So overall pizza is very good but the prices are insane $3 for a topping is crazy. Still would recommend

Location and being the only pizza place on the square are really the only pros to this place. The pizza is fine but it's not worth the price. If they had more topping options with a nicer eating area I could see the price being over $25 per pizza. It just doesn't match up. read more

Amazing pizza!!!!! Crust, sauce and toppings are all delicious. Everything I have ordered from here has been excellent

Drove up from Columbus to meet some family "halfway" to hit some antique stores. Stopped here and will definitely be back. Great staff. Very clean. But, most importantly, a great pizza. Very good quality crust, sauce was the perfect spice and the topping were generous and delicious. Thank you for keeping it simple. A great quality pizza at a fair price. read more

This is now my 2nd favorite Pizza place in Medina. If they sold Taco Pizza it would be #1. The staff is very friendly. The food is fast and hot. And it is great for thin pizza. Prices are great, wheelchair friendly. Plus it has a view of Medina Square. Beautiful year round. Wish I could score more than 5 stars. read more

Stopped by with my wife and kids and got 3 slices. Pleasantly surprised to find out how large the slices actually were! Definitely get your bang for your buck(s). Traditional thin crust NY style. Will definitely be back again when I'm in the area. read more

I've always had a good experience with Courthouse. We have done both dine in and carry out. The Pizza is good and the slices are large. They do get busy and with that comes longer wait times, but no more then any other business. read more

Food is great but don't appreciate when I call to ask what the daily special is they tell me it can be breadsticks or cheese sticks but when I call back a half hour later they want to charge $4 more for the cheese. Might want to ask for the manager if you need to know their specials. read more

I am giving Courthouse Pizza three stars but they should get 3 1/2 - they are not 4...yet! I have read the older reviews and some of the complaints have been changed/fixed. They now have metal silverware, the pizzas are 18" now (not 16") and they will give you a New York slice (you need to fold it) or they will cut it in half so you can hold it....ummmm...Ohio style? The restaurant is clean and is has a well designed interior. I do wish they had better quality napkins and tables/chairs with more style. It is a thin crust pizza and if you don't like that you won't like their pizza. I like thick, thin, Chicago, hot, cold, round, square...wait sorry got lost dreaming of pizza...well any type of pizza. As you can see in the pictures they give a generous amount of toppings and the staff was friendly. It is hard to find a good local, eat-in pizza place (sorry no yellow/orange plastic franchise McPizza for me - I hope McBurger doesn't try pizza next). I will be back and I hope Courthouse continues to improve...give them a try when in Medina. read more

This review is for a NY style pizza in a traditional pizzeria. If you are expecting deep dish, or what we consider traditional pizza, that isn't what is served here. I do usually prefer a traditional style pizza, but when I'm looking for NY style, this place is it! Great staff, great location, and a stonebaked pie that tastes great! Do yourself a favor and order some cheesy bread to go with it. You won't regret it! read more

I really like Courthouse Pizza, costs a little more than some of the other locals but it is worth it. I only have one comment, every time we get pepperoni we have to be careful not to choke on the outer skin. Don't know if it is supposed to be removed before it goes on the pizza but I would change suppliers or make an effort to get rid of this problem. Other than that 5/5 stars, I just hate to stop eating to spit out the skins, in fact I am eating reheated Courthouse Pizza as I write this review. read more

Get out and support a small business in our community! Courthouse is welcoming and friendly and the pizza is better than NYC!

We ordered a pizza and my husband ordered a chicken parm sub. The sub was a crusty bun with two pieces of frozen type chicken you get from GFS, cheese and a little bit of sauce. My guess is the green pieces on the sub is lettuce? The pizza was just OK , a bit soggy because it's so thin. Nothing special here. We won't be back. read more

Courthouse Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Medina, Ohio

Great pizza. They made a one with all our special requests for food alergys. Came out perfect. Service is spot on. Definatly will come back

This certainly is not my top choice when the intense craving for delicious pizza hits. This may have to do with the fact that in not really a fan of New York style pizza. Ive been here more than a few times since they opened last year and while the inner workings of the establishment have improved over time (organization on the front end in terms of lines and congested dining area merging with line to order) I feel like the pizza hasn't really changed much. Without fail, every time we order pizza here I end up blotting it with an entire stack of napkins to get the pools of grease off the slice, and I certainly wouldn't say that it's even "great" pizza. In reality it simply does the job when it's one of the fastest options for food while on Medina Square. I will say that the staff are usually very friendly but some of the younger employees could definitely use some work in area of smiling when greeting customers throughout the ordering/pick up process. On the plus side, they have bathrooms and you can order by the slice (1/4 of a pizza) if you don't want to deal with ordering an entire pie. Also, they have (had) a buy 10 slices get the 11th slice free but it only applies to purchasing single slices not whole pizza pies (4 slices in a pie). read more

