Craft 31 promised excellent food and craft beer, and delivered. Fried oysters on a jumbo Caesar salad and my wife had a chicken cobb salad. Excellent selection of great craft beer. Exceptional! Our server Jaedin was terrific. The only aspect to mar our visit was a snippy, snarky little-bit-of-a-thing hostess who never made eye contact and barked at us when we asked to be seated in a booth... said they were reserved, but we ordered, ate and finished and two booths remained open. This would be a five-star review if not for Ms. Demeanor... read more

My cousins came down from Richmond to visit me, and wanted to try this place. It's like a restaurant attached to a small town Midwest motel in decor, but clean and bright. We were there for a Monday lunch, can't speak to the dinner service. We also weren't drinking alcohol that day, though I thought the beer flights looked tempting. One of us had a cheeseburger that was requested to be "pink" and was overcooked and just blah. One of us had a chicken salad that was served with no chicken. Someone from the kitchen rushed out with a soup bowl filled with chicken slices that looked like those Perdue rotisserie chicken slices you buy at the grocery store. Dumped them on the salad. She did apologize. Our third order was a Restaurant Week special fried oyster salad vouched for by our server, Bailey, who was pleasant and efficient. It came with corn,black beans, mixed greens, cotija cheese and a spicy dressing. It wasn't awful but I think the overall concept was weird. Fried oyster taco salad? The few oyster pieces were tasty. Maybe we were there on a bad day, which happens. The chicken salad fiasco was funny. Not a place I would drive across town to try twice. Maybe stick to burgers and plenty of beer. read more

The restaurant looks absolutely beautiful inside and out. We walked in and the hostesses gave us funny looks. Our waiter was great though. The manager came to check us on multiple times and was super sweet. The food was delicious. The appetizer came out quietly. We had to wait a bit for our lunch but they communicated well about where we were in the line up. It was a Sunday afternoon right after church so it was expected. We will definitely be coming back to try different meals and drinks!! The menu had a lot we want to try!! read more

See all

20 golfers invaded Craft 31 in Williamsburg for dinner and unfortunately watched the Philadelphia Flyers get beat by the Pittsburgh Penguins. That is another story. Our waiter was very friendly, efficient, and patient. We ordered a variety of craft beers and food from their menu. The beer selection is large. It is made by local microbreweries so you should be able to find one you like. I had two Billsburg Lagers which hit the spot. I ordered a Diner Hamburger with French Fries and a side salad. The burger was thick but a little on the salty side. Not a lot of salty taste but noticeable which is why I gave them 4 stars instead of five. I would have rated our waiter 9 stars. He was excellent. I would also note the receptionist took us to our table and came back and balance one the legs on the table. She was nice to do that. One waiter handled 20 golfers very well. We all had a good noisy time dining together. There is also outdoor seating which we took advantage of. Cash or credit. $$-$$$. Plenty of parking. read more

Food was great, service could be better. I felt rushed by the server to order came to my table three times in less than 5 minutes aprox asking if I was ready to order. The hostess had very low energy wasn't welcoming at all, luckily decided to stay because food is great. However, ambiance wasn't as great since their local has terrible echo and it gets terribly loud. Every conversation and laugh echoed and made it terribly noisy. read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

For my first visit to Craft 31, I ordered the Pub Burger with a veggie patty. Although there were several beer-infused components of the sandwich, I didn't pick up any noticeable notes of beer. That said, the burger was delicious. Veggie patty are usually blended to a degree where I can't tell what I'm eating. However, this had small chunks of vegetables which I really liked. The braised onions paired well with the tangy "31 Sauce." The American cheese on top contributed a layer of creaminess. Even though its flavor profile wasn't beer-forward, the bun was fluffy yet sturdy enough to hold everything together. The fries were crispy and well seasoned. If you're a fan of honey mustard and spicy dips, this one will clear your sinuses. The service was great and I liked the laid-back atmosphere. I would definitely return to explore more of the menu, specifically the pizzas. read more

