostly empty lot behind the deli. 2) The bathroom door doesn't lock. Station a guard outside it if you don't want company. We would stop by again driving through the area (if it's a Sunday and we can find parking).

Always a great place for deli sandwiches and much much more. Super nice and place is clean as…read morealways. Owners are great. This place is a must!

Amicis has really good sandwiches from breakfast to lunch, the food is always fresh. The staff is…read morefriendly and the place is clean. They are also good if you're having a party with their catering menu. I highly recommend this place.

Classic Italian deli, a destined institution with such fresh mozzarella, breads, and the kindest…read moreItalian folks working the counter. Reminds me of my years in Staten Island. Delicious cheddar-roast beef sandwich, summer corn salad, and homemade banana breads of all kinds. Lots of Italian goodies like pastas and candies and drinks. Outdoor seating for a warm day. 5 stars!!!!

Solid offerings, from hot to frozen. The staff is always ready to help. The store is clean and well…read moreorganized. The chicken parm and eggplant parm were on point. Heard about it from a local doctor who provides turkey sandwiches from here for her patients after minor procedures (minor procedures are those that happen to others, by the way). The banana bread with multiple types of chocolate chips is top notch. The frozen stuffed breads are well made. From salads to a large variety of sandwiches to the hot options to the dry goods, oils, pastas and beyond. This is the place for it all. Well done!

I have a very yummy sandwich spread for lunch because of these people! The woman at the counter was…read morefriendly and even offered a tip for my family! Thanks to her - my kids had a "fun" hike and whining was at a minimum :) My fav sandwich was the Italian sandwich with red peppers! Don't forgot the sweet red peppers! The apple and brie sandwich was good as well But my kids weren't a family. They did make a good hand and cheese sandwich for my son! I recommend this place for sure !! And many do catering which I totally understand!!

The food is delicious -and the service is amazing! We cater luncheons from them frequently and…read morehave never been disappointed!