Good (but not great) pizza. Just got a slice. Used to be $5 for 1/4 of a large, now its $4 for 1/6. Let's do some math by the slice: old pricing was a little high 1/4 x 4 =$20 for a large cheese, new pricing is 1/6 x 6 = $24. That's rather rarefied air...good pizza, poor value read more

I wanted to update my review. Because after a year or two it seems like these guys have really figured out what it is that makes them unique. The pizza itself seems to have gotten better. And they have figured out how to make their New York style pizza without having an undercooked crust. Also if you just ask for a crispy that helps a lot too. Not to mention their cheesy bread is absolutely amazing. The online ordering and service is also running very smoothly. They have really come a long way and it is great to have a gourmet pizza place in Medina. read more

Thin crust NY style slices large enough to fold. Pizza was great, but canned mushrooms made me only give 4 stars

INCREDIBLY POOR SERVICE. We ordered a pizza for delivery and were contacted about 10 minutes later to let us know that they could not deliver the pizza because their delivery driver called off work. I work in the food industry and a staffing issue should never effect the customer. This is the second time this has happened with Courthouse Pizzeria and they offer no sort of service recovery. read more

The pizza here is pretty good. When you order breadsticks, you get a ton! They have a lunch combo deal which is decently priced. Other prices are decent as well. It's a good place to meet friends for lunch. Will be back! read more

Courthouse Pizzeria occupies the old Whitey's Army Navy store, and patrons will be surprised at how different the inside looks. The space is wide and open, and there's plenty of shared seating available; just be aware that as it's shared, you may likely have to share a space with others if it's busy. The menu is somewhat simple, as they only have either pizza slices or a full 18" pizza. They also have sub sandwiches on their menu, as well as things like cheesy bread and side salads. They don't offer much in terms of "specialty" pies, they had 3 to choose from, but unfortunately they don't list the descriptions on the large chalkboard menu near the register. The pricing is pretty straightforward as well, you can get a plain slice of pizza for $4 and an 18" pizza for $16. Toppings are extra ($2 for regular, $3 for specialty toppings for the large pizzas). If you stop in on Mondays, you'll be happy to find this price is greatly reduced, and you can purchase any one-topping pizza for just $10. If you choose to get more than one-topping during this special, you'll just pay full price for the topping, but you'll still get the discount price for the 18" pizza. I found the service here to be pretty good, we were greeted immediately when we entered, and the staff was very friendly when cashing us out. The fast-casual style allows you to grab a seat wherever and help yourself to the soda fountain while you wait for your pizza to be prepared; it doesn't take long as it's a rather thin crust. My biggest gripe about the space itself is that the whole place has that burnt-pizza Chuck-E-Cheese smell to it, which I personally find really revolting. The pizza itself is nothing special to me personally;some will really enjoy how thin the crust is, but for me it was so thin that it turned into a floppy, sloppy mess. it doesn't have that wood-fire oven taste to it either. My boyfriend loved how generous they were with the toppings, and I agree, they definitely didn't skimp in this area- but again, the thin crust isn't really conducive to holding up so much topping. The cheese and sauce were completely ordinary to me. I feel like if I had payed full price, I may have been a bit disappointed, but I do know there are those that really enjoy this kind of pizza. I think it's worth a try if you enjoy thin crust pizza, but definitely not worth a long drive from out of town just to try it. read more

My husband and I stopped in for lunch and ordered two slices of pizza and also a calzone. Clean restaurant and friendly staff. The food was absolutely delicious! We will definitely be back for more. read more

This place is da bomb! I always root for the family biz who pours their heart and soul into it...it shows for sure, keep up the good work!!

We love this place. HUGE slices, reasonable prices and as authentic as NYC. Try it, you won't be disappointed.

Love this place. Clean, friendly kids work here, fresh hot New York style folding slice. My husband I are trying to work our way through the toppings menu one slice at a time. I love the fact that the kids that work here are always moving! You never see anyone leaving and waiting. They are cleaning or baking. Nice place shop local read more

First and foremost the owner is rude, moody and yells under his breath to his staff. Over the summer there was a fly infestation, constantly swatting flies as I eat it not ok. The music was all over the place, the decor was cheap as was plates. Overall the pizza is OK at best, Nothing special and by no means new York style, at best an overpriced east coast pizza and for the price you can go to Dominic's pizza, Santosuossos, hell even lil ceasers and get real pizza made from long established authentic Italian family's and restaurants. You can see they are struggling when in the summer there pies were 18$ for a large and now you can get 2 18' pies for 20 on delivery. I recommend going to any of the other 18 other pizza joints in towns e and get a better quality pie, a friendlier owner and overall greater experience. read more

I knew it wasn't going to be good, the guy who opened it was interviewed by the gazette and he literally said he didn't have a recipe for pizza dough. It is not awful, but its close. It's like a hand tossed chuckie cheese pizza. Clearly canned sauce on a flavorless crust with the toppings thrown on after they make it. There are probably people who will like it, but I'm not taking my family of 6 to spend $30 on pizza served on paper plates. I'm in here now and I'm literally being attacked by flies as I sit here. It sucks, because I really wanted to like this place, it would have been perfect if they knew how to make pizza... read more