Craft 31 - Pub Burger with a veggie patty and fries - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Tasty food, excellent service, welcoming atmosphere. The spinach & artichoke crab dip with lots of cheesy pita bread pieces is very good--great way to start off. I enjoyed the fish n' chips (main course) that comes with a lemon-pepperoncini tartar sauce (subtle yet some punch to it). Also partook of the diner burger which is nicely prepared. Apple cobbler served with a mound of vanilla ice cream was the coup de grace for my dessert. No way could I finish all that food, so, "to-go" boxes were used, and got a second meal out of it the next day. Fabulous. Crystal (waitress) was superb and the rest of the crew at the bar and those helping out on the floor were fun and friendly, made me feel at home. And encouraged me to watch all of the Caps versus Les Habs game that evening, if I wanted (and I did), long after my meal was finished. What more can one ask for?! I'd come back for sure. read more

See all

I actually ate at Craft 31 twice with five days recently. The first time was to experience their 2025 Winter Restaurant Week menu and the other was for Happy Hour to try their pizzas and Ground Beef Tot-Cho's. Both visits were quite enjoyable. I learned that Craft 31 also offers a $12 express lunch menu that includes a soup or salad started then an assortment of lunch choices. I ordered the starter salad with peach dressing and the fried fish sandwich, which also came with a side. I chose the house made chips, which were really good! When we went for Happy Hour, we ordered the $10 medium pizzas with one topping from the Happy Hour menu, as well as an order of Ground Beef Tot-Cho's. The star hands-down was the Tot-Cho's. They were flavorful and not at all greasy. I highly recommend them. The pizzas had too much cheese for our liking. I don't know if you order more toppings there would be less cheese. The crust was thin and crispy. The red sauce was sweet and smooth. In addition to seating in the dining area, they have a bar area as well as a year-round enclosed patio with a fireplace. While it was 26 degrees outside, the patio room was very comfortable. Service was friendly and efficient. The servers stopped by to check in for refills, but they were not intrusive. They represented the establishment very well. Craft 31 is tucked away off 199 on Strawberry Plains Road. They have lots of parking. read more

See all

The two of us went to Craft 31 for the first time today. Parking was readily available and we were seated immediately on comfortable furniture. Our server (Riley) brought us water and introduced himself. We perused the extensive menu. I opted for brunch and ordered a seafood omelet and a spicy Bloody Mary. Riley was friendly, professional, and brought our drinks and food very quickly. The food was piping hot, well plated, large portioned, and delicious. We were very happy with our overall experience and easily recommend Craft 31 as a comfortable, affordable, friendly place to have a good meal with good friends! read more

Ordered the 31 loaded pizza and the Mexican - Both were good. Our waitress was helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. We sat outside on the patio next to the beautiful fireplace. I look forward to trying some of the beer on my next visit. read more

Craft 31 - Caft31 patio vibe - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

what an awesome restaurant here in the burg. I got a burger (so many to choose from on this menu!) and it was DELICIOUS!! definitely in the top 5 best burgers i've had. can't wait to go back read more

Craft 31 - Blackened Blue Cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Sunday brunch is good here. Prices are ok too. I gave it just 4 stars because I've had several dinners here and none were great. Service is usually slow. read more

They are known for the burgers. Get a burger. And make a reservation. We walked in on a Monday night and it was an hour wait (we made a reservation for the next day). The waitress was great and attentive. Our bill was wrong and they did what they needed to to fix it. There are TVs for games so that makes it fun too. read more

I've been here a couple times on a lunch date with friends and family which is always really good but we choose to eat here this year for Thanksgiving! We got the traditional plate but they had other limited options on the menu if that wasn't your thing. The service was impeccable and everyone was super friendly and nice. Going to comeback for dinner soon! Oh did I mention the plates where VERY generous! We had the Thanksgiving itis. read more

See all

Tried this place with my sister's family and her friends. There was a lot of us so a bit chaotic so I forgot to take a photo of what we ate lol. I did with my drinks though since my sister and I decided to try the drink flight that they had. It was nice that they were able to sit us all together on a big table. It was a fun time! read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Good food. Good service. We liked it a lot. We'll look for it again next time we're up that way.

