Amazing service from start to finish! We had a 2-day rental over the 4th of July. Everything was…read morethoroughly explained, and we were given a map with great spots to check out for fishing, snorkeling and sandbars. GPS on the boat had routes mapped and made both the Gulf and the Atlantic easy to navigate. Even the clerks in the stores were wonderful! Boat was in great shape, ran well and was perfect for the 4 of us. They have many options to choose from and make renting super smooth. A refreshing experience and we would HIGHLY recommend! We'll be back in our next trip to the Keys!

We had an amazing time fishing and snorkeling thanks to Coco's!…read more Our boat was great and everyone was super helpful and super friendly! Highly highly recommended!

This is my 3rd time in 12 months renting from this location off CoCo Plum…read more Please note this location is under new management - Elio and his crew are doing a great job catching up on repairs to motors, radios and GPS units. I rented the Sea For 226 which had a new Suzuki motor, new radio and speakers. the boat was clean and ran well. It was a pleasant experience from reservations, to signing papers at pick-up, to boat overview to drop-off and fueling. We usually head out the Sombrero Lighthouse reef or Cotton Patch reef to snorkel for the day. They have a very good selection of boats from deck boat, to pontoons to center consoles to fit every budget. Call them to make reservation, book months ahead of busy season. I already booked our October trip

Rented 21 foot bay boat from them for 4 days for time around marathon and the keys. Boat had def…read morehad some wear and tear with a cracked and repaired front with exposed spots in the fiberglass. Scratched up and ripped top canopy. The shifting was tough and you just knew it was worn hard and for the $1200 price tag (plus fuel) it was def not what we were expecting. We know boat rentals are expensive but there were moments that left us uneasy with inability to reverse and the vibration over 20mph. Noted to the team but they were apathetic to it and when taking my family out that's not enough for us. Wouldn't recommend if heading out to sea for fishing or anything less than flat waters.

We had a great time and great snorkeling. Both Captain Stewart and Marla were very attentive and…read morehelpful. A nice time on the ocean. Highly recommend

Incredible day of snorkeling with Captain Stewart and Marla! This was the highlight of our trip to…read morethe keys. We booked the half day snorkeling excursion for the two of us and our four children (14, 12, 8, and 7) and it was a picture perfect day in the water. Both our guides were friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable, not to mention incredibly patient as they fitted each of us up and made sure that the youngest were safe and able to enjoy the snorkeling as much as the older ones. Sweet Marla even snorkeled alongside our daughter and gave her the confidence to go out a second time alone. Great company, great boat, great snacks, great sea life! We can't wait to come back soon and do it again!

The staff was amazing! I am retiring soon and wanted to start fishing from my Kayak. I have no…read moreidea what I am doing and I was honest and up front with them. A very lovely lady helped me in what equipment I needed and walked me through the process. Wonderful customer service, an amazing selection of poles from very low priced to several thousands. If they don't have you don't need it! I look forward to visiting several times over the next few years.

Staff is always very helpful. Staff gave tips on what to use for the type of fishing we were doing…read more They have a great supply of shirts and hats as well.

It's our first time to Duck Cay and I was looking for a boat charter for the day, I was referred to…read morea group that was totally booked and asked the captain if he knew of anyone else that did something other than fishing and he said these "new guys" are at the Faro Blanco Marina and they have a new boat and are very nice. So I gave them a call and I am so glad that the other place was booked up because this is by far the best charter I've ever been on. We snorkeled, had snacks, learned how to sail (a bit) and it was just amazing. My ten year old twins want me to book again tomorrow. Captain Scott and skipper Brody are outstanding. They made our day! Fresh fruit, yogurt, bagels and great sailing. What more can you ask for! Book with these guys! You won't regret it! Cannot beat the experience of the service. Don't go anywhere else! I'll be booking another tour, hopefully before we leave to return home, my husband had to miss it and after he heard about it from us, he wants to go :). Don't miss out on these guys!