Great pizza place right off the Medina Square! These New York Style Pizza Slices are 1/4 a whole pizza and come out of the oven nice and hot! The proportions of crust, to sauce, to cheese is nearly perfect and service is great! The $6 Slice and Soda is a GREAT DEAL. For me, they sliced the pizza in half to make eating easier and free refills on soft drinks. Only 4 stars because I've had a New York slice in New York, and it's hard to come by in Ohio! Overall, great pizza local to the historical Medina Square area, great service, and great deals! read more

Have been eagerly anticipating their opening for several weeks now, as Medina has relatively weak pizza offerings (chains, etc...) Courthouse Pizzeria produces a tasty pie, crust is very good when ordered 'well done'. (I saw a few slices on tables inside that were visually inedible, undercooked - might chalk that up to opening day bumps....) Sauce is very good, cheese is excellent. Overall, the pizza is much better than anything else you can buy in Medina. However, I'd like them to extend the toppings edge to edge (I had a good 2+ inches of crust only all around the pie), and I sort of felt a little ripped off at the price tag - I paid $3 for pepperoni, and got a total of 17 pieces of pepperoni covering a 16" pizza. Not OK at all. I understand the pricing structure at $4/slice, but my sense is that they'll get some pushback at charging $16 for a whole pie, no price break at all - and at the very least I'd think they would discount the toppings on a whole pie. Very good pizza, but the last thing I'd want is my customers feeling a little ripped off at the price tag....much better to have us thrilled at the pizza and feel like the value was there. Great potential here though. read more

Being from New Jersey, it is very hard to find a good pizza here in Ohio. I have only found one so far, Napolis in downtown Canton. So, needless to say, i really wanted to like this place. It was a big letdown though. While it looks close to a New York style pie, there really is no crust to be had and barely any taste coming from extra spices. Couple that with all of the flies and a weird regge atmosphere for an Italian place, it just really fell short of my hopes. read more

Most criticisms for the pizza usually revolve around Midwest sensibilities of how pizza should be. Courthouse is New York Style - the way it's supposed to be (the only other legitimate claim Is Sicilian/Mediterranean as far as authenticity). Chicago has deep dish, but it's a myth that they like deep dish. They prefer thin, NY style as well. They only eat the deep dish pizza when their friends and family come to visit for "something Chicago". Lost between Manhattan and Chicago is us where we came up with something in-between the two and it became the norm and default, which is the same reason frozen and franchise pies resemble this as well. In my opinion, this place is great; it's acceptable NY style pizza. read more

Pizza taste good. The pizza is 16 inches long. The quality is great. Good service. Nice staff and workers.

My family absolutely loves this place. Wednesday night family special is unbeatable! We get 1 pizza, salad and bread sticks. Keeps us coming back! read more

Hoping for more flavor in the pizza. Plain-tasting crust, cheese was 7/10, sauce not flavorful. Waited a LONG time to get our pizza. So long that 10 people went before us getting whole pizzas! Summary: avg base flavor and cardboard crust, poor service from staff. On the high side for what you get. read more

So the first time I ordered here, I called it in and was told 20 minutes. I get there in 20 and they're just making it and acted as if it was still baking. Second time I ordered it while there, but to go. Good thing I was watching because they screwed up the items and I caught it going in the oven, it was also real salty. This time I order Monday $10 one item and they charge me for two items. Half was plain and the other half was onion and mushrooms, which is considered at any other pizza place as "1" item! They up charge for bacon here too, as it's a premium item! read more

Was expecting much more from the location and effort put into the facility. Just not much to say about the product. Just your basic pizza.

My husband and I have been wanting to check this place out,for awhile!Our last visit to the medina sq,we did just that!We both agreed,it was one of the best pizza's we had,in a long time.We also ordered ,the garlic/parm btreadsticks..WOW!Best breadsticks,hands down!The portion sizes on both the pizza and bread sticks were generous.We will be back.Service was great as well. read more

Was passing through town and stopped for lunch Saturday. Walked around the square and the smell of pizza pulled me in. Got a NY double slice with bacon and a fountain drink. Delicious food and great service! The place was busy on a weekend lunch but still wasn't more than 10 minutes. Staff was friendly, especially one lady with dark hair and glasses who never stopped. She bussed tables and helped keep things moving. read more

Went to order a pizza and their website said that their walk in business was overwhelming and they weren't taking phone orders. When I drove past them to get the pizza we ordered there were only a couple people there. They have a prime location on Medina. Hire more staff! We would love to order your pizza and support locally!!' read more

Delicious NYC style pizza! Great staff! This was the perfect business to take over the old courthouse and Whitey's.