Such a simple thing is to refill a glass ? One star deduction immediately for not offering me a refill. We got the tater tot appetizer, which seemed a little strange but was pretty good. I ordered the Carolina not burger sandwich and I had to ask what it was as it's not described on the menu as pulled pork. It does say barbecue sauce but funny enough mine didn't come with the barbecue sauce? Looks like a nice place. We'll try it again. I'll be scouring reviews as to what to order. read more

Craft 31 - BBQ sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Looking for a new dining experience, our group found Craft 31. The six of us chose foods from the daily lunch special menu, and we all were delighted with our choices. Our servers (sorry I do not remember her name) was absolutely amazing. Not only was she attentive and knowledgeable about foods choices offered, but she went the extra mile refilling beverages, providing extra napkins, and brining to go boxes without any is us asking in advanced. Great dining experience! read more

The food was amazing the micro brews here are top notch. April was our waitress but it was the team work of Bella and April that caused us to call the manager over and brag about our experience. The ambiance is nice for a craft beer place but the food deals like and appetizer and entree for $12 was enjoyed by each member of our party of four. If we could give this place a 6 star review we would. read more

Craft 31 - The daily special. . . Well worth the visit. If we lived here this would be our regular watering hole. - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Everything was amazing!! The pizza, sub, sweet potato waffle fries with the glaze and bread tracks were just so delicious!! Cheyanne was very attentive and we never had to wait for anything. She was always smiling every time we saw her!! Very appreciative of the great service we received on our anniversary lunch/dinner. Thank you Cheyanne!! read more

See all

Service was good. Food was fair and had a wait time of 40+ minutes, burgers were sadly overdone, fries and chips were good. We brought a birthday cake and were stopped by staff member who then told us we would be charged $1.50/person for outside dessert which is fine just giving a heads up to anyone considering the same. We did have to ask them to remove the dessert charge for the infant at the table (which felt slightly petty but still it shouldn't have happened) Parties over 10 will be put on one check with 18% gratuity added, same as a lot of other restaurants. We won't return, the experience was just okay for the amount we usually spend on our family of 12 we're looking for something more than just okay. read more

We went there for my birthday in the middle of the day, The patio with the fireplace was magical. Their menu is extensive ... the burgers are the best! We love this place! read more

Not great. This has been a staple for our Williamsburg trips for the last 4 years, we've brought tons of friends here over the years and after tonight I'd be embarrassed to recommend it anymore. I've noticed it consistently going down hill. The service is slow usually, so that's not new, but after a long wait our food came out cold. the food has massively slipped. The tuna poke was virtually flavorless. No depth of flavor whatsoever. The pizzas were bland and the mozzarella tracks had hardly any cheese. I'd never order anything we got tonight again. I liked the local beer flights for $5 but there were two beers in the flight that were pretty gross. This has been a bummer because we used to really like this place. read more

See all

Googled top restaurants to eat at in Williamsburg. Craft 31 was on the list so we decided to try it out. The food is outstanding, the service is amazing and the decor is right in line with a craft beer restaurant. I don't think you can go wrong with coming here and having a nice meal. Prices are good and Brittany our server did a great job. read more

See all

This is a great spot! Food, beverages, and staff all get five stars! It isn't anything fancy so you can just relax and enjoy yourself here.

After a day at Colonial Williamsburg, we were craving a burger. A few minutes away is this gem. Server said they are known for their burgers (advertise craft beers and burgers) and we certainly ordered some. There were lots of options for drink both on tap and otherwise. I really liked the blue frog brewery peach tea cider- light and refreshing. Cheap too- $2 for 5oz, $5 for 12oz. Flight options is up to 4 choices of a 5oz beer. We chose all beers from VA, as we are just visiting from PA. I was a fan of the music/playlist they had on- Renee Rapp, Kacey Musgraves, and Zach Bryan all played within about 10 mins. Exactly my style! Crab dip 4/5 not a strong crab taste but fried pitas are good Wings are marinated overnight and fried to order. We got 6 of the Dr Pepper, which are made with Dr Pepper syrup, and 6 of the Memphis sweet & sticky wings. The Dr Pepper ones were really interesting; more of a coating than a sauce and a little on the sweet side but not overpowering. Not sure I would have noted the Dr Pepper taste if I didn't know in advance. I was a big fan of the Memphis ones in contrast. The ranch on the side was delicious. Crunch burger with truffle fries 3/5 : didn't like the sauce on it. Fries were good but could have been crispier DIY burger with tater tots 4/5: tried to cut it in half because it was huge but everything fell out. Didn't have much flavor (house BBQ sauce) Lone Star burger with sweet potato fries (unglazed): 3/5: the sweet potato fries were small and crispy which was a bit of a bummer because I prefer my fries on the softer side but that's just a personal thing. The burger I was expecting more flavor from. Really interesting to have both brisket and a burger there. Lone star burger is served on Texas Toast. Blackened Bleu Burger 5/5 just right Irish Burger 4/5: wouldn't order again. Said it was well done but felt all the moisture was gone. Seemed dry because of how well done it was. Wish there was more cheese because it had melted completely into the bun which was disappointing. Overall review is would go back again, but order different things as our menu items felt lacking in flavor. Unfortunately we were crunched for time due to reservations elsewhere (Barbie time!) but they were very nice about it. Manager swung by to greet, which isn't something that happens very often at restaurants anymore. read more