Captain Scott was a wonderful host and an excellent boat captain! First , his boat is easy access…read moreto the marina parking lot. We had no issues finding his clean, new boat. Second , he has impeccable details to boating safety guidelines. You feel like you are in good hands with Captain Scott as he navigates the ocean. As we anchored at Sombrero Key Reef, Captain Scott paid attention to all safety concerns. Plenty of water toys to enjoy the abundance of surrounding fish and the blue waters of the Florida Keys! The boat was well stocked with towels, ice , water and soft drinks. If you need a catamaran rental for a slice of island paradise, go see Captain Scott!

Bob is the best! We came in with an unusual request, and he helped us out no questions asked. His…read morecustomer service is unmatched. Check him out!

Amazing, amazing, tour. Can say enough! Our tour guide was really knowledgeable, learned tons of…read morenew information about the wild life and the mangroves.

Definitely one of our top fishing trips Hooked on the keys!!! Andrew is an awesome Captain, finds…read morethe fish, very accommodating, friendly great guy! We caught Spanish Mackerel (large good eating light flavor fish) and Mango Snapper (awesome eating fish) - Captain Andrew filet's everything and suggested we take it to Hide Away restaurant close by which we did and was the right call they cooked it perfect yeah we wanted!

Me and my wife recently planned a trip to Key West in June of 2012. We have owned boats for years…read moreand decided we wanted to rent a boat for the day while we were in Key West. A couple weeks before our trip we reserved a center console from Boat Rentals of Key West for 8 hours. On the day of the rental we arrived at their office in the Marina at Downtown Key West. The staff was courteous and gave us all the needed instructions we would need for the day. The boat was clean, gassed up and ready to go. We had a blast exploring the area and reefs around Key West. The Boat performed and ran great. Me and my wife have rented boats before and never have we encountered a staff as professional and courteous as the people working at Boat Rentals of Key West and their boats are in very good condition and obviously well maintained. In the future, we will be back to Key West and we will only rent a boat from Boat Rentals of Key West. Thanks again for the great service. Our boat rental was the highlight of our key West trip.

Will try to keep this as short as possible, only focusing on the facts that impacted the…read moreexperience. I never leave bad reviews, but in this case it was absolutely necessary. - "Boat Rentals of Key West" is a broker, but does not disclose at time of booking. After making a deposit on phone, we were sent to pickup our boat at a place called "Paradise Boat Rentals" at Murray Marine on Stock Island. - We arrived at Paradise Boat Rentals at 1pm where final payment was charged. Upon which, the owner "Rocky" recommended he guide us through the narrow channels to main water. Very shallow area that surrounded the location. - When we hit open waters, Rocky waived us through and we were on our way. 35 minutes later, the boat broke down. From 1st contact, it took them 3 hours to come assist us. - By 5:15pm, we had everything swapped over to a replacement boat. We used this replacement boat to tow Rocky 45 minutes closer to KW (out of courtesy). - It was cloudy, windy and the water was very choppy that day, not to mention, we were in a flat bottom deck boat. It was extremely rough to say the least, and we still had to make it back to Murray on Stock Island. - By 6:45pm we could barely see. We realize at this time, the replacement boat has NO lights and NO navigation device. My wife calls Rocky on his cell, and explained we were about 500 yards from his marina, but needed an assist due to no lights or nav - it was not safe trying to navigate the narrow channels without someone experienced with such area. He begins screaming at her and accusing us of being intoxicated. I get on the phone and he begins cursing "I know what F...n games you are playing", "I'm not coming to help you", "Just wait until you get here and see who you are messing with", etc, etc. I explain to him that 3 of us on the boat, including driver had not taken 1 sip of alcohol that day. - At this point, due to the situation and the threats from Rocky, we pulled over to a bulk-headed area and called the local authorities. They agreed we should not drive the boat as it was very dangerous to do so without lights. They then helped return the boat and coordinated our vehicle pickup from Murray. At 9:30pm, we were finally returning to our hotel. - We are now going through the channels of dispute with our credit card company for right at $400 in charges (from both this broker and Paradise rentals)! Rant over. Proceed with caution.