See all

We stopped here for dinner on our way down to Hampton to visit my sister. We came on a Friday night around 8pm and had a reservation but there were still a lot of tables when we got there so we probably didn't need one. The inside of the restaurant was very nice, it was modern and gave the vibes of a fancier restaurant. They had a wide variety of beer and cocktails, I ended up getting the Margarita Flight ($13.95) which came with 4 different flavors of Margarita. They were all really good but my favorite was either the Sunset or the Peach. For dinner, I ended up getting the Waygu Beef Chili Cheese Dog ($13.95) and added the Glazed Sweet Potato Waffle Fries (+$2.25) as my side. The hot dog was so good and very flavorful, I could do without beans in the chili but that is just personal preference. The glazed waffle fries were absolutely AMAZING!! They were like a dessert and tasted like cinnamon rolls. My husband got the Pretzel Bites ($10.95) which were pretty standard but the beer cheese was very good. I would definitely stop here again! read more

See all

Ordered buffalo wings amongst other menu items. Everything was good except for the wings. They were not only dried out, but had ZERO sauce on them. Also ordered with this meal was extra ranch. However, no ranch or celery at all was included with this order. read more

Craft 31 - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Great Sunday brunch and extremely well priced. French Toast with bacon was great and their use of multi grain bread was a nice update. My partner ordered eggs and bacon and was very happy. Always enjoyed dinner here but will definitely do brunch again read more

Craft 31 - Bottoms Up Loaded Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Gotta say, the margarita flight is what got me in the door. Three out of four of them were good. Our server was super nice and accommodating. Food was good. Prices weren't bad. I got a pizza, I think it was crab . She's a keeper! Portion size was pretty big and the decor was nice. I'd return. read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We visited the restaurant last night around 7:30 PM a party of six (four adults and two kids). We were greeted by the host, a young man with a mustache, who unfortunately seemed tired or frustrated from the start. He offered us a table on the patio, which we accepted, not realizing there was live music. Before heading outside, we politely asked if we could sit at a large round booth inside. He quickly replied, "That table is for five," in a dismissive tone. I mentioned that my daughter, who's 3 and autistic, would be more comfortable indoors, but he didn't seem to care. My father-in-law, visiting from England, asked again, and the host responded even more abruptly. It felt like we had upset him just for asking -- definitely not the kind of welcome you expect at a hospitality business. Thankfully, things turned around once we were seated. Our server, Sami, was wonderful professional, friendly, and attentive from start to finish. The musician playing guitar even gave my daughter a small giraffe toy, which absolutely made her night. The food and drinks were excellent, and the overall atmosphere (thanks to the live music and Sami's service) ended up being very enjoyable. I'd gladly return I just hope management can coach the host on basic hospitality and empathy so every guest feels welcome from the start. read more

The place is nice, but the name is deceiving. When I see " Craft" I'm expecting something different. Not the case here. I ordered a BBQ chicken pizza. Average at best. It was thin crust not a deal breaker but the crust had zero flavor. Age your dough. The chicken was chunks. Take time to shred the chicken and mix it with BBQ sauce. The sauce was nothing special. No bite or tang. They used white onions. Use red. They used cheddar not a fan it doesn't melt great and has too much fat so it becomes oily. And garnish something to make it pop. The service was good, the server was friendly. read more

Craft 31 - BBQ pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

This had to be one of my worst experiences dining in Williamsburg since my 14 years of living here. Food was not complete to standard, my burger was wrong and even worse, RAW! Service was so unbelievably questionable, we arrived at the start of dinner time and the restaurant did not even seem at half capacity, yet it seemed like no one was ready to greet or sit us down for the evening. 0/5 stars if I could. Do not eat here! They don't want your money! read more

It was another awesome time at Craft 31. Julie was so helpful in getting our table together for our large group and Kelly (I hope that was the correct name) our waitress was just amazing!!! Kelly was just perfect in her service and conversation, lots of fun. We started off with 3 flights. My beer flight which was great (awesome selection of brews) and 2 Margherita flights which were very impressive. This time around I went for one of their personal pizzas. I ordered a pepperoni and Anchovy pizza. OMG I was so impressed that they had anchovies, I had to get the pie. That pizza was just so amazing, just like a NY thin crust pizza. (Note: I own my own outdoor brick oven and have experience making many pizzas). The pizza was delicious, The crust, nice and crispy!! I was so impressed with this pizza, I was 100% focused on finishing it all! The pizza was a very nice size too, I think 12" but it certainly looked bigger! My friends enjoyed their burgers and salads as well. Top it off, if you order a pint of beer, you can get a 1/2 price growler! What's better than that! I highly recommend Craft 31! I am so glad that I found Craft on my trip to Williamsburg last year. They are one of my go to spots when I visit! read more

See all

It's been a year since we had tried it this place but wanted to give it another shot and it was better. If there was a half star option I would totally give it a 3.5. Here is the rundown on our most recent visit: Extremely nice hostess and server this time around. Checked in on us regularly and food came out in a timely fashion. Food- Salad-good garlicky ranch. Still lots of red onions in the salad so just be prepared if you are not an onion lover. Sausage corn chowder-good Pizzas-good with lots of toppings. Desserts- chocolate brownie-rich and yummy and pretzel blondie-very yummy! read more

See all

By Williamsburg standards, this is probably one of the best. And it was fairly good. The service was a bit slow. The margarita flight was very cute but tasted like powdered juice mix like cool aid full of sugar, no alcohol came through. The burgers were offered "pink or no pink" I asked for pink, and it was indeed a medium cook. My wife ordered the lamb burger and it was sadly only well done. The truffle fries were limp and cold. Fried Oreos were tasty. Not sure how you mess that one up. The food overall was good, just some details here or there were missing. Our server was friendly, but could have stepped it up just a bit. I'd say give it a shot... there are not very man great options around here. read more

See all

We made a reservation and were seated right away, which was a great start. My husband and I both ordered flights--beer and margarita. The beer flight was definitely worth it, but the margarita one didn't quite hit the mark. The kids really enjoyed their meals--classic mac and cheese and pepperoni pizza, both solid choices. My husband got wings and the parmesan truffle fries. He said the wings lacked flavor, and the fries were a bit heavy on the truffle oil. I tried the crunch (?) burger. It was much thicker than expected and just wasn't my favorite in terms of flavor or texture. We ended the night with fried Oreos and the brownie dessert. The Oreos were fun, but the brownie didn't taste homemade. Overall, service was slow, and while there were a few highlights, the experience was hit or miss. read more

Service was absolutely horrible. They were not busy and took forever to get a burger and sandwich. Food was ok,not great. Ordered refills on drinks and never got them. Had to eat without the drinks we ordered. Will not go back ever. read more

My overall experience here was mediocre at best. The service was alright, but the food took an unacceptably long time to arrive. Once my food was finally prepared it had none of the advertised features, and was just unimpressive. after that I ordered some cheese curds, to go. I was hoping that they would somewhat redeem themselves, but predictably the food was once again subpar. Not to mention, the portions were pitiful as you can see by the picture I attached. I would recommend finding somewhere else to eat; it was a waste of time and money. read more

Craft 31 - Cheese curds - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My wife and I stopped on a Sunday during brunch. We were offered the brunch and lunch menus and we were seated on the patio. The ambiance was quiet and comfortable on the patio, the inside was a bit more formal and louder. This does not appear to be a tourist spot. My wife ordered the fish and chips and I had the Irish burger. Both dishes were very good. The fish was well cooked and flaky and the fries were nice and crisp. The Irish burger was delicious, it has corned beef, caramelized onions and cheese on a pretzel roll. It was served with old bay chips. I would also recommend that you take a good look at the beer menu. There are some great craft beers available. The service was friendly and efficient. We will certainly be returning